Comparison of treatment outcomes in chronic coccygodynia patients treated with ganglion impar blockade versus caudal epidural steroid injection: a prospective randomized comparison study
2
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Background: Coccygodynia is one of the chronic, refractory painful musculoskeletal disorders. Interventional procedures are applied to patients unresponsive to initial treatment in coccygodynia. This study aims to compare the treatment outcomes of ganglion impar block (GIB) and caudal epidural steroid injection (CESI) in patients with chronic coccygodynia. Methods: This study was a prospective randomized comparison study conducted between June 2019 and January 2021. Patients diagnosed with chronic coccygodynia were randomly divided into two groups: the GIB group and the CESI group. The severity of pain, presence of neuropathic pain, and quality of life were evaluated using the Numeric Rating Scale, Leeds Assessment of the Neuropathic Symptoms and Signs Scale, and Short Form-12 Health Survey (SF-12), respectively. Results: A total of 34 patients in each group were included in the final analyses. While there was a significant decrease in pain intensity in both groups in the 3-month follow-up, this decrease was more significant in the GIB group at the 3rd week. There was a significant improvement in the SF-12 physical score and the number of patients with neuropathic pain in both groups in the 3rd week, but this improvement was not observed in the 3rd month. Conclusions: Although GIB may provide more pain relief in short term, both GIB and CESI are useful treatment methods in coccygodynia unresponsive to more conservative treatments.
Abstract
Background: Coccygodynia is one of the chronic, refractory painful musculoskeletal disorders. Interventional procedures are applied to patients unresponsive to initial treatment in coccygodynia. This study aims to compare the treatment outcomes of ganglion impar block (GIB) and caudal epidural steroid injection (CESI) in patients with chronic coccygodynia. Methods: This study was a prospective randomized comparison study conducted between June 2019 and January 2021. Patients diagnosed with chronic coccygodynia were randomly divided into two groups: the GIB group and the CESI group. The severity of pain, presence of neuropathic pain, and quality of life were evaluated using the Numeric Rating Scale, Leeds Assessment of the Neuropathic Symptoms and Signs Scale, and Short Form-12 Health Survey (SF-12), respectively. Results: A total of 34 patients in each group were included in the final analyses. While there was a significant decrease in pain intensity in both groups in the 3-month follow-up, this decrease was more significant in the GIB group at the 3rd week. There was a significant improvement in the SF-12 physical score and the number of patients with neuropathic pain in both groups in the 3rd week, but this improvement was not observed in the 3rd month. Conclusions: Although GIB may provide more pain relief in short term, both GIB and CESI are useful treatment methods in coccygodynia unresponsive to more conservative treatments.
참고문헌 (25)
- Garg B, "Coccydynia-a comprehensive review on etiology, radiological features and management options", J Clin Orthop Trauma, 12, pp.123~129 (2021)
- Patijn J, "Coccygodynia", Pain Pract, 10, pp.554~559 (2010)
- Lirette LS, "Coccydynia : an overview of the anatomy, etiology, and treatment of coccyx pain", Ochsner J, 14, pp.84~87 (2014)
- Karadimas EJ, "Surgical treatment of coccygodynia : an analytic review of the literature", Eur Spine J, 20, pp.698~705 (2011)
- Foye PM, "Coccydynia : tailbone pain", Phys Med Rehabil Clin N Am, 28, pp.539~549 (2017)
- Gunduz OH, "Pain relief due to transsacrococcygeal ganglion impar block in chronic coccygodynia : a pilot study", Pain Med, 16, pp.1278~1281 (2015)
- Gonnade N, "Ganglion impar block in patients with chronic coccydynia", Indian J Radiol Imaging, 27, pp.324~328 (2017)
- Sencan S, "Ganglion Impar block improves neuropathic pain in coccygodynia : a preliminary report", Neurol Neurochir Pol, 52, pp.612~617 (2018)
- Elkhashab Y, "A review of current treatment options for coccygodynia", Curr Pain Headache Rep, 22, pp.28~ (2018)
- Govardhani Y, "A comparative retrospective study of the efficacy of caudal epidural with manipulation versus ganglion impar block with manipulation in patients with coccydynia", Indian J Pain, 35, pp.42~45 (2021)
- Yucel A, "Results of the Leeds assessment of neuropathic symptoms and signs pain scale in Turkey : a validation study", J Pain, 5, pp.427~432 (2004)
- Soylu C, "Reliability and validity of the Turkish version of SF-12 Health Survey", Turk Psikiyatri Derg (2021)
- Savas Sencan, "Are steroids required in the treatment of ganglion impar blockade in chronic coccydynia? a prospective double-blinded clinical trial", The Korean Journal of Pain, 32(4), pp.301~306 (2019), 대한통증학회[DOI]
- Oh CS, "Clinical implications of topographic anatomy on the ganglion impar", Anesthesiology, 101, pp.249~250 (2004)
- Sagir O, "Retrospective evaluation of pain in patients with coccydynia who underwent impar ganglion block", BMC Anesthesiol, 20, pp.110~ (2020)
- Sir E, "Comparison of block and pulsed radiofrequency of the ganglion impar in coccygodynia", Turk J Med Sci, 49, pp.1555~1559 (2019)
- Ghai A, "A prospective study to evaluate the efficacy of ultrasoundguided ganglion impar block in patients with chronic perineal pain", Saudi J Anaesth, 13, pp.126~130 (2019)
- Ferreira F, "Ganglion impar neurolysis in the management of pelvic and perineal cancer-related pain", Case Rep Oncol, 13, pp.29~34 (2020)
- Foye PM, "Successful injection for coccyx pain", Am J Phys Med Rehabil, 85, pp.783~784 (2006)
- De Andrés J, "Coccygodynia : a proposal for an algorithm for treatment", J Pain, 4, pp.257~266 (2003)
- Atim A, "Pulsed radiofrequency in the treatment of coccygodynia", Agri, 23, pp.1~6 (2011)
- Lee DW, "Sacral burst neuromodulation via caudal approach as a treatment for chronic coccydynia", Neuromodulation, 22, pp.992~994 (2019)
- Kaydu A, "Anosmia after caudal epidural steroid injection", Anesth Essays Res, 12, pp.291~293 (2018)
- Kaydu A, "Unexpected complication after caudal epidural steroid injection : hiccup", Anesth Essays Res, 11, pp.776~777 (2017)
- Gupta N, "An unusual complication after ganglion impar block for chronic cancer pain management", AANA J, 85, pp.424~426 (2017)