목 및 가슴신경뿌리병증의 임상적 고찰: 비침습적 중재시술치료
Clinical Characteristics of Cervical and Thoracic Radiculopathies: Non-Invasive Interventional Therapy
1
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Cervical and thoracic radiculopathies are among the most common causes of neck pain. The most common causes are cervical disc herniation and cervical spondylosis in patients with cervical radiculopathy, and diabetes mellitus and thoracic disc herniation in thoracic radiculopathy. A thorough history, physical examination, and testing that includes electrodiagnostic examination and imaging studies may distinguish radiculopathy from other pain sources. Although various electrodiagnostic examinations may help evaluate radiculopathy, needle electromyography is the most important, sensitive, and specific method. Outcome studies of conservative treatments have shown varying results and have not been well controlled or systematic. When legitimate incapacitating symptoms continue despite conservative treatment attempts, more invasive spinal procedures and intradiscal treatment may be appropriate. Surgery has been shown to have excellent clinical outcomes in patients with disc extrusion and neurological deficits. However, patients with minimal disc herniation have fair or poor surgical outcomes. In addition, conventional open disc surgery entails various inadvertent surgical related risks. Although there has not yet been a non-surgical interventional procedure developed with the therapeutic efficacy of open surgery, conservative procedures can offer substantial benefits, are less invasive, and avoid surgical complications. While more invasive procedures may be appropriate when conservative treatment fails, prospective studies evaluating cervical and thoracic radiculopathies treatment options would help guide practitioners toward optimally cost-effective patient evaluation and care.
Abstract
Cervical and thoracic radiculopathies are among the most common causes of neck pain. The most common causes are cervical disc herniation and cervical spondylosis in patients with cervical radiculopathy, and diabetes mellitus and thoracic disc herniation in thoracic radiculopathy. A thorough history, physical examination, and testing that includes electrodiagnostic examination and imaging studies may distinguish radiculopathy from other pain sources. Although various electrodiagnostic examinations may help evaluate radiculopathy, needle electromyography is the most important, sensitive, and specific method. Outcome studies of conservative treatments have shown varying results and have not been well controlled or systematic. When legitimate incapacitating symptoms continue despite conservative treatment attempts, more invasive spinal procedures and intradiscal treatment may be appropriate. Surgery has been shown to have excellent clinical outcomes in patients with disc extrusion and neurological deficits. However, patients with minimal disc herniation have fair or poor surgical outcomes. In addition, conventional open disc surgery entails various inadvertent surgical related risks. Although there has not yet been a non-surgical interventional procedure developed with the therapeutic efficacy of open surgery, conservative procedures can offer substantial benefits, are less invasive, and avoid surgical complications. While more invasive procedures may be appropriate when conservative treatment fails, prospective studies evaluating cervical and thoracic radiculopathies treatment options would help guide practitioners toward optimally cost-effective patient evaluation and care.
참고문헌 (111)
- Cote P., "The Saskatchewan Health andBack Pain Survey. The prevalence of neck pain and relateddisability in Saskatchewan adults", Spine, 23, pp.1689~1698 (1998)
- Bovim G., "Neck pain in the generalpopulation", Spine, 19, pp.1307~1309 (1994)
- Linton SJ, "Can we screen for problematic backpain? A screening questionnaire for predicting outcome inacute and subacute back pain", Clin J Pain, 14, pp.209~215 (1998)
- Ylinen J., "Clinical use of neck isometric strengthmeasurement in rehabilitation", Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 75, pp.465~469 (1994)
- Hellsing AL, "Predictors of musculoskeletalpain in men: A twenty-year follow-up from examination atenlistment", Spine, 25, pp.3080~3086 (2000)
- Radhakrishnan K., "Epidemiology of cervical radiculopathy. A population-basedstudy from Rochester, Minnesota, 1976 through 1990", Brain, 117(2), pp.325~335 (1994)
- Kelsey JL, "Epidemiology of radiculopathies", Adv Neurol, 19, pp.385~398 (1978)
- Lees F., "Natural History and Prognosis of CervicalSpondylosis", Br Med J, 2, pp.1607~1610 (1963)
- Dillin W., "Cervical radiculopathy. A review", Spine, 11, pp.988~991 (1986)
- "Pain in the neck and arm: a multicentre trial of the effectsof physiotherapy, arranged by the British Association ofPhysical Medicine", Br Med J, 1, pp.253~258 (1966)
- Carragee EJ, "A prospective analysis of magneticresonance imaging findings in patients with sciatica andlumbar disc herniation. Correlation of outcomes with discfragment and canal morphology", Spine, 22, pp.1650~1660 (1997)
- Maroon JC, "Is there a future forpercutaneous intradiscal therapy?", Clin Neurosurg, 43, pp.239~251 (1996)
- Onik G, "Automated percutaneousdiscectomy: a prospective multi-institutional study", Neurosurgery, 26, pp.228~232 (1990)
- Chen Y, "Epidemiology of disc, root, jointpain in Whiplash in: Interventional Spine: an algorithmic approach", pp.607~612 (2007), Elsevier
- Spurling RG, "Lateral intervertebral disklesions in the lower cervical region", J Am Med Assoc, 151, pp.354~359 (1953)
- Tong HC, "The Spurling test andcervical radiculopathy", Spine, 27, pp.156~159 (2002)
- Wainner RS, "Reliability and diagnostic accuracy of the clinicalexamination and patient self-report measures for cervicalradiculopathy", Spine, 28, pp.52~62 (2003)
- Blumenkopf B., "Thoracic intervertebral disc herniations: diagnosticvalue of magnetic resonance imaging", Neurosurgery, 23, pp.36~40 (1988)
- Streib EW, "Diabetic thoracic radiculopathy: electrodiagnosticstudy", Muscle Nerve, 9, pp.548~553 (1986)
- Kikta DG, "Thoracic root pain indiabetes: the spectrum of clinical and electromyographicfindings", Ann Neurol, 11, pp.80~85 (1982)
- Liveson JA, "Thoracic radiculopathy related to collapsedthoracic vertebral bodies", J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry, 47, pp.404~406 (1984)
- Marinacci AA, "Radicular syndromes simulatingintra-abdominal surgical conditions", Am Surg, 28, pp.59~63 (1962)
- Kim BJ, "Polyradiculomyelitis associated with clinically diagnosed tuberculousmeningitis", Eur Neurol, 46, pp.156~157 (2001)
- Russell T., "Thoracic intervertebral disc protrusion: experienceof 67 cases and review of the literature", Br J Neurosurg, 3, pp.153~160 (1989)
- Levin KH, "Neurologic manifestations of compressive radiculopathyof the first thoracic root", Neurology, 53, pp.1149~1151 (1999)
- Morgan H., "Disc herniation at T1-2. Report of fourcases and literature review", J Neurosurg, 88, pp.148~150 (1998)
- Arce CA, "Thoracic disc herniation. Improveddiagnosis with computed tomographic scanning and a reviewof the literature", Surg Neurol, 23, pp.356~361 (1985)
- McInerney J., "The pathophysiology of thoracic discdisease", Neurosurg Focus, 9(e1) (2000)
- Alvarez O., "Multilevel thoracic diskherniations: CT and MR studies", J Comput Assist Tomogr, 12, pp.649~652 (1988)
- Brown CW, "The natural history of thoracic disc herniation", Spine, 17, pp.S97~102 (1992)
- Parke WW, "The applied anatomy of the intervertebraldisc", Orthop Clin North Am, 2, pp.309~324 (1971)
- DePalma AF, "The natural history of severe cervical disc degeneration", ActaOrthop Scand, 43, pp.392~396 (1972)
- Maiman DJ, "Anatomy and clinical biomechanicsof the thoracic spine", Clin Neurosurg, 38, pp.296~324 (1992)
- Stillerman CB, "Experience in the surgical management of 82 symptomaticherniated thoracic discs and review of the literature", J Neurosurg, 88, pp.623~633 (1998)
- Wood KB, "The natural history of asymptomaticthoracic disc herniations", Spine, 22, pp.525~529 (1997)
- Epstein NE, "Intraduraldisc herniations in the cervical, thoracic, and lumbar spine:report of three cases and review of the literature", J SpinalDisord, 3, pp.396~403 (1990)
- Vanichkachorn JS, "Thoracic disk disease: diagnosisand treatment", J Am Acad Orthop Surg, 8, pp.159~169 (2000)
- Manifold SG, "Cervical radiculitis and shoulderdisorders", Clin Orthop Relat Res, pp.105~113 (1999)
- Levin KH, "Electrodiagnostic approach to the patient withsuspected radiculopathy", Neurol Clin, 20, pp.397~421 (2002)
- Wilbourn AJ, "AAEE minimonograph #32: theelectrophysiologic examination in patients with radiculopathies", Muscle Nerve, 11, pp.1099~1114 (1988)
- Aminoff MJ, "Electrophysiological evaluation of root andspinal cord disease", Semin Neurol, 22, pp.197~204 (2002)
- Date ES, "Cervical paraspinalspontaneous activity in asymptomatic subjects", Muscle Nerve, 34, pp.361~364 (2006)
- Gough JG, "Electromyographic determination ofmotor root levels in erector spinae muscles", Arch Phys MedRehabil, 47, pp.9~11 (1966)
- Kim BJ, "Electromyographic technique for lumbar multifidus examination:comparison of previous techniques used to localize themultifidus", Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 86, pp.1325~1329 (2005)
- Dillingham TR, "Identification of cervical radiculopathies:optimizing the electromyographic screen", Am J Phys MedRehabil, 80, pp.84~91 (2001)
- Date ES, "Cervical and Thoracic Radiculopathies. In:Kimura J. Peripheral Nerve Diseases: Handbook of clinicalNeurophysiology. Amsterdam", pp.601~612 (2006), Elsevier
- Johnson ER, "Intercostal nerveconduction and posterior rhizotomy in the diagnosis andtreatment of thoracic radiculopathy", J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry, 37, pp.330~332 (1974)
- Levin KH, "Cervical radiculopathies:comparison of surgical and EMG localization ofsingle-root lesions", Neurology, 46, pp.1022~1025 (1996)
- Jabre JF, "Surface recording of the H-reflex of the flexor carpiradialis", Muscle Nerve, 4, pp.435~438 (1981)
- Katz JS, "Cervicobrachial involvementin diabetic radiculoplexopathy", Muscle Nerve, 24, pp.794~798 (2001)
- Bastron JA, "Diabetic polyradiculopathy: clinicaland electromyographic findings in 105 patients", Mayo ClinProc, 56, pp.725~732 (1981)
- Chaudhuri KR, "Unilateralabdominal muscle herniation with pain: a distinctive variantof diabetic radiculopathy", Diabet Med, 14, pp.803~807 (1997)
- Kim BJ, "Clinical Scales for Radiculopathy", J Kor NeurolAssoc, 23, pp.78~87 (2005)
- Williams NH, "Extending the AberdeenBack Pain Scale to include the whole spine: a set ofoutcome measures for the neck, upper and lower back", Pain, 94, pp.261~274 (2001)
- Hurst H., "Assessing the clinical significance ofchange scores recorded on subjective outcome measures", J Manipulative Physiol Ther, 27, pp.26~35 (2004)
- BenDebba M, "Cervicalspine outcomes questionnaire: its development and psychometricproperties", Spine, 27, pp.2116~2123 (2002)
- Chiu TT, "Psychometric properties of ageneric health measure in patients with neck pain", ClinRehabil, 19, pp.505~513 (2005)
- Hoving JL, "Validity of the neck disability index, Northwick Park neckpain questionnaire, and problem elicitation technique for measuringdisability associated with whiplash-associated disorders", Pain, 102, pp.273~281 (2003)
- Olson SL, "Tender point sensitivity, range of motion, and perceiveddisability in subjects with neck pain", J Orthop Sports PhysTher, 30, pp.13~20 (2000)
- Ylinen J., "Association of neck pain, disability andneck pain during maximal effort with neck muscle strengthand range of movement in women with chronic non-specificneck pain", Eur J Pain, 8, pp.473~478 (2004)
- Pinfold M., "Validity and internal consistency of awhiplash-specific disability measure", Spine, 29, pp.263~268 (2004)
- Bombardier C., "Outcome assessments in the evaluation oftreatment of spinal disorders: summary and general recommendations", Spine, 25, pp.3100~3103 (2000)
- Ware JE Jr, "SF-36 health survey update", Spine, 25, pp.3130~3139 (2000)
- Downie WW, "Studies with pain rating scales", Ann RheumDis, 37, pp.378~381 (1978)
- Fejer R., "Categorising the severity ofneck pain: establishment of cut-points for use in clinical andepidemiological research", Pain, 119, pp.176~182 (2005)
- Vernon H., "The Neck Disability Index: a study ofreliability and validity", J Manipulative Physiol Ther, 14, pp.409~415 (1991)
- Jordan A., "TheCopenhagen Neck Functional Disability Scale: a study ofreliability and validity", J Manipulative Physiol Ther, 21, pp.520~527 (1998)
- Leak AM, "The Northwick Park Neck Pain Questionnaire,devised to measure neck pain and disability", Br J Rheumatol, 33, pp.469~474 (1994)
- Chen Y., "Epidural SteroidInjections: Past, Present and Future", SpineLine, 4, pp.9~19 (2003)
- Derby R., "Non-surgicalinterventional treatment of cervical and thoracic radiculopathies", Pain Physician, 7, pp.389~394 (2004)
- Franson RC, "Human disc phospholipase A2is inflammatory", Spine, 17, pp.S129~132 (1992)
- Badalamente MA, "Mechanical stimulation of dorsal root ganglia induces increasedproduction of substance P: a mechanism for pain followingnerve root compromise", Spine, 12, pp.552~555 (1987)
- Chatani K, "Characterization of thermal hyperalgesia, c-fos expression,and alterations in neuropeptides after mechanical irritationof the dorsal root ganglion", Spine, 20, pp.277~289 (1995)
- Johansson A., "Local corticosteroid applicationblocks transmission in normal nociceptive C-fibres", Acta Anaesthesiol Scand, 34, pp.335~338 (1990)
- Claman HN, "Corticosteroids and lymphoid cells", N Engl J Med, 287, pp.388~397 (1972)
- Byrod G., "Methylprednisolone reduces the early vascular permeabilityincrease in spinal nerve roots induced by epidural nucleuspulposus application", J Orthop Res, 18, pp.983~987 (2000)
- Derby R., "Complicationsfollowing cervical epidural steroid injections by expert interventionalistsin 2003", Pain Physician, 7, pp.445~449 (2004)
- Derby R., "Size andaggregation of corticosteroids used for epidural injections", Pain Med, 9, pp.227~234 (2008)
- Woodard J, "Epidural procedures in spine pain and management.In, Physiatric Procedures in Clinical Practice" (1995), Hanky and Belfus
- Rowlingson JC, "Epidural analgesic techniquesin the management of cervical pain", Anesth Analg, 65, pp.938~942 (1986)
- Shulman M., "Treatment of neck pain with cervical epiduralsteroid injection", Regional Anesth, 11(92) (1986)
- Ferrante FM, "Clinical classification as a predictor of therapeuticoutcome after cervical epidural steroid injection", Spine, 18, pp.730~736 (1993)
- Bush K., "Outcome of cervical radiculopathy treatedwith periradicular", epidural corticosteroid injections: a prospectivestudy with independent clinical review, 1996, pp.5, 319~325
- Mixter W., "Rupture of the intervertebral disc withinvolvement of the spinal canal", NEJM, 211, pp.210~215 (1934)
- Chen Y., "Percutaneous disc decompressionin the management of chronic low back pain", Orthop ClinNorth Am, 35, pp.17~23 (2004)
- Case RB, "Intervertebral disc pressure asa function of fluid volume infused", J Clin Laser Med Surg, 13, pp.143~147 (1985)
- Lee SH, "In vitromeasurement of pressure in intervertebral discs and annulusfibrosus with and without annular tears during discography", Spine J, 4, pp.614~618 (2004)
- Smith L, "Enzyme dissolution of the nucleus pulposus inhumans", JAMA, pp.137~140 (1964)
- Smith L., "Enzymedissolution of the nucleus pulposus", Nature, 198, pp.1311~1312 (1963)
- Ascher PW, "Application of the laser in neurosurgery", Lasers Surg Med, 2, pp.91~97 (1986)
- Hijikata S, "Percutaneous nucleotomy. A new concept techniqueand 12 years’ experience", Clin Orthop, pp.9~23 (1989)
- Brown MD, "Update on chemonucleolysis", Spine, 21, pp.62S~68S (1996)
- Hoogland T., "Low-dose chemonucleolysiscombined with percutaneous nucleotomy in herniated cervicaldisks", J Spinal Disord, 8, pp.228~232 (1995)
- Gomez-Castresana F., "Cervical chymopapain nucleolysis: MRimaging assessment of chymopapain efficacy", Neurosurg ClinN Am, 7, pp.1~16 (1996)
- Krause D., "Cervical Chymopapain Chemonucleolysis", Semin Musculoskelet Radiol, 1, pp.207~214 (1997)
- Agre K., "Chymodiactinpostmarketing surveillance. Demographic and adverse experiencedata in 29,075 patients", Spine, 9, pp.479~485 (1984)
- "Spine", 1996, 1952~1956
- Wittenberg RH, "Fiveyearresults from chemonucleolysis with chymopapain orcollagenase: a prospective randomized study", Spine, 26, pp.1835~1841 (2001)
- Mitra R., "Chymopapain: a shot fromthe past", Pain Pract, 8, pp.331~332 (2008)
- Bonaldi G., "Percutaneousdiscectomy using Onik’s method: 3 years’ experience", Neuroradiology, 33, pp.516~519 (1991)
- Kotilainen E., "Percutaneous nucleotomy in the treatment ofcervical disc herniation: report of three cases and review", Minim Invasive Neurosurg, 42, pp.152~155 (1999)
- Maroon JC, "Current concepts in minimally invasive discectomy", Neurosurgery, 51, pp.S137~145 (2002)
- Choy DS, "Percutaneous laser nucleolysis of lumbar disks", N Engl J Med, 317, pp.771~772 (1987)
- Quigley MR, "Percutaneous laser discectomy", urosurg ClinN Am, 7, pp.37~42 (1996)
- Turgut M, "Extensive damage tothe end-plates as a complication of laser discectomy. Anexperimental study using an animal model", Acta Neurochir, 139, pp.404~409 (1997)
- Ohnmeiss DD, "Laser discdecompression. The importance of proper patient selection", Spine, 19, pp.2054~2058 (1994)
- Siebert W., "Percutaneous laser discectomy of cervical discs:preliminary clinical results", J Clin Laser Med Surg, 13, pp.205~207 (1995)
- Chen YC, "Histologic findingsof disc, end plate and neural elements after coblation ofnucleus pulposus: an experimental nucleoplasty study", Spine J, 3, pp.466~470 (2003)
- Chen YC, "Intradiscal pressure study ofpercutaneous disc decompression with nucleoplasty in humancadavers", Spine, 28, pp.661~665 (2003)
- Li J, "Percutaneous cervical nucleoplastyin the treatment of cervical disc herniation", Eur Spine J, 17, pp.1664~1669 (2008)
- Nardi PV, "Percutaneous cervicalnucleoplasty using coblation technology. Clinical results infifty consecutive cases", Acta Neurochir Suppl, 92, pp.73~78 (2005)
