Fuzzy Cognitive Map and Bayesian Belief Network for Causal Knowledge Engineering: A Comparative Study
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Fuzzy Cognitive Map (FCM) and Bayesian Belief Network (BBN) are two major frameworks for modeling, representing and reasoning about causal knowledge. Despite their extensive use in causal knowledge engineering, there is no reported work which compares their respective roles. This paper aims to fill the gap by providing a qualitative comparison of the two frameworks through a systematic analysis based on some inherent features of the frameworks. We proposed a set of comparison criteria which covers the entire process of causal knowledge engineering, including modeling, representation, and reasoning. These criteria are usability, expressiveness, reasoning capability, formality, and soundness. The results of comparison have revealed some important facts about the characteristics of FCM and BBN, which will help to determine how FCM and BBN should be used, with respect to each other, in causal knowledge engineering.
Abstract
Fuzzy Cognitive Map (FCM) and Bayesian Belief Network (BBN) are two major frameworks for modeling, representing and reasoning about causal knowledge. Despite their extensive use in causal knowledge engineering, there is no reported work which compares their respective roles. This paper aims to fill the gap by providing a qualitative comparison of the two frameworks through a systematic analysis based on some inherent features of the frameworks. We proposed a set of comparison criteria which covers the entire process of causal knowledge engineering, including modeling, representation, and reasoning. These criteria are usability, expressiveness, reasoning capability, formality, and soundness. The results of comparison have revealed some important facts about the characteristics of FCM and BBN, which will help to determine how FCM and BBN should be used, with respect to each other, in causal knowledge engineering.
참고문헌 (40)
- A. Gopnik, "Causal Maps and Bayes Nets: A Cognitive and Computational Account of Theory-Formation", pp.117~132 (2002), The Cognitive Basis of Science, Cambridge University Press
- A. Gopnik, "A Theory of Causal Learning in Children: Causal Maps and Bayes Nets", Psychological Review, 111(1), pp.3~32 (2004)
- Z.Q. Liu, "Causation, Bayesian Networks and Cognitive Maps", ACTA Automatica Sinica, 27(4), pp.552~566 (2001)
- L. M. Deborah, "Usability Issues in Knowledge Representation Systems", Proceedings of the Fifteenth National Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Tenth Innovative Applications of Artificial Intelligence Conference, pp.608~614 (1998)
- A. Holzinger, "Usability Engineering for Software Developers", ACM Communications, 48(1), pp.71~74 (2005)
- H.J. Levesque, "Expressiveness and Tractability in Knowledge Representation and Reasoning", Computational Intelligence, 3(2), pp.78~93 (1987)
- R. Bingi, "A Framework for the Comparative Analysis and Evaluation of Knowledge Representation Schemes", Journal of Information Processing and Management, 31(2), pp.233~247 (1995)
- F. Baader, "A Formal Definition of the Expressive Power of Terminological Knowledge Representation Languages", Journal of Logic and Computation, 6(1), pp.33~54 (1996)
- S. Kendal, "An Introduction to Knowledge Engineering" (2007), Springer
- C.G.Cordell, "Formality Helps Scalability and Robustness", ACM Computing Surveys, 28(4), pp.5~5 (1996)
- S.M. Frank, "Formality Considered Harmful: Experiences, Emerging Themes, and Directions on the Use of Formal Representations in Interactive Systems", Computer Supported Cooperative Work, 8(4), pp.333~352 (1999)
- R. Axelrod, "Structure of Decision: The Cognitive Maps of Political Elites" (1976), Princeton
- B. Kosko, "Fuzzy Cognitive Maps", International Journal of Man-Machine Studies, 24(1), pp.65~75 (1986)
- B. Kosko, "Neural Networks and Fuzzy Systems: A Dynamical Systems Approach to Machine Intelligence" (1992), Prentice-Hall
- J.P. Carvalho, "Rule-Based Fuzzy Cognitive Maps and Fuzzy Cognitive Maps: A Comparative Study", Proceedings of the International Conference of the North American Fuzzy Information Processing Society, pp.115~119 (1999)
- J. Aguilar, "A Survey about Fuzzy Cognitive Maps Papers", International Journal of Computational Cognition, 3(2), pp.27~33 (2005)
- K.C. Lee, "A Fuzzy Cognitive Map-Based Bi-Directional Inference Mechanism: An Application to Stock Investment Analysis", Intelligent Systems in Accounting Finance & Management, 65(1), pp.41~57 (1997)
- Z.Q. Liu, "Contextual Fuzzy Cognitive Map for Decision Support in Geographic Information Systems", IEEE Transactions on Fuzzy Systems, 7(5), pp.495~507 (1999)
- I. Kang, "Using Fuzzy Cognitive Map for the Relationship Management in Airline Service", Expert Systems with Applications, 26(4), pp.545~555 (2004)
- F. Sumita, "A Fuzzy Cognitive Mapping Analysis of the Impacts of An Eco-Industrial Park", Journal of Intelligent and Fuzzy Systems, 15(2), pp.75~88 (2004)
- V. Georgopoulos, "Augmented Fuzzy Cognitive Maps Supplemented with Case Base Reasoning for Advanced Medical Decision Support,Soft Computing for Information Processing and Analysis Enhancing the Power of the Information Technology., Studies in Fuzziness and Soft Computing", ~ (2005)
- K.Y. Kim, "The Role of the Fuzzy Cognitive Map in Hierarchical Semantic Net Model-Based Assembly Design Decision Making", International Journal of Computer-Integrated Manufacturing
- K.Y. Kim, "The Role of the Fuzzy Cognitive Map in Hierarchical Semantic Net Model-Based Assembly Design Decision Making", International Journal of Computer-Integrated Manufacturing
- J.Pearl, "Fusion, Propagation, and Structuring in Belief Networks", Artificial Intelligence, 29(3), pp.241~288 (1986)
- J. Pearl, "Probabilistic Reasoning in Intelligent Systems: Network of Plausible Inference" (1988), Morgan Kaufmann
- E. Charniak, "Bayesian Networks Without Tears", AI Magazine, 12(4), pp.50~63 (1991)
- W.Long, "Medical Diagnosis Using A Probabilistic Causal Network", Applied Artificial Intelligence, 3(3), pp.367~383 (1989)
- E. Horvitz, "The Lumiere Project: Bayesian User Modeling for Inferring the Goals and Needs of Software Users", Proceedings of the Conference of the Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence, pp.256~265 (1998)
- C. Skaanning, "Printer Troubleshooting Using Bayesian Networks., Intelligent Problem Solving, Methodologies and Approaches", LNCS, 1821, pp.367~379 (2000)
- A. Tang, "Using Bayesian Belief Networks for Change Impact Analysis in Architecture Design", Journal of Systems and Software, 80(1), pp.127~148 (2007)
- "Hugin Expert"[URL]
- [URL]
- K.B. Korb, "Bayesian Artificial Intelligence", pp.2004, Chapman and Hall
- B.Das, "Generating Conditional Probabilities for Bayesian Networks: Easing the Knowledge Acquisition Problem", Journal CoRR, 0411034 (2004)
- S. Nadkarni, "A Bayesian Network Approach to Making Inferences in Causal Maps", European Journal of Operational Research, 128(3), pp.479~498 (2001)
- R. Kremer, "Visual Languages for Knowledge Representation", Proceedings of the Workshop on Knowledge Acquisition, Modeling and Management, pp.8~14 (1998)
- B. Kosko, "Fuzzy Systems as Universal Approximators", Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Fuzzy Systems, pp.1153~1162 (1992)
- J.A. Dickerson, "Virtual Worlds in Fuzzy Cognitive Maps", pp.498~528 (1997), Prentice Hall
- W.P. Cheah, "A Manufacturing-Environmental Model using Bayesian Belief Networks for Assembly Design Decision Support", LNAI, 4570, pp.374~383 (2007)
- K.Y. Kim, "A Framework of Assembly Design and Maintenance Analysis and Fault Diagnosis using Bayesian Belief Network and Fuzzy Cognitive Map", Proceedings of the International Conference on Flexible Automation and Intelligent Manufacturing, pp.757~764 (2007)