Reference values for pulp oxygen saturation as a diagnostic tool in endodontics: a systematic review and meta-analysis
1
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Objectives: This systematic review aimed to identify mean oxygen saturation values (SpO2) using pulse oximetry in permanent maxillary anterior teeth. Materials and Methods: The MEDLINE, Scientific Electronic Library Online, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, EMBASE, and Literatura Latino Americana em Ciências da Saúde electronic databases were searched. Combinations and variations of “oximetry” AND “dental pulp test” were used as search terms. Studies reporting means and standard deviations of SpO2 values were included. Two reviewers independently extracted data following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses checklist. Heterogeneity was assessed using the I2 statistic, and all analyses were performed using R software. Study quality was assessed using the Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies-2 tool and the Newcastle-Ottawa scale. Results: Of the 251 studies identified, 19 met the eligibility criteria and were included (total sample, 4,541 teeth). In the meta-analysis, the mean SpO2 values were 84.94% (95% confidence interval [CI], 84.85%–85.04%) for the central incisors, 89.29% (95% CI, 89.22%–89.35%) for the lateral incisors, and 89.20% (95% CI, 89.05%–89.34%) for the canines. The studies were predominantly low-quality due to the high risk of bias associated with the index test, unclear risk regarding patient selection, and concerns about outcome assessment. Conclusions: Although most studies were low-quality, the oxygen saturation levels in normal pulp could be established (minimum saturation, 77.52%). Despite the risk of bias of the included studies, the reference values reported herein are clinically relevant for assessments of changes in pulp status.
Abstract
Objectives: This systematic review aimed to identify mean oxygen saturation values (SpO2) using pulse oximetry in permanent maxillary anterior teeth. Materials and Methods: The MEDLINE, Scientific Electronic Library Online, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, EMBASE, and Literatura Latino Americana em Ciências da Saúde electronic databases were searched. Combinations and variations of “oximetry” AND “dental pulp test” were used as search terms. Studies reporting means and standard deviations of SpO2 values were included. Two reviewers independently extracted data following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses checklist. Heterogeneity was assessed using the I2 statistic, and all analyses were performed using R software. Study quality was assessed using the Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies-2 tool and the Newcastle-Ottawa scale. Results: Of the 251 studies identified, 19 met the eligibility criteria and were included (total sample, 4,541 teeth). In the meta-analysis, the mean SpO2 values were 84.94% (95% confidence interval [CI], 84.85%–85.04%) for the central incisors, 89.29% (95% CI, 89.22%–89.35%) for the lateral incisors, and 89.20% (95% CI, 89.05%–89.34%) for the canines. The studies were predominantly low-quality due to the high risk of bias associated with the index test, unclear risk regarding patient selection, and concerns about outcome assessment. Conclusions: Although most studies were low-quality, the oxygen saturation levels in normal pulp could be established (minimum saturation, 77.52%). Despite the risk of bias of the included studies, the reference values reported herein are clinically relevant for assessments of changes in pulp status.
참고문헌 (33)
- Kataoka SH, "Pulp vitality in patients with intraoral and oropharyngeal malignant tumors undergoing radiation therapy assessed by pulse oximetry", J Endod, 37, pp.1197~1200 (2011)
- Setzer FC, "Clinical diagnosis of pulp inflammation based on pulp oxygenation rates measured by pulse oximetry", J Endod, 38, pp.880~883 (2012)
- Sadique M, "Evaluation of efficacy of a pulse oximeter to assess pulp vitality", J Int Oral Health, 6, pp.70~72 (2014)
- Karayilmaz H, "Comparison of the reliability of laser Doppler flowmetry, pulse oximetry and electric pulp tester in assessing the pulp vitality of human teeth", J Oral Rehabil, 38, pp.340~347 (2011)
- Mejàre IA, "Diagnosis of the condition of the dental pulp : a systematic review", Int Endod J, 45, pp.597~613 (2012)
- Giovanella LB, "Assessment of oxygen saturation in dental pulp of permanent teeth with periodontal disease", J Endod, 40, pp.1927~1931 (2014)
- Gopikrishna V, "Comparison of electrical, thermal, and pulse oximetry methods for assessing pulp vitality in recently traumatized teeth", J Endod, 33, pp.531~535 (2007)
- Bruno KF, "Oxygen saturation in the dental pulp of permanent teeth : a critical review", J Endod, 40, pp.1054~1057 (2014)
- Radhakrishnan S, "Pulse oximetry : a diagnostic instrument in pulpal vitality testing", J Clin Pediatr Dent, 26, pp.141~145 (2002)
- Estrela C, "Oxygen saturation in the dental pulp of maxillary and mandibular molars – Part 2", Braz Dent J, 28, pp.704~709 (2017)
- Siddheswaran V, "Pulse oximetry : a diagnostic instrument in pulpal vitality testing—An in vivo study", World J Dent, 2, pp.225~230 (2011)
- Dastmalchi N, "Comparison of the efficacy of a custom-made pulse oximeter probe with digital electric pulp tester, cold spray, and rubber cup for assessing pulp vitality", J Endod, 38, pp.1182~1186 (2012)
- Moher D, "Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses : the PRISMA statement", PLoS Med, 6, pp.e1000097~ (2009)
- Whiting PF, "QUADAS-2: a revised tool for the quality assessment of diagnostic accuracy studies", Ann Intern Med, 155, pp.529~536 (2011)
- Modesti PA, "Panethnic differences in blood pressure in Europe : a systematic review and meta-analysis", PLoS One, 11, pp.e0147601~ (2016)
- Schnettler JM, "Pulse oximetry as a diagnostic tool of pulpal vitality", J Endod, 17, pp.488~490 (1991)
- Gopi Krishna V, "Assessment of the efficacy of an indigeniously developed pulse oximeter dental sensor holder for pulp vitality testing", Indian J Dent Res, 17, pp.111~113 (2006)
- Calil E, "Determination of pulp vitality in vivo with pulse oximetry", Int Endod J, 41, pp.741~746 (2008)
- Pozzobon MH, "Assessment of pulp blood flow in primary and permanent teeth using pulse oximetry", Dent Traumatol, 27, pp.184~188 (2011)
- Ciobanu G, "Testing of pulp vitality by pulse oximetry", Odontology, 16, pp.94~98 (2012)
- Stella JP, "Oxygen saturation in dental pulp of permanent teeth : difference between children", adolescents and adults, 2015, pp.41, 1445~1449
- Kosturkov D, "Evaluation of condition of the pulp by pulse oximetry", J Int Med Assoc Bulgaria, 21, pp.1003~1007 (2015)
- Kataoka SH, "Late effects of head and neck radiotherapy on pulp vitality assessed by pulse oximetry", J Endod, 42, pp.886~889 (2016)
- Khademi AA, "Pulp vitality of maxillary canines after alveolar cleft bone grafting : pulse oximetry versus electric pulp test versus cold test", J Craniofac Surg (2017)[DOI]
- Kosturkov D, "Pulse oximetry as a diagnostic tool in dental medicine", 19th International Conference and School on Quantum Electronics: Laser Physics and Applications (2016), SPIE - International Society for Optics and Photonics
- Kosturkov D, "Pulse oximetry and electric pulp test in intact teeth and teeth with hyperaemia pulpae", Acta Med Bulg, 44, pp.10~13 (2017)
- Souza SF, "Healthy dental pulp oxygen saturation rates in subjects with homozygous sickle cell anemia : a cross-sectional study nested in a cohort", J Endod, 43, pp.1997~2000 (2017)
- Kosturkov D, "Influence of the gingival tissues on the measured saturation level of the dental pulp blood flow", Bulgarian J Chem Educ, 27, pp.454~459 (2018)
- Solda C, "Effect of at-home bleaching on oxygen saturation levels in the dental pulp of maxillary central incisors", Braz Dent J, 29, pp.541~546 (2018)
- Lima LF, "Effect of dental bleaching on pulp oxygen saturation in maxillary central incisors-a randomized clinical trial", J Appl Oral Sci, 27, pp.e20180442~ (2019)
- Mainkar A, "Diagnostic accuracy of 5 dental pulp tests : a systematic review and meta-analysis", J Endod, 44, pp.694~702 (2018)
- Egger M, "Systematic reviews in healthcare: meta-analysis in context", pp.211~227 (2007), John Wiley & Sons
- Gopikrishna V, "Evaluation of efficacy of a new custom-made pulse oximeter dental probe in comparison with the electrical and thermal tests for assessing pulp vitality", J Endod, 33, pp.411~414 (2007)