본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Effect of needle type on intravascular injection in transforaminal epidural injection: a meta-analysis

Chulmin Park|Jae Hun Kim|Jae Yun Kim|Soo Nyoung Kim|Ho Young Lim
대한통증학회 (The Korean Pain Society)|2019.01|The Korean Journal of Pain|제32권 제1호|pp. 39-46|DOI 10.3344/kjp.2019.32.1.39

2

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

.Meta-analysisHumanComplicationNeedleInjectionEpidural anesthesiaSpinal diseasesEpidural injectionTransforaminal injection.

초록

Background: Lumbosacral transforaminal epidural injection (TFEI) is an effective treatment for spinal disease. However, TFEI may have several types of complications, some of which can be attributed to intravascular injection. We reviewed studies to compare the intravascular injection rate among different needle types. Methods: We searched the literature for articles on the intravascular injection rate among different needle types used in TFEI. The search was performed using PubMed, MEDLINE, the Cochrane Library, EMBASE, and Web of Science. Results: A total of six studies comprising 2359 patients were identified. Compared with the Quincke needle, the Whitacre needle reduced the intravascular injection rate (OR = 0.57, 95% CI = [0.44–0.73], P ＜ 0.001). However, compared with the Quincke needle, the Chiba needle did not reduce the intravascular injection rate (OR = 0.80, 95% CI = [0.44–1.45], P = 0.46). In one study, the intravascular injection rate using a blunt-tip needle was lower than that using a sharp needle. In another study, the Whitacre and the blunt-tip needle have similar intravascular injection rates, while, the catheter-extension needle showed a reduced intravascular injection rate. Conclusions: This meta-analysis showed that the Whitacre needle reduced the intravascular injection rate as compared with the Quincke needle, but failed to establish that the Chiba needle can decrease the intravascular injection rate in TFEI. Moreover, the blunt-tip needle can reduce the intravascular injection rate compared with the Quincke needle, and the catheter-extension needle can reduce the intravascular injection rate compared with the Whitacre and the blunt-tip needle.

Abstract

Background: Lumbosacral transforaminal epidural injection (TFEI) is an effective treatment for spinal disease. However, TFEI may have several types of complications, some of which can be attributed to intravascular injection. We reviewed studies to compare the intravascular injection rate among different needle types. Methods: We searched the literature for articles on the intravascular injection rate among different needle types used in TFEI. The search was performed using PubMed, MEDLINE, the Cochrane Library, EMBASE, and Web of Science. Results: A total of six studies comprising 2359 patients were identified. Compared with the Quincke needle, the Whitacre needle reduced the intravascular injection rate (OR = 0.57, 95% CI = [0.44–0.73], P ＜ 0.001). However, compared with the Quincke needle, the Chiba needle did not reduce the intravascular injection rate (OR = 0.80, 95% CI = [0.44–1.45], P = 0.46). In one study, the intravascular injection rate using a blunt-tip needle was lower than that using a sharp needle. In another study, the Whitacre and the blunt-tip needle have similar intravascular injection rates, while, the catheter-extension needle showed a reduced intravascular injection rate. Conclusions: This meta-analysis showed that the Whitacre needle reduced the intravascular injection rate as compared with the Quincke needle, but failed to establish that the Chiba needle can decrease the intravascular injection rate in TFEI. Moreover, the blunt-tip needle can reduce the intravascular injection rate compared with the Quincke needle, and the catheter-extension needle can reduce the intravascular injection rate compared with the Whitacre and the blunt-tip needle.

참고문헌 (45)

  1. Marshall LL, "Chemical radiculitis. A clinical, physiological and immunological study", Clin Orthop Relat Res, pp.61~67 (1977)
  2. Boswell MV, "Interventional techniques : evidence-based practice guidelines in the management of chronic spinal pain", Pain Physician, 10, pp.7~111 (2007)
  3. Buenaventura RM, "Systematic review of therapeutic lumbar transforaminal epidural steroid injections", Pain Physician, 12, pp.233~251 (2009)
  4. Davis N, "Transforaminal epidural steroid injection in lumbar spinal stenosis : an observational study with two-year follow-up", Br J Neurosurg, 31, pp.205~208 (2017)
  5. 홍지희, "Comparison of clinical efficacy in epidural steroid injections through transforaminal or parasagittal approaches", The Korean Journal of Pain, 30(3), pp.220~228 (2017), 대한통증학회
  6. Laxmaiah Manchikanti, "Comparison of the Efficacy of Caudal, Interlaminar, and Transforaminal Epidural Injections in Managing Lumbar Disc Herniation: Is One Method Superior to the Other?", The Korean Journal of Pain, 28(1), pp.11~21 (2015), 대한통증학회
  7. Ruchi Gupta, "Correlation between Epidurographic Contrast Flow Patterns and Clinical Effectiveness in Chronic Lumbar Discogenic Radicular Pain Treated with Epidural Steroid Injections Via Different Approaches", The Korean Journal of Pain, 27(4), pp.353~359 (2014), 대한통증학회
  8. Eckel TS, "Epidural steroid injections and selective nerve root blocks", Tech Vasc Interv Radiol, 12, pp.11~21 (2009)
  9. Cohen SP, "Epidural steroids : a comprehensive, evidence-based review", Reg Anesth Pain Med, 38, pp.175~200 (2013)
  10. Quraishi NA, "Transforaminal injection of corticosteroids for lumbar radiculopathy : systematic review and meta-analysis", Eur Spine J, 21, pp.214~219 (2012)
  11. Lee JH, "Comparison of clinical efficacy between transforaminal and interlaminar epidural injections in lumbosacral disc herniation:a systematic review and meta-analysis", Pain Physician, 21, pp.433~448 (2018)
  12. Alleyne CH Jr, "Microsurgical anatomy of the artery of Adamkiewicz and its segmental artery", J Neurosurg, 89, pp.791~795 (1998)
  13. Botwin KP, "Complications of fluoroscopically guided transforaminal lumbar epidural injections", Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 81, pp.1045~1050 (2000)
  14. Kennedy DJ, "Paraplegia following image-guided transforaminal lumbar spine epidural steroid injection : two case reports", Pain Med, 10, pp.1389~1394 (2009)
  15. Bogduk N, "Complications of spinal diagnostic and treatment procedures", Pain Med, 9, pp.S11~S34 (2008)
  16. McLain RF, "Transient paralysis associated with epidural steroid injection", J Spinal Disord, 10, pp.441~444 (1997)
  17. Reitman CA, "Subdural hematoma after cervical epidural steroid injection", Spine (Phila Pa 1976), 27, pp.E174~E176 (2002)
  18. Scanlon GC, "Cervical transforaminal epidural steroid injections: more dangerous than we think?", Spine (Phila Pa 1976), 32, pp.1249~1256 (2007)
  19. Murthy NS, "Intraforaminal location of the great anterior radiculomedullary artery(artery of Adamkiewicz) : a retrospective review", Pain Med, 11, pp.1756~1764 (2010)
  20. Özcan U, "Comparison of blunt and sharp needles for transforaminal epidural steroid injections", Agri, 24, pp.85~89 (2012)
  21. 홍지희, "Comparison of incidence of intravascular injections during transforaminal epidural steroid injection using different needle types", Korean Journal of Anesthesiology, 67(3), pp.193~197 (2014), 대한마취통증의학회
  22. Shin J, "A comparison of Quincke and Whitacre needles with respect to risk of intravascular uptake in S1 transforaminal epidural steroid injections: a randomized trial of 1376 cases", Anesth Analg, 117, pp.1241~1247 (2013)
  23. Smuck M, "Differential rates of inadvertent intravascular injection during lumbar transforaminal epidural injections using blunt-tip, pencil-point, and catheter-extension needles", Pain Med, 16, pp.2084~2089 (2015)
  24. Smuck M, "Influence of needle type on the incidence of intravascular injection during transforaminal epidural injections : a comparison of shortbevel and long-bevel needles", Spine J, 10, pp.367~371 (2010)
  25. Hong J, "Whitacre needle reduces the incidence of intravascular uptake in lumbar transforaminal epidural steroid injections", Pain Physician, 18, pp.325~331 (2015)
  26. Jadad AR, "Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials : is blinding necessary", Control Clin Trials, 17, pp.1~12 (1996)
  27. Liberati A, "The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions : explanation and elaboration", Ann Intern Med, 151, pp.W65~W94 (2009)
  28. Selander D, "Peripheral nerve injury due to injection needles used for regional anesthesia. An experimental study of the acute effects of needle point trauma", Acta Anaesthesiol Scand, 21, pp.182~188 (1977)
  29. Lavi R, "Standard vs atraumatic Whitacre needle for diagnostic lumbar puncture : a randomized trial", Neurology, 67, pp.1492~1494 (2006)
  30. Peterman SB, "Postmyelography headache rates with Whitacre versus Quincke 22-gauge spinal needles", Radiology, 200, pp.771~778 (1996)
  31. Akins EW, "The blunt needle : a new percutaneous access device", AJR Am J Roentgenol, 152, pp.181~182 (1989)
  32. Heavner JE, "Sharp versus blunt needle : a comparative study of penetration of internal structures and bleeding in dogs", Pain Pract, 3, pp.226~231 (2003)
  33. Kloth DS, "Improving the safety of transforaminal epidural steroid injections in the treatment of cervical radiculopathy", Pain Physician, 14, pp.285~293 (2011)
  34. Kim DW, "Intravascular flow patterns in transforaminal epidural injections : a comparative study of the cervical and lumbar vertebral segments", Anesth Analg, 109, pp.233~239 (2009)
  35. Furman MB, "Incidence of intravascular penetration in transforaminal lumbosacral epidural steroid injections", Spine (Phila Pa 1976), 25, pp.2628~2632 (2000)
  36. Furman MB, "Incidence of intravascular penetration in transforaminal cervical epidural steroid injections", Spine (Phila Pa 1976), 28, pp.21~25 (2003)
  37. El Abd OH, "Intravascular flow detection during transforaminal epidural injections : a prospective assessment", Pain Physician, 17, pp.21~27 (2014)
  38. Wolter T, "CT-guided cervical selective nerve root block with a dorsal approach", AJNR Am J Neuroradiol, 31, pp.1831~1836 (2010)
  39. Desai MJ, "Epidural contrast flow patterns of transforaminal epidural steroid injections stratified by commonly used final needle-tip position", Pain Med, 12, pp.864~870 (2011)
  40. Min Hye Lee, "Accuracy of Live Fluoroscopy to Detect Intravascular Injection During Lumbar Transforaminal Epidural Injections", The Korean Journal of Pain, 23(1), pp.18~23 (2010), 대한통증학회
  41. Sae Young Kim, "Detection Rate of Intravascular Injections during Cervical Medial Branch Blocks: A Comparison of Digital Subtraction Angiography and Static Images from Conventional Fluoroscopy", The Korean Journal of Pain, 28(2), pp.105~108 (2015), 대한통증학회
  42. Visnjevac O, "Digital subtraction angiography versus real-time fluoroscopy for detection of intravascular penetration prior to epidural steroid injections: meta-analysis of prospective studies", Pain Physician, 18, pp.29~36 (2015)
  43. Chang Chien GC, "Digital subtraction angiography does not reliably prevent paraplegia associated with lumbar transforaminal epidural steroid injection", Pain Physician, 15, pp.515~523 (2012)
  44. Jasper JF, "Role of digital subtraction fluoroscopic imaging in detecting intravascular injections", Pain Physician, 6, pp.369~372 (2003)
  45. Kim DH, "Incidence of intravascular injection and the spread of contrast media during S1transforaminal epidural steroid injection by two approaches:anteroposterior vs oblique", Anaesthesia, 70, pp.975~984 (2015)

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (9건)

The role and position of antipsychotics in managing chronic painYoung Hoon Kimpp. 1-2Antipsychotics for patients with painSu Jung Lee, 이진성, Kyung Hoon Kim, Salahadin Abdi, Sang Wook Shinpp. 3-11Animals models of spinal cord contusion injuryRenuka Verma, Amteshwar Singh Jaggi, Nirmal Singh, Jasleen Kaur Virdipp. 12-21Acceptance versus catastrophizing in predicting quality of life in patients with chronic low back painMagdalena S. Halim, Gracia Mayuni Semerupp. 22-29The analgesic efficacy of the continuous adductor canal block compared to continuous intravenous fentanyl infusion with a single-shot adductor canal block in total knee arthroplasty: a randomized controlled trialChoon Gun Ryu, Hwa Yong Shin, Hyun Kang, Min Kyoung Kim, Hyoung Yong Moon, Han Jun Leepp. 30-38
원문 보기