본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Effect of endodontic sealer on postoperative pain: a network meta-analysis

Reis Alessandra|Monteiro Cynthia Maria Chaves|Martins Ana Cristina Rodrigues|de Geus Juliana Larocca
대한치과보존학회 (Korean Academy Of Conservative Dentistry)|2023.02|Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics|제48권 제1호|pp. 1-22|DOI 10.5395/rde.2023.48.e5

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

Systematic reviewMeta-analysisRoot canal obturationRoot canal filling materialsPain postoperative
주제분류치의학

초록

This systematic review and network meta-analysis aimed to answer the following focused research question: “Does the type of endodontic sealer affect the postoperative pain in patients who received endodontic treatment?” Different databases and grey literature were surveyed. Only one randomized controlled trial were included. The risk of bias in the studies was evaluated by using the Cochrane Collaboration’s tool. A random-effects meta-analysis was conducted to compare the risk and intensity of postoperative pain. The quality of the body of evidence was assessed using the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation approach. Out of 11,601 studies, 15 remained for qualitative analyses and 12 for meta-analysis. Seven studies were classified at high risk of bias, and 8 studies raised some concerns. No significant differences between the endodontic materials were observed in the direct comparisons, both in risk and in intensity of postoperative pain (pairwise comparisons with 2 studies: I2 = 0%; p > 0.05 and 8 studies: I2 = 23%; p > 0.05, respectively). The certainty of the evidence was graded as low or moderate. There was no difference in the risk and intensity of postoperative pain after filling with different endodontic sealers. Further systematic reviews should be conducted.

Abstract

This systematic review and network meta-analysis aimed to answer the following focused research question: “Does the type of endodontic sealer affect the postoperative pain in patients who received endodontic treatment?” Different databases and grey literature were surveyed. Only one randomized controlled trial were included. The risk of bias in the studies was evaluated by using the Cochrane Collaboration’s tool. A random-effects meta-analysis was conducted to compare the risk and intensity of postoperative pain. The quality of the body of evidence was assessed using the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation approach. Out of 11,601 studies, 15 remained for qualitative analyses and 12 for meta-analysis. Seven studies were classified at high risk of bias, and 8 studies raised some concerns. No significant differences between the endodontic materials were observed in the direct comparisons, both in risk and in intensity of postoperative pain (pairwise comparisons with 2 studies: I2 = 0%; p > 0.05 and 8 studies: I2 = 23%; p > 0.05, respectively). The certainty of the evidence was graded as low or moderate. There was no difference in the risk and intensity of postoperative pain after filling with different endodontic sealers. Further systematic reviews should be conducted.

참고문헌 (69)

  1. Benenati FW, "Endodontics", pp.1053~1087 (2008), BC Decker
  2. Holland R, "Factors affecting the periapical healing process of endodontically treated teeth", J Appl Oral Sci, 25, pp.465~476 (2017)
  3. Sathorn C, "The prevalence of postoperative pain and flare-up in single-and multiple-visit endodontic treatment : a systematic review", Int Endod J, 41, pp.91~99 (2008)
  4. Manfredi M, "Single versus multiple visits for endodontic treatment of permanent teeth", Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 12 (2016)
  5. AlRahabi MK, "Predictors, prevention, and management of postoperative pain associated with nonsurgical root canal treatment: a systematic review", J Taibah Univ Med Sci, 12, pp.376~384 (2017)
  6. Zuckerman O, ""Flare-up"during endodontic treatment--etiology and management", Refuat Hapeh Vehashinayim, 2007, pp.19~26 (1993)
  7. Mostafa ME, "Postoperative pain following endodontic irrigation using 1.3% versus 5.25% sodium hypochlorite in mandibular molars with necrotic pulps: a randomized double-blind clinical trial", Int Endod J, 53, pp.154~166 (2020)
  8. Saha SG, "Comparison of the incidence of postoperative pain after using a continuous rotary system, a reciprocating system, and a Self-Adjusting File system in single-visit endodontics: a prospective randomized clinical trial", J Conserv Dent, 21, pp.333~338 (2018)
  9. Vianna EC, "Effect of occlusal adjustment on postoperative pain after root canal treatment: a randomized clinical trial", Braz Dent J, 31, pp.353~359 (2020)
  10. Javidi M, "Post-treatment flare-up incidence after using nano zinc oxide eugenol sealer in mandibular first molars with irreversible pulpitis", J Dent(Shiraz), 21, pp.307~313 (2020)
  11. Rosen E, "The prognosis of altered sensation after extrusion of root canal filling materials : a systematic review of the literature", J Endod, 42, pp.873~879 (2016)
  12. Ørstavik D, "Materials used for root canal obturation: technical, biological and clinical testing", Endod Topics, 12, pp.25~38 (2005)
  13. Lim Miyoung, "Calcium silicate-based root canal sealers: a literature review", Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics, 45(3), pp.1~17 (2020), 대한치과보존학회[DOI]
  14. Thakur S, "Evaluation of mineral trioxide aggregate as root canal sealer : a clinical study", J Conserv Dent, 16, pp.494~498 (2013)
  15. Paz A, "Evaluation of postoperative pain after using bioceramic materials as endodontic sealers", EC Dent Sci, 10, pp.1739~1748 (2018)
  16. Fonseca B, "Assessment of extrusion and postoperative pain of a bioceramic and resin-based root canal sealer", Eur J Dent, 13, pp.343~348 (2019)
  17. Aslan T, "The effect of two calcium silicate-based and one epoxy resin-based root canal sealer on postoperative pain : a randomized controlled trial", Int Endod J, 54, pp.190~197 (2021)
  18. Gudlavalleti B, "Comparative evaluation of postoperative pain after root canal treatment using three different sealers, Viz., Tubli-Seal EWT, Apexit Plus, AH Plus: an in-vivo study", J Clin Diagn Res, 14, pp.ZC04~ZC09 (2020)
  19. Tan HS, "Postobturation pain associated with tricalcium silicate and resinbased sealer techniques : a randomized clinical trial", J Endod, 47, pp.169~177 (2021)
  20. Sponchiado Junior EC, "Calcium silicate-based sealers do not reduce the risk and intensity of postoperative pain after root canal treatment when compared with epoxy resin-based sealers : a systematic review and meta-analysis", Eur J Dent, 15, pp.347~359 (2021)
  21. Page MJ, "The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews", BMJ, 372, pp.n71~ (2020)
  22. Larocca de Geus J, "Different anesthetics on the efficacy of inferior alveolar nerve block in patients with irreversible pulpitis : a network systematic review and meta-analysis", J Am Dent Assoc, 151, pp.87~97 (2020)
  23. Maran BM, "Different light-activation systems associated with dental bleaching : a systematic review and a network meta-analysis", Clin Oral Investig, 23, pp.1499~1512 (2019)
  24. Sterne JA, "RoB 2: a revised tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials", BMJ, 366, pp.l4898~ (2019)
  25. Dias S, "Checking consistency in mixed treatment comparison metaanalysis", Stat Med, 29, pp.932~944 (2010)
  26. Puhan MA, "A GRADE Working Group approach for rating the quality of treatment effect estimates from network meta-analysis", BMJ, 349, pp.g5630~ (2014)
  27. Nabi S, "Comparison of various sealers on postoperative pain in single-visit endodontics : a randomized clinical study", Indian J Dent Sci, 11, pp.99~102 (2019)
  28. Sharma N, "A study to compare various sealers on postoperative pain in single visit endodontics", Ann Int Med Dent Res, 6, pp.40~42 (2019)
  29. Graunaite I, "Effect of resin-based and bioceramic root canal sealers on postoperative pain : a split-mouth randomized controlled trial", J Endod, 44, pp.689~693 (2018)
  30. Yoshii S, "A pilot study on the effects of two types of root canal sealer on postoperative pain", J Jpn Endod Assoc, 39, pp.43~48 (2018)
  31. Atav Ates A, "Post-obturation pain following the use of carrier-based system with AH Plus or iRoot SP sealers : a randomized controlled clinical trial", Clin Oral Investig, 23, pp.3053~3061 (2019)
  32. Ferreira NS, "Postoperative pain after root canal filling with different endodontic sealers : a randomized clinical trial", Braz Oral Res, 34, pp.e069~ (2020)
  33. Jacoub MS, "The influence of two instrumentation techniques with two sealers on postoperative pain after endodontic treatment"randomized clinical trial"", Future Dent J, 4, pp.175~180 (2018)
  34. Shashirekha G, "Assessment of pain and dissolution of apically extruded sealers and their effect on the periradicular tissues", J Conserv Dent, 21, pp.546~550 (2018)
  35. Estrela C, "Influência da substância química, do cimento obturador e do número de sessões na incidência de pericementite traumática", Rev Odontol Bras Cent, 6, pp.9~13 (1996)
  36. Alacam T, "Incidence of postoperative pain following the use of different sealers in immediate root canal filling", J Endod, 11, pp.135~137 (1985)
  37. Komabayashi T, "Comprehensive review of current endodontic sealers", Dent Mater J, 39, pp.703~720 (2020)
  38. Desai S, "Calcium hydroxide-based root canal sealers : a review", J Endod, 35, pp.475~480 (2009)
  39. Raghavendra SS, "Bioceramics in endodontics-a review", J Istanb Univ Fac Dent, 51, pp.S128~S137 (2017)
  40. Lodienė G, "Detection of leachables and cytotoxicity after exposure to methacrylate-and epoxy-based root canal sealers in vitro", Eur J Oral Sci, 121, pp.488~496 (2013)
  41. Seo DG, "Biocompatibility and mineralization activity of three calcium silicate-based root canal sealers compared to conventional resin-based sealer in human dental pulp stem cells", Materials(Basel), 12, pp.E2482~ (2019)
  42. Silva-Herzog D, "Preliminary study of the inflammatory response to subcutaneous implantation of three root canal sealers", Int Endod J, 44, pp.440~446 (2011)
  43. Zhang W, "Tissue reactions after subcutaneous and intraosseous implantation of iRoot SP, MTA and AH Plus", Dent Mater J, 34, pp.774~780 (2015)
  44. Nusstein J, "Injection pain and postinjection pain of the anterior middle superior alveolar injection administered with the Wand or conventional syringe", Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod, 98, pp.124~131 (2004)
  45. Wambier LM, "A randomized clinical trial evaluating rubber dam clamp pain reduction from a new topical liposomal anesthetic gel", Pediatr Dent, 40, pp.190~194 (2018)
  46. Khan J, "Acute and chronic pain in orofacial trauma patients", Dent Traumatol, 35, pp.348~357 (2019)
  47. Bernáth M, "Tissue reaction initiated by different sealers", Int Endod J, 36, pp.256~261 (2003)
  48. Pocock SJ, "Clinical trials : a practical approach" (1983), John Wiley & Sons
  49. Schulz KF, "Empirical evidence of bias. Dimensions of methodological quality associated with estimates of treatment effects in controlled trials", JAMA, 273, pp.408~412 (1995)
  50. Khan KS, "The importance of quality of primary studies in producing unbiased systematic reviews", Arch Intern Med, 156, pp.661~666 (1996)
  51. Albashaireh ZS, "Postobturation pain after single- and multiple-visit endodontic therapy. A prospective study", J Dent, 26, pp.227~232 (1998)
  52. Su Y, "Healing rate and post-obturation pain of single-versus multiple-visit endodontic treatment for infected root canals : a systematic review", J Endod, 37, pp.125~132 (2011)
  53. Almeida DO, "Outcome of single-vs multiple-visit endodontic therapy of nonvital teeth : a meta-analysis", J Contemp Dent Pract, 18, pp.330~336 (2017)
  54. Gondim E Jr, "Postoperative pain after the application of two different irrigation devices in a prospective randomized clinical trial", J Endod, 36, pp.1295~1301 (2010)
  55. Ramamoorthi S, "Comparative evaluation of postoperative pain after using endodontic needle and EndoActivator during root canal irrigation : a randomised controlled trial", Aust Endod J, 41, pp.78~87 (2015)
  56. Gotler M, "Postoperative pain after root canal treatment : a prospective cohort study", Int J Dent, 2012, pp.310467~ (2012)
  57. Alonso-Ezpeleta LO, "Postoperative pain after one-visit root-canal treatment on teeth with vital pulps : comparison of three different obturation techniques", Med Oral Patol Oral Cir Bucal, 17, pp.e721~e727 (2012)
  58. Rahimi S, "A stereomicroscopy study of root apices of human maxillary central incisors and mandibular second premolars in an Iranian population", J Oral Sci, 51, pp.411~415 (2009)
  59. Fillingim RB, "Sex, gender, and pain: a review of recent clinical and experimental findings", J Pain, 10, pp.447~485 (2009)
  60. Pieretti S, "Gender differences in pain and its relief", Ann Ist Super Sanita, 52, pp.184~189 (2016)
  61. Cooper NJ, "How valuable are multiple treatment comparison methods in evidence-based health-care evaluation?", Value Health, 14, pp.371~380 (2011)
  62. Caldwell DM, "Extending treatment networks in health technology assessment : how far should we go?", Value Health, 18, pp.673~681 (2015)
  63. Chaimani A, "Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions version 6.2" (2021), John Wiley & Sons
  64. Fonseca DA, "Biocompatibility of root canal sealers : a systematic review of in vitro and in vivo studies", Materials(Basel), 12, pp.4113~ (2019)
  65. Coghill RC, "Individual differences in the subjective experience of pain : new insights into mechanisms and models", Headache, 50, pp.1531~1535 (2010)
  66. Martín-González J, "Influence of root canal instrumentation and obturation techniques on intra-operative pain during endodontic therapy", Med Oral Patol Oral Cir Bucal, 17, pp.e912~e918 (2012)
  67. Breivik H, "Assessment of pain", Br J Anaesth, 101, pp.17~24 (2008)
  68. Williamson A, "Pain : a review of three commonly used pain rating scales", J Clin Nurs, 14, pp.798~804 (2005)
  69. Schünemann H, "GRADE handbook for grading quality of evidence and strength of recommendations" (2013), The GRADE Working Group

관련 논문AI추천

Calcium hydroxide intracanal medication effects on pain and flare-up: a systematic review and meta-analysisAmin Suzan Abdul Wanees, Ibrahim Ahmed Mohamed, Zakhary Siza Yacoub대한치과보존학회 · Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics2020 · 제45권 제3호Effect of intracanal cryotherapy on postoperative pain after endodontic treatment: systematic review with meta-analysisAntunes Leonardo Santos, Antunes Lívia Azeredo Alves, Guimarães Ludmila Silva, Hespanhol Fernanda Garcias대한치과보존학회 · Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics2022 · 제47권 제3호The status of clinical trials regarding root canal sealersAl Ziab Mira, Baroud Tarek, Malak Ahmad AL, Masri Yasmina EL, Salameh Pascale, Zrara Nancy대한치과보존학회 · Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics2024 · 제49권 제1호수종의 수산화칼슘 근관 첩약제와 레진계 근관 실러의 사용 후 통증 발생 빈도에 관한 연구곽상원, 김현철대한치과의사협회 · 대한치과의사협회지2018 · 제56권 제5호Influence of the root canal filling technique on the success rate of primary endodontic treatments: a systematic reviewda Rosa Ricardo Abreu, da Silva Giovana Siocheta, Jahnke Leonardo Thomasi, Marconi Daniel Feijolo, Silva Isadora Ames, Skupien Jovito Adiel, Só Gabriel Barcelos, Só Marcus Vinicius Reis, Weissheimer Theodoro대한치과보존학회 · Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics2022 · 제47권 제4호Postoperative pain after endodontic treatment of necrotic teeth with large intentional foraminal enlargementComparin Daniel, Ignácio Sérgio Aparecido, Machado Ricardo, Silva Neto Ulisses Xavier da대한치과보존학회 · Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics2021 · 제46권 제3호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (10건)

Antimicrobial and cytotoxic properties of calcium-enriched mixture cement, Iranian propolis, and propolis with herbal extracts in primary dental pulp stem cellsEsmaeilzadeh Mohammad, Moradkhani Shirin, Daneshyar Fahimeh, Arabestani Mohammad Reza, Soleimani Asl Sara, Tayebi Soudeh, Farhadian Maryampp. 1-12Push-out bond strength and intratubular biomineralization of a hydraulic root-end filling material premixed with dimethyl sulfoxide as a vehicle김희진, 유미경, 이광원, 민경산, Park Ju-Happ. 1-8High-plasticity mineral trioxide aggregate and its effects on M1 and M2 macrophage viability and adherence, phagocyte activity, production of reactive oxygen species, and cytokinesBenetti Francine, Vasconcellos Betânia Canal, Tavares Layara Cristine Tomaz, da Silva Danilo Couto, Fonseca Francielen Oliveira, Sobrinho Antônio Paulino Ribeiro, Tavares Warley Luciano Fonsecapp. 1-14Comparative analysis of torsional and cyclic fatigue resistance of ProGlider, WaveOne Gold Glider, and TruNatomy Glider in simulated curved canalDuarte Marco Antonio Hungaro, Vivan Rodrigo Ricci, Calefi Pedro Henrique Souza, Dias Pedro de Souza, Kato Augusto Shoji, Bueno Carlos Eduardo da Silveira, Pelegrine Rina Andréapp. 1-10Dentinal tubule penetration of sodium hypochlorite in root canals with and without mechanical preparation and different irrigant activation methodsWeissheimer Theodoro, Souza Matheus Albino, da Rosa Ricardo Abreu, de Oliveira Renata Aqel, Só Gabriel Barcelos, Ribeiro Rodrigo Gonçalves, Só Marcus Vinicius Reispp. 1-11
원문 보기