Efficacy of Herbal Medicines on Lung Function in Asthma: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials
2
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Objectives: The present study was designed to conduct a comprehensive systematic review and meta-analysis to assess the efficacy of herbal medicines as add-on therapy on lung function in asthmatic patients. Methods: A comprehensive search of online databases was performed up to December 2021 to identify randomized controlled trials that used orally herbal preparations for asthma as add-on therapy. Studies were assessed for methodological quality using the Cochrane Collaboration’s Risk of Bias tool. The main outcome was percent predicted value of forced expiratory volume (% predicted FEV1). Pooled weighted mean difference (WMD) estimate with corresponding 95% confidence interval (CI) was calculated using inversevariance weights method while random effects meta-analysis was used, taking into account clinical and conceptual heterogeneity. Results: As a result, 1,525 studies were identified. 169 studies were reviewed in-depth and 23 studies met our systematic review inclusion criteria. Finally, nine randomized controlled trials were included in the meta-analysis. Findings indicated that use of herbal medicines in patients with asthma significantly improved % predicted FEV1 (WMD: 3.73, 95% CI: 1.76-5.70), with no evidence for significant heterogeneity (p = 0.56 [Q statistic], I 2 = 0.0%). In subgroup analysis by age, improvement in % predicted FEV1 was higher and significant in adults (WMD: 5.16; 95% CI: 2.68-7.63) compared to children (WMD = 1.27; 95% CI: −1.98-4.51). Sensitivity analysis showed the significant effect of herbal medicine consumption on improving FEV1 was consistently (range of summary WMDs: 3.27-4.59), indicating that the meta-analysis model was robust. There was no evidence of publication bias both visually and statistically. Conclusion: Findings support, the complementary use of herbal medicines resulted in significant improvement in the lung function compared to standard treatment in asthmatic patients with no considerable adverse events. This improvement is more likely to be observed amongst adults.
Abstract
Objectives: The present study was designed to conduct a comprehensive systematic review and meta-analysis to assess the efficacy of herbal medicines as add-on therapy on lung function in asthmatic patients. Methods: A comprehensive search of online databases was performed up to December 2021 to identify randomized controlled trials that used orally herbal preparations for asthma as add-on therapy. Studies were assessed for methodological quality using the Cochrane Collaboration’s Risk of Bias tool. The main outcome was percent predicted value of forced expiratory volume (% predicted FEV1). Pooled weighted mean difference (WMD) estimate with corresponding 95% confidence interval (CI) was calculated using inversevariance weights method while random effects meta-analysis was used, taking into account clinical and conceptual heterogeneity. Results: As a result, 1,525 studies were identified. 169 studies were reviewed in-depth and 23 studies met our systematic review inclusion criteria. Finally, nine randomized controlled trials were included in the meta-analysis. Findings indicated that use of herbal medicines in patients with asthma significantly improved % predicted FEV1 (WMD: 3.73, 95% CI: 1.76-5.70), with no evidence for significant heterogeneity (p = 0.56 [Q statistic], I 2 = 0.0%). In subgroup analysis by age, improvement in % predicted FEV1 was higher and significant in adults (WMD: 5.16; 95% CI: 2.68-7.63) compared to children (WMD = 1.27; 95% CI: −1.98-4.51). Sensitivity analysis showed the significant effect of herbal medicine consumption on improving FEV1 was consistently (range of summary WMDs: 3.27-4.59), indicating that the meta-analysis model was robust. There was no evidence of publication bias both visually and statistically. Conclusion: Findings support, the complementary use of herbal medicines resulted in significant improvement in the lung function compared to standard treatment in asthmatic patients with no considerable adverse events. This improvement is more likely to be observed amongst adults.
참고문헌 (83)
- Wang L, "Adverse drug reactions of Shuanghuanglian injection : a systematic review of public literatures", J Evid Based Med, 3(1), pp.18~26 (2010)
- Rawat S, "Hedychium spicatum : a systematic review on traditional uses, phytochemistry, pharmacology and future prospectus", J Pharm Pharmacol, 70(6), pp.687~712 (2018)
- Pareek A, "Feverfew(Tanacetum parthenium L. ) : a systematic review", Pharmacogn Rev, 5(9), pp.103~110 (2011)
- Babayigit A, "Ginseng ameliorates chronic histopathologic changes in a murine model of asthma", Allergy Asthma Proc, 29(5), pp.493~498 (2008)
- Yue GG, "Screening for anti-inflammatory and bronchorelaxant activities of 12 commonly used Chinese herbal medicines", Phytother Res, 26(6), pp.915~925 (2012)
- Hofmann D, "Efficacy of dry extract of ivy leaves in children with bronchial asthma--a review of randomized controlled trials", Phytomedicine, 10(2-3), pp.213~220 (2003)
- Chan CK, "Ding Chuan Tang, a Chinese herb decoction, could improve airway hyper-responsiveness in stabilized asthmatic children : a randomized, double-blind clinical trial", Pediatr Allergy Immunol, 17(5), pp.316~322 (2006)
- Kim KI, "A traditional herbal medication, Maekmoondong-tang, for cough : a systematic review and meta-analysis", J Ethnopharmacol, 178, pp.144~154 (2016)
- Zhang Y, "History of uses, phytochemistry, pharmacological activities, quality control and toxicity of the root of Stephania tetrandra S. Moore : a review", J Ethnopharmacol, 260, pp.112995~ (2020)
- Yang T, "Euphorbia ebracteolata Hayata(Euphorbiaceae) : a systematic review of its traditional uses, botany, phytochemistry, pharmacology, toxicology, and quality control", Phytochemistry, 186, pp.112736~ (2021)
- Yadav V, "A systematic review on Piper longum L.: bridging traditional knowledge and pharmacological evidence for future translational research", J Ethnopharmacol, 247, pp.112255~ (2020)
- Zhang C, "Efficacy and safety of Anluohuaxian in the treatment of patients with severe Coronavirus disease 2019-a multicenter, open label, randomized controlled study : a structured summary of a study protocol for a randomised controlled trial", Trials, 21(1), pp.495~ (2020)
- Hashempur MH, "Medicinal plants’ use among patients with dyslipidemia: an Iranian cross-sectional survey", J Complement Integr Med, 16(3) (2019)
- Moghimi Sarani E, "Evaluation of the effect of alkaloid berberine on the positive and negative symptoms of the patients with schizophrenia : a double-blind randomized placebo-controlled clinical trial", Trad Integr Med, 7(3), pp.287~293 (2022)
- Ou-Yang SH, "Dioscorea nipponica Makino : a systematic review on its ethnobotany, phytochemical and pharmacological profiles", Chem Cent J, 12(1), pp.57~ (2018)
- Namazi N, "The effects of Nigella sativa L. on obesity : a systematic review and meta-analysis", J Ethnopharmacol, 219, pp.173~181 (2018)
- Miraj S, "A systematic review of the relationship between dystemprament(sue Mizaj)and treatments and management of diseases(Ilaj and Eslah-e-Mizaj)", Electron Physician, 8(12), pp.3378~3384 (2016)
- Ji T, "A comprehensive review on traditional uses, chemical compositions, pharmacology properties and toxicology of Tetrastigma hemsleyanum", J Ethnopharmacol, 264, pp.113247~ (2021)
- He Y, "Comprehensive investigation and risk study on pyrrolizidine alkaloid contamination in Chinese retail honey", Environ Pollut, 267, pp.115542~ (2020)
- Chen G, "Sanao decoction for asthma : protocol of a systematic review", Medicine(Baltimore), 98(18), pp.e15313~ (2019)
- Jiang S, "Botany, traditional uses, phytochemistry, pharmacology and toxicology of Ilex pubescens Hook et Arn", J Ethnopharmacol, 245, pp.112147~ (2019)
- Chen Z, "A systematic review on the rhizome of Ligusticum chuanxiong Hort. (Chuanxiong)", Food Chem Toxicol, 119, pp.309~325 (2018)
- Khorasanchi Z, "Crocus sativus a natural food coloring and flavoring has potent anti-tumor properties", Phytomedicine, 43, pp.21~27 (2018)
- Chen PY, "18-Carbon polyunsaturated fatty acids ameliorate palmitate-induced inflammation and insulin resistance in mouse C2C12 myotubes", J Nutr Biochem, 26(5), pp.521~531 (2015)
- Huntley AL, "The safety of herbal medicinal products derived from Echinacea species : a systematic review", Drug Saf, 28(5), pp.387~400 (2005)
- Wang Y, "Comparison of clinical effectiveness of acupuncture and a Western drug on allergic rhinitis : study protocol for a randomized controlled trial", J Tradit Chin Med, 34(3), pp.254~260 (2014)
- Clark CE, "Herbal interventions for chronic asthma in adults and children : a systematic review and meta-analysis", Prim Care Respir J, 19(4), pp.307~314 (2010)
- Huntley A, "Herbal medicines for asthma : a systematic review", Thorax, 55(11), pp.925~929 (2000)
- Arnold E, "Herbal interventions for chronic asthma in adults and children", Cochrane Database Syst Rev, (1), pp.CD005989~ (2010)
- Ernst E, "Frankincense: systematic review", BMJ, 337, pp.a2813~ (2008)
- Shergis JL, "Herbal medicine for adults with asthma : a systematic review", J Asthma, 53(6), pp.650~659 (2016)
- Singh BB, "Herbal treatments of asthma : a systematic review", J Asthma, 44(9), pp.685~698 (2007)
- Chan PH, "A randomized placebo-controlled trial of traditional Chinese medicine as an add-on therapy to oral montelukast in the treatment of mild persistent asthma in children", Complement Ther Med, 29, pp.219~228 (2016)
- Houssen ME, "Natural anti-inflammatory products and leukotriene inhibitors as complementary therapy for bronchial asthma", Clin Biochem, 43(10-11), pp.887~890 (2010)
- Salem AM, "Effect of Nigella sativa supplementation on lung function and inflammatory mediatorsin partly controlled asthma : a randomized controlled trial", Ann Saudi Med, 37(1), pp.64~71 (2017)
- Urata Y, "Treatment of asthma patients with herbal medicine TJ-96 : a randomized controlled trial", Respir Med, 96(6), pp.469~474 (2002)
- Nejatbakhsh F, "Squill Oxymel, a traditional formulation from Drimia Maritima(L. )Stearn, as an add-on treatment in patients with moderate to severe persistent asthma : a pilot, triple-blind, randomized clinical trial", J Ethnopharmacol, 196, pp.186~192 (2017)
- Fleming PS, "Blinded by PRISMA: are systematic reviewers focusing on PRISMA and ignoring other guidelines?", PLoS One, 9(5), pp.e96407~ (2014)
- Lin J, "Chinese expert consensus on diagnosis and management of severe asthma", J Thorac Dis, 10(12), pp.7020~7044 (2018)
- Changizi Ashtiyani S, "A critical review of the works of pioneer physicians on kidney diseases in ancient Iran : Avicenna, Rhazes, Al-akhawayni, and Jorjani", Iran J Kidney Dis, 5(5), pp.300~308 (2011)
- Cumpston M, "Updated guidance for trusted systematic reviews : a new edition of the Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions", Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 10, pp.ED000142~ (2019)
- Marín-Martínez F, "Weighting by inverse variance or by sample size in random-effects meta-analysis", Educ Psychol Meas, 70(1), pp.56~73 (2010)
- Huedo-Medina TB, "Assessing heterogeneity in meta-analysis : Q statistic or I2 index?", Psychol Methods, 11(2), pp.193~206 (2006)
- Somes GW, "The generalized Mantel-Haenszel statistic", Am Stat, 40(2), pp.106~108 (1986)
- Simmonds M, "Quantifying the risk of error when interpreting funnel plots", Syst Rev, 4, pp.24~ (2015)
- Sterne JAC, "Publication bias in meta‐analysis: prevention, assessment and adjustments", pp.99~110 (2005), John Wiley &Sons
- Gjerdevik M, "Improving the error rates of the Begg and Mazumdar test for publication bias in fixed effects metaanalysis", BMC Med Res Methodol, 14, pp.109~ (2014)
- Hosseini SA, "An evaluation of the effect of saffron supplementation on the antibody titer to heat-shock protein(HSP)70, hsCRP and spirometry test in patients with mild and moderate persistent allergic asthma : a triple-blind, randomized placebo-controlled trial", Respir Med, 145, pp.28~34 (2018)
- Wang X, "Traditional Chinese medicine as an adjunctive therapy to oral montelukast for treating patients with chronic asthma", Medicine (Baltimore), 96(51), pp.e9291~ (2017)
- Chan PH, "A randomized placebo-controlled trial of traditional Chinese medicine as an add-on therapy to oral montelukast in the treatment of mild persistent asthma in children", Complement Ther Med, 29, pp.219~228 (2016)
- Wong EL, "Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of herbal therapy for children with asthma", J Altern Complement Med, 15(10), pp.1091~1097 (2009)
- Hsu CH, "Efficacy and safety of modified Mai-Men-Dong-Tang for treatment of allergic asthma", Pediatr Allergy Immunol, 16(1), pp.76~81 (2005)
- Wen MC, "Efficacy and tolerability of anti-asthma herbal medicine intervention in adult patients with moderate-severe allergic asthma", J Allergy Clin Immunol, 116(3), pp.517~524 (2005)
- Chang TT, "Clinical evaluation of the Chinese herbal medicine formula STA-1 in the treatment of allergic asthma", Phytother Res, 20(5), pp.342~347 (2006)
- Murali PM, "Plant-based formulation for bronchial asthma : a controlled clinical trial to compare its efficacy with oral salbutamol and theophylline", Respiration, 73(4), pp.457~463 (2006)
- "Pak J Nutr", 2006, 373~376
- Boskabady MH, "Bronchodilatory effect of Carum copticum in airways of asthmatic patients", Therapie, 62(1), pp.23~29 (2007)
- Hoang BX, "New approach in asthma treatment using excitatory modulator", Phytother Res, 21(6), pp.554~557 (2007)
- Thomas M, "AKL1, a botanical mixture for the treatment of asthma : a randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled, cross-over study", BMC Pulm Med, 7, pp.4~ (2007)
- Watson RR, "Oral administration of the purple passion fruit peel extract reduces wheeze and cough and improves shortness of breath in adults with asthma", Nutr Res, 28(3), pp.166~171 (2008)
- Kelly-Pieper K, "Safety and tolerability of an antiasthma herbal Formula(ASHMI)in adult subjects with asthma : a randomized, doubleblinded, placebo-controlled, dose-escalation phase I study", J Altern Complement Med, 15(7), pp.735~743 (2009)
- 박찬선, "Effects of Add-On Therapy with NDC-052, an Extract from Magnoliae Flos, in Adult Asthmatic Patients Receiving Inhaled Corticosteroids", The Korean Journal of Internal Medicine, 27(1), pp.84~90 (2012), 대한내과학회
- Smith LJ, "Effect of a soy isoflavone supplement on lung function and clinical outcomes in patients with poorly controlled asthma: a randomized clinical trial", JAMA, 313, pp.2033~2043 (2015)
- Kong L, "The antiinflammatory effects of invigorating kidney and supplementing Qi Chinese herbal formulae in asthma patients", Evid Based Complement Alternat Med, 2017, pp.3754145~ (2017)
- Koshak A, "Medicinal benefits of Nigella sativa in bronchial asthma : a literature review", Saudi Pharm J, 25(8), pp.1130~1136 (2017)
- Power S, "RCT of the effect of berryfruit polyphenolic cultivar extract in mild steroid-naive asthma : a cross-over, placebocontrolled study", BMJ Open, 7(3), pp.e013850~ (2017)
- Yugandhar P, "A novel herbal composition containing extracts of Boswellia serrata gum resin and Aegle marmelos fruit alleviates symptoms of asthma in a placebo controlled double-blind clinical study", Phytother Res, 32(1), pp.140~150 (2018)
- Manarin G, "Curcuma longa L. ameliorates asthma control in children and adolescents : a randomized, double-blind, controlled trial", J Ethnopharmacol, 238, pp.111882~ (2019)
- Qasemzadeh MJ, "The effect of Viola odorata flower syrup on the cough of children with asthma : a double-blind, randomized controlled trial", J Evid Based Complementary Altern Med, 20(4), pp.287~291 (2015)
- Silva BM, "Phenolic profile of quince fruit(Cydonia oblonga Miller)(pulp and peel)", J Agric Food Chem, 50(16), pp.4615~4618 (2002)
- Huang WY, "Survey of antioxidant capacity and phenolic composition of blueberry, blackberry, and strawberry in Nanjing", J Zhejiang Univ Sci B, 13(2), pp.94~102 (2012)
- Smruthi R, "The active compounds of Passiflora spp and their potential medicinal uses from both in vitro and in vivo evidences", J Adv Biomed Pharm Sci, 4(1), pp.45~55 (2021)
- Dong Y, "Determination of alkaloids and flavonoids in Sophora flavescens by UHPLC-QTOF", MS, 2021, pp.2021, 9915027~
- Liu H, "Chemical constituents of Panax ginseng and Panax notoginseng explain why they differ in therapeutic efficacy", Pharmacol Res, 161, pp.105263~ (2020)
- Ghahari S, "Chemical composition, antioxidant and biological activities of the essential oil and extract of the seeds of Glycine max(Soybean)from North Iran", Curr Microbiol, 74(4), pp.522~531 (2017)
- Sharma V, "Sweeteners: Pharmacology, Biotechnology, and Applications", pp.87~100 (2018), Springer
- Topcagic A, "Evaluation of phenolic profile, enzyme inhibitory and antimicrobial activities of Nigella sativa L. seed extracts", Bosn J Basic Med Sci, 17(4), pp.286~294 (2017)
- Mittal P, "Phytochemical and pharmacological potential of Viola odorata", Int J Pharm, 2(5), pp.215~220 (2015)
- Ude C, "Ginkgo biloba extracts : a review of the pharmacokinetics of the active ingredients", Clin Pharmacokinet, 52(9), pp.727~749 (2013)
- Huang HC, "Sowing the seeds of health : is the era of food prescriptions coming?", J Chin Med Assoc, 77(6), pp.273~274 (2014)
- Chen L, "Effect of loaded glycyrrhizic acid on PLGA nano-particle on treatment of allergic asthma", Iran J Allergy Asthma Immunol, 21(1), pp.65~72 (2022)
- Derakhshan AR, "Natural treatments for fissure in Ano used by traditional Persian scholars, Razi(Rhazes)and Ibn Sina(Avicenna)", J Evid Based Complementary Altern Med, 22(2), pp.324~333 (2017)
- Ghasemzadeh A, "Antioxidant activities, total phenolics and flavonoids content in two varieties of Malaysia young ginger(Zingiber officinale Roscoe)", Molecules, 15(6), pp.4324~4333 (2010)
