본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

자원 소유권의 귀속 -석유와 가스를 중심으로-

The Ownership of Mineral - Focused on Oil and Gas -

류권홍
법학연구소 (The Institute of Legal Studies Konkuk University)|2009.06|원광법학|제25권 제2호|pp. 35-64

0

조회

0

다운로드

5

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

국유화해외자원개발Oil and Gas자원 소유권석유․가스자원 주권경성 자원연성 자원천상에서 연옥까지의 원칙선점의 원칙헌법 제120조.Ownership of natural resourcesHard mineralSoft mineralDevelopment of minerals in overseasSovereignty over mineral resourcesArticle 120 of the Korea ConstitutionAd coelum doctrine(Heaven to Hell)Rule of Capture.

초록

Abstract

After the time when oil and gas replaced the position of coal as 'the king' of fundamental energy sources required for the industrial society since World War Ⅱ, human- being has been called as 'hydro-carbon man'. Because of environmental problem and its scarcity in amount, however in recent years, many nations, representatively America and Korea, have been trying to make change the fundamental sources from fossil fuel society to hydrogen society with the strong investment in green energy such as solar, or alternative energy. In spite of this effort, it is the important fact that the dependance on oil and gas will be constant in at least 20 years. There are variety kinds of risks in oil and gas development such as political, legal, financial problems, and culture-social differences in world wide operation. So, It is natural consequence that development of oil and gas is the most difficult and risky project. In order to help to make risks minimize in legal aspect, this article focused on one issue; the ownership of oil and gas as the representative of all kinds of minerals. The study on sovereignty over natural resources, the practical implication of mineral ownership issue, and comparative research on the mineral(or oil and gas) Acts of representative States are the main topics discussed in the article. The early concession system gave the privileges with long term over 60 years, wide area covering almost the whole country, ownership of oil and gas in nature, and exclusive right to explore, develop to the international developers, including 'seven sisters'. This system caused serious side effects on host countries met its final with the General Assembly resolution 1803 (XVII) of 14 December 1962, "Permanent sovereignty over natural resources" and nationalization trend in South America and Middle East. Even though sovereignty over the oil and gas became an international rule, some countries such as America has kept the principle of personal ownership of land owner. This is totally different from the mineral law system of England and Australia having the same legal system of common law. Since the decision of the Court of Exchequer in 1567 and the Acts relating to minerals, oil and gas in these two countries belong to His or Her Majesty, the King. The problem in relation to the ownership of oil and gas in Korea is that there is no explicit provisions in mineral Acts, even in the Constitution on the ownership issue. It will be better for the provisional developer to give clear legal rules on who is the owner of oil and gas, and the definitions on what is oil and gas, or petroleum. On top of that, it is required to be upgraded the policy on oil and gas development in order to make the process and the conditions for getting the permission for the development clear and transparent. These works will contribute to achieving the national goal for securing energy security.

참고문헌 (40)

  1. 권영성, "헌법학원론" (2008), 법문사
  2. 에너지경제연구원, "주간 국제유가 및 시장 동향(212호)", ~ (2009)
  3. 염명천, "에너지 시장, 산업 & 정책", 한국생산성본부, ~ (2006)
  4. 이경한, "광업권 관리제도 개선 연구", 한국지질자원연구원, ~ (2004)
  5. 新고유가 대응전략연구: 유가상승의 원인과 파급효과 분석’, "이달석", 에너지경제연구원, ~, pp.기본보고서 07 (2007)
  6. 이연승, "광업법축조연구", 한국동력자원연구소, ~ (1998)
  7. 허 영, "한국헌법론" (2008), 박영사
  8. Association of International Petroleum Negotiators, "Host Government Contract Handbook", for the International Petroleum Industry, n1 (1999)
  9. Bryan A. Garner, "Black's Law Dictionary", ~ (2004)
  10. Daniel Yergin, "The Prize: the Epic Question for Oil", Money and Power, ~ (1991)
  11. Dr. Atef Suleiman, "The Oil Experience of the United Arab Emirates and its Legal Framework", J. Energy & Natural Resources Law, 6 (1988)
  12. Ernest E. Smith, "A Fifty-Year Perspective on World Petroleum Arrangements", Texas International Law Journal, 24 (1989)
  13. Ernst E. Smith, "International Petroleum Transaction", ~ (2000)
  14. Hazel Fox, "Joint Development of Offshore Oil And Gas", ~ (1990)
  15. Jan H. Kalicki, "'Introduction: The Need to Integrate Energy and Foreign Policy'", Energy & Security, ~ (2005)
  16. John P. Williams, "'Legal Reform in Mining: Past, Present and Future'", International and Comparative Mineral Law and Policy: Trends, and Prospects, ~ (2005)
  17. Jerome J. Bensing, "'Due Diligence in Foreign Countries : The Landman's Role'", ANNUAL INSTITUTE PROCEEDINGS, 43 (1997), Rocky Mountain Mineral Law Institute
  18. John, S. Lowe, "Oil and Gas Law", ~ (2003)
  19. Leonardo Maugeri, "The Age of Oil", ~ (2006)
  20. Lowe, Bruce M. Kramer, "International Petroleum Transaction", ~ (2000)
  21. Michelle, "The Model Surface Use and Mineral Development Accommodation Act: Easy Easements for Mining Interests", American Law Review, 42 (1993)
  22. Michael Crommelin, "Austraian Mineral Law as a Resource Management Regime", Australian Journal of Forensic Sciences, 14 (1981)
  23. Michael Crommelin, "Resources Law and Public Policy", University of Western Australia Law Review, 15 (1983)
  24. Norman J. Hyne, "Dictionary of Petroleum Exploration" (2006), Drilling & Production
  25. Plexus Energy Ltd, "Expropriation of Oil and Gas Investments: Historical", Legal and Economic Perspectives in a New Age of Resource Nationalism, ~ (2008)
  26. Rex J. Zedalis, "Distribution of Oil and Gas Earnings Under the Proposed Iraqi Revenue Sharing Law: Legal Complications and the Kurdistan Region", OGEL, 3 (2008)
  27. Rovert Pritchard, "'Safeguards for Foreign Investment in Mining'", International and Comparative Mineral Law and Policy; Trends and Prospects, ~ (2005)
  28. Sakmar, Susan L, "The status of the draft Iraq oil and gas law", Houston Journal of International Law, ~ (2008)
  29. William F. Martin, "The International Energy Agency", 'Energy & Security, ~ (2005)
  30. "Del Monte Mining & Mining Co. v. Lase Chance Mining & Milling Co. 171 U.S. 55", ~ (1898)
  31. "Earl of Lonsdale v Attorney General", All ER, 3, pp.579~ (1982)
  32. "Edwards v. Lachman 534 P.2d 670", ~ (1974)
  33. "Kelly v. Ohio Oil Co. 49 N.E. 399", ~ (1897)
  34. "The Case of Mines", Eng. Rep, 75, pp.472~477
  35. "COASTAL WATERS (STATE POWERS) ACT 1980"[URL]
  36. "Iraq Constitution"[URL]
  37. "Mineral Resources (Sustainable Development) Act 1990"[URL]
  38. "OFFSHORE MINERALS ACT 1994"[URL]
  39. "Petroleum Act 1998"[URL]
  40. "U.N.G.A. Res 1809 (ⅩⅤⅡ)"[URL]

관련 논문AI추천

국제법상 월경자원의 처리에 관한 고찰 -해저석유 및 가스자원을 중심으로-이용희한국해양과학기술원 · Ocean and Polar Research2007 · 제29권 제2호카자흐스탄의 지하자원 사용권 법제 -생산물분배계약법을 중심으로-박원석법학연구원 · 法學論文集2009 · 제33권 제2호월경천연자원 개발의 법규강보석한국해사법학회 · 해사법연구2006 · 제18권 제2호석유ㆍ가스전 개발에서의 양허계약류권홍국제거래법학회 · 국제거래법연구2010 · 제19권 제2호브라질 석유자원개발의 법률제도와 개정논의에 대한 소고조희문한국라틴아메리카학회 · 라틴아메리카연구2009 · 제22권 제1호환경권과 소유권론이승우한국환경법학회 · 환경법연구2005 · 제27권 제4호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (16건)

표현증명 -독일도로교통법상에 있어서의 표현증명을 중심으로-반흥식pp. 9-34미국법상 온라인 라이센스 계약의 유효성이경규pp. 65-88변론종결 후의 승계인에 대한 기판력 · 집행력의 확장이정환pp. 89-111지주회사에서 주주의 법적 이익보호와 이사의 책임문제황근수pp. 113-140대집행의 요건김성원pp. 141-164
원문 보기