한 · 불 경찰관기동대 집회 · 시위 관리 전술 비교 연구
A Comparative study on the Tactics for Assembly and Demonstration Control between Korea and France Police forces
0
조회
0
다운로드
3
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Korea National Police Agency (KNPA) plans to establish more than 40 Riot Police Companies composed of only professional police officer not riot police by 2010. On condition that KNPA and the Ministry of National Defense (MND) reach an agreement that would abolish both riot police and auxiliary police system during renegotiation, it is expected that current riot police forces will be replaced by professional police officers. On the second anniversary of the Korean Riot Police Company(hereinafter called ‘KRPC’), It will be possibly very meaningful to make a comparative study on the measures of Assembly and demonstration control between Korean and french police with which Korea police have been cooperating closely in the field of law enforcement, especially for Assembly and demonstration control measures. The introduction of the basic 5-manned squad tactics of the republic security company of France(CRS : Compagnines Republicaine de Sécurite; the Riot Police company for the Republic of France; hereinafter called ‘CRS’) to the KRPC will be of help to make a company smaller tactically and economically; the law can be executed more actively in many situations. Reorganization of the KRPC as of CRS system can be positively considered, if the KRPC are dispatched to the front Wing line of Riot Police forces to be used for apprehension. And also, in order to get desired effects, it is required to reinforce counter-riot equipments, such as tonfa(T-shaped police batton), nonlethal weapons and prjectiles like DMP and grenade launcher like COUGAR, which are widely used by CRS. Although KRPC uses many counter-riot gears like riot shield, light police batton and tear gas like capsaicin, the introduction of advanced and effective counter-riot equipments will not only improve the effectiveness but also guarantee the safety of both protesters and officers. The change and modification of the KRPC counter-riot tactics should be followed by the systematized Field Manual(FM) to upgrade tactics securely. If a unified, well-organized Field Manual is completed on the basis of its successful riot control experiences, it could be a milestone for Korea Police's riot control capability to go forward. For one step further, the criteria of tactical performance evaluation should be renovated to evaluate the practical counter-riot capability with realism not in a way of well-scenarioed movies souly for demonstration. Now is the time for the operation of KRPC to turn from old-fashioned tactics of riot police forces by adopting future-oriented riot police tactics, because the actual operators of KRPC will be full-time officers who passed the examination for services and completed 6-month intensive training courses. Hence, follow-up studies are necessary to focus on the future of the KRPC composed of professional law-enforcement officers and on the settlement of a sound culture of assembly and demonstration enough to find an echo in every citizens' heart.
Abstract
Korea National Police Agency (KNPA) plans to establish more than 40 Riot Police Companies composed of only professional police officer not riot police by 2010. On condition that KNPA and the Ministry of National Defense (MND) reach an agreement that would abolish both riot police and auxiliary police system during renegotiation, it is expected that current riot police forces will be replaced by professional police officers. On the second anniversary of the Korean Riot Police Company(hereinafter called ‘KRPC’), It will be possibly very meaningful to make a comparative study on the measures of Assembly and demonstration control between Korean and french police with which Korea police have been cooperating closely in the field of law enforcement, especially for Assembly and demonstration control measures. The introduction of the basic 5-manned squad tactics of the republic security company of France(CRS : Compagnines Republicaine de Sécurite; the Riot Police company for the Republic of France; hereinafter called ‘CRS’) to the KRPC will be of help to make a company smaller tactically and economically; the law can be executed more actively in many situations. Reorganization of the KRPC as of CRS system can be positively considered, if the KRPC are dispatched to the front Wing line of Riot Police forces to be used for apprehension. And also, in order to get desired effects, it is required to reinforce counter-riot equipments, such as tonfa(T-shaped police batton), nonlethal weapons and prjectiles like DMP and grenade launcher like COUGAR, which are widely used by CRS. Although KRPC uses many counter-riot gears like riot shield, light police batton and tear gas like capsaicin, the introduction of advanced and effective counter-riot equipments will not only improve the effectiveness but also guarantee the safety of both protesters and officers. The change and modification of the KRPC counter-riot tactics should be followed by the systematized Field Manual(FM) to upgrade tactics securely. If a unified, well-organized Field Manual is completed on the basis of its successful riot control experiences, it could be a milestone for Korea Police's riot control capability to go forward. For one step further, the criteria of tactical performance evaluation should be renovated to evaluate the practical counter-riot capability with realism not in a way of well-scenarioed movies souly for demonstration. Now is the time for the operation of KRPC to turn from old-fashioned tactics of riot police forces by adopting future-oriented riot police tactics, because the actual operators of KRPC will be full-time officers who passed the examination for services and completed 6-month intensive training courses. Hence, follow-up studies are necessary to focus on the future of the KRPC composed of professional law-enforcement officers and on the settlement of a sound culture of assembly and demonstration enough to find an echo in every citizens' heart.
참고문헌 (35)
- 강영규, "경찰경비총서" (2009), 경찰대학
- 김종민, "경비" (2009), 중앙경찰학교
- 김성수, "한국경찰사" (2009), 경찰대학
- 경기지방경찰청, "오산 세교지구 전철연 망루농성 관련 경찰 실전대응 매뉴얼" (2005)
- 경찰청, "경찰관기동대 업무편람" (2009)
- 경찰청, "세계 각국의 경찰관부대 편제 및 운영" (2007)
- 경찰청, "평화적 준법시위문화 정착을 위한 韓·日·佛 공공질서유지 전략세미나" (2007)
- 경찰청, "평화시위 매뉴얼" (2006)
- 경찰청, "기동대 중대장 매뉴얼" (2005)
- 경찰종합학교, "집회시위 안전·관리기법" (2006)
- 경찰종합학교, "전술학" (1990)
- 서울지방경찰청, "집회시위 대처 매뉴얼" (2004)
- 이운주, "경찰학개론" (2002), 경찰대학
- 전용선, "기동경찰을 위한 집회․시위 관리" (2009), 중앙경찰학교
- ACPO Public Order Working Group, "Public Order Standards, Tactics, and Training Manual" (2004), Central Police Training and Development Authority
- 김택수, "외국의 집회․시위 관리시 물리력 사용에 관한 규정 및 실태에 관한 연구 - 프랑스와 독일의 사례를 중심으로 -", 치안논총, 25 (2009), 치안정책연구소
- 김철준, "집회 및 시위에 관한 법제연구", 박사, pp.2004
- 류재혁, "환경변화에 따른 경찰작전 개선방안에 관한 연구", 경찰학연구, 7(3), pp.123~150 (2007), 경찰대학
- 박준기, "집회시위의 안전관리 방안 연구", 박사, pp.2006
- 배종대, "화염병시위 대책에 관한 연구" (2001), 치안연구소
- 이선엽, "경찰억압성의 전략적 유형에 관한 연구 : 시위진압의 사례검토", 한국행정사학회, (17), pp.113~127 (2005), 한국행정사학회
- 이영남, "불법시위에 대한 경찰의 공권력 사용의 정당성 확보방안", 통일로 (2001), 안보문제연구원
- 이창무, "각국 경찰의 집회시위 관리방식의 변천과정에 대한 비교 연구: 미국·영국· 독일·일본 사례를 중심으로", 한국공안행정학회보, 16(1), pp.11~39 (2007), 한국공안행정학회
- 육군대학 전술학처, "전술의 원리", 군사평론, (378) (2006), 육군대학
- 프랑스와 아이요, "프랑스 CRS의 역사와 전망 & 프랑스 경찰의 공공질서 관리", 평화적 준법시위문화 정착을 위한 韓·日·佛 공공질서유지 전략세미나 (2007), 경찰청
- 홍순원, "선진시위문화 정착을 위한 집회시위의 효율적 관리방안 연구", 안보과정우수논문집, 9 (2003), 국방대학교
- 경찰청, "전의경 경찰관 대체 종합계획", ~ (2008)
- 경찰청, "10년 경찰관기동대 창설을 위한 경찰관 모집 및 지방청별 부대배치 계획", ~ (2009)
- 경찰청, "경찰관기동대 관련 신임순경 운영 개선계획", ~ (2009)
- 경찰청, "2009년 집회․시위 관리지침", ~ (2009)
- 국회전자도서관, "한말근대법령집Ⅰ", ~
- 서울지방경찰청 기동본부(교육대), "경찰관기동대 교육훈련 매뉴얼", ~ (2008)
- 이종화, "프랑스 임용 및 교육제도", 경찰학연구, 7(3) (2007), 경찰대학
- 조현준, "경찰관기동대가 세상에 모습을 드러내다", 청람, 24 (2008), 경찰대학
- 프랑스 경찰관기동대, "프랑스 기동대 전략 전술(경찰청 번역본)", ~ (2007)
