Marxism with Korean Characteristics Re-reading the Marxist Analyses of Japanese Colonialism in Korea by Korean Diasporic Revolutionaries in the USSR in the 1920-30s
0
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The current article deals with a forgotten part of the intellectual genealogy of ‘colonial exploitation theory’ (sut’allon) in Korea – namely with the contribution made by Soviet-Korean activists and researchers of the 1920s and 1930s in formulating this theory in its application to the Korean realities. Initially, this theory was built by Lenin in 1916 on the basis of the pre-existing liberal critiques of imperialism and colonialism. According to Lenin, imperialist colonialism aimed at acquisition of resource extraction bases and captive markets which, in turn, could help to buy off the ‘labour aristocracy’ of the imperialist metropoles via sharing the ‘colonial super-profits’ with it. Following this logic, such diasporic Soviet-Korean revolutionaries as Pak Chinsun or Nam Manch’un described in the 1920s Japanese colonialism in Korea as a process of exploiting the colony by extracting cheap rice and minerals from there while dumping Japanese consumer goods on the captive colonial market. In the 1930s, Valentin Kim-Serebryakov built further on this analysis, describing Japanese domination of Korean banking and industry as well as geopolitical considerations-driven industrialization in the northern parts of Korea. This theory, pioneered in Korea proper by such Communist economists as Pae Sŏngnyong in the 1920s, was further systemized by Moscow-educated Kim Seyong and his collaborator, YiYŏsŏng, in the 1930s on the vast statistical material. It retained a status of orthodoxy even in anti-communist South Korea until the early 1990s. However, the Leninist roots of this theory were comfortably forgotten and the contributions of Soviet-Korean revolutionaries were too erased from South (and North) Korean public memory.
Abstract
The current article deals with a forgotten part of the intellectual genealogy of ‘colonial exploitation theory’ (sut’allon) in Korea – namely with the contribution made by Soviet-Korean activists and researchers of the 1920s and 1930s in formulating this theory in its application to the Korean realities. Initially, this theory was built by Lenin in 1916 on the basis of the pre-existing liberal critiques of imperialism and colonialism. According to Lenin, imperialist colonialism aimed at acquisition of resource extraction bases and captive markets which, in turn, could help to buy off the ‘labour aristocracy’ of the imperialist metropoles via sharing the ‘colonial super-profits’ with it. Following this logic, such diasporic Soviet-Korean revolutionaries as Pak Chinsun or Nam Manch’un described in the 1920s Japanese colonialism in Korea as a process of exploiting the colony by extracting cheap rice and minerals from there while dumping Japanese consumer goods on the captive colonial market. In the 1930s, Valentin Kim-Serebryakov built further on this analysis, describing Japanese domination of Korean banking and industry as well as geopolitical considerations-driven industrialization in the northern parts of Korea. This theory, pioneered in Korea proper by such Communist economists as Pae Sŏngnyong in the 1920s, was further systemized by Moscow-educated Kim Seyong and his collaborator, YiYŏsŏng, in the 1930s on the vast statistical material. It retained a status of orthodoxy even in anti-communist South Korea until the early 1990s. However, the Leninist roots of this theory were comfortably forgotten and the contributions of Soviet-Korean revolutionaries were too erased from South (and North) Korean public memory.
참고문헌 (60)
- An, Pyŏngjik, "Kŭndae Chosŏn Kongŏphwa ŭi Yŏn’gu, 1930-1945nyŏn (Research on Industrialization in Modern Korea, 1930-1945)" (1993), Ilchogak
- Anonymous, "Pyŏngjung P’igo Posŏk ŭro Chaep’anso Tangguk e Kyosŏp(Negotiations with the Juridical Authorities on the Release of the Accused on Bail due to Illness)", Chosŏn Ilbo, ~ (1927)
- Anonymous, "Kharakteristika (Assessment)", RGASPI F. 495 op. 228 d. 472 l. 020v, ~ (1933)
- Archer, Bob, "Second Congress of the Communist International: Minutes of the Proceedings. Vol.1" (1977), New Park Publications
- Baylis, John, "The Globalization of World Politics: An Introduction to International Relations" (2020), Oxford University Press
- Ch’oe, Hojin, "Kŭndae Han’guk Kyŏngjesa (Modern Korean Economic History)" (1973), Sŏmundang
- Cho, Kijun, "Han’guk Chabonjuŭi Sŏngnipsa ron (On the Formation of Capitalism in Korea)" (1977), Taewangsa
- 전명혁, "1920년 코민테른 2차대회 시기 朴鎭淳의 민족？식민지문제 인식", 한국사연구, (134), pp.195~219 (2006), 한국사연구회
- Chŏn, Sŏktam, "Minjung Chosŏnsa (People’s History of Korea)" (1989), Pŏm’usa
- Somyŏng Publishing, , 2020
- Chung, Young-Iob, "Korea under Siege, 1876-1945: Capital Formation and Economic Transformation" (2006), Oxford University Press
- Haithcox, John Patrick, "M. N. Roy and the Comintern: The Controversy Over Colonial Policy" (1959), University of California
- Haithcox, John Patrick, "Communism and Nationalism in India: M.N. Roy and Comintern Policy, 1920-1939" (1971), Princeton University Press
- 홍종욱, "주변부의 근대－남북한의 식민지 반봉건론을 다시 생각한다－", 사이間SAI, (17), pp.181~219 (2014), 국제한국문학문화학회
- 임경석, "반식민주의 역사인식과 마르크스주의 - 박진순의 『개벽』 기고문을 중심으로 -", 사림, (56), pp.37~66 (2016), 수선사학회
- In, Chŏngsik, "Chōsen no Nōgyō Kikō Bunseki (An Analysis of the Agrarian Structures in Korea)" (1937), Paegyangsa
- In, Chŏngsik, "Pando Kyŏngje esŏ Chŏmhanŭn Chosŏnin Kiŏp ŭi Hyŏnse (The Current Position of the Korean-owned Businesses in the Peninsular Economy)", Samch’ŏlli, 12(9), pp.70~75 (1940)
- Shirinya, Kirill, "VKP(b), Komintern i Koreya,. 1918-1941 (All-Russian Communist Party of Bolsheviks, Comintern and Korea)", pp.655~670 (2007), ROSSPEN
- Jacobson, Jon, "When the Soviet Union Entered World Politics" (1994), University of California Press
- Kay, Geoffrey, "Development and Underdevelopment: A Marxist Analysis" (1982), Macmillan Press
- Kim, Kyŏng’il, "Cheguk ŭi Sidae wa Tongasia Yŏndae (The Era of the Empires and East Asian Solidarity)" (2011), Ch’angbi
- Kim, Nangnyŏn, "Ilcheha Han’guk Kyŏngje (Korean Economy under the Japanese Imperialism)" (2003), Haenaem
- Kim, Tongmyŏng, "Chibae wa Chŏhang, kŭrigo Hyŏmnyŏk (The Governance, Resistance and Collaboration)" (2006), Kyŏng’in Munhwasa
- Kim, Tongsŏng, "Chosŏnin ŭi Kwanch’alhan Chosŏn Sanŏp Taegwan (An Overview of Korean Industries as Seen by a Korean)", 1-2 Tong’a Ilbo, 1~ (1922)
- Kim, Yunhŭi, "Chosŏn’in Kyŏngje ŭi T’ansaeng kwa Sijang ŭi Palgyŏn (The Birth of Koreans’ Economy and the Discovery of the Market)" (2018), Sŏn’in
- Kim, Inessa, "Krivye nebesa (The Convoluted Heavens)" (2004), DuckDesign
- Kim, Seyong, "Maksagwa ũi Hoesang (Moscow’s Recollections)", Samch’ŏlli, 4(3), pp.58~61 (1932)
- Kimura Mitsuhiko, "Standards of Living in Colonial Korea: Did the Masses Become Worse Off or Better Off Under Japanese Rule?", The Journal of Economic History, 53(3), pp.629~652 (1993)
- Kraft, Diane, "South Korea’s National Security Law: A Tool of Oppression in an Insecure World", Wisconsin International Law Journal, 24(2), pp.627~659 (2006)
- Kumanin, "Kharakteristika Slushatelya Lektorskogo Kursa KUTV Imeni Tovarishcha Stalina Vypuska 1928-29 goda (Assessment of a Student at KUTV Named after Comrade Stalin, Group for Teachers’ Training, Graduates of 1928-1929)", RGASPI F. 495 op. 228 d. 457 l. 22, ~ (1929)
- Kwôn Hûiyông, "Koryô Kongsandang Ironka Pak Chinsun ûi Saengae wa Sasang(Life and Ideas of Pak Chinsun, a Korean Communist Party Theoretician)", Yôksa Pip’yông, 3, pp.285~294 (1989)
- Lenin, Vladimir Ilich, "Lenin’s Selected Works, Vol.1", pp.667~766 (1963), Progress Publishers
- Vanin, Yuri, "Kolonial’naya Koreya: Iz Publikatsiy v SSSR 1920kh-30kh Godov (Colonial Korea: from the Publications in the USSR of the 1920-30s)", pp.146~179 (2007), Institut Vostokovedeniya
- Vanin, Yuri, "Kolonial’naya Koreya: Iz Publikatsiy v SSSR 1920kh-30kh Godov (Colonial Korea: from the Publications in the USSR of the 1920-30s)", pp.347~366 (2007), Institut Vostokovedeniya
- Nam, Manch’un, "Nam Manch’un", pp.213~230 (2017), Institut Vostokovedeniya
- Nam, Manch’un, "Nam Manch’un", pp.271~300 (2017), Institut Vostokovedeniya
- Pae, Sŏngnyong, "Hyŏnha ŭi Chosŏn kwa Ch’ongdokpu Kyŏngjech’aek(Contemporary Korea and the Economical Plicies of the Government General)", Tong’a Ilbo, ~ (1926)
- Pae, Sŏngnyong, "Ch’oegûn Chôngch’i ûi Pubunjôk Pip’an(A Partial Criticism of the Recent Policies)", Samch’ôlli, 17, pp.6~7 (1931)
- Pak, Ae. ca, "Anketa(Questionnaire)", RGASPI F. 495, op. 228, d. 437, l. 10, 1930
- Pak, Bella, "Nam Manch’un" (2017), Institut Vostokovedeniya
- Pak, Boris, "Kim Man’gyŏm" (2007), Institut Vostokovedeniya RAN
- Pak, Chaeman, "Charyo: K’omint’erûn che3ch’a Taehoe esôûi Koryô Kongsandang ûi Pogo(Material: The Report by the Korean Communist Party to the Third Congress of Comintern)", Yôksa Pip’yông, 8 (1989)
- , a Korean Communist Party Member), "RGASPI F. 495 op. 228 d. 481 l. 76", 1929
- Pak, Hŏnyŏng, "Nash Put’–Revolutsiya ili Smert’(Our Path is Revolution or Death)", RGASPI F. 495 op. 228 d. 23 l. 132, ~ (1928)
- Pak, Hŏnyŏng, "Ijŏng Pak Hŏnyŏng Chŏnjip(Complete Works by Ijŏng Pak Hŏnyŏng) Vol.4" (2004), Yŏksa Pip’yŏng
- Pak, Mun’gyu, "Nōson Shakai Bunka no Kiten toshite no Tochi Chōsa Jigyō ni tsuite(On the Land Survey as the Starting Point of the Stratification of the Rural Society)", Chōsen Shakai Keizaishi Kenkyū(Research on Korea’s Socio-Economic History), 1(6), pp.521~567 (1933), Tōkō Shoin
- Han’guk Oegugŏ Taehakkyo Dijit’ŏl Han’gukhak Yŏn’guso, "Mosŭk’ŭba Tongbang Noryŏkcha Kongsan Taehak ŭi (1921-1938) Hanin tül. Rŏsia Munsŏ Pogwanso Charyojip 2 (Koreans of the Moscow Communist University of the Eastern Toilers, 1921-1938. Collection of Documents from the Russian Archives 2)", pp.233~ (2020), Hanul
- 박용규, "1920년 조선어 민간신문 창간의 배경과 과정", 한국언론학보, 62(5), pp.107~135 (2018), 한국언론학회[DOI]
- Poulantzas, Nicos, "Fascism and Dictatorship: The Third International and the Problem of Fascism" (2018), Verso
- Pak Boris, "Kim Man’gyŏm", pp.178~195 (2007), Institut Vostokovedeniya RAN
- Son, Zhanna, "Sovetskie Koreitsy–Vsesilie Vlasti I Bespravie Etnicheskoi Obshchnosti, 1920-30 (The Soviet Koreans: the Omnipotence of the Authorities and Rightlessness of the Ethnic Community, the 1920-30s)" (2013), Grif
- "Stenogramma Soveshchaniya Koreiskoi i Yaponskoi Sektsii KUTV(The Stenographic Record of the Meeting of the Korean and Japanese Sections of KUTV)", RGASPI F. 532 op. 1 d. 86, ~ (1929)
- van der Linden, Marcel, "The ‘Law’ of Uneven and Combined Development: Some Underdeveloped Thoughts", Historical Materialism, 15, pp.145~165 (2007)
- Vanin, Yuri, "Kolonial’naya Koreya: Iz Publikatsiy v SSSR 1920kh-30kh Godov(Colonial Korea: from the Publications in the USSR of the 1920-30s)" (2007), Institut Vostokovedeniya
- Weiner, Michael, "The Comintern: A History of International Communism from Lenin to Stalin", pp.158~190 (1996), Macmillan
- Yi, Hŏnch’ang, "Han’guk Kyŏngje T’ongsa (Outline Economical History of Korea)" (1999), Pŏmmunsa
- Yi, Kyehyŏng, "Succha ro Pon Singminji Chosŏn (Colonial Korea Seen through Figures)" (2014), Yŏksa Konggan
- Yi, Yôsông, "Succha Chosŏn Yŏn’gu (A Study on Korea through Figures) Vol.1-5" (1992), Kukhak Charyowôn
- Yoon, Jong-Pil, "Recent history wars in South Korea", Paedagogica Historica, 56(4), pp.548~567 (2020)