Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Efficacy and Safety of Fire Needling and Warm Needling on Acute Gout
1
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Objectives: This study aimed to evaluate the efficacy and safety of heat stimuli (e.g., fire needling, warm needling) in acupuncture for acute gout. Methods: Four international online databases (PubMed, Cochrane, Embase, and Chinese National Knowledge Infrastructure) were searched to identify randomized, controlled trials (RCTs) that used fire needling and warm needling for acute gout. The methodological quality of the RCTs was evaluated using the Cochrane risk-of-bias (RoB) tool. Thirteen RCTs (840 patients) were included and analyzed. Three evaluation tools (total effective rate, uric acid level, and pain score) were mainly used. Comparisons were made between Western medicine (WM) and i) fire needling or warm needling treatment alone, ii) fire needling and bloodletting combination treatment, iii) combination of fire needling, bloodletting, and herbal medicine, iv) warm needling (concurrently). Heat stimuli in acupuncture alone or in combination treatment were more effective in terms of the total efficacy rates, uric acid levels, and pain scores than WM alone. Results: In all the evaluation tools, the treatment effects in the fire needling alone or warm needling alone treatment group and the fire needling and bloodletting combination intervention group were significantly better than those in the WM control group. The warm needling and WM combination intervention groups also experienced significantly better treatment effects in terms of total efficacy rates and uric acid levels. Only the pain scores in the fire needling, bloodletting, and herbal medicine combination groups demonstrated significant improvement. Only four studies mentioned adverse reactions: one reported loss of appetite; three studies reported none. According to the Cochrane RoB tool, most studies showed either high or uncertain RoB. Conclusion: Heat stimuli during acupuncture could be effective for acute gout. However, as the included studies were regionally biased, more high-quality studies are needed to confirm the level of evidence.
Abstract
Objectives: This study aimed to evaluate the efficacy and safety of heat stimuli (e.g., fire needling, warm needling) in acupuncture for acute gout. Methods: Four international online databases (PubMed, Cochrane, Embase, and Chinese National Knowledge Infrastructure) were searched to identify randomized, controlled trials (RCTs) that used fire needling and warm needling for acute gout. The methodological quality of the RCTs was evaluated using the Cochrane risk-of-bias (RoB) tool. Thirteen RCTs (840 patients) were included and analyzed. Three evaluation tools (total effective rate, uric acid level, and pain score) were mainly used. Comparisons were made between Western medicine (WM) and i) fire needling or warm needling treatment alone, ii) fire needling and bloodletting combination treatment, iii) combination of fire needling, bloodletting, and herbal medicine, iv) warm needling (concurrently). Heat stimuli in acupuncture alone or in combination treatment were more effective in terms of the total efficacy rates, uric acid levels, and pain scores than WM alone. Results: In all the evaluation tools, the treatment effects in the fire needling alone or warm needling alone treatment group and the fire needling and bloodletting combination intervention group were significantly better than those in the WM control group. The warm needling and WM combination intervention groups also experienced significantly better treatment effects in terms of total efficacy rates and uric acid levels. Only the pain scores in the fire needling, bloodletting, and herbal medicine combination groups demonstrated significant improvement. Only four studies mentioned adverse reactions: one reported loss of appetite; three studies reported none. According to the Cochrane RoB tool, most studies showed either high or uncertain RoB. Conclusion: Heat stimuli during acupuncture could be effective for acute gout. However, as the included studies were regionally biased, more high-quality studies are needed to confirm the level of evidence.
참고문헌 (48)
- Roddy E, "Epidemiology of gout", Arthritis Res Ther, 12(6), pp.223~ (2010)
- Wu EQ, "Comorbidity burden, healthcare resource utilization, and costs in chronic gout patients refractory to conventional urate-lowering therapy", Am J Ther, 19(6), pp.e157~e166 (2012)
- Chai W, "Electroacupuncture alleviates pain responses and inflammation in a rat model of acute gout arthritis", Evid Based Complement Alternat Med, 2018, pp.2598975~ (2018)
- Dalbeth N, "Mechanisms of inflammation in gout", Rheumatology (Oxford), 44(9), pp.1090~1096 (2005)
- 송정수, "통풍관리의 최신지견", 대한의사협회지, 59(5), pp.379~384 (2016), 대한의사협회[DOI]
- 송정수, "한국인 맞춤형 통풍 치료 지침", 대한류마티스학회지, 20(5), pp.280~285 (2013), 대한류마티스학회
- Jayaprakash V, "Colchicine overdose : the devil is in the detail", N Z Med J, 120(1248), pp.U2402~ (2007)
- Zhao ZQ, "Neural mechanism underlying acupuncture analgesia", Prog Neurobiol, 85(4), pp.355~375 (2008)
- Hui KK, "The integrated response of the human cerebro-cerebellar and limbic systems to acupuncture stimulation at ST 36 as evidenced by fMRI", Neuroimage, 27(3), pp.479~496 (2005)
- Feng Y, "Electroacupuncture promotes insulin-like growth factors system in ovariectomized osteoporosis rats", Am J Chin Med, 36(5), pp.889~897 (2008)
- Korean Acupuncture & Moxibustion Medicine Society, "Acupuncture medicine" (2020), Hanmi Medical Publishing Co
- Ko KM, "A clinical study on the case of medial collateral ligament injury treated with burning acupuncture therapy", J East West Med, 34(1), pp.25~32 (2009)
- Lim GM, "Three cases of postpartum low back pain patients treated by heating-conduction acupuncture therapy", J Korea CHUNA Man Med Spine Nerves, 7(1), pp.49~57 (2012)
- Han SH, "A case report on burning acupuncture treatments for stable compression fracture", J Korea CHUNA Man Med, 3(1), pp.167~174 (2002)
- Kim HS, "Case reports : the effect of burning acupuncture therapy on the sacroiliac joint syndrome", Res Inst Korean Med Taejon Univ, 16(1), pp.133~138 (2007)
- 장동호, "요통에 대한 추나요법과 가열식 화침 병행 치료의 효과", 한방재활의학과학회지, 21(3), pp.21~32 (2011), 한방재활의학과학회
- 정세호, "요추 추간판 탈출증 환자에 대하여 기타 한방치료를 병행한 가열식 화침과 일반침의 효능 비교 연구: 무작위배정, 평가자 맹검, 평행군 설계", Journal of Acupuncture Research, 32(4), pp.29~36 (2015), 대한침구의학회
- Kim DH, "A clinical study of burning acupuncture therapy on SI11 in post-stroke patient with shoulder pain", J Orient Spinal Arthrosc, 7(1), pp.1~7 (2010)
- Yeon CH, "The two cases report of bee venom injection on patient with low back pain maintaining after heating-conduction acupuncture therapy", J Korea CHUNA Man Med Spine Nerves, 7(2), pp.75~81 (2012)
- Oh SG, "Stimulation therapy", pp.688~ (2011), Koonja Publisher
- Li YJ, "Warm acupuncture treatment of 40 cases of wind cold dampness arthralgia", Shandong J Tradit Chin Med, 14, pp.264~ (1995)
- Yang YL, "To observe the clinical curative effect of warm acupuncture and moxibustion in the treatment of chronic pelvic inflammation", pp.2011
- 김백곤, "만성 근 골격계 통증에서의 프로로테라피의 효과", Annals of Rehabilitation Medicine, 25(1), pp.128~133 (2001), 대한재활의학회
- 고홍제, "Systematic Review of Fire Needling or Warm Needling Treatment for Ankle Sprain", Journal of Acupuncture Research, 37(1), pp.19~27 (2020), 대한침구의학회
- 정지윤, "근골격계 통증성 질환에 대한 온침의 임상 연구 고찰 -계통적 고찰-", Journal of Acupuncture Research, 26(4), pp.11~18 (2009), 대한침구의학회
- Wang R, "Introduction to warm needling acupuncture therapy", Chin Acupunct Moxib, 26(1), pp.36~38 (2006)
- Sun J, "Efficacy and safety of fire-needle in the treatment of gouty arthritis: a protocol for systematic review and meta analysis", Medicine (Baltimore), 99(30), pp.e21259~ (2020)
- Kim SW, "Analysis on the research situations on gout in oriental medicines", J East West Med, 37(4), pp.21~29 (2012)
- Kim SW, "Analysis on the gout-related experiment literatures in Korean medicine", J East West Med, 40(4), pp.15~27 (2015)
- 황지혜, "통풍의 한의임상진료현황 - 온라인(웹기반) 설문조사", Korean Journal of Acupuncture, 38(1), pp.16~31 (2021), 경락경혈학회[DOI]
- 황지혜, "급성 통풍에 적용한 침전기자극술에 대한 체계적 문헌 고찰 및 메타 분석", 대한한의학회지, 43(2), pp.92~109 (2022), 대한한의학회
- Kim S, "NECA’s guidance for undertaking systematic reviews and meta-analyses for intervention" (2011), National Evidence-Based Healthcare Collaborating Agency
- Wu JH, "Observation on the clinical effect of modified fire acupuncture in the treatment of acute gouty arthritis", Smart Healthc, 6(17), pp.103~104 (2020)
- Xie LQ, "The clinical effect of fire needle with"fire stagnation requiring dissipation"treating acute gouty arthritis", China Mod Med, 25(16), pp.190~193 (2018)
- Zong JJ, "40 cases of acute gouty arthritis treated by warming needle moxibustion", J Sichuan Tradit Chin Med, 29(3), pp.115~117 (2011)
- Zuo HF, "Fifty cases with acute gouty arthritis treated by needle warming moxibustion", Henan Tradit Chin Med, 36(10), pp.1826~1828 (2016)
- Ding DL, "Observation on the effect of fire needle pricking collaterals and bloodletting in the treatment of acute gouty arthritis", World Latest Med Inf, 17(78), pp.135~144 (2017)
- Hu FC, "Clinical observation of pricking blood with pyronysis therapy on acute gout", J Tradit Chin Orthop Traumatol, 19(1), pp.9~10 (2007)[DOI]
- Kuang QH, "Clinical observation of modified fire acupuncture in the treatment of acute gouty arthritis", J Emerg Tradit Chin Med, 19(3), pp.414~416 (2010)[DOI]
- Lei XW, "Observation on the effect of fire needle pricking and bloodletting in the treatment of 68 patients with acute gout", Chin Prim Health Care, 29(8), pp.123~124 (2015)[DOI]
- Zhang ZM, "Clinical observation on the treatment of acute gouty arthritis by fire acupuncture and bloodletting", J New Chin Med, 44(10), pp.87~89 (2012)[DOI]
- Wang F, "Curative analysis of using Xuanbi decoction addition and subtraction combined with needle pricking blood therapy to treat acute gouty arthritis", J Sichuan Tradit Chin Med, 32(12), pp.119~120 (2014)
- Xie HY, "Clinical efficacy of Baihu Guizhi decoction plus fire needle pricking and bloodletting therapy in acute gouty arthritis", J Guangdong Med Univ, 37(5), pp.561~563 (2019)
- Yang XY, "Clinical observation on 30 cases of Gout Treated by fire needle pricking collaterals and bloodletting combined with oral honeysuckle vine Decoction", Pract Clin J Integr Tradit Chin West Med, 16(1), pp.22~24 (2016)[DOI]
- Zhao J, "Randomized parallel controlled study of warm acupuncture and moxibustion combined with western medicine in the treatment of acute gouty arthritis", J Pract Tradit Chin Intern Med, 33(5), pp.56~67 (2019)[DOI]
- Lee WB, "Acupuncture for gouty arthritis : a concise report of a systematic and meta-analysis approach", Rheumatology (Oxford), 52(7), pp.1225~1232 (2013)
- Lu WW, "Update on the clinical effect of acupuncture therapy in patients with gouty arthritis : systematic review and meta-analysis", Evid Based Complement Alternat Med, 2016, pp.9451670~ (2016)
- Ryu DH, "The assessment of risk of bias on clinical trials of Korean medicine for alopecia", J Haehwa Med, 24(1), pp.25~36 (2015)