Hip Labral Repair versus Reconstruction: Meta-analysis
2
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The purpose of this meta-analysis is to compare the postoperative outcomes and complications of labral repair with those of labral reconstruction. An electronic search strategy was conducted from 1986 until August 2023 using the following databases: PubMed, Cochrane, and Google Scholar (pages 1-20). The primary objectives included the postoperative clinical outcomes determined by the number of patients who reached minimal clinical important difference (MCID) on the visual analog scale (VAS), modified Harris hip score (mHHS), Hip Outcome Score-Sports Subscale (HOS-SS), Hip Outcome Score-Activities of Daily Life (HOS-ADL), and International Hip Outcome Tool-12 (iHOT-12). In addition, analysis of the rate of revision arthroscopy, the rate of conversion to total hip arthroplasty (THA), the postoperative VAS, mHHS, HOS-SS, HOS-ADL, iHOT12, nonarthritic hip score (NAHS), patient satisfaction, lower extremity function scale (LEFS), and the SF-12 (12-item shortform) was also performed. Any differences arising between the investigators were resolved by discussion. Seventeen studies were relevant to the inclusion criteria and were included in this meta-analysis. A higher rate of patients who reached MCID in the mHHS (P=0.02) as well as a higher rate of revision arthroscopy was observed for labral repair (P=0.03). The remaining studied outcomes were comparable. Despite the greater predictability of success in the reconstruction group, conduct of additional studies will be required for evaluation of the benefits of such findings. In addition, labral reconstruction is more technically demanding than a labral repair
Abstract
The purpose of this meta-analysis is to compare the postoperative outcomes and complications of labral repair with those of labral reconstruction. An electronic search strategy was conducted from 1986 until August 2023 using the following databases: PubMed, Cochrane, and Google Scholar (pages 1-20). The primary objectives included the postoperative clinical outcomes determined by the number of patients who reached minimal clinical important difference (MCID) on the visual analog scale (VAS), modified Harris hip score (mHHS), Hip Outcome Score-Sports Subscale (HOS-SS), Hip Outcome Score-Activities of Daily Life (HOS-ADL), and International Hip Outcome Tool-12 (iHOT-12). In addition, analysis of the rate of revision arthroscopy, the rate of conversion to total hip arthroplasty (THA), the postoperative VAS, mHHS, HOS-SS, HOS-ADL, iHOT12, nonarthritic hip score (NAHS), patient satisfaction, lower extremity function scale (LEFS), and the SF-12 (12-item shortform) was also performed. Any differences arising between the investigators were resolved by discussion. Seventeen studies were relevant to the inclusion criteria and were included in this meta-analysis. A higher rate of patients who reached MCID in the mHHS (P=0.02) as well as a higher rate of revision arthroscopy was observed for labral repair (P=0.03). The remaining studied outcomes were comparable. Despite the greater predictability of success in the reconstruction group, conduct of additional studies will be required for evaluation of the benefits of such findings. In addition, labral reconstruction is more technically demanding than a labral repair
참고문헌 (45)
- Seldes RM, "Anatomy, histologic features, and vascularity of the adult acetabular labrum", Clin Orthop Relat Res, (382), pp.232~240 (2001)[DOI]
- Safran MR, "Microinstability of the hip-gaining acceptance", J Am Acad Orthop Surg, 27, pp.12~22 (2019)[DOI]
- Reiman MP, "Examination of acetabular labral tear : a continued diagnostic challenge", Br J Sports Med, 48, pp.311~319 (2014)[DOI]
- Bozic KJ, "Trends in hip arthroscopy utilization in the United States", J Arthroplasty, 28(8 Suppl), pp.140~143 (2013)[DOI]
- Palmer AJ, "Past and projected temporal trends in arthroscopic hip surgery in England between 2002 and 2013", BMJ Open Sport Exerc Med, 2, pp.e000082~ (2016)[DOI]
- Bsat S, "The acetabular labrum : a review of its function", Bone Joint J, 98-B, pp.730~735 (2016)[DOI]
- Haddad B, "Debridement versus reattachment of acetabular labral tears : a review of the literature and quantitative analysis", Bone Joint J, 96-B, pp.24~30 (2014)[DOI]
- Nepple JJ, "The hip fluid seal--part II : the effect of an acetabular labral tear, repair, resection, and reconstruction on hip stability to distraction", Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc, 22, pp.730~736 (2014)[DOI]
- Philippon MJ, "The hip fluid seal--part I : the effect of an acetabular labral tear, repair, resection, and reconstruction on hip fluid pressurization", Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc, 22, pp.722~729 (2014)[DOI]
- Weber AE, "Amateur and recreational athletes return to sport at a high rate following hip arthroscopy for femoroacetabular impingement", Arthroscopy, 33, pp.748~755 (2017)[DOI]
- Frangiamore SJ, "Career length and performance among professional baseball players returning to play after hip arthroscopy", Am J Sports Med, 46, pp.2588~2593 (2018)[DOI]
- Menge TJ, "Femoroacetabular impingement in professional football players : return to play and predictors of career length after hip arthroscopy", Am J Sports Med, 45, pp.1740~1744 (2017)[DOI]
- Begly JP, "Femoroacetabular impingement in professional basketball players : return to play, career length, and performance after hip arthroscopy", Am J Sports Med, 46, pp.3090~3096 (2018)[DOI]
- Lee S, "Ability to return to work without restrictions in workers compensation patients undergoing hip arthroscopy", J Hip Preserv Surg, 4, pp.30~38 (2016)[DOI]
- Philippon MJ, "Arthroscopic labral reconstruction in the hip using iliotibial band autograft : technique and early outcomes", Arthroscopy, 26, pp.750~756 (2010)[DOI]
- Chandrasekaran S, "Arthroscopic reconstruction of segmental defects of the hip labrum : results in 22 patients with mean 2-year follow-up", Arthroscopy, 33, pp.1685~1693 (2017)[DOI]
- Scanaliato JP, "Primary circumferential acetabular labral reconstruction : achieving outcomes similar to primary labral repair despite more challenging patient characteristics", Am J Sports Med, 46, pp.2079~2088 (2018)[DOI]
- White BJ, "Allograft use in arthroscopic labral reconstruction of the hip with front-to-back fixation technique : minimum 2-year follow-up", Arthroscopy, 32, pp.26~32 (2016)[DOI]
- Cadet ER, "Investigation of the preservation of the fluid seal effect in the repaired, partially resected, and reconstructed acetabular labrum in a cadaveric hip model", Am J Sports Med, 40, pp.2218~2223 (2012)[DOI]
- Scanaliato JP, "Primary arthroscopic labral management : labral repair and complete labral reconstruction both offer durable, promising results at minimum 5-year follow-up", Am J Sports Med, 50, pp.2622~2628 (2022)[DOI]
- Sterne JA, "ROBINS-I : a tool for assessing risk of bias in non-randomised studies of interventions", BMJ, 355, pp.i4919~ (2016)[DOI]
- Bodendorfer BM, "Multicenter outcomes after primary hip arthroscopy : a comparative analysis of two-year outcomes after labral repair, segmental labral reconstruction, or circumferential labral reconstruction", Arthroscopy, 38, pp.352~361 (2022)[DOI]
- Bodendorfer BM, "Multicenter outcomes after revision hip arthroscopy : comparative analysis of 2-year outcomes after labral repair versus labral reconstruction", Am J Sports Med, 49, pp.2968~2976 (2021)[DOI]
- Chandrasekaran S, "Arthroscopic reconstruction of the irreparable acetabular labrum : a matchcontrolled study", Arthroscopy, 35, pp.480~488 (2019)[DOI]
- Domb BG, "Minimum 5-year outcomes of arthroscopic hip labral reconstruction with nested matched-pair benchmarking against a labral repair control group", Am J Sports Med, 47, pp.2045~2055 (2019)[DOI]
- Domb BG, "Circumferential labral reconstruction for irreparable labral tears in the primary setting : minimum 2-year outcomes with a nested matched-pair labral repair control group", Arthroscopy, 36, pp.2583~2597 (2020)[DOI]
- Jimenez AE, "Revision hip arthroscopy with labral reconstruction for irreparable labral tears in athletes : minimum 2-year outcomes with a benchmark control group", Am J Sports Med, 50, pp.1571~1581 (2022)[DOI]
- Jimenez AE, "Return to sports and minimum 2-year outcomes of primary arthroscopic hip labral reconstruction for irreparable tears in high-level athletes with a propensity-matched benchmarking against a labral repair control group", Am J Sports Med, 49, pp.3261~3269 (2021)[DOI]
- Maldonado DR, "Labral tear management in patients aged 40 years and older undergoing primary hip arthroscopy : a propensity-matched case-control study with minimum 2-year follow-up", Am J Sports Med, 49, pp.3925~3936 (2021)[DOI]
- Matsuda DK, "Arthroscopic hip labral reconstruction with a gracilis autograft versus labral refixation : 2-year minimum outcomes", Am J Sports Med, 41, pp.980~987 (2013)[DOI]
- Nakashima H, "Clinical and radiographic predictors for unsalvageable labral tear at the time of initial hip arthroscopic management for femoroacetabular impingement", Am J Sports Med, 47, pp.2029~2037 (2019)[DOI]
- Perets I, "In revision hip arthroscopy, labral reconstruction can address a deficient labrum, but labral repair retains its role for the reparable labrum : a matched control study", Am J Sports Med, 46, pp.3437~3445 (2018)[DOI]
- Philippon MJ, "Labral preservation : outcomes following labrum augmentation versus labrum reconstruction", Arthroscopy, 34, pp.2604~2611 (2018)[DOI]
- White BJ, "Revision arthroscopic acetabular labral treatment : repair or reconstruct?", Arthroscopy, 32, pp.2513~2520 (2016)[DOI]
- White BJ, "Bilateral hip arthroscopy : direct comparison of primary acetabular labral repair and primary acetabular labral reconstruction", Arthroscopy, 34, pp.433~440 (2018)[DOI]
- White BJ, "Hip arthroscopy in patients aged 40 years and older : greater success with labral reconstruction compared with labral repair", Arthroscopy, 36, pp.2137~2144 (2020)[DOI]
- Maldonado DR, "In search of labral restoration function with hip arthroscopy : outcomes of hip labral reconstruction versus labral repair : a systematic review", Hip Int, 31, pp.704~713 (2021)[DOI]
- Herickhoff PK, "Surgical decision making for acetabular labral tears : an international perspective", Orthop J Sports Med, 6, pp.2325967118797324~ (2018)[DOI]
- Rosinsky PJ, "Determining clinically meaningful thresholds for the Nonarthritic Hip Score in patients undergoing arthroscopy for femoroacetabular impingement syndrome", Arthroscopy, 37, pp.3113~3121 (2021)[DOI]
- Wolff AB, "Management of the acetabular labrum", Clin Sports Med, 35, pp.345~360 (2016)[DOI]
- Domb BG, "Decision making for labral treatment in the hip : repair versus débridement versus reconstruction", J Am Acad Orthop Surg, 25, pp.e53~e62 (2017)[DOI]
- Westermann RW, "Trends in hip arthroscopic labral repair : An American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery database study", Arthroscopy, 35, pp.1413~1419 (2019)[DOI]
- Maldonado DR, "Hip labral reconstruction : consensus study on indications, graft type and technique among high-volume surgeons", J Hip Preserv Surg, 6, pp.41~49 (2019)[DOI]
- Domb BG, "Revision hip preservation surgery with hip arthroscopy : clinical outcomes", Arthroscopy, 30, pp.581~587 (2014)[DOI]
- Perets I, "Circumferential labral reconstruction using the knotless pull-through technique-surgical technique", Arthrosc Tech, 6, pp.e695~e698 (2017)[DOI]
