The Narcissistic Entrapment of Scarlett O’Hara
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The popular image of Scarlett O'Hara's character easily polarizes readers into extreme and equally superficial opposites. Her existence in readers' minds as feisty American heroine or self-centered princess neglects the nuanced depiction of her complex and destructive personality. The author's achievement lies in providing a morally superficial and simplistic character with a complex subtext of motivations. In conjunction with a clinical understanding of narcissism, it can be shown that she ought neither to be admired as icon nor scorned as psychotic, but seen as the profoundly flawed character the text carefully conveys. The clinical understanding of narcissistic personality disorder is currently under debate again. It stands to be eliminated from the next edition of The American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) due to renewed uncertainty whether narcissism should be seen as a clinical disease or just a collection of signs and symptoms better understood in terms of other disorders. In Scarlett's actions and motivations it is possible to see such a collection of signs that invite the broader label of narcissistic personality traits. Specifically, Scarlett's narcissistic complex stems from the insufficient mirroring supplied by her distant mother Ellen and the resultant overidealization of Ellen's womanhood. The aim of this essay is to show that Scarlett's enchantment with the image of her mother and consequently her own ego-ideal, has consequences for relating adequately to others and being able to mature. Since her lack of self-analysis cannot aid her in detecting these flaws, she is also unable to avert a regression to girlhood strategies and fantasies. This dynamic can best be constructed as a narcissistic entrapment.
Abstract
The popular image of Scarlett O'Hara's character easily polarizes readers into extreme and equally superficial opposites. Her existence in readers' minds as feisty American heroine or self-centered princess neglects the nuanced depiction of her complex and destructive personality. The author's achievement lies in providing a morally superficial and simplistic character with a complex subtext of motivations. In conjunction with a clinical understanding of narcissism, it can be shown that she ought neither to be admired as icon nor scorned as psychotic, but seen as the profoundly flawed character the text carefully conveys. The clinical understanding of narcissistic personality disorder is currently under debate again. It stands to be eliminated from the next edition of The American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) due to renewed uncertainty whether narcissism should be seen as a clinical disease or just a collection of signs and symptoms better understood in terms of other disorders. In Scarlett's actions and motivations it is possible to see such a collection of signs that invite the broader label of narcissistic personality traits. Specifically, Scarlett's narcissistic complex stems from the insufficient mirroring supplied by her distant mother Ellen and the resultant overidealization of Ellen's womanhood. The aim of this essay is to show that Scarlett's enchantment with the image of her mother and consequently her own ego-ideal, has consequences for relating adequately to others and being able to mature. Since her lack of self-analysis cannot aid her in detecting these flaws, she is also unable to avert a regression to girlhood strategies and fantasies. This dynamic can best be constructed as a narcissistic entrapment.
참고문헌 (14)
- Brenna, Susan, "Margaret Mitchell: The Rebellious Southern Belle Who Created Scarlett and Rhett", Biography Magazine, 104 (2000), Academic Search Premier
- Crockatt, Phillip, "Freud’s ‘On narcissism: an introduction", Journal of Child Psychology, 32(1), pp.4~20 (2006), Academic Search Premier
- Deeks, Launa, "Scarlett O’Hara: The Classic ‘Getting Type’", Individual Psychology, 53(3), pp.310~321 (1997), Academic Search Premier
- Fox-Genovese, Elizabeth, "Scarlett O’Hara: The Southern Lady as New Woman", American Quarterly, 33, pp.391~411 (1981), Academic Search Premier
- Hall, Glinda Fountain, "Inverting the Southern Belle: Romance Writers Redefine Gender Myths", The Journal of Popular Culture, 41(1), pp.37~55 (2008), Academic Search Premier
- Holtzman, Nicholas S., "Sounds like a narcissist: Behavioral manifestations of narcissism in everyday life", Journal of Research in Personality, 44(4), pp.478~484 (2012), Academic Search Premier
- Marck, Nancy Anne, "Narrative Transference and Female Narcissism: The Social Message of Adam Bede", Studies in the Novel, 35(4), pp.447~470 (2003), Academic Search Premier
- Mitchell, Margaret, "Gone With The Wind" (1936), Scribner
- Myers, Erin M., "How much do narcissists rally like themselves? Using the bogus pipeline procedure to better understand the self-esteem of narcissists", Journal of Research in Personality, 46(1), pp.102~105 (2012), Academic Search Premier
- Pierpont, Claudia Roth, "A Study in Scarlett", The New Yorker, 31, pp.87~103 (1992)
- Pies, Ronald, "How to Eliminate Narcissism Overnight: DSM-V and the Death of Narcissistic Personality Disorder", Innovations in Clinical Neuroscience, 8(2), pp.23~27 (2011), Academic Search Premier
- Siomopoulos, V., "Narcissistic Personality Disorder: Clinical Features", American Journal of Psychotherapy, XLII(2), pp.240~253 (1988), Academic Search Premier
- Staples, Rosemary, "Margaret Mitchell: 70 years of Gone with the Wind and the Woman Behind It All", Pink Magazine, 6(12) (2009)