Rhetorical Analysis for Critical Thinking: A Pilot Study in an EFL Presentation Class
2
조회
0
다운로드
4
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The current study examined the influence of rhetorical analysis instruction on critical thinking (CT) in an EFL PPT presentation class. The study utilized an experimental design to implement rhetorical analysis with 26 participants in a control group and 28 participants in an experimental group. The two groups were equivalent in terms of their English proficiency level as well as their critical thinking ability as measured by the Critical Thinking Test (CTT, available online) before the experiment. The participants in the experimental group were instructed to utilize rhetorical devices in their presentation scripts and rhetorical analysis in their presentations. In group discussions, participants in the experimental group explored the use of rhetorical devices in other students’ presentations in terms of how and for what purpose they were used and whether they were well applied. The results of a post-test (CTT) demonstrated that teaching rhetorical devices had a positive and promising influence on CT. Exploring rhetorical devices and analysis was also found to have a great impact on three components of CT: noticing arguments, recognizing the way an assumption is rhetorically manipulated, and interpreting conclusions. The study reinforced other earlier research findings, which support the use of rhetorical analysis to enhance EFL learners’ CT.
Abstract
The current study examined the influence of rhetorical analysis instruction on critical thinking (CT) in an EFL PPT presentation class. The study utilized an experimental design to implement rhetorical analysis with 26 participants in a control group and 28 participants in an experimental group. The two groups were equivalent in terms of their English proficiency level as well as their critical thinking ability as measured by the Critical Thinking Test (CTT, available online) before the experiment. The participants in the experimental group were instructed to utilize rhetorical devices in their presentation scripts and rhetorical analysis in their presentations. In group discussions, participants in the experimental group explored the use of rhetorical devices in other students’ presentations in terms of how and for what purpose they were used and whether they were well applied. The results of a post-test (CTT) demonstrated that teaching rhetorical devices had a positive and promising influence on CT. Exploring rhetorical devices and analysis was also found to have a great impact on three components of CT: noticing arguments, recognizing the way an assumption is rhetorically manipulated, and interpreting conclusions. The study reinforced other earlier research findings, which support the use of rhetorical analysis to enhance EFL learners’ CT.
참고문헌 (68)
- Atakent, A., "The effects of teaching L2 rhetorical organization on Turkish freshman students’ L1 expository writing", Master, pp.1999
- Bailin, S., "The Blackwell guide to the philosophy of education", pp.181~193 (2003), Blackwell
- "Rhetorics, poetics, and cultures: Refiguring college English studies" (1996)[URL]
- Bernard, L. B., "Methods of rhetorical criticism: A twentieth century perspective" (1980), Wayne State University Press
- Billig, M., "Arguing and thinking: A rhetorical approach to social psychology" (1987), Cambridge University Press
- Bormann, E. G., "The rhetoric of Western thought", pp.431~449 (1983), Kendall Hunt
- Brock, B. L., "Methods of rhetorical criticism: A twentieth-century perspective" (1980), Wayne State University Press
- Burke, K. A., "A rhetoric of motives" (1969), University of California Press
- Carrel, P., "The effects of rhetorical organization on ESL readers", TESOL Quarterly, 18(3), pp.441~469 (1984)
- Clyne, M., "Cultural differences in the organization of academic texts", Journal of Pragmatics, 11(2), pp.211~247 (1987)
- Corbett, E. P. J., "Classical rhetoric for the modern student" (1990), Oxford University Press
- Cornor, U., "Contrastive rhetoric: Cross-cultural aspects of second language writing" (1996), Cambridge University Press
- Cots, J. M., "Teaching ‘with an attitude’ : Critical discourse analysis in EFL teaching", ELT Journal, 60(4), pp.336~345 (2006)
- Davidson, B., "Assessing ESL student progress in critical thinking with the Ennis Weir critical thinking essay test", JALT Journal, 19(1), pp.43~57 (1997)
- Emilia, E., "A critical genre-based approach to teaching academic writing in a tertiary EFL context in Indonesia", Doctor, pp.2005
- Facione, N. C., "Externalizing the critical thinking in knowledge development and clinical judgment", Nursing Outlook, 44(3), pp.129~136 (1996)
- Facione, P. A., "The California critical thinking disposition inventory" (1992), The California Academic Press
- Facione, P. A., "The disposition toward critical thinking", Journal of General Education, 44(1), pp.1~25 (1995)
- Fairclough, N. L., "Critical discourse analysis" (1995), Longman
- Fairclough, N. L., "A new agenda in (critical) discourse analysis", pp.53~70 (2005), John Benjamins
- Fisher, A., "Critical thinking: An introduction" (2001), Cambridge University Press
- Flemming, E. L., "Reading for thinking" (2000), Houghton Mifflin
- Frijters, S., "Effects of dialogic learning on valueloaded critical thinking", Learning and Instruction, 18(1), pp.66~82 (2007)
- Garcia, T., "Critical thinking and its relationship to motivation, learning strategies and classroom experience" (1992), University of Michigan
- Gershon, S., "Present yourself 2" (2015), Cambridge University Press
- Grabe, W., "Richness in writing: Empowering ESL students", pp.263~283 (1989), Longman
- Halliday, M. A. K., "Explorations in the function of language" (1973), Arnold
- Hare, W., "The aims of education", pp.85~99 (1999), Routledge
- Hashemi, R. H., "Critical discourse analysis and critical thinking : An experimental study in an EFL context", System, 40(1), pp.37~47 (2012)
- Hyland, K., "Writing theories and writing pedagogies", Indonesian Journal of English Language Teaching, 4(2), pp.91~110 (2009)
- Johnson, R., "Logical self-defense" (2006), International Debate Education Association
- Kachru, Y., "Cultural meaning and contrastive rhetoric in English education", World Englishes, 16(3), pp.337~350 (1997)
- Kaplan, R. B., "Readings in English as a second language", pp.246~262 (1972), Winthrop
- Kennedy, G. A., "The art of rhetoric in the Roman world 300 B.C.-A.D. 300" (1972), Princeton University Press
- 김언조, "Fostering Criticality in English Presentation Class for EFL Learners", 언어연구, 33(1), pp.45~70 (2017), 한국현대언어학회[DOI]
- 김언조, "Scrutinizing Critical Reading Strategies (CRS) for Implicit Meaning Comprehension in EFL Context", 언어학 연구, (47), pp.279~305 (2018), 한국중원언어학회[DOI]
- 김언조, "Criticality: A Framework for Teaching English in EFL Context", 영어학연구, 24(1), pp.123~152 (2018), 한국영어학학회[DOI]
- 김언조, "A Study on Self-Critical Reflections of Illocutionary Act Strategies Utilized in L2 Learners’ Social Network Service", 영상영어교육, 19(2), pp.121~143 (2018), 영상영어교육학회[DOI]
- Knapp, P., "Genre, text grammar : Technologies for teaching and assessing writing" (2005), University of New South Wales Press
- Leki, I., "Twenty-live years of contrastive rhetoric : Text analysis and writing pedagogies", TESOL Quarterly, 25(1), pp.123~143 (1991)
- Martin, J. E., "Towards a theory of text for contrastive rhetoric: An introduction to issues of text for students and practitioners of contrastive rhetoric" (1992), Peter Lang
- Matsuda, P. K., "Contrastive rhetoric in context : A dynamic model of L2 writing", Journal of Second Language Writing, 6(1), pp.45~60 (1997)[DOI]
- Mauranen, A., "Cultural differences in academic rhetoric" (1993), Peter Lang
- Mauranen, A., "Contrastive ESP rhetoric : Metatext in Finnish-English economics texts", English for specific purposes, 12, pp.3~22 (1993)[DOI]
- McGuire, J. M., "Why has the critical thinking movement not come to Korea?", Asia Pacific Education Review, 8(2), pp.224~232 (2008)
- McGuire, L. A., "Improving student critical thinking and perceptions of critical thinking through direct instruction of rhetorical analysis", Doctor, pp.2010
- Mercier, H., "In two minds: Dual processes and beyond", pp.149~170 (2009), Oxford University Press
- Meyers, C., "Teaching students to think critically" (1986), Jossey Bass
- Neuman, Y., "Inconsistency as an interactional problem : A lesson from political rhetoric", Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 32(3), pp.251~267 (2003)
- Odlin, T., "Language transfer: Cross-linguistic influence in language learning" (1989), Cambridge University Press
- Paul, R. W., "Critical thinking : What, why", and how? New Directions for Community Colleges, 77, pp.3~24 (1992)
- Paul, R., "The miniature guide to critical thinking: Concepts and tools" (2007), Foundation for Critical Thinking Press
- Perelman, C., "The new rhetoric: A treatise on argumentation" (1969), University of Notre Dame Press
- Petty, R. E., "Communication and persuasion: Central and peripheral routes to attitude change" (1986), Springer-Verlag
- Purves, A. C., "Writing across languages and cultures: Issues in contrastive rhetoric", pp.9~21 (1988), Sage
- Ramsay, G., "Linearity in rhetorical organization : A comparative cross-cultural analysis of newstext from the People’s Republic of China and Australia", International Journal of Applied Linguistics, 10(2), pp.241~258 (2000)
- Scollon, R., "Discourse identity, social identity, and confusion in intercultural communication", Intercultural Communication Studies, 6(10) (1996)
- Scollon, R., "Intercultural communication : A discourse approach" (1995), Basil Blackwell
- Thompson, S., "Frequency and the emergence of linguistic structure", pp.27~60 (2001), John Benjamins
- Tom, G., "The use of rhetorical devices in advertising", Journal of Advertising Research, 39(4), pp.39~43 (1999)
- Uysal, H. H., "Tracing the culture behind writing : Rhetorical patterns and bidirectional transfer in L1 and L2 essays of Turkish writers in relation to educational context", Journal of Second Language Writing, 17(3), pp.183~207 (2008)[DOI]
- Van Noppen, J., "CDA: A discipline come of age?", Journal of Sociolinguistics, 8(1), pp.107~126 (2004)
- Varpio, L., "Using rhetorical appeals to credibility, logic, and emotions to increase your persuasiveness", Perspect Med Educ, 7(3), pp.207~210 (2018)[DOI]
- Wallace, C., "Critical language awareness", pp.59~92 (1992), Longman
- Watson, G. B., "Watson-Glaser critical thinking appraisal" (2002), The Psychological
- Wodak, R., "Disorders of discourse" (1996), Longman
- Wodak, R., "The discourse of politics in action: Politics as usual" (2011), Palgrave
- Wodak, R., "Critical discourse analysis" (2013), Sage
