Nature of Data Assets and Their Protection and Exemption Measures for Analysis
0
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This study has realized the essential purpose of data assets, which is the creation of utility through the promotion of the industrial and social use of data. Furthermore, this work compared and analyzed international discussions and the legislative trends in major countries regarding the conflicting concepts of “data protection (ownership)” and “immunity for data analysis,” which are the most controversial issues, to present appropriate alternatives. Unlike previous studies that mainly addressed various theoretical discussions centering around data ownership, this study will help data leaders and latecomers in that it provides legislative guidelines for data protection and immunity for analysis. This study proposes the necessity of and measures for “appropriate legal protection” regarding data, and as an alternative, to maintain “data protection based on the doctrine of unfair competition.” Japan has already prepared such enactments, while South Korea has also been preparing a legal framework for the appropriate protection of data and development of the data industry. Meanwhile, this study considered the interests of copyright holders, and simultaneously, the practical difficulty in obtaining the consent of all copyright holders for works such as sounds, videos, and images used for big data analysis.
Abstract
This study has realized the essential purpose of data assets, which is the creation of utility through the promotion of the industrial and social use of data. Furthermore, this work compared and analyzed international discussions and the legislative trends in major countries regarding the conflicting concepts of “data protection (ownership)” and “immunity for data analysis,” which are the most controversial issues, to present appropriate alternatives. Unlike previous studies that mainly addressed various theoretical discussions centering around data ownership, this study will help data leaders and latecomers in that it provides legislative guidelines for data protection and immunity for analysis. This study proposes the necessity of and measures for “appropriate legal protection” regarding data, and as an alternative, to maintain “data protection based on the doctrine of unfair competition.” Japan has already prepared such enactments, while South Korea has also been preparing a legal framework for the appropriate protection of data and development of the data industry. Meanwhile, this study considered the interests of copyright holders, and simultaneously, the practical difficulty in obtaining the consent of all copyright holders for works such as sounds, videos, and images used for big data analysis.
참고문헌 (30)
- Asbroeck, B. V., "White paper building the european data economy data ownership" (2017), Bird&Bird
- Banterle, F., "Data ownership in the data economy: A European dilemma", EU Internet Law in the Digital Era, 199~225 (2020)
- Bincoletto, G., "Italian DPA balancing data protection and freedom of expression: Essentiality and Fairness as key principles", European Data Protection Law Review, 7(1), pp.554~559 (2021)
- Checkland, P., "Information, systems, and information systems: Making sense of the field" (1997), John Wiley & Sons
- Rapport d'activité 2017: Protéger les données personnelles, Accompagner l'innovation. Préserver les libertés individuelles, "Commission Nationale Informatique & Libertés", DILA, ~ (2017)
- Contreras, J. L., "Patient data ownership", JAMA, 319(9), pp.935~937 (2018)
- Dorner, M., "Big data und dateneigentum", CR, 9, pp.617~628 (2014)
- France National Digital Council, "Neutralité des plateformes", Conseil National du Numérique, ~ (2014)
- Gantz, J., "Extracting value from chaos", IDC IVIEW, 1142, pp.1~12 (2011)
- Garstka, H., "Strukturwandel der privatheit, wovon–für wen–wozu, systemdenken wider die diktatur der daten 2014", Hermann von Helmholtz-Zentrum für Kulturtechnik, ~ (2014)
- Graziadei, M., "Comparative property law: Global perspectives" (2017), Elgar
- Herbert, Z., "Daten als wirtschaftsgut–Überlegungen zu einem, recht des datenerzeugers", CR, 31, pp.137~146 (2015)
- Hoeren, T., "Data ownership is dead: Long live data ownership", European Intellectual Property Review, 40(6), pp.347~348 (2018)
- Hofheinz, P., "Making Europe a data economy: A new framework for free movement of data in the digital age", The Lisbon Council Asbl, ~ (2017)
- Jeffrey, H. M., "Managing intellectual assets in the digital age" (2003), Artech House
- Jones, C., "Nonrivalry and the economics of data", American Economic Review, 110(9), pp.2819~2858 (2020)
- Koji, O., "Trade secrets and limited provision data of intellectual deliverables peculiar to AI appropriateness", Legal Times, 91(8), pp.24~32 (2019)
- "A study on legal protection of big data. IMES Discussion Paper, No. 2019-J-5" (2021)[URL]
- Lee, D. H., "Issues and challenges in data utilization for artificial intelligence development", Proceedings of the 7th Korea Legislation Research Institute(KLRI) Regulatory Innovation Legislation Forum on 2020 (2020)
- 이동진, "데이터 소유권(Data Ownership), 개념과 그 실익", 정보법학, 22(3), pp.219~242 (2018), 한국정보법학회
- Lipton, J., "Mixed metaphors in cyberspace: Property in information and information systems", Loy. Univ. Chi. L. J, 35(1), pp.235~274 (2003)
- Lohsse, S., "Trading data in the digital economy: Legal concepts and tools(Münster Colloquia on EU Law and the Digital Economy III)", pp.2017, Nomos
- Loshin, D., "Enterprise knowledge management: The data quality approach" (2001), Morgan Kaufmann
- Manyika, J., "Big data: The next frontier for innovation, competition, and productivity", McKinsey Global Institute, ~ (2011)
- "Expert workshop on enhanced access to data: Reconciling risks and benefits of data re-use" (2021)[URL]
- Ritter, J., "Regulating data as property: A new construct for moving forward", Duke Law & Tech R, 220, pp.226~245 (2018)
- Saint-Aubin, T., "Les nouveaux enjeux juridiques des donnéess (big data, web sémantique et linked data): Les droits de l'opérateur de données sur son patrimoine numérique informationnel", IRJS, 102, pp.94~101 (2014)
- 손승우, "著作權과 쉬링크랩 라이선스 상의 S", W Reverse Engineering의 法的 地位, 2003, pp.14, 193~224[DOI]
- 손승우, "Legal Challenges to AI･Big Data Utilization", 스포츠엔터테인먼트와 법, 22(3), pp.176~194 (2019), 한국스포츠엔터테인먼트법학회
- Tommaso, F., "An alternative to data ownership: Managing access to non-personal data through the commons", Global Jurist, 21(1), pp.181~210 (2021)