Escalation of Commitment: An Experimental Study
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Top managers are expected to be rational decision makers. Otherwise, a less than optimal allocation of limited resources results in a loss of competitiveness. Previous studies in accounting, management, and psychology provide evidences on the management's escalation of commitment to an alternative with negative feedback, which may cause suboptimal performances. The purpose of this study is to examine the escalation of commitment by managers. Firstly, it is examined whether managers exhibits such behavior. Secondly, the extent to which variables of individual responsibility, information asymmetry, and risk preference affect the level of commitment is examined. To achieve research purposes, a laboratory experiment is conducted. Analyses of data indicate that escalation of commitment persist in the face of the negative feedback. The higher the level of individual responsibility, subjects committed more resources to an investment project with a negative feedback. Information asymmetry significantly contributed to the level of commitment. Risk preference, however, was found to have little effects on the escalation of commitment. The results suggest that managers are exposed to the risk of escalating commitment to the suboptimal decisions. This study extended previous research by allowing subjects to make investment decisions for their own, and by clearly communicating negative feedback. Development of accounting information systems is needed to help management reduce escalation of commitment in the face of negative feedback.
Abstract
Top managers are expected to be rational decision makers. Otherwise, a less than optimal allocation of limited resources results in a loss of competitiveness. Previous studies in accounting, management, and psychology provide evidences on the management's escalation of commitment to an alternative with negative feedback, which may cause suboptimal performances. The purpose of this study is to examine the escalation of commitment by managers. Firstly, it is examined whether managers exhibits such behavior. Secondly, the extent to which variables of individual responsibility, information asymmetry, and risk preference affect the level of commitment is examined. To achieve research purposes, a laboratory experiment is conducted. Analyses of data indicate that escalation of commitment persist in the face of the negative feedback. The higher the level of individual responsibility, subjects committed more resources to an investment project with a negative feedback. Information asymmetry significantly contributed to the level of commitment. Risk preference, however, was found to have little effects on the escalation of commitment. The results suggest that managers are exposed to the risk of escalating commitment to the suboptimal decisions. This study extended previous research by allowing subjects to make investment decisions for their own, and by clearly communicating negative feedback. Development of accounting information systems is needed to help management reduce escalation of commitment in the face of negative feedback.
참고문헌 (65)
- Arkes, H. R., "The sunk cost and concorde effects: Are human less rational than lower animals?", Psychological Bulletin, 125, pp.591~600 (1999)
- Arkes, H. R., "The psychology of sunk cost", Organizational Behavior and Human Decisions Processes, 35(Feb), pp.124~140 (1985)
- Aronson, E., "The social animal" (1995), W.H. Freeman & Company
- Bazerman, M. H., "The relevance of Kahneman and Tversky’s concept of framing to organizational behavior", Journal of Management, 10, pp.333~343 (1984)
- Bazerman, M. H., "Performance evaluation in a dynamic context: A laboratory study of the impact of prior commitment to the ratee", Journal of Applied Psychology, 67, pp.873~876 (1982)
- Bazerman, M. H., "Escalation of commitment in individual and group decision-making", Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 33, pp.141~152 (1984)
- Bettman, J. R., "Perceived Risk and Its Components: A model of empirical test", Journal of Marketing Research, pp.184~190 (1973)
- Adverse selection, ethical environment and escalation of commitment in managers project evaluation decisions. Working paper, "Booth, P.", University of New South Wales, ~ (1998)
- Bowen, M., "The escalation phenomenon reconsidered: Decision dilemmas or decision errors?", Academy of Management Review, 12(1), pp.52~66 (1987)
- Brockner, J., "The escalation of commitment to a failing course of action: Toward theoretical progress", Academy of Management Review, 17, pp.39~62 (1992)
- Brockner, J., "Entrapment in escalating conflicts. in: a social psychological analysis" (1985), Springer-Verlag
- Brockner, J., "Factors affecting withdrawal from an escalating conflict: Quitting before it's too late", Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 15, pp.492~503 (1979)
- Brownell, P, "Research methods in management accounting", Accounting Research Methodology Monograph, 2, pp.321~367 (1995)
- Camerer, C. F., "The econometrics and behavioral economics of escalation of commitment: A re-examination of Staw and Hoang's NBA data", Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 39, pp.59~82 (1999)
- Chenhall, R., "The effect of cognitive style and sponsorship bias on the treatment of opportunity costs in resource allocation decisions", Accounting Research, 8(3), pp.347~361 (1991)
- Chow, C. W., "Escalating commitment to unprofitable projects: Replication and cross-cultural extension", Management Accounting Research, 8, pp.347~361 (1997)
- Conlon, E., "Sunk costs and financial decision making: Integration and implications", Advances in Financial Planning and Forecasting, 3, pp.37~61 (1989)
- Denison, C. A., "Real options and escalation of commitment: A behavioral analysis of capital investment decisions", Accounting Review, 84(1), pp.133~155 (2009)
- Foster, G., "Frontiers of management accounting research", Journal of Management Accounting Research, 9, pp.63~77 (1997)
- Fox, F. V., "The trapped administrator: Effects of job insecurity and policy resistance upon commitment to a course of action", Administrative Science Quarterly, 24(3), pp.449~471 (1979)
- Garland, H., "Throwing good money after bad: The effect of sunk costs on the decision to escalate commitment to an ongoing project", Journal of Applied Psychology, 75, pp.728~731 (1990)
- Ghosh, D., "De-escalation strategies: Some experimental evidence", Behavioral Research in Accounting, 9, pp.89~112 (1997)
- Harrison, P. D., "Impact of adverse selection on managers' project evaluation decisions", Academy of Management Journal, 36(3), pp.635~643 (1993)
- Harrison, P. D., "Initial responsibility, prospective information, and manager's project evaluation decisions", Advances in Management Accounting, 4, pp.127~146 (1995)
- Horngren, C. T., "Cost Accounting. in: A managerial emphasis" (2009), Prentice-Hall, Inc
- Keil, M., "Pulling the plug: Software project management and the problem of project escalation", MIS Quarterly, 19, pp.421~447 (1995)
- Keil, M., "Why software projects escalate: An empirical analysis and test of four theoretical models", MIS Quarterly, 24, pp.631~664 (2000)
- Khalil, E. L., "Respect, admiration, aggrandizement: Adam Smith as economic psychologist", Journal of Economic Psychology, 17, pp.555~577 (1996)
- Kiesler, C. A., "The psychology of commitment" (1971), Academic Press
- Knight, F. H., "Risk, uncertainty and profit" (1957), Houghton-Mifflin Company
- Langer, E. J., "The illusion of control", The Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 32, pp.311~328 (1975)
- Leland, H., "Information asymmetries, financial structure and financial intermediation", Journal of Finance, pp.371~381 (1977)
- McGraw, K. M., "Guilt following transgression: An attribution of responsibility approach", Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 53(2), pp.247~256 (1987)
- Nocera, J., "Investing in a fool's paradise", Fortune, (15), pp.86~94 (1996)
- O'Reilly, C. A., "The commitment and job tenure of new employees: Some evidence of post decisional justification", Administrative Science Quarterly, 26, pp.597~616 (1981)
- Oskamp, S., "Overconfidence in case-study judgments", The Journal of Consulting Psychology, 29, pp.261~265 (1965)
- Roh, S., "Microeconomics" (2002), Bubmoonsa
- Ross, S. A., "The determination of financial structure: The incentive-signalling approach", The Bell Journal of Economics, pp.23~40 (1977)
- Ross, S. A., "Expo 86: An escalation prototype", Administrative Science Quarterly, 31, pp.274~294 (1986)
- Ross, S. A., "Organizational escalation and exit: Lessons from the Shoreham Nuclear Power Plant", Academy of Management Journal, 36, pp.701~732 (1993)
- Rubin, J. Z., "Factors affecting entrapment in waiting situations: The Rosencrantz and Guildenstern effect", Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 31, pp.1054~1063 (1975)
- Rutledge, R. W., "The influence of self interest and ethical considerations on managers evaluation judgement", Accounting Organizations and Society, 24(2), pp.173~184 (1999)
- Salancik, G. R., "Commitment and the control of organizational behavior and belief. in: New directions in organizational behavior", pp.1~54 (1977), St. Clair
- Schoorman, F. D., "Escalating bias in performance appraisals: And unintended consequence of supervisor participation in hiring decisions", Journal of Applied Psychology, 73(1), pp.58~62 (1988)
- Schoorman, F. D., "Psychological antecedents of escalation behaviour: Effects of choice, responsibility and decision consequences", Journal of Applied Psychology, 81(6), pp.786~794 (1996)
- Schulz, A. K-D., "Persistence in capital budgeting reinvestment decisions ― personal responsibility antecedent and information asymmetry moderator: A note", Accounting and Finance, 42(2), pp.187~ (2002)
- Shefrin, H., "The disposition to sell winners too early and ride losers too long: Theory and evidence", Journal of Finance, 40(3), pp.777~790 (1984)
- Sogin, S. R., "Bad decisions, responsibility, and attitude change: Effects of volition, foreseeability, and locus of causality of negative consequences", Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 33, pp.300~306 (1976)
- Staw, B. M., "Knee-deep in big muddy: A study of escalating commitment to a chosen course of action", Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Performance, 16, pp.27~44 (1976)
- Staw, B. M., "The escalation of commitment: An update and appraisal. in: Organizational decision making", pp.191~215 (1997), Cambridge University Press
- Staw, B. M., "Escalation: The determinants of commitment to a previously chosen course of action", Human Relations, 30, pp.431~450 (1977)
- Staw, B. M., "Sunk costs in the NBA: Why draft order affects playing time and survival in professional basketball", Administrative Science Quarterly, 40, pp.474~494 (1995)
- Staw, B. M., "Commitment to a policy decision: A multi-theoretical perspective", Administrative Science Quarterly, 23, pp.40~64 (1978)
- Staw, B. M., "Commitment in an experimenting society: An experiment on the attribution of leadership from administrative scenarios", Journal of Applied Psychology, 65, pp.249~260 (1980)
- Staw, B. M., "Understanding escalation situations: Antecedents, prototypes, and solutions. in: Research in organizational behavior Vol. 9", pp.39~78 (1987), JAI Press
- Staw, B. M., "Understanding behavior in escalation situations", Science, 246, pp.216~220 (1989)
- Tang, M., "An economic perspective on escalating commitment", Strategic Management Journal, 9, pp.79~92 (1988)
- Thaler, R. H., "Mental accounting and consumer choice", Marketing Science, 4(3), pp.199~214 (1985)
- Thaler, R. H., "The psychology and economics conference handbook: Comments on Simon, on Einhorn and Hogarth, and on Tversky and Kahneman. in: In Rational Choice: The contrast between economics and psychology", pp.167~184 (1986), University of Chicago Press
- Tversky, A., "Availability: A heuristic for judging frequency and probability", Cognitive Psychology, 4, pp.207~232 (1973)
- Webb, E. J., "Nonreactive measures in social science" (1981), Houghton Mifflin
- Whyte, G., "Escalating commitment to a course of action: A reinterpretation", Academy of Management Review, 11, pp.311~321 (1986)
- Whyte, G., "Escalation of commitment in individual and group decision-making: A prospect theory approach", Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 54, pp.430~455 (1993)
- Yoon, H., "Imagination, Clinging, and Counseling", The Korean Journal of Psychology: Counseling and Psychotherapy, 13(3), pp.~18 (2001)
- Young, S. M., "Participative budgeting: The effects of risk aversion and asymmetric information on budgetary slack", Journal of Accounting Research, 23(2), pp.829~842 (1985)