본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Adherence to a Vegetarian Diet is not Associated With Depression: Results From the National Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys

2

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류정신과학

초록

Objective Adherence to vegetarian diets has been associated with physical health benefits, whereas vegetarian mental health is less well documented. We sought to investigate whether adherence to a vegetarian diet was associated with depression in a nationally-representative sample of US adults.Methods We used population-based data from the US National Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys to examine said associations. Depression was assessed using the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9), vegetarian status was self-reported. Multivariate regression was used to measure the magnitude of associations, controlling for a range of covariables known to be associated with depressive symptoms.Results Our analysis included 9,584 individuals, of which 910 individuals had PHQ-9 scores suggestive of depression. Vegetarian diet was associated with reduced odds of PHQ-9 defined depression (odds ratio [OR]: 0.49 [95% confidence interval {CI}: 0.24–0.98], p=0.047) in a model adjusting for sex, age, ethnicity, income, and marital status. When adjusting for additional factors (educational level, smoking status, serum C-reactive protein, and body mass index) in a second model, the previously observed association was no longer significant (OR: 0.66 [CI: 0.34–1.26], p=0.203).Conclusion Vegetarian diet was not associated with PHQ-9 defined depression in this nationally-representative sample of adults. Additional longitudinal examinations are warranted to evolve the understanding of the role of vegetarian diets in mental health.

Abstract

Objective Adherence to vegetarian diets has been associated with physical health benefits, whereas vegetarian mental health is less well documented. We sought to investigate whether adherence to a vegetarian diet was associated with depression in a nationally-representative sample of US adults.Methods We used population-based data from the US National Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys to examine said associations. Depression was assessed using the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9), vegetarian status was self-reported. Multivariate regression was used to measure the magnitude of associations, controlling for a range of covariables known to be associated with depressive symptoms.Results Our analysis included 9,584 individuals, of which 910 individuals had PHQ-9 scores suggestive of depression. Vegetarian diet was associated with reduced odds of PHQ-9 defined depression (odds ratio [OR]: 0.49 [95% confidence interval {CI}: 0.24–0.98], p=0.047) in a model adjusting for sex, age, ethnicity, income, and marital status. When adjusting for additional factors (educational level, smoking status, serum C-reactive protein, and body mass index) in a second model, the previously observed association was no longer significant (OR: 0.66 [CI: 0.34–1.26], p=0.203).Conclusion Vegetarian diet was not associated with PHQ-9 defined depression in this nationally-representative sample of adults. Additional longitudinal examinations are warranted to evolve the understanding of the role of vegetarian diets in mental health.

참고문헌 (74)

  1. Ruby MB, "Vegetarianism. A blossoming field of study", Appetite, 58, pp.141~150 (2012)
  2. Marrone G, "Vegan diet health benefits in metabolic syndrome", Nutrients, 13, pp.817~ (2021)
  3. Williams KA, "Healthy plant-based diet : what does it really mean?", J Am Coll Cardiol, 70, pp.423~425 (2017)
  4. Rosenfeld DL, "Vegetarian on purpose : understanding the motivations of plant-based dieters", Appetite, 116, pp.456~463 (2017)
  5. Hopwood CJ, "Health, environmental, and animal rights motives for vegetarian eating", PLoS One, 15, pp.e0230609~ (2020)
  6. Storz MA, "Will the plant-based movement redefine physicians’ understanding of chronic disease?", New Bioeth, 26, pp.141~157 (2020)
  7. Kahleova H, "Cardio-metabolic benefits of plantbased diets", Nutrients, 9, pp.848~ (2017)
  8. Jardine MA, "Perspective : plant-based eating pattern for type 2 diabetes prevention and treatment : efficacy, mechanisms, and practical considerations", Adv Nutr, 12, pp.2045~2055 (2021)
  9. Barnard ND, "A Mediterranean diet and low-fat vegan diet to improve body weight and cardiometabolic risk factors : a randomized, cross-over trial", J Am Nutr Assoc, 41, pp.127~139 (2022)
  10. Beezhold BL, "Vegetarian diets are associated with healthy mood states : a cross-sectional study in seventh day adventist adults", Nutr J, 9, pp.26~ (2010)
  11. Michalak J, "Vegetarian diet and mental disorders : results from a representative community survey", Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act, 9, pp.67~ (2012)
  12. Hibbeln JR, "Vegetarian diets and depressive symptoms among men", J Affect Disord, 225, pp.13~17 (2018)
  13. Shen YC, "Vegetarian diet is associated with lower risk of depression in Taiwan", Nutrients, 13, pp.1059~ (2021)
  14. Forestell CA, "Vegetarianism, depression, and the five factor model of personality", Ecol Food Nutr, 57, pp.246~259 (2018)
  15. Burkert NT, "Nutrition and health-the association between eating behavior and various health parameters : a matched sample study", PLoS One, 9, pp.e88278~ (2014)
  16. Lai JS, "A systematic review and meta-analysis of dietary patterns and depression in community-dwelling adults", Am J Clin Nutr, 99, pp.181~197 (2014)
  17. Storz MA, "Lifestyle adjustments in long-COVID management : potential benefits of plant-based diets", Curr Nutr Rep, 10, pp.352~363 (2021)
  18. Akbaraly TN, "dietary pattern and depressive symptoms in middle age", Br J Psychiatry, 195, pp.408~413 (2009)
  19. Wattick RA, "Relationship between diet and mental health in a young adult appalachian college population", Nutrients, 10, pp.957~ (2018)
  20. Zhang Y, "Is meat consumption associated with depression? A meta-analysis of observational studies", BMC Psychiatry, 17, pp.409~ (2017)
  21. Nucci D, "Red and processed meat consumption and risk of depression : a systematic review and meta-analysis", Int J Environ Res Public Health, 17, pp.6686~ (2020)
  22. Dobersek U, "Meat and mental health : a systematic review of meat abstention and depression, anxiety, and related phenomena", Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr, 61, pp.622~635 (2021)
  23. Askari M, "Vegetarian diet and the risk of depression, anxiety, and stress symptoms : a systematic review and meta-analysis of observational studies", Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr, 62, pp.261~271 (2022)
  24. Fazelian S, "Adherence to the vegetarian diet may increase the risk of depression : a systematic review and meta-analysis of observational studies", Nutr Rev, 80, pp.242~254 (2022)
  25. "National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey"[URL]
  26. Lee WC, "Association between periodontitis and pulmonary function based on the Third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey(NHANES III)", J Clin Periodontol, 47, pp.788~795 (2020)
  27. "About the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey"[URL]
  28. Yu B, "Trends in depression among adults in the United States, NHANES 2005-2016", J Affect Disord, 263, pp.609~620 (2020)
  29. O’Neil A, "The association between poor dental health and depression : findings from a large-scale, population-based study(the NHANES study)", Gen Hosp Psychiatry, 36, pp.266~270 (2014)
  30. "NHANES Survey Methods and Analytic Guidelines"[URL]
  31. "NHANES Response Rates and Population Totals"[URL]
  32. "NCHS Ethics Review Board (ERB) Approval"[URL]
  33. Beard C, "Validation of the PHQ-9 in a psychiatric sample", J Affect Disord, 193, pp.267~273 (2016)
  34. Kroenke K, "The PHQ-9 : validity of a brief depression severity measure", J Gen Intern Med, 16, pp.606~613 (2001)
  35. Martin A, "Validity of the brief Patient Health Questionnaire mood scale(PHQ-9)in the general population", Gen Hosp Psychiatry, 28, pp.71~77 (2006)
  36. Manea L, "Optimal cut-off score for diagnosing depression with the Patient Health Questionnaire(PHQ-9) : a meta-analysis", CMAJ, 184, pp.E191~E196 (2012)
  37. Ghazisaeedi M, "Validity, reliability, and optimal cut-off scores of the WHO-5, PHQ-9, and PHQ-2 to screen depression among university students in Iran", Int J Ment Health Addict, 20, pp.1824~1833 (2022)
  38. Levis B, "Accuracy of Patient Health Questionnaire-9(PHQ-9)for screening to detect major depression : individual participant data meta-analysis", BMJ, 365, pp.l1476~ (2019)
  39. "2007-2008 Demographics Data - Continuous NHANES"[URL]
  40. Storz MA, "Diet and consumer behavior in U. S. vegetarians : a National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey(NHANES)data report", Int J Environ Res Public Health, 19, pp.67~ (2022)
  41. Heeringa SG, "Applied survey data analysis", pp.2017, Chapman and hall
  42. Hosmer DWJ, "Applied logistic regression", pp.89~151 (2013), John Wiley & Sons, Inc
  43. Fresán U, "Influence of the socio-cultural environment and external factors in following plant-based diets", Sustainability, 12, pp.9093~ (2020)
  44. Davey GK, "EPIC-Oxford : lifestyle characteristics and nutrient intakes in a cohort of 33883 meat-eaters and 31 546 non meat-eaters in the UK", Public Health Nutr, 6, pp.259~269 (2003)
  45. Haghighatdoost F, "Association of vegetarian diet with inflammatory biomarkers : a systematic review and meta-analysis of observational studies", Public Health Nutr, 20, pp.2713~2721 (2017)
  46. Archer KJ, "Goodness-of-fit test for a logistic regression model fitted using survey sample data", Stata J, 6, pp.97~105 (2006)
  47. Psaltopoulou T, "Mediterranean diet, stroke, cognitive impairment, and depression : a meta-analysis", Ann Neurol, 74, pp.580~591 (2013)
  48. O’Neil A, "Relationship between diet and mental health in children and adolescents : a systematic review", Am J Public Health, 104, pp.e31~e42 (2014)
  49. Chiu TH, "Relative validity and reproducibility of a quantitative FFQ for assessing nutrient intakes of vegetarians in Taiwan", Public Health Nutr, 17, pp.1459~1466 (2014)
  50. Li X, "Adhering to a vegetarian diet may create a greater risk of depressive symptoms in the elderly male Chinese population", J Affect Disord, 243, pp.182~187 (2019)
  51. Jin Y, "Vegetarian diet is inversely associated with prevalence of depression in middle-older aged South Asians in the United States", Ethn Health, 26, pp.504~511 (2021)
  52. Kahleova H, "Vegetarian diet in type 2 diabetes-improvement in quality of life, mood and eating behaviour", Diabet Med, 30, pp.127~129 (2013)
  53. Beezhold BL, "Restriction of meat, fish, and poultry in omnivores improves mood : a pilot randomized controlled trial", Nutr J, 11, pp.9~ (2012)
  54. Berk M, "So depression is an inflammatory disease, but where does the inflammation come from?", BMC Med, 11, pp.200~ (2013)
  55. Dinan TG, "Inflammatory markers in depression", Curr Opin Psychiatry, 22, pp.32~36 (2009)
  56. Dowlati Y, "A meta-analysis of cytokines in major depression", Biol Psychiatry, 67, pp.446~457 (2010)
  57. Osimo EF, "Inflammatory markers in depression : a meta-analysis of mean differences and variability in 5, 166 patients and 5, 083 controls", Brain Behav Immun, 87, pp.901~909 (2020)
  58. Turner-McGrievy GM, "Randomization to plant-based dietary approaches leads to larger short-term improvements in Dietary Inflammatory Index scores and macronutrient intake compared with diets that contain meat", Nutr Res, 35, pp.97~106 (2015)
  59. Eichelmann F, "Effect of plant-based diets on obesity-related inflammatory profiles : a systematic review and meta-analysis of intervention trials", Obes Rev, 17, pp.1067~1079 (2016)
  60. Shao A, "Oxidative stress at the crossroads of aging, stroke and depression", Aging Dis, 11, pp.1537~1566 (2020)
  61. Barbosa ML, "Oxidative stress, antioxidant defense and depressive disorders : a systematic review of biochemical and molecular markers", Neurol Psychiatry Brain Res, 36, pp.65~72 (2020)
  62. Pellegrini N, "Total antioxidant capacity of plant foods, beverages and oils consumed in Italy assessed by three different in vitro assays", J Nutr, 133, pp.2812~2819 (2003)
  63. Rauma AL, "Antioxidant status in vegetarians versus omnivores", Nutrition, 16, pp.111~119 (2000)
  64. Galor SW, "Aging", pp.81~91 (2014), Academic Press
  65. Chiu THT, "Vegetarian diet and incidence of total, ischemic, and hemorrhagic stroke in 2 cohorts in Taiwan", Neurology, 94, pp.e1112~e1121 (2020)
  66. Lin CL, "Reply from author for letter to the editor concerning : stroke and diets : a review", Tzu Chi Med J, 34, pp.253~ (2022)
  67. Juan W, "Food intake patterns of self-identified vegetarians among the U. S. population, 2007-2010", Procedia Food Sci, 4, pp.86~93 (2015)
  68. Baines S, "How does the health and well-being of young Australian vegetarian and semi-vegetarian women compare with non-vegetarians?", Public Health Nutr, 10, pp.436~442 (2007)
  69. Lehto E, "Vegetarians and different types of meat eaters among the finnish adult population from 2007 to 2017", Br J Nutr, 127, pp.1060~1072 (2022)
  70. Allès B, "Comparison of sociodemographic and nutritional characteristics between self-reported vegetarians, vegans, and meat-eaters from the NutriNet-Santé study", Nutrients, 9, pp.1023~ (2017)
  71. Storz MA, "Bowel health in U. S. vegetarians : a 4-year data report from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey(NHANES)", Nutrients, 14, pp.681~ (2022)
  72. Le LT, "Beyond meatless, the health effects of vegan diets : findings from the Adventist cohorts", Nutrients, 6, pp.2131~2147 (2014)
  73. "1 in 10 Americans say they don’t eat meat - a growing share of the population. Alliance for Science" (2022)[URL]
  74. Goodwin RD, "Trends in U. S. depression prevalence from 2015 to 2020 : the widening treatment gap", Am J Prev Med, 63, pp.726~733 (2022)

관련 논문AI추천

Healthy and Unhealthy Dietary Patterns Are Related to Depression: A Case-Control StudyAhmad Esmaillzadeh, Firoozeh Raisi, Gity Sotoudeh, Maryam Khosravi, Maryam Sorayani, Reza Majdzadeh, Samaneh Darabi, Somayeh Nejati대한신경정신의학회 · PSYCHIATRY INVESTIGATION2015 · 제12권 제4호The association between dietary pattern and depression in middle-aged Korean adultsHae-Jeung Lee, Myung Sunny Kim, Seon Joo Park한국영양학회 · Nutrition Research and Practice2019 · 제13권 제4호Association between weekly fruit and vegetable consumption and depressive symptoms: results from the Korean Elderly Environmental Panel studyChoi Yoon-Jung, Han Chae-Rin, Hong Yun-Chul, Jang Yoonyoung, Yuk Youjeong한국역학회 · Epidemiology and Health2021 · 제43권 한국 성인에서 식이섭취와 우울증 유병의 관련성: 2010년 국민건강영양조사 자료를 이용하여김자형, 신새론, 이수영, 정용준, 한아름한국농촌의학.지역보건학회 · 농촌의학.지역보건2016 · 제41권 제2호Relationship between psychological distress and the adherence to the Korean healthy eating index (KHEI): the Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (KNHANES) 2013 and 2015오상우, 윤영숙한국영양학회 · Nutrition Research and Practice2021 · 제15권 제4호Association between dietary omega-3 fatty acid intake and depression in postmenopausal women박경, Minjeong Chae한국영양학회 · Nutrition Research and Practice2021 · 제15권 제4호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (11건)