국제조세회피 행위에 대한 조세법적 검토
Consideration of the System of Taxation in International Tax Avoidance
2
조회
0
다운로드
3
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Recently with the unification of international trade market and fueling of opening of our finance market, the taxation avoidance is increasing rapidly using the gap between the tax law system of each country and tax agreement. The types can be classified into treaty shopping, transfer pricing taxation and loaning that excessively greater than the capital. The basis for taxation response for tax avoidance is on the principal of material taxation. Although in case the 3rd party in involved in the international trade relations, the ultimate beneficial owner becomes the tax obligator to apply the taxation. This material taxation principle is realized on the frame law on national taxes and the law for the coordination of international tax affairs. The treaty shopping is a avoidance of taxation by involving the paper company in the 3rd country using the blind spot of the taxation treaties between Korea and other countries. The Cayman Islands and Bermuda regions are commonly used. As a counter plan for this, consider the paper company as one conduit company and impose the tax to the real supremacy. The transfer pricing taxation is a method of tax avoidance that transfers the income by appropriating the price higher or lower than the regular price in trade with a special participator in abroad. For this, when there are no special relations, there is a method of imposing the tax based on the trading price between the company. Also, the method which report the price in advance called APA (advanced pricing agreement) is being used. There is a no inclusion of deficit for the interest considered as a dividend, so called thin capitalization. This is a method for tax avoidance that pays excess interest price after loaning the capital by excessively large scale loaning than the capital rather than receiving share investment from the investors. For this, the interest payment for more than 3 folds (6 folds in financial sector) of the original capital is considered as the share to impose tax. Due to the increase of interdependence of international economy and complication of trade and invest trade, the environment surrounding the problem of international tax avoidance is becoming radical and complicated day by day. Therefore, the study on this matter should be a consideration for all of us whether it is the taxation law or economic administration law.
Abstract
Recently with the unification of international trade market and fueling of opening of our finance market, the taxation avoidance is increasing rapidly using the gap between the tax law system of each country and tax agreement. The types can be classified into treaty shopping, transfer pricing taxation and loaning that excessively greater than the capital. The basis for taxation response for tax avoidance is on the principal of material taxation. Although in case the 3rd party in involved in the international trade relations, the ultimate beneficial owner becomes the tax obligator to apply the taxation. This material taxation principle is realized on the frame law on national taxes and the law for the coordination of international tax affairs. The treaty shopping is a avoidance of taxation by involving the paper company in the 3rd country using the blind spot of the taxation treaties between Korea and other countries. The Cayman Islands and Bermuda regions are commonly used. As a counter plan for this, consider the paper company as one conduit company and impose the tax to the real supremacy. The transfer pricing taxation is a method of tax avoidance that transfers the income by appropriating the price higher or lower than the regular price in trade with a special participator in abroad. For this, when there are no special relations, there is a method of imposing the tax based on the trading price between the company. Also, the method which report the price in advance called APA (advanced pricing agreement) is being used. There is a no inclusion of deficit for the interest considered as a dividend, so called thin capitalization. This is a method for tax avoidance that pays excess interest price after loaning the capital by excessively large scale loaning than the capital rather than receiving share investment from the investors. For this, the interest payment for more than 3 folds (6 folds in financial sector) of the original capital is considered as the share to impose tax. Due to the increase of interdependence of international economy and complication of trade and invest trade, the environment surrounding the problem of international tax avoidance is becoming radical and complicated day by day. Therefore, the study on this matter should be a consideration for all of us whether it is the taxation law or economic administration law.
참고문헌 (36)
- 최근의 지역별, 통화별 국제투자동향, In 국민계정, "최승필", 108~125 (2006)
- 김석태, "일반규정 방식의 입법에 의한 방지", 한국정책과학학회보, 5(1), pp.101~
- "대판 00.2.11, 97누13184", ~ (2000)
- "대판 93.6.8, 93누 6744", ~ (1993)
- 김백영, "지방세법상 조세회피방지에 관한 고찰", 공법학연구, 7(3), pp.429~450 (2006), 한국비교공법학회
- 홍기용, "국제조세의 회피사례 및 규제방안에 관한 연구", 회계연구, pp.61~ (2003)
- 임승순, "조세법", pp.990~ (2007), 박영사
- 홍정선, "행정법원론(하), 제13판", pp.825~ (2005), 박영사
- "대법원 판례 (2001. 1.19 선고 97다 21604)", ~ (2001)
- "국제조세조정에 관한 법률 제2조 제1항", ~
- 4석종현, "일반행정법(하), 제11판", pp.748~ (2005), 삼영사
- "국조법 제2조 제2항", ~
- 박일렬, "국제조세와 지방세의 관련문제에 대한 검토", 지방재정연구, (2), pp.222~ (1998)
- 大崎 滿, "國際的租稅回避, - その對抗策を中心として", pp.43~ (1990), 大藏省
- 안창남, "국제조세론", pp.91~93 (2004), 세학사
- 이용섭, "국제조세", pp.735~736 (2003), 세경사
- OECD, "Progress on Identifying and Eliminating Harmful Tax Practices" (2000)
- 룩셈부르크 금융센터의 발전배경, "한국은행", ~, pp.해외경제정보(2005-52) (2005)
- "국조법 제17조 제2항", ~
- "국조법 제18조 제1항", ~
- "한겨레신문, 2007.6.28일자, 20면", ~ (2007)
- "문화일보, 2007.6.28일자, 16면", ~
- 파트너십 과세제도 도입방안, "안종석", 한국조세연구원, 5~ (2007)
- 재정경제부, "파트너십 과세제도 도입추진", 보도참고자료 2007.9, ~ (2007)
- "조선일보, 2007년4월20일 B1면", ~
- "경향신문, 2007년 7월17일자, 17면", ~
- 국세청, "조세피난처(TAX HAVEN)를 이용한 조세회피 실태와 규제대책", ~ (2002)
- "IRS Accepts Settlement Offer in Largest Transfer Pricing Dispute" (2007)[URL]
- "서울경제신문, 2007년 5월 21일 1면", ~ (2007)
- 서희열, "우리나라 국제조세관련 과세제도의 개편방안", 세무와회계저널, 6(3), pp.55~81 (2005), 한국세무학회
- "대판 01. 10. 23, 99두 3423", ~ (2001)
- 홍범교, "무형자산의 국제이전가격세제에 대한 소고", 재정포럼, pp.10~ (2007)
- "국조법 제6조 제2항 및 국조법 시행령 11조의 2 제1항", ~
- 국제적 조세회피 방지를 위한 연구 - 조세피난처의 이용과 조세조약 남용방지를 중심으로 -, "윤현석", 한국법제연구원, 47~, pp.현안분석 2005-7 (2005)
- 국세청, "외국인투자기업 납세안내, 제5장 과소자본과세제도(4-5면)", ~ (2004)
- "OECD 국세청장회의의 제1주제(국제조세회피행위 방지대책)", 국세청, 보도 자료(2005.9), ~ (2005)
