Hearing Outcomes According to the Types of Mastoidectomy: A Comparison between Canal Wall Up and Canal Wall Down Mastoidectomy
2
조회
0
다운로드
3
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Objectives. The aim of this study was to compare the hearing outcomes between canal wall up mastoidectmy (CWUM)and canal wall down mastoidectmy (CWDM). Methods. One hundred seventy one chronic suppurative otitis media (CSOM) patients were enrolled in this retrospective study. The patients who underwent the second staged ossiculoplasty at least 6 months after mastoidectomy and who had an intact, well aerated tympanic cavity as well as intact mobile stapes at the time of operation were selected from the medical record. Based on the type of mastoid surgery, the patients were categorized into two groups: the CWUM (n=38) and CWDM groups (n=133). The hearing results of the CWUM and CWDM groups were compared using the pre- and post-operative air-bone gap (ABG) at 3 months after ossiculoplasty. Results. The preoperative ABG in both groups (CWUM and CWDM) were 28.4±15.6 dB and 31.8±14.5 dB, respectively (P=0.18). Both groups didn’t show any significant difference (10.9 dB vs. 13.5 dB, respectively) (P=0.21) for the postoperative ABG closure. The proportion of patients with an ABG less than 20 dB was 58.6% of the CWDM patients and 68.4% of the CWUM patients (P=0.25). Conclusion. The type of mastoid surgery (CWUM and CWDM) did not affect the hearing results of CSOM patients. When choosing the type of mastoidectomy procedure for CSOM surgery, the hearing outcomes are basically the same for both types of procedure.
Abstract
Objectives. The aim of this study was to compare the hearing outcomes between canal wall up mastoidectmy (CWUM)and canal wall down mastoidectmy (CWDM). Methods. One hundred seventy one chronic suppurative otitis media (CSOM) patients were enrolled in this retrospective study. The patients who underwent the second staged ossiculoplasty at least 6 months after mastoidectomy and who had an intact, well aerated tympanic cavity as well as intact mobile stapes at the time of operation were selected from the medical record. Based on the type of mastoid surgery, the patients were categorized into two groups: the CWUM (n=38) and CWDM groups (n=133). The hearing results of the CWUM and CWDM groups were compared using the pre- and post-operative air-bone gap (ABG) at 3 months after ossiculoplasty. Results. The preoperative ABG in both groups (CWUM and CWDM) were 28.4±15.6 dB and 31.8±14.5 dB, respectively (P=0.18). Both groups didn’t show any significant difference (10.9 dB vs. 13.5 dB, respectively) (P=0.21) for the postoperative ABG closure. The proportion of patients with an ABG less than 20 dB was 58.6% of the CWDM patients and 68.4% of the CWUM patients (P=0.25). Conclusion. The type of mastoid surgery (CWUM and CWDM) did not affect the hearing results of CSOM patients. When choosing the type of mastoidectomy procedure for CSOM surgery, the hearing outcomes are basically the same for both types of procedure.
참고문헌 (15)
- Whittemore KR Jr, "Acoustic mechanisms:canal wall-up versus canal wall-down mastoidectomy", Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg, 118(6), pp.751~761 (1998)
- McElveen JT, "Effect of mastoid cavity modification on middle ear sound transmission", Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol, 91(5 Pt 1), pp.526~532 (1982)
- Tos M, "Hearing after surgery for cholesteatoma using various techniques", Auris Nasus Larynx, 16(2), pp.61~73 (1989)
- Cook JA, "Hearing results following modified radical versus canal-up mastoidectomy", Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol, 105(5), pp.379~383 (1996)
- Dornhoffer JL, "Prognostic factors in ossiculoplasty:a statistical staging system", Otol Neurotol, 22(3), pp.299~304 (2001)
- Becvarovski Z, "Smoking and tympanoplasty:implications for prognosis and the Middle Ear Risk Index(MERI)", Laryngoscope, 111(10), pp.1806~1811 (2001)
- Kartush JM, "Ossicular chain reconstruction:capitulum to malleus", Otolaryngol Clin North Am, 27(4), pp.689~715 (1994)
- Gyo K, "Effect of middle ear modification on umbo vibration.Human temporal bone experiments with a new vibration measuring system", Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg, 112(12), pp.1262~1268 (1986)
- Black B, "Ossiculoplasty prognosis:the spite method of assessment", Am J Otol, 13(6), pp.544~551 (1992)
- Austin DF, "Reporting results in tympanoplasty", Am J Otol, 6(1), pp.85~88 (1985)
- Moon IS, "Hearing results after ossiculoplasty using Polycel prosthesis", Acta Otolaryngol, 127(1), pp.20~24 (2007)
- Mundada PS, "1989A method for ossicular reconstruction with tragal cartilage autografts", Laryngoscope, 99(9), pp.955~962 (1990)
- Shelton C, "Tympanoplasty:review of 400 staged cases", Laryngoscope, 100(7), pp.679~681 (1990)
- Evans RA, "Open-cavity mastoid surgery:its effect on the acoustics of the external ear canal", Clin Otolaryngol Allied Sci, 14(4), pp.317~321 (1989)
- Cho YS, "Changes in external ear resonance after 3 types of surgery in the patients with chronic otitis media", Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg, 125(4), pp.364~369 (2001)