Comparison of Effectiveness of Manual Therapy for Infant Crying: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials
2
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Objectives: The aim of this systematic review and meta-analysis is to assess and compare the effectiveness of manual therapy in alleviating infant crying, a common symptom of nocturnal crying (NC) and infantile colic (IC). Methods: Total effective rate, crying time and adverse events were used as outcome indicators. To assess the quality, the risk of bias was determined for each study by two authors, using the Cochrane Collaboration’s risk of bias tool. RevMan 5.0 was used for data analysis. A total of 98 articles were identified from 6 electronic databases. Results: Among them, twenty-seven studies which included 13 NC and 14 IC were included. Meta-analysis showed favorable effects tuina therapy on total effective rate (TER) of NC (RR: 1.20 [95% CI 1.05 to 1.37], p = 0.007), chiropractic therapy on crying time change of IC (SMD: –0.83 [95% CI –1.61 to –0.06], p = 0.04) and massage on total crying time of IC (SMD: –0.86 [95% CI –1.09 to –0.63], p < 0.00001). This systematic review compares different manual therapies for the treatment of NC and IC. While tuina, chiropractic, and massage show results in alleviating symptoms, the overall evidence remains limited due to the low quality and heterogeneity of the included studies. Conclusion: Therefore, further high-quality research with unified control groups is needed to establish manual therapy as a recommended treatment option for NC and IC. Protocol registration number is CRD42022348143 01/08/2022.
Abstract
Objectives: The aim of this systematic review and meta-analysis is to assess and compare the effectiveness of manual therapy in alleviating infant crying, a common symptom of nocturnal crying (NC) and infantile colic (IC). Methods: Total effective rate, crying time and adverse events were used as outcome indicators. To assess the quality, the risk of bias was determined for each study by two authors, using the Cochrane Collaboration’s risk of bias tool. RevMan 5.0 was used for data analysis. A total of 98 articles were identified from 6 electronic databases. Results: Among them, twenty-seven studies which included 13 NC and 14 IC were included. Meta-analysis showed favorable effects tuina therapy on total effective rate (TER) of NC (RR: 1.20 [95% CI 1.05 to 1.37], p = 0.007), chiropractic therapy on crying time change of IC (SMD: –0.83 [95% CI –1.61 to –0.06], p = 0.04) and massage on total crying time of IC (SMD: –0.86 [95% CI –1.09 to –0.63], p < 0.00001). This systematic review compares different manual therapies for the treatment of NC and IC. While tuina, chiropractic, and massage show results in alleviating symptoms, the overall evidence remains limited due to the low quality and heterogeneity of the included studies. Conclusion: Therefore, further high-quality research with unified control groups is needed to establish manual therapy as a recommended treatment option for NC and IC. Protocol registration number is CRD42022348143 01/08/2022.
참고문헌 (50)
- Barr RG, "The"colic"enigma : prolonged episodes of a normal predisposition to cry", Infant Ment Health J, 11(4), pp.340~348 (1990)
- Evanoo G, "Infant crying : a clinical conundrum", J Pediatr Health Care, 21(5), pp.333~338 (2007)
- Ahn HS, "Hong Chang Eui pediatrics", pp.1416~ (2012), Mirae N
- 황만석, "소아 야제에 대한 추나요법 효과; 체계적 문헌고찰", 한방재활의학과학회지, 25(3), pp.51~57 (2015), 한방재활의학과학회
- James-Roberts IS, "Helping parents to manage infant crying and sleeping: a review of the evidence and its implications for services", Child Abus Rev, 16(1), pp.47~69 (2007)
- Reijneveld SA, "Excessive infant crying : the impact of varying definitions", Pediatrics, 108(4), pp.893~897 (2001)
- Zeevenhooven J, "Infant colic : mechanisms and management", Nat Rev Gastroenterol Hepatol, 15(8), pp.479~496 (2018)
- "The ICD-10 classification of symptoms, signs and abnormal clinical and laboratory findings, not elsewhere classified, tenth revision (ICD-10)" (2019)[URL]
- Sung V, "Infantile colic", Aust Prescr, 41(4), pp.105~110 (2018)
- Wessel MA, "Paroxysmal fussing in infancy, sometimes called colic", Pediatrics, 14(5), pp.421~435 (1954)
- Hannula L, "A pilot study of parents’ experiences of reflexology treatment for infants with colic in Finland", Scand J Caring Sci, 34(4), pp.861~870 (2020)
- Kheir AE, "Infantile colic, facts and fiction", Ital J Pediatr, 40(1), pp.9~ (2014)
- Kim YH, "The clinical study of a children’s night crying disease", J Korean Orient Pediatr, 13(1), pp.239~252 (1999)
- Kaley F, "The psychology of infant colic : a review of current research", Infant Ment Health J, 32(5), pp.526~541 (2011)
- Ouald Chaib A, "The influence of the gastrointestinal microbiome on infant colic", Expert Rev Gastroenterol Hepatol, 14(10), pp.919~932 (2020)
- Rhoads JM, "Infant colic represents gut inflammation and dysbiosis", J Pediatr, 203, pp.55~61 (2018)
- Carnes D, "Manual therapy for unsettled, distressed and excessively crying infants : a systematic review and meta-analyses", BMJ Open, 8(1), pp.e019040~ (2018)
- 박태용, "An introduction to Chuna manual medicine in Korea: History, insurance coverage, education, and clinical research in Korean literature", Integrative Medicine Research, 3(2), pp.49~59 (2014), 한국한의학연구원[DOI]
- 김상민, "야제 (夜啼)의 한의학 치료에 대한 최신 중의학 임상 연구 동향-2000년대 이후 발표된 임상 연구 논문을 중심으로-", 대한한방소아과학회지, 32(3), pp.100~118 (2018), 대한한방소아과학회[DOI]
- Dobson D, "Manipulative therapies for infantile colic", Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 12, pp.CD004796~ (2012)
- Jiao C, "Clinical observation of massage and patching therapy on Yongquan point on treating morbid night crying of babies with hyperactivity of heart-fire", J Liaoning Coll Tradit Chin Med, 18(12), pp.184~187 (2016)
- Wang L, "Treatment of 35 cases of scary night crying in children with massage and Chinese medicine", Shandong J Tradit Chin Med, 12, pp.934~935 (2015)
- Cai K, "Clinical observation on treatment of children’s night crying with traditional Chinese medicine massage and calcium", J Clin Med Lit, 75, pp.14683~14684 (2017)
- Li Y, "Observation on therapeutic effect of three-character transgenic massage on children with cardiac hyperthermia at night", China’s Naturop, 3, pp.16~17 (2017)
- Cheng C, "Clinical observation on Zhenjing powder umbilical therapy combined with three characters Tuina in treating infantile night crying", Chin Medi Mod Distance Educ China, 24, pp.106~107 (2018)
- Mai J, "Effect of massage combined with traditional Chinese medicine granule on the treatment of 200 children with fright night cry", China Med Pharm, 13, pp.89~91 (2018)
- Hwang C, "Treatment of 29 cases of night crying in children with panic and traumatic type by Taiji massage", J Extern Ther Tradit Chin Med, 6, pp.58~60 (2019)
- Chen R, "Observation on the effect of massage combined with auricular acupressure on nocturnal crowing in children with developmental retardation", Contemp Med Symp, 17(2), pp.174~175 (2019)
- Wang Z, "Observation on the curative effect of children massage combined with moxibustion at Shenque point on night cry with cold air stagnation of spleen", pp.2020
- Fan X, "Tuina therapy based on data mining clinical study of night terror (cold spleen and qi stagnation type)", pp.2021
- Fu Q, "Clinical study of infantile massage therapy combined with modified Wuyao Powder plus Yunqi Powder for nocturnal crying of stagnation of spleen cold Qi", Hebei J Tradit Chin Med, 43(7), pp.1115~1118 (2021)
- Li J, "Clinical observation on the treatment of children’s night crying with three-character transgenic massage and Qingxin Daochi granule", J Pract Tradit Chin Med, 37(4), pp.564~565 (2021)
- Huang C, "Clinical effect of applying five-meridian acupoints massage(Qingxin-Qinggan Meridians)combined with chiropractic therapy in the treatment of children with night terrors and crying", J Sichuan Tradit Chin Med, 40(5), pp.185~188 (2022)
- Wiberg JM, "The short-term effect of spinal manipulation in the treatment of infantile colic : a randomized controlled clinical trial with a blinded observer", J Manipulative Physiol Ther, 22(8), pp.517~522 (1999)
- Huhtala V, "Infant massage compared with crib vibrator in the treatment of colicky infants", Pediatrics, 105(6), pp.E84~ (2000)
- Olafsdottir E, "Randomised controlled trial of infantile colic treated with chiropractic spinal manipulation", Arch Dis Child, 84(2), pp.138~141 (2001)
- Hayden C, "A preliminary assessment of the impact of cranial osteopathy for the relief of infantile colic", Complement Ther Clin Pract, 12(2), pp.83~90 (2006)
- Arikan D, "Effectiveness of massage, sucrose solution, herbal tea or hydrolysed formula in the treatment of infantile colic", J Clin Nurs, 17(13), pp.1754~1761 (2008)
- Miller JE, "Efficacy of chiropractic manual therapy on infant colic : a pragmatic single-blind, randomized controlled trial", J Manipulative Physiol Ther, 35(8), pp.600~607 (2012)
- Sheidaei A, "The effectiveness of massage therapy in the treatment of infantile colic symptoms : a randomized controlled trial", Med J Islam Repub Iran, 30, pp.351~ (2016)
- Nahidi F, "the comparison of the effects of massaging and rocking on infantile colic", Iran J Nurs Midwifery Res, 22(1), pp.67~71 (2017)
- Icke S, "Effect of reflexology on infantile colic", J Altern Complement Med, 24(6), pp.584~588 (2018)
- Mansouri S, "A placebo-controlled clinical trial to evaluate the effectiveness of massaging on infantile colic using a random-effects joint model", Pediatric Health Med Ther, 9, pp.157~163 (2018)
- Castejón-Castejón M, "Effectiveness of craniosacral therapy in the treatment of infantile colic. A randomized controlled trial", Complement Ther Med, 47, pp.102164~ (2019)
- Holm LV, "The effect of chiropractic care on infantile colic : results from a single-blind randomised controlled trial", Chiropr Man Therap, 29(1), pp.15~ (2021)
- Karatas N, "Is foot reflexology effective in reducing colic symptoms in infants : a randomized placebo-controlled trial", Complement Ther Med, 59, pp.102732~ (2021)
- Moghaddam K, "Comparison of the effect of abdominal massage and Hugo point acupressure on infantile colic symptoms", Evid Based Care J, 11(4), pp.40~47 (2022)
- Lee D, "Acupuncture for infantile colic : a systematic review of randomised controlled trials", Evid Based Complement Alternat Med, 2018, pp.7526234~ (2018)
- Leaver AM, "A randomized controlled trial comparing manipulation with mobilization for recent onset neck pain", Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 91(9), pp.1313~1318 (2010)
- Irnich D, "Myofascial trigger points:comprehensive diagnosis and treatment", pp.2013, Churchill Livingstone
