고린도후서 11:23-12:10의 네 가지 주제와 바울의 거짓사도 논쟁
Four Topics in Second Corinthians 11:23-12:10 and Paul’s False Apostle Controversy
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Four Topics in Second Corinthians 11:23-12:10 and Paul’s False Apostle Controversy Chulhong Kim (Presbyterian University and Theological Seminary) In the middle of the controversy against his opponents, reaching its climax in 2 Cor 11:13, where he labels them ‘false apostles’ and subsequently ‘servants of Satan,’ Paul unexpectedly turns our attention to his sufferings(2 Cor 11:23–30), and then to his escape from officers of King Aretas(2 Cor 11:31–33), who tracked him down as far as Damascus, a city located outside the border of Nabatean Kingdom at the time. Right after that episode, in 12:1–10, he mentions his having been taken up to the third heaven and suffering from the thorn in his flesh. What does Paul have in mind when he mentions four seemingly unrelated topics? What would have been the integrating motive behind them, especially in relation to his debate against Corinthian opponents in 2 Corinthians? This study attempts to answer these questions by reinterpreting the four topics, which are his catalogue of sufferings, his escape from Damascus, his trip to the third heaven, and finally, the physical problems ensuing from it, in the context of false prophet controversies in the Old Testament. Placing Paul’'s false apostle controversy in the context of the Old Testament false prophet traditions gives us an opportunity to discover a consistent thrust running through all of the four episodes. False apostle controversy is a dynamic dimension of 2 Corinthians, even though it is often hidden from its ordinary occasional readers. However, it certainly provides decisive clues by which we may view the letter as an integrated whole. The seemingly loosely-related four themes are in fact quite closely interrelated. The unifying motive lying behind these issues is the controversy surrounding false apostles, prominent in the Old and New Testament alike. Paul’s defense of his apostleship is best framed against the Old Testament background that true prophets persevere through suffering, are rescued from harm by God himself, receive ecstatic visions, and experience weakness not as a divine punishment but as a gift.
Abstract
Four Topics in Second Corinthians 11:23-12:10 and Paul’s False Apostle Controversy Chulhong Kim (Presbyterian University and Theological Seminary) In the middle of the controversy against his opponents, reaching its climax in 2 Cor 11:13, where he labels them ‘false apostles’ and subsequently ‘servants of Satan,’ Paul unexpectedly turns our attention to his sufferings(2 Cor 11:23–30), and then to his escape from officers of King Aretas(2 Cor 11:31–33), who tracked him down as far as Damascus, a city located outside the border of Nabatean Kingdom at the time. Right after that episode, in 12:1–10, he mentions his having been taken up to the third heaven and suffering from the thorn in his flesh. What does Paul have in mind when he mentions four seemingly unrelated topics? What would have been the integrating motive behind them, especially in relation to his debate against Corinthian opponents in 2 Corinthians? This study attempts to answer these questions by reinterpreting the four topics, which are his catalogue of sufferings, his escape from Damascus, his trip to the third heaven, and finally, the physical problems ensuing from it, in the context of false prophet controversies in the Old Testament. Placing Paul’'s false apostle controversy in the context of the Old Testament false prophet traditions gives us an opportunity to discover a consistent thrust running through all of the four episodes. False apostle controversy is a dynamic dimension of 2 Corinthians, even though it is often hidden from its ordinary occasional readers. However, it certainly provides decisive clues by which we may view the letter as an integrated whole. The seemingly loosely-related four themes are in fact quite closely interrelated. The unifying motive lying behind these issues is the controversy surrounding false apostles, prominent in the Old and New Testament alike. Paul’s defense of his apostleship is best framed against the Old Testament background that true prophets persevere through suffering, are rescued from harm by God himself, receive ecstatic visions, and experience weakness not as a divine punishment but as a gift.
참고문헌 (57)
- Murray J. Harris, "The Second Epistle to the Corinthians (NIGTC)" (2005), Eerdmans
- Karl Olav Sandnes, "Paul—One of the Prophets?: A Contribution to the Apostle’s Self-Understanding" (1991), Mohr
- Contra Jacob Jervell, "The Unknown Paul: Essays on Luke-Acts and Early Christian History" (1984), Augsburg
- Rudolf Bultmann, "The Second Letter to the Corinthians", pp.231~ (1984), Augsburg
- Louis Ginzberg, "The Legends of the Jews (7 vols)", pp.262~ (1909), Jewish Publication Society of America
- Gerald L. Keown, "Jeremiah 26–52", pp.21~22 (1995), Word
- Jack R. Lundbom, "Jeremiah 21–36: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary", pp.290~ (2004), Doubleday
- Robert Jewett, "Dating Paul's Life" (1979), SCM Press
- C. H. Turner, "Dictionary of the Bible, vol. 1", pp.416~417 (1963), Scribner
- E. F. F. Bishop, "Does Aretas Belong in 2 Corinthians or Galatians?", ExpTim, 64, pp.188~189 (1953)
- H. L. Goudge, "The Second Epistle to the Corinthians", pp.110~ (1927), Methuen
- Alfred Plummer, "A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Second Epistle of St. Paul to the Corinthians (ICC)", pp.333~ (1915), T&T Clark
- Ralph P. Martin, "2 Corinthians", pp.384~ (1986), Word
- E. A. Judge, "Paul’s Boasting in Relation to Contemporary Professional Practice", ABR, 16, pp.47~ (1968)
- S. H. Travis, "Paul's Boasting in 2 Corinthians 10–12", SE, 6, pp.530~ (1973)
- C. M. Edwards, "Tyche at Corinth", Hesperia, 59, pp.529~542 (1990)
- Ben Witherington III, "Conflict and Community in Corinth: A Socio-Rhetorical Commentary on 1 and 2 Corinthians", pp.458~459 (1995), Eerdmans
- 김철홍, "바울이 아라비아로 간 까닭은?: 갈라디아서 1:17에 나타난 바울의 선지자적 자의식"", 신약논단, 16(1), pp.173~198 (2009), 한국신약학회
- Seyoon Kim, "Paul and the New Perspective: Second Thoughts on the Origin of Paul's Gospel" (2002), Eerdmans
- Margaret E. Thrall, "A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Second Epistle to the Corinthians, vol. 2 (ICC)" (2000), T&T Clark
- Robert H. Strachan, "The Second Epistle of Paul to the Corinthians (MNTC)", pp.31~ (1935), Hodder and Stoughton
- C. K. Barrett, "A Commentary on the Second Epistle to the Corinthians", pp.310~ (1987), Hendrickson
- J. M. Scott, "Paul and the Scriptures of Israel", pp.187~220 (1993), JSOT Press
- Andrew T. Lincoln, "Paradise Now and Not Yet", pp.79~ (1981), Cambridge University Press
- F. F. Bruce, "Was Paul a Mystic?", RTR, 34 (1975)
- Peter Schäfer, "New Testament and Hekhalot Literature: The Journey into Heaven in Paul and in Merkavah Mysticism", JJS, 35, pp.22~ (1984)
- Thomas Stegman, "Second Corinthians", pp.267~ (2010), Baker Academic
- T. H. Robinson, "Prophecy and the Prophets in Ancient Israel", pp.50~51 (1953), Duckworth
- T. H. Robinson, "The Ecstatic Element in Old Testament Prophecy", The Expositor, 8th series, 21(123), pp.217~238 (1921)
- Sigmund Mowinckel, "Ecstatic Experience and Rational Elaboration in Old Testament Prophecy", AcOr, 13, pp.264~291 (1935)
- G. Widengren, "Literary and Psychological Aspects of the Hebrew Prophets", pp.98~120 (1948), Lundequist
- J. Lindblom, "Prophecy in Ancient Israel", pp.47~65 (1962), Muhlenberg
- Ronald E. Clement, "One Hundred Years of Old Testament Interpretation", pp.54~ (1976), Westminster Press
- H. Gunkel, "The Secret Experiences of the Prophets", The Expositor, 9(1), pp.427~432 (1924)
- E. T. Mullen Jr., "The Divine Council in Canaanite and Early Hebrew Literature" (1980), Scholars Press
- Patrick D. Miller, Jr., "Genesis 1–11: Studies in Structure & Theme", pp.9~26 (1978), Department of Biblical Studies
- H. Wheeler Robinson, "The Council of Yahweh", JTS, 45, pp.151~157 (1944)
- Edwin C. Kingsbury, "The Prophets and the Council of Yahweh", JBL, 83, pp.280~ (1964)
- Paul, "Amos", 112~
- James L. Mays, "Amos (OTL)", pp.62~ (1969), Westminster Press
- Raymond E. Brown, "The Pre-Christian Semitic Concept of ‘Mystery’", CBQ, 20 (1958)
- Lester L. Grabbe, "Priests, Prophets, Diviners, Sages: A Socio-Historical Study of Religious Specialists in Ancient Israel", pp.114~ (1995), Trinity Press International
- J. Camery-Hoggatt, "Dictionary of Paul and His Letters", pp.965~ (1993), IVP
- J. S. Hanson, "Dreams and Visions in the Graeco-Roman World and Early Christianity", ANRW II, 23(2), pp.1395~1427 (1980)
- F. F. Bruce, "1 and 2 Corinthians (New Century Bible Commentary)", pp.83~ (1971), Oliphants
- Barrett, "First Epistle", 200~
- Hans Conzelmann, "1 Corinthians: A Commentary on the First Epistle to the Corinthians (Hermeneia)", pp.152~ (1975), Fortress
- Gordon D. Fee, "The First Epistle to the Corinthians (NICNT)", pp.395~ (1987), Eerdmans
- 조충현, "다니엘 10장의 관점에서 본 바울의 다메섹 체험", 신약연구, 9(4), pp.683~714 (2010), 한국복음주의신약학회[DOI]
- H. Windisch, "Der zweite Korintherbrief", pp.368~ (1970)
- Alan Segal, "Paul the Convert: The Apostolate and Apostasy of Saul the Pharisee", pp.37~ (1990), Yale University Press
- Gilles Quispel, "Ezekiel 1:26 in Jewish Mysticism and Gnosis", VC, 34, pp.8~ (1980)
- Ludwig Koehler, "The Hebrew ＆ Aramaic Lexicon of the Old Testament", pp.745~ (2000), Brill
- Günther Bornkamm, "TDNT 4", pp.815~816
- L. L. Welborn, "End to Enmity: Paul and the “Wrongdoer” of Second Corinthians", pp.187~208 (2011), De Gruyter
- 김철홍, "바울은 제정신이 아니다?(고후 11:23): 바울의 영적 근원에 대한 논쟁", 장신논단, 32, pp.11~43 (2008)
- 이민규, "사도바울의 세 번째 하늘 체험－신비주의 종교체험의 관점에서 본 고린도후서 12:1-4", 신약논단, 14(1), pp.65~98 (2007), 한국신약학회