본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Development of the Korean Association for Lung Cancer Clinical Practice Guidelines: Recommendations on Radial Probe Endobronchial Ultrasound for Diagnosing Lung Cancer - An Updated Meta-Analysis

정현성|김진미|김미현|이민기|김인수|김수한|엄중섭
대한암학회 (Korean Cancer Association)|2024.04|Cancer Research and Treatment|제56권 제2호|pp. 464-483|DOI 10.4143/crt.2023.749

1

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

Meta-analysisPulmonary noduleLung neoplasmsBronchoscopyRadial probe endobronchial ultrasound
주제분류의학일반

초록

Purpose Radial probe endobronchial ultrasound (RP-EBUS) accurately locates peripheral lung lesions (PLLs) during transbronchial biopsy (TBB). We performed an updated meta-analysis of the diagnostic yield of TBB for PLLs using RP-EBUS to generate recommendations for the development of the Korean Association of Lung Cancer guidelines. Materials and Methods We systematically searched MEDLINE and EMBASE (from January 2013 to December 2022), and performed a meta-analysis using R software. The diagnostic yield was evaluated by dividing the number of successful diagnoses by the total lesion number. Subgroup analysis was performed to identify related factors. Results Forty-one studies with a total of 13,133 PLLs were included. The pooled diagnostic yield of RP-EBUS was 0.72 (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.70 to 0.75). Significant heterogeneity was observed among studies (χ2=292.38, p < 0.01, I2=86.4%). In a subgroup analysis, there was a significant difference in diagnostic yield based on RP-EBUS findings (within, adjacent to, invisible), with a risk ratio of 1.45 (95% CI, 1.23 to 1.72) between within and adjacent to, 4.20 (95% CI, 1.89 to 9.32) between within and invisible, and 2.59 (95% CI, 1.32 to 5.01) between adjacent to and invisible. There was a significant difference in diagnostic yield based on lesion size, histologic diagnosis, computed tomography (CT) bronchus sign, lesion character, and location from the hilum. The overall complication rate of TBB with RP-EBUS was 6.8% (bleeding, 4.5%; pneumothorax, 1.4%). Conclusion Our study showed that TBB with RP-EBUS is an accurate diagnostic tool for PLLs with good safety profiles, especially for PLLs with within orientation on RP-EBUS or positive CT bronchus sign.

Abstract

Purpose Radial probe endobronchial ultrasound (RP-EBUS) accurately locates peripheral lung lesions (PLLs) during transbronchial biopsy (TBB). We performed an updated meta-analysis of the diagnostic yield of TBB for PLLs using RP-EBUS to generate recommendations for the development of the Korean Association of Lung Cancer guidelines. Materials and Methods We systematically searched MEDLINE and EMBASE (from January 2013 to December 2022), and performed a meta-analysis using R software. The diagnostic yield was evaluated by dividing the number of successful diagnoses by the total lesion number. Subgroup analysis was performed to identify related factors. Results Forty-one studies with a total of 13,133 PLLs were included. The pooled diagnostic yield of RP-EBUS was 0.72 (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.70 to 0.75). Significant heterogeneity was observed among studies (χ2=292.38, p < 0.01, I2=86.4%). In a subgroup analysis, there was a significant difference in diagnostic yield based on RP-EBUS findings (within, adjacent to, invisible), with a risk ratio of 1.45 (95% CI, 1.23 to 1.72) between within and adjacent to, 4.20 (95% CI, 1.89 to 9.32) between within and invisible, and 2.59 (95% CI, 1.32 to 5.01) between adjacent to and invisible. There was a significant difference in diagnostic yield based on lesion size, histologic diagnosis, computed tomography (CT) bronchus sign, lesion character, and location from the hilum. The overall complication rate of TBB with RP-EBUS was 6.8% (bleeding, 4.5%; pneumothorax, 1.4%). Conclusion Our study showed that TBB with RP-EBUS is an accurate diagnostic tool for PLLs with good safety profiles, especially for PLLs with within orientation on RP-EBUS or positive CT bronchus sign.

참고문헌 (68)

  1. Gould MK, "Recent trends in the identification of incidental pulmonary nodules", Am J Respir Crit Care Med, 192, pp.1208~1214 (2015)
  2. National Lung Screening Trial Research Team, "Results of initial low-dose computed tomographic screening for lung cancer", N Engl J Med, 368, pp.1980~1991 (2013)
  3. Gould MK, "Evaluation of individuals with pulmonary nodules : when is it lung cancer? Diagnosis and management of lung cancer, 3rd ed : American College of Chest Physicians evidence-based clinical practice guidelines", Chest, 143, pp.e93S~e120S (2013)
  4. Kim SH, "Problems in the pathologic diagnosis of suspected lung cancer", Tuberc Respir Dis(Seoul), 86, pp.176~182 (2023)
  5. Herth FJ, "Endobronchial ultrasoundguided transbronchial lung biopsy in solitary pulmonary nodules and peripheral lesions", Eur Respir J, 20, pp.972~974 (2002)
  6. Kurimoto N, "Endobronchial ultrasonography using a guide sheath increases the ability to diagnose peripheral pulmonary lesions endoscopically", Chest, 126, pp.959~965 (2004)
  7. Wang Memoli JS, "Meta-analysis of guided bronchoscopy for the evaluation of the pulmonary nodule", Chest, 142, pp.385~393 (2012)
  8. Asano F, "A virtual bronchoscopic navigation system for pulmonary peripheral lesions", Chest, 130, pp.559~566 (2006)
  9. Eberhardt R, "Electromagnetic navigation diagnostic bronchoscopy in peripheral lung lesions", Chest, 131, pp.1800~1805 (2007)
  10. Oki M, "Diagnostic value of ultrathin bronchoscopy in peripheral pulmonary lesions : a narrative review", J Thorac Dis, 12, pp.7675~7682 (2020)
  11. McInnes MD, "Preferred reporting items for a systematic review and meta-analysis of diagnostic test accuracy studies : the PRISMA-DTA statement", JAMA, 319, pp.388~396 (2018)
  12. Baaklini WA, "Diagnostic yield of fiberoptic bronchoscopy in evaluating solitary pulmonary nodules", Chest, 117, pp.1049~1054 (2000)
  13. Whiting PF, "QUADAS-2 : a revised tool for the quality assessment of diagnostic accuracy studies", Ann Intern Med, 155, pp.529~536 (2011)
  14. Ali MS, "Computed tomography bronchus sign and the diagnostic yield of guided bronchoscopy for peripheral pulmonary lesions : a systematic review and meta-analysis", Ann Am Thorac Soc, 15, pp.978~987 (2018)
  15. Kim SH, "Ultrathin bronchoscopy for the diagnosis of peripheral pulmonary lesions : a meta-analysis", Respiration, 102, pp.34~45 (2023)
  16. Higgins JP, "Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses", BMJ, 327, pp.557~560 (2003)
  17. Dinnes J, "A methodological review of how heterogeneity has been examined in systematic reviews of diagnostic test accuracy", Health Technol Assess, 9, pp.1~113 (2005)
  18. Borenstein M, "A basic introduction to fixed-effect and random-effects models for meta-analysis", Res Synth Methods, 1, pp.97~111 (2010)
  19. Hunter JP, "In meta-analyses of proportion studies, funnel plots were found to be an inaccurate method of assessing publication bias", J Clin Epidemiol, 67, pp.897~903 (2014)
  20. Egger M, "Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test", BMJ, 315, pp.629~634 (1997)
  21. Begg CB, "Operating characteristics of a rank correlation test for publication bias", Biometrics, 50, pp.1088~1101 (1994)
  22. Oki M, "Use of an ultrathin vs thin bronchoscope for peripheral pulmonary lesions : a randomized trial", Chest, 156, pp.954~964 (2019)
  23. Fuso L, "Role of ultrasound-guided transbronchial biopsy in the diagnosis of peripheral pulmonary lesions", Lung Cancer, 81, pp.60~64 (2013)
  24. Tamiya M, "Diagnostic yield of combined bronchoscopy and endobronchial ultrasonography, under LungPoint guidance for small peripheral pulmonary lesions", Respirology, 18, pp.834~839 (2013)
  25. Tay JH, "Radial probe endobronchial ultrasound : factors influencing visualization yield of peripheral pulmonary lesions", Respirology, 18, pp.185~190 (2013)
  26. Chen A, "Radial probe endobronchial ultrasound for peripheral pulmonary lesions : a 5-year institutional experience", Ann Am Thorac Soc, 11, pp.578~582 (2014)
  27. Evison M, "Can computed tomography characteristics predict outcomes in patients undergoing radial endobronchial ultrasoundguided biopsy of peripheral lung lesions?", J Thorac Oncol, 9, pp.1393~1397 (2014)
  28. Kuo CH, "Endobronchial ultrasound-guided transbronchial biopsy and brushing : a comparative evaluation for the diagnosis of peripheral pulmonary lesions", Eur J Cardiothorac Surg, 45, pp.894~898 (2014)
  29. Sanchez-Font A, "Endobronchial ultrasound for the diagnosis of peripheral pulmonary lesions : a controlled study with fluoroscopy", Arch Bronconeumol, 50, pp.166~171 (2014)
  30. Asano F, "Virtual bronchoscopic navigation improves the diagnostic yield of radial-endobronchial ultrasound for peripheral pulmonary lesions with involved bronchi on CT", Intern Med, 54, pp.1021~1025 (2015)
  31. Boonsarngsuk V, "Comparison of diagnostic performances among bronchoscopic sampling techniques in the diagnosis of peripheral pulmonary lesions", J Thorac Dis, 7, pp.697~703 (2015)
  32. Chan A, "Radial endobronchial ultrasound in diagnosing peripheral lung lesions in a high tuberculosis setting", BMC Pulm Med, 15, pp.90~ (2015)
  33. Guvenc C, "Computed tomography characteristics predictive for radial EBUS-miniprobe-guided diagnosis of pulmonary lesions", J Thorac Oncol, 10, pp.472~478 (2015)
  34. Minezawa T, "Bronchus sign on thin-section computed tomography is a powerful predictive factor for successful transbronchial biopsy using endobronchial ultrasound with a guide sheath for small peripheral lung lesions : a retrospective observational study", BMC Med Imaging, 15, pp.21~ (2015)
  35. Oki M, "Ultrathin bronchoscopy with multimodal devices for peripheral pulmonary lesions : a randomized trial", Am J Respir Crit Care Med, 192, pp.468~476 (2015)
  36. Jacomelli M, "Radial-probe EBUS for the diagnosis of peripheral pulmonary lesions", J Bras Pneumol, 42, pp.248~253 (2016)
  37. Kunimasa K, "Diagnostic utility of additional conventional techniques after endobronchial ultrasonography guidance during transbronchial biopsy", Respirology, 21, pp.1100~1105 (2016)
  38. Steinfort DP, "Sequential multimodality bronchoscopic investigation of peripheral pulmonary lesions", Eur Respir J, 47, pp.607~614 (2016)
  39. Wang C, "Endobronchial ultrasonography with guide sheath versus computed tomography guided transthoracic needle biopsy for peripheral pulmonary lesions : a propensity score matched analysis", J Thorac Dis, 8, pp.2758~2764 (2016)
  40. Asano F, "Virtual bronchoscopic navigation without X-ray fluoroscopy to diagnose peripheral pulmonary lesions : a randomized trial", BMC Pulm Med, 17, pp.184~ (2017)
  41. Huang CT, "Experience improves the performance of endobronchial ultrasoundguided transbronchial biopsy for peripheral pulmonary lesions : a learning curve at a medical centre", PLoS One, 12, pp.e0179719~ (2017)
  42. Eom JS, "Radial probe endobronchial ultrasound using a guide sheath for peripheral lung lesions in beginners", BMC Pulm Med, 18, pp.137~ (2018)
  43. Good WR, "Radial-probe endobronchial ultrasound outcomes in the investigation of peripheral pulmonary lesions : a New Zealand perspective", Intern Med J, 48, pp.1481~1487 (2018)
  44. Tanner NT, "Standard bronchoscopy with fluoroscopy vs thin bronchoscopy and radial endobronchial ultrasound for biopsy of pulmonary lesions : a multicenter, prospective, randomized trial", Chest, 154, pp.1035~1043 (2018)
  45. Zhang SJ, "Radial endobronchial ultrasonography with distance measurement through a thin bronchoscope for the diagnosis of malignant peripheral pulmonary lesions", Transl Lung Cancer Res, 7, pp.80~87 (2018)
  46. Bo L, "Diagnosing a solitary pulmonary nodule using multiple bronchoscopic guided technologies : a prospective randomized study", Lung Cancer, 129, pp.48~54 (2019)
  47. Kho SS, "Performance of transbronchial cryobiopsy in eccentrically and adjacently orientated radial endobronchial ultrasound lesions", ERJ Open Res, 5, pp.00135~2019 (2019)
  48. Xu C, "Usefulness of virtual bronchoscopic navigation combined with endobronchial ultrasound guided transbronchial lung biopsy for solitary pulmonary nodules", Medicine(Baltimore), 98, pp.e14248~ (2019)
  49. Zhu J, "Diagnosis of peripheral pulmonary lesions using endobronchial ultrasonography with a guide sheath and computed tomography guided transthoracic needle aspiration", Clin Respir J, 13, pp.765~772 (2019)
  50. Boonsarngsuk V, "Comparison of different transbronchial biopsy sampling techniques for the diagnosis of peripheral pulmonary lesions with radial endobronchial ultrasound-guided bronchoscopy : a prospective study", Respir Investig, 58, pp.381~386 (2020)
  51. Samaranayake CB, "A randomized controlled trial on optimal sampling sequence in radial guide sheath endobronchial ultrasound lung biopsy", J Bronchology Interv Pulmonol, 27, pp.205~211 (2020)
  52. Goel MK, "Radial EBUS-guided cryobiopsy of peripheral lung lesions with flexible bronchoscopy without using guide-sheath", J Bronchology Interv Pulmonol, 28, pp.184~191 (2021)
  53. Hong KS, "Radial probe endobronchial ultrasound using guide sheathguided transbronchial lung biopsy in peripheral pulmonary lesions without fluoroscopy", Tuberc Respir Dis(Seoul), 84, pp.282~290 (2021)
  54. Jiang L, "Diagnosis of peripheral pulmonary lesions with transbronchial lung cryobiopsy by guide sheath and radial endobronchial ultrasonography : a prospective control study", Can Respir J, 2021, pp.6947037~ (2021)
  55. Zheng X, "Ultrathin bronchoscope combined with virtual bronchoscopic navigation and endobronchial ultrasound for the diagnosis of peripheral pulmonary lesions with or without fluoroscopy : a randomized trial", Thorac Cancer, 12, pp.1864~1872 (2021)
  56. Ito T, "A diagnostic predictive model of bronchoscopy with radial endobronchial ultrasound for peripheral pulmonary lesions", Respiration, 101, pp.1148~1156 (2022)
  57. Kim SH, "The additive impact of transbronchial cryobiopsy using a 1.1-mm diameter cryoprobe on conventional biopsy for peripheral lung nodules", Cancer Res Treat, 55, pp.506~512 (2023)
  58. Lee J, "Safety and diagnostic yield of radial probe endobronchial ultrasound-guided biopsy for peripheral lung lesions in patients with idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis : a multicenter cross-sectional study", Respiration, 101, pp.401~407 (2022)
  59. Liu Y, "Diagnostic yield of virtual bronchoscope navigation combined with radial endobronchial ultrasound guided transbronchial cryo-biopsy for peripheral pulmonary nodules : a prospective, randomized, controlled trial", Ann Transl Med, 10, pp.443~ (2022)
  60. Oki M, "Guide sheath versus non-guide sheath method for endobronchial ultrasound-guided biopsy of peripheral pulmonary lesions : a multicentre randomised trial", Eur Respir J, 59, pp.2101678~ (2022)
  61. Tanaka M, "Diagnostic value of a new cryoprobe for peripheral pulmonary lesions : a prospective study", BMC Pulm Med, 22, pp.226~ (2022)
  62. Zheng X, "Virtual bronchoscopic navigation and endobronchial ultrasound with a guide sheath without fluoroscopy for diagnosing peripheral pulmonary lesions with a bronchus leading to or adjacent to the lesion : a randomized non-inferiority trial", Respirology, 28, pp.389~398 (2023)
  63. Ali MS, "Radial endobronchial ultrasound for the diagnosis of peripheral pulmonary lesions : a systematic review and meta-analysis", Respirology, 22, pp.443~453 (2017)
  64. Huang CT, "Factors influencing visibility and diagnostic yield of transbronchial biopsy using endobronchial ultrasound in peripheral pulmonary lesions", Respirology, 14, pp.859~864 (2009)
  65. Folch EE, "Sensitivity and safety of electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopy for lung cancer diagnosis : systematic review and meta-analysis", Chest, 158, pp.1753~1769 (2020)
  66. Torky M, "Endobronchial ultrasound guided transbronchial cryobiopsy versus forceps biopsy in peripheral lung lesions", Clin Respir J, 15, pp.320~328 (2021)
  67. Ankudavicius V, "Diagnostic yield of transbronchial cryobiopsy guided by radial endobronchial ultrasound and fluoroscopy in the radiologically suspected lung cancer : a single institution prospective study", Cancers(Basel), 14, pp.1563~ (2022)
  68. Nadig TR, "Guided bronchoscopy for the evaluation of pulmonary lesions : an updated meta-analysis", Chest, 163, pp.1589~1598 (2023)

관련 논문AI추천

The Additive Impact of Transbronchial Cryobiopsy Using a 1.1-mm Diameter Cryoprobe on Conventional Biopsy for Peripheral Lung Nodules김기욱, 김미현, 김수한, 목정하, 박혜경, 엄중섭, 이광하, 이민기, 조은정대한암학회 · Cancer Research and Treatment2023 · 제55권 제2호Endobronchial Ultrasound-Guided Transbronchial Needle Aspiration for Re-biopsy in Previously Treated Lung Cancer강효재, 김주혜, 김혜영, 문성호, 이건국, 이종목, 이진수, 황보빈대한암학회 · Cancer Research and Treatment2019 · 제51권 제4호가상항법장치 유도 기관지경술의 안전성 및 유효성: 체계적 문헌고찰박은지, 박주연, 신채민, 이월숙한국보건의료기술평가학회 · 보건의료기술평가2021 · 제9권 제1호An update on the role of bronchoscopy in the diagnosis of pulmonary disease안준홍영남대학교 의과대학 · Journal of Yeungnam Medical Science2020 · 제37권 제4호Association of Shorter Time to Recurrence and Recurrence-free Survival with Transthoracic Lung Biopsy in Stage I Lung Cancer박형인, 윤순호, 채금주, 홍현숙대한암학회 · Cancer Research and Treatment2025 · 제57권 제2호Diagnostic approach for incidental pulmonary nodulesSeoung Ju Park, SeungYong Park대한내과학회 · The Korean Journal of Internal Medicine2025 · 제40권 제5호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (31건)

Applicability of Spatial Technology in Cancer Research안상정, 이혜승pp. 343-356Cancer Statistics in Korea: Incidence, Mortality, Survival, and Prevalence in 2021공현주, 강미주, 김혜진, 김정은, 서홍관, 박남주, 정규원, 윤이화, 임정수, 박은혜pp. 357-371Prediction of Cancer Incidence and Mortality in Korea, 2024정규원, 서홍관, 윤이화, 강미주, 김혜진, 공현주, 김정은, 임정수, 박은혜pp. 372-379Health Inequities in Cancer Incidence According to Economic Status and Regions Are Still Existed even under Universal Health Coverage System in Korea: A Nationwide Population Based Study using National Health Insurance Database조상아, 황수희, 이진용, 이혜진, 조은별, 장영수pp. 380-403Impact of Patient Sex on Adverse Events and Unscheduled Utilization of Medical Services in Cancer Patients Undergoing Adjuvant Chemotherapy: A Multicenter Retrospective Cohort Study고수진, 안용철, 김화정, 백진호, 서경진, 민영주, 최송지, 김좌훈, 김진원, 최창민, 김지원, 김지현, 윤신교, 김상위, 박숙련, 김태원, 서세영, 이주현, 이대호, 김유정, 홍용상, 김선영, 김정은, 이재철, 이근욱, 김세현pp. 404-413
원문 보기