본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

독일 자연치료사(Heilpraktiker) 제도 현황과 형성과정

German Heilpraktiker system, its history and current status

김동수|박인효
대한예방한의학회 (Society of Preventive Korean Medicine)|2018.12|대한예방한의학회지 (Society of Preventive Korean Medicine)|제22권 제3호|pp. 45-60|DOI 10.25153/spkom.2018.22.3.005

0

조회

0

다운로드

2

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

Heilpraktikercomplementary medicinealternative medicineGerman health systemmedical pluralism
주제분류한의학

초록

Background : There have been a variety of healthcare systems related to CAM practitioners developed in each country. However, the European cases have not been widely introduced in Korea so far. In the case of Germany, CAM practices have been developed in the frame of "Heilpraktiker" system. Objectives : The objectives of this study were to review the historical development and current situation of German Heilpraktiker system and its conflicting relationship with Western medical doctors, in order to utilize it as basic data for the conflict resolution between Western- and KM doctors in Korea. Methods : The historical development, current regulations and education system of Heilpraktiker were assessed. Research articles, reports, government publications and websites dealing with this issue were searched for and analyzed. Results : Heilpraktiker system was developed within German historical and cultural situation where naturopathic traditions were reilluminated in connection with modernization process of the state under the influence of romanticism formulating German nationalism. Between the concept of “Kurierverbot”(prohibition on medical treatment by non-physicians) and “Kurierfreiheit”(freedom of medical treatment), Heilpraktiker achieved a limited but legitimated right to conduct non-biomedical treatments from the state in the process of the formulation of modern German medical system. In this process, the conflicts between medical doctors and heilpraktikers have been also growing up to now. Conclusions : Heilpraktiker system, officially recognized with the legislation of Heilpraktiker law in 1939, stands at a crossroads between the continual development through strengthening its professionality, and abolition of the system due to its lack of quality control and medical evidence mostly argued by Western medical doctors, which has considerable implications for Korean situations in terms of the conflicting relationship between KM- and Western medical doctors. In this regard, it is necessary to discuss the debates on the concept “Kurierfreiheit”(freedom of medical treatment) developed within German tradition of medical pluralism.

Abstract

Background : There have been a variety of healthcare systems related to CAM practitioners developed in each country. However, the European cases have not been widely introduced in Korea so far. In the case of Germany, CAM practices have been developed in the frame of "Heilpraktiker" system. Objectives : The objectives of this study were to review the historical development and current situation of German Heilpraktiker system and its conflicting relationship with Western medical doctors, in order to utilize it as basic data for the conflict resolution between Western- and KM doctors in Korea. Methods : The historical development, current regulations and education system of Heilpraktiker were assessed. Research articles, reports, government publications and websites dealing with this issue were searched for and analyzed. Results : Heilpraktiker system was developed within German historical and cultural situation where naturopathic traditions were reilluminated in connection with modernization process of the state under the influence of romanticism formulating German nationalism. Between the concept of “Kurierverbot”(prohibition on medical treatment by non-physicians) and “Kurierfreiheit”(freedom of medical treatment), Heilpraktiker achieved a limited but legitimated right to conduct non-biomedical treatments from the state in the process of the formulation of modern German medical system. In this process, the conflicts between medical doctors and heilpraktikers have been also growing up to now. Conclusions : Heilpraktiker system, officially recognized with the legislation of Heilpraktiker law in 1939, stands at a crossroads between the continual development through strengthening its professionality, and abolition of the system due to its lack of quality control and medical evidence mostly argued by Western medical doctors, which has considerable implications for Korean situations in terms of the conflicting relationship between KM- and Western medical doctors. In this regard, it is necessary to discuss the debates on the concept “Kurierfreiheit”(freedom of medical treatment) developed within German tradition of medical pluralism.

참고문헌 (58)

  1. WHO, "2014-2023 WHO Traditional medicine stratagy", ~ (2013)
  2. Vinjar Fønnebø, "Cambrella Work Package2-Legal status and regulation of CAM in Europe", The 7th Framework Programme of European Union Commision (2012)
  3. Park HL, "Traditional Medicine in China, Korea, and Japan; A Brief Introduction and Comparison", Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine, 2012, pp.1~9 (2012)
  4. Current Status and Implications of traditional Chinese Medicine - West Medicine in China and Taiwan, "KJ Yoon", Korea institute for international economic policy, ~ (2016)
  5. 김동수, "대만 중·서의 의료이원화 현황에 관한 연구- 면허제도 및 교육제도 확립을 중심으로 -", 동의생리병리학회지, 28(1), pp.9~15 (2014), 한의병리학회
  6. JM Shim, "Cross-national differences in the holistic use of traditional East Asian medicine in East Asia", Health Promotion International, pp.1~9 (2016)
  7. JM Shim, "The Relationship Between the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicine and the Use of Biomedical Services: Evidence From East Asian Medical Systems", Asia-Pacific Journal of Public Health, 28(1), pp.51~60 (2016)
  8. JM Shim, "Three plural medical systems in East Asia: interpenetrative pluralism in China, exclusionary pluralism in Korea and subjugatory pluralism in Japan", Health Policy and Planning (2018)
  9. "ärztliche Ausbildung. Heilpraktiker"[URL]
  10. ", die Krankheiten mit natürlichen Methoden heiltBerufsbezeichnung. Heilpraktiker"[URL]
  11. "Gesetz über die berufsmäßige Ausübung der Heilkunde ohne Bestallung (Heilpraktikergesetz). Ausfertigungsdatum: 17.02.1939" (1939)[URL]
  12. "Gesamtzahl der Ärzte in Deutschland im Zeitraum von 1990 bis 2017 (in 1.000)" (1990)[URL]
  13. "Repräsentative Umfrage: Jeden Tag gehen in Deutschland 128.000 Patienten zum Heilpraktiker"[URL]
  14. CH Han, "Guidebook for KM doctors’ working in Europe(Han-uisa-ui Europe Jinchul Guidebook)", pp.146~ (2017), Ministry of Health and Welfare
  15. "Heilpraktikerausbildung"[URL]
  16. 변무웅, "독일의 민간의술자 법률", 한양법학, (25), pp.305~332 (2009), 한양법학회
  17. "KGS: Körper, Geist, Seele –Ein Magazin für Gesundheit"[URL]
  18. "Leitlinien: Gerüst, nicht Korsett" (2013)[URL]
  19. "Bekanntmachung von Leitlinien zur Überprüfung von Heilpraktikeranwärterinnen und –anwärtern nach § 2 des Heilpraktikergesetzes in Verbindung mit § 2 Absatz 1 Buchstabe i der Ersten Durchführungsverordnung zum Heilpraktikergesetz" (2017)[URL]
  20. "Fachverband Deutscher Heilpraktiker e.V"[URL]
  21. "Arche Medica – Akademie für Heilpraktiker"[URL]
  22. "“Basic information on Hildegard(9.17)”(Hildegard Gibon Jeongbo)"[URL]
  23. Hildegard von Bingen, "Liber subtilitatum diversarum naturarum creaturarum. Band 3: Kommentiertes Register der deutschen Wörter" (2014)
  24. 김기녀, "중세 독일의 여성 자연과학자 힐데가르트 폰 빙엔", 독일언어문학, (69), pp.1~22 (2015), 한국독일언어문학회[DOI]
  25. C Feldmann, "Hildegard von Bingen(Korean edition)", pp.119~ (2017), Bundo Press
  26. Das “Speyerer Kräuterbuch”mit den Heilpflanzen Hildegards von Bingen. Eine Studie zur mittelhochdeutschen “Physica”-Rezeption mit kritischer Ausgabe des Textes, "B Fehringer", Königshausen & Neumann, ~ (1994)
  27. 고유경, "제바스티안 크나이프와 독일 자연치유운동 - 자연주의와 근대의학 사이에서", 의사학, 25(3), pp.557~590 (2016), 대한의사학회[DOI]
  28. "Hildegaard von Bingen Online Shop"[URL]
  29. CA Burtis, "Tietz Textbook of Clinical Chemistry and Molecular Diagnostics" (2018), Elsevier
  30. "Grundprinzipien Paracelsischer Heilweise"[URL]
  31. "Paraculsus Schule, die Heilpraktikerschule"[URL]
  32. J Freder, "Die Geschichte des Heilpraktikerberufs in Deutschland unter besonderer Berücksichtigung der Verhältnisse in der DDR", pp.59~ (2003), Verlag Volksheilkunde
  33. "Nacktkultur, Lebensreform, Körperkultur - Neue Forschungsliteratur und Methodenfragen"[URL]
  34. WR Krabbe, "Handbuch der deutschen Reformbewegungen 1880–1933", pp.74~ (1998)
  35. KE Rothschuh, "Naturheilbewegung, Reformbewegung, Alternativbewegung", pp.9~10 (1983), Hippokrates Verlag
  36. Hans-Christian Deter, "Die Arzt-Patient-Beziehung in der modernen Medizin", pp.88~ (2010), Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht
  37. "Die Geschicte der Naturheilkunde"[URL]
  38. "The German ‘Heilpraktiker’ is a relic from the Nazis that endangers public health"[URL]
  39. "Die Geschicthe des Heilpraktikers"[URL]
  40. "80 Jahre ‘Der Heilpraktiker’"[URL]
  41. "Wer die Heilkunde, ohne als Arzt bestallt zu sein, bisher befufsmäßig nicht ausgeübt hat, kann eine Erlaubnis nach § 1 in Zukunft nur in besonders begründeten Ausnahmefällen erhalten", Heilpraktikergesetz, ~ (1939)
  42. "Es ist verboten, Ausbildungsstaetten fuer Personen, die sich der Ausuebung der Heilkunde im Sinne dieses Gesetzes widmen wollen, einzurichten oder sie zu unterhalten", Heilpraktikergesetz, ~ (1939)
  43. K Franz, "Naturheilmittel und Recht", pp.165~ (1992)
  44. "Die AGTCM e.V. von 1954 bis Heute. Homepage of Arbeitsgemeinschaft für klassische Akupunktur und Traditionelle Chinesische Medizin, e.V" (1954)[URL]
  45. D Young, "Traditional Health Systems and Public Policy", pp.62~ (1994)
  46. M Last, "Medical Anthropology-Contemporary Theory and Method", pp.375~395 (1996), Prager
  47. "Tod von drei Krebspatienten: Anklage gegen Heilpraktiker" (2018)[URL]
  48. "Münsteraner Kreis"[URL]
  49. "Münsteraner Memorandum Heilpraktiker"[URL]
  50. "Deutsches Netzwerk Evidenzbasierte Medizin e.V" (2017)
  51. "Mediziner Konflikt-Neuauflage im alten Streit zwischen Heilpraktikern und Ärzten" (2017)[URL]
  52. "BDH weist Kritik an Heilpraktiker-Beruf in Deutschland zurück", Heilpraktiker Fakten, ~
  53. "Heilpraktiker setzen auf Qualität – Ärzte wollen dies verhindern" (2017)[URL]
  54. "Zwingende Reformbedürftigkeit: Gesundheitsminister planen Heilpraktiker-Reform"[URL]
  55. "Beschlüsse der 91.(2018). TOP: 6.4Reform des Heilpraktikerwesens" (2018)[URL]
  56. Robert Jütte, "Medical Pluralism; Past-Present-Future", pp.127~140 (2013), Franz Steiner Verlag Stuttgart
  57. R Brubaker, "Citizenship and Nationhood in France and Germany" (1992), Cambridge
  58. 김동수, "스위스에서의 국민투표에 의한 보완의학 건강보험 급여화 사례 연구", 대한예방한의학회지, 21(3), pp.29~42 (2017), 대한예방한의학회[DOI]

관련 논문AI추천

선진국의 보완대체의료 정책의 함의한동운대한예방한의학회 · 대한예방한의학회지2008 · 제12권 제3호33개국 대한민국 재외공관을 통한 전통의학 및 보완대체의학 관련 제도 조사박유리대한예방한의학회 · 대한예방한의학회지2015 · 제19권 제1호독일에서의 침술 건강보험 급여화 사례 연구김동수, 박인효, 임병묵대한예방한의학회 · 대한예방한의학회지2019 · 제23권 제3호대만 중·서의 의료이원화 현황에 관한 연구- 면허제도 및 교육제도 확립을 중심으로 -권수현, 권영규, 김동수, 이현지, 최병희한의병리학회 · 동의생리병리학회지2014 · 제28권 제1호Two Paths for Alternative Medicine: Professionalization of Oriental Medicine and the Growth of Lay Acupuncturists in Korea조병희한국학중앙연구원 · Korea Journal2009 · 제49권 제3호캐나다의 보완대체의학 현황에 대한 연구남현진, 유지은, 이기용, 임병묵대한예방한의학회 · 대한예방한의학회지2024 · 제28권 제2호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (7건)

건강보험 시범사업 기관에 내원한 요통환자에 대한 추나요법 유효성 평가 연구김동수, 임병묵, 류지선, 신병철pp. 1-10약물역학분야의 한약연구동향우연주pp. 11-19한의대생의 생활양식 연구 – 음주양태와 섭식태도를 중심으로고호연, 이재혁pp. 21-29한약제제 보험급여 확대 및 활성화 방안에 대한 한의사 인식도 조사박준상, 박선아, 이은경, 김주철, 장보형, 고성규, 신용철, 주용준, 정덕현, 최재영pp. 31-44한포진에 대한 최근 한의학적 연구 동향 - 국내 학술지를 중심으로 -오용택, 송범용, 이명선, 김종욱, 육태한, 김경한, 정종민pp. 61-72
원문 보기