Psychometric Properties of Assessment Tools for Depression, Anxiety, Distress, and Psychological Problems in Breast Cancer Patients: A Systematic Review
2
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Objective Various and accurate psychiatric assessments in patients with breast cancer who frequently suffer from psychological problems due to long-term survivors are warranted. This systematic review aimed to investigate the current evidence on psychometric properties of psychiatric assessment for evaluating psychological problems in breast cancer patients.Methods This systematic review progressed according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guideline. Four electronic databases such as Web of Science, PubMed, Embase, and Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature were searched. This study protocol was registered on Open Science Framework.Results Of the 2,040 articles, 21 papers were finally included. Among them, only five studies showed the performance of psychiatric assessment tools. Among 13 assessment tools used in the selected articles, the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS), Distress Thermometer (DT), or Mini-Mental Adjustment to Cancer Scale was frequently used for the evaluation of psychological problems. The DT and Psychosocial Distress Questionnaire-Breast Cancer showed acceptable performances for the prediction of depression and anxiety assessed by the HADS.Conclusion This systematic review found psychiatric assessment tools with acceptable reliability and validity for breast cancer patients. However, comparative studies on reliability and validity of various scales are required to provide useful information for the selection of appropriate assessment tools based on the clinical settings and treatment stages of breast cancer. Joint research among the fields of psychiatry and breast surgery is needed for research to establish the convergent, concurrent, and predictive validity of psychiatric assessment tools in breast cancer patients.
Abstract
Objective Various and accurate psychiatric assessments in patients with breast cancer who frequently suffer from psychological problems due to long-term survivors are warranted. This systematic review aimed to investigate the current evidence on psychometric properties of psychiatric assessment for evaluating psychological problems in breast cancer patients.Methods This systematic review progressed according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guideline. Four electronic databases such as Web of Science, PubMed, Embase, and Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature were searched. This study protocol was registered on Open Science Framework.Results Of the 2,040 articles, 21 papers were finally included. Among them, only five studies showed the performance of psychiatric assessment tools. Among 13 assessment tools used in the selected articles, the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS), Distress Thermometer (DT), or Mini-Mental Adjustment to Cancer Scale was frequently used for the evaluation of psychological problems. The DT and Psychosocial Distress Questionnaire-Breast Cancer showed acceptable performances for the prediction of depression and anxiety assessed by the HADS.Conclusion This systematic review found psychiatric assessment tools with acceptable reliability and validity for breast cancer patients. However, comparative studies on reliability and validity of various scales are required to provide useful information for the selection of appropriate assessment tools based on the clinical settings and treatment stages of breast cancer. Joint research among the fields of psychiatry and breast surgery is needed for research to establish the convergent, concurrent, and predictive validity of psychiatric assessment tools in breast cancer patients.
참고문헌 (52)
- Krebber AM, "Prevalence of depression in cancer patients : a meta-analysis of diagnostic interviews and self-report instruments", Psychooncology, 23, pp.121~130 (2014)
- Waraich P, "Prevalence and incidence studies of mood disorders : a systematic review of the literature", Can J Psychiatry, 49, pp.124~138 (2004)
- Linden W, "Anxiety and depression after cancer diagnosis : prevalence rates by cancer type, gender, and age", J Affect Disord, 141, pp.343~351 (2012)
- Zhao G, "Physical activity, psychological distress, and receipt of mental healthcare services among cancer survivors", J Cancer Surviv, 7, pp.131~139 (2013)
- Stein KD, "Physical and psychological long-term and late effects of cancer", Cancer, 112, pp.2577~2592 (2008)
- Suppli NP, "Survival after early-stage breast cancer of women previously treated for depression : a nationwide Danish cohort study", J Clin Oncol, 35, pp.334~342 (2017)
- Mausbach BT, "Healthcare use and costs in adult cancer patients with anxiety and depression", Depress Anxiety, 37, pp.908~915 (2020)
- Söllner W, "How successful are oncologists in identifying patient distress, perceived social support, and need for psychosocial counselling?", Br J Cancer, 84, pp.179~185 (2001)
- Vodermaier A, "Screening for emotional distress in cancer patients : a systematic review of assessment instruments", J Natl Cancer Inst, 101, pp.1464~1488 (2009)
- Schmid-Büchi S, "Experiencing the disease of breast cancer and getting life under control again", Pflege, 18, pp.345~352 (2005)
- Herschbach P, "Psychological problems of cancer patients : a cancer distress screening with a cancer-specific questionnaire", Br J Cancer, 91, pp.504~511 (2004)
- Ramírez M, "Measurement issues in health disparities research", Health Serv Res, 40, pp.1640~1657 (2005)
- Stewart AL, "Health-related quality-of-life assessments in diverse population groups in the United States", Med Care, 38(Suppl 9), pp.II102~II124 (2000)
- Dewalt DA, "Literacy and health outcomes : a systematic review of the literature", J Gen Intern Med, 19, pp.1228~1239 (2004)
- Ashing-Giwa K, "A cross-cultural validation of patient-reported outcomes measures : a study of breast cancers survivors", Qual Life Res, 22, pp.295~308 (2013)
- Bidstrup PE, "Accuracy of the Danish version of the ‘distress thermometer’", Psychooncology, 21, pp.436~443 (2012)
- Bogaarts MP, "The Psychosocial Distress Questionnaire-Breast Cancer(PDQ-BC)is a useful instrument to screen psychosocial problems", Support Care Cancer, 20, pp.1659~1665 (2012)
- Bogaarts MP, "Reliability and validity of the psychosocial distress questionnaire-breast cancer", J Nurs Meas, 22, pp.E14~E28 (2014)
- Charalampopoulou M, "Reliability and validity of the newly diagnosed Breast Cancer Stress scale in the Greek population", J Mol Biochem, 9, pp.5~12 (2020)
- De Vries J, "A breast cancer specific screening questionnaire for psychosocial problems : the PDQBC", Psycho-Oncol, 22, pp.296~ (2013)
- De Vries J, "Development of a short version of the Dutch version of the Spielberger STAI trait anxiety scale in women suspected of breast cancer and breast cancer survivors", J Clin Psychol Med Settings, 20, pp.215~226 (2013)
- Estapé T, "On-line assessment of psychological distress in breast cancer patients", Psycho-Oncol, 22, pp.16~17 (2013)
- Estapé T, "Psychometric characteristics of the mini-MAC scale used online for breast cancer patients", Psycho-Oncol, 26, pp.154~155 (2017)
- Hajian-Tilaki K, "Factor structure and reliability of Persian version of hospital anxiety and depression scale in patients with breast cancer survivors", Health Qual Life Outcomes, 18, pp.176~ (2020)
- Iskandarsyah A, "The distress thermometer and its validity : a first psychometric study in Indonesian women with breast cancer", PLoS One, 8, pp.e56353~ (2013)
- Kim J, "Depression screening using daily mental-health ratings from a smartphone application for breast cancer patients", J Med Internet Res, 18, pp.e216~ (2016)
- Lee TY, "Measuring reliability and validity of a newly developed stress instrument : newly diagnosed breast cancer stress scale", J Clin Nurs, 22, pp.2417~2425 (2013)
- Neto V, "Adaptation to breast cancer : validation of the Portuguese version of psychological adaptation scale", Revista Iberoamericana de Diagnostico y Evaluacion-e Avaliacao Psicologica, 3, pp.55~69 (2021)
- Ragala MEA, "Validation of Mini-Mental Adjustment to Cancer Scale in a Moroccan sample of breast cancer women", BMC Cancer, 21, pp.1042~ (2021)
- Saboonchi F, "Examination of the construct validity of the Swedish version of hospital anxiety and depression scale in breast cancer patients", Qual Life Res, 22, pp.2849~2856 (2013)
- Tomljenović H, "Hospital anxiety and depression scale : psychometric validation on a sample of Croatian breast cancer patients", Libri Oncol, 49, pp.101~102 (2021)
- Torres A, "Preliminary psychometric characteristics of the Portuguese version of Patient Health Questionnaire 9(PHQ-9)in a sample of Portuguese breast cancer women", Eur Psychiatry, 28(Suppl 1), pp.1~ (2013)
- Andreu Vaillo Y, "Mini-Mental Adjustment to Cancer Scale : construct validation in Spanish breast cancer patients", J Psychosom Res, 114, pp.38~44 (2018)
- Yong HW, "Validation of Malaysian translated distress thermometer with problem checklist among the breast cancer survivors in Malaysia", Asian J Psychiatr, 5, pp.38~42 (2012)
- Zhang N, "Psychometric assessment of the Chinese version of the brief illness perception questionnaire in breast cancer survivors", PLoS One, 12, pp.e0174093~ (2017)
- Cronbach LJ, "Coefficient alpha and the internal structure of tests", Psychometrika, 16, pp.297~334 (1951)
- Cho E, "Making reliability reliable : a systematic approach to reliability coefficients", Organ Res Methods, 19, pp.651~682 (2016)
- Nunnally JC, "Psychometric theory" (1994), McGraw-Hill, Inc
- Zigmond AS, "The hospital anxiety and depression scale", Acta Psychiatr Scand, 67, pp.361~370 (1983)
- Lisspers J, "Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale(HAD) : some psychometric data for a Swedish sample", Acta Psychiatr Scand, 96, pp.281~286 (1997)
- Malasi TH, "Validation of the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale in Arab patients", Acta Psychiatr Scand, 84, pp.323~326 (1991)
- Roth AJ, "Rapid screening for psychologic distress in men with prostate carcinoma : a pilot study", Cancer, 82, pp.1904~1908 (1998)
- National Comprehensive Cancer Network, "NCCN guidelines version 1.2022. Distress management", Plymouth Meeting (2021), National Comprehensive Cancer Network
- Sarenmalm EK, "Swedish version of the distress thermometer : validity evidence in patients with colorectal cancer", J Natl Compr Canc Netw, 16, pp.959~966 (2018)
- Alosaimi FD, "Validity and feasibility of the Arabic version of distress thermometer for Saudi cancer patients", PLoS One, 13, pp.e0207364~ (2018)
- Watson M, "The mini-MAC : further development of the mental adjustment to cancer scale", J Psychosoc Oncol, 12, pp.33~46 (1994)
- Grassi L, "Styles of coping with cancer : the Italian version of the Mini-Mental Adjustment to Cancer(Mini-MAC)scale", Psychooncology, 14, pp.115~124 (2005)
- Ho SM, "Psychometric properties of the Chinese version of the Mini-Mental Adjustment to Cancer(mini-MAC)scale", Psychooncology, 12, pp.547~556 (2003)
- Kang JI, "Standardization of the Korean version of Mini-Mental Adjustment to Cancer(K-Mini-MAC)scale : factor structure, reliability and validity", Psychooncology, 17, pp.592~597 (2008)
- Anagnostopoulos F, "The Mini-Mental Adjustment to Cancer(Mini-MAC)scale : construct validation with a Greek sample of breast cancer patients", Psychooncology, 15, pp.79~89 (2006)
- Watson M, "Mental adjustment to cancer scale : psychometric properties in a large cancer cohort", Psychooncology, 17, pp.1146~1151 (2008)
- Zucca A, "Rasch analysis of the Mini-Mental Adjustment to Cancer Scale(mini-MAC)among a heterogeneous sample of long-term cancer survivors : a cross-sectional study", Health Qual Life Outcomes, 10, pp.55~ (2012)
