본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

유구치 인접면 우식증 수복 시 지르코니아 전장관과 기성금속관의 생존율 비교 평가: 후향적 연구

Comparative Evaluation of the Survival Rates of Zirconia Crown and Stainless Steel Crown for Proximal Caries in Primary Molars: a Retrospective Study

박수현|신혜원|이난영|지명관|정가희
대한소아치과학회 (The Korean Academy Of Pediatric Dentistry)|2023.08|대한소아치과학회지 (Journal of the Korean academy of pediatric dentistry)|제50권 제3호|pp. 307-317

2

조회

0

다운로드

1

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

Stainless steel crownSurvival rateZirconia crownPrimary molar
주제분류치의학

초록

심미성에 대한 요구가 증가함에 따라 유구치 수복을 위한 지르코니아 전장관은 더 활발하게 사용되고 있으나, 지르코니아 전장관으로 수복한 치아를 장기간 추적 관찰하거나 다른 재료와 비교한 연구는 많지 않다. 따라서 이 연구의 목적은 인접면 우식증에 대한 지르코니아 전장관과 기성금속관의 36개월 동안의 생존율을 비교하여 평가하고, 각 기성관의수복 실패 양상을 분석하는 것이다. 2017년부터 2019년까지 조선대학교 치과병원 소아치과와 두 개의 개인 치과의원에 내원하여 두 기성관으로 수복 치료를 받은 498명 환자에 대한 1,061개의 유구치에 대한 전자의무기록지와 방사선 사진을 수집하고 분석하였다. 생존분석 결과, 기성금속관으로 수복한 치아의 생존율이 지르코니아 전장관에 비해 유의하게높았다. 치수 치료 시행 여부를 나눠 생존 분석을 시행한 결과, 치수 치료를 시행하지 않은경우, 기성금속관의 생존율이 지르코니아 전장관에 비해 유의하게 높았던 반면, 치수 치료를 시행한 경우에는 두 기성관의 생존율에 유의한 차이가 없었다. 기성금속관의 주된 수복실패 원인은 비정상적 치근 흡수 또는 치근단 투과상 병소의 발생이었고, 지르코니아 전장관의 경우 수복물의 탈락이었다. 이 연구는 임상가들에게 구치부 기성관 재료 선택 시 참고 자료로 활용될 수 있을 것이라 생각된다.

Abstract

Due to increasing demand for aesthetics, zirconia crowns have become a popular choice for treating primary molars. However, there is limited literature available comparing the survival rates of zirconia crowns with those of other restorative materials. The objective of this study was to compare the 36-month survival rates of zirconia crowns and stainless steel crowns for proximal caries, as well as to analyze failure types associated with each crown type. Electronic medical records and radiographs of 1,061 primary molars from 498 patients treated with 2 types of prefabricated crowns at Chosun University Dental Hospital and 2 private dental clinics between 2017 and 2019 were collected and analyzed. The survival rate of zirconia crowns was found to be lower compared to that of stainless steel crowns. Regarding the groups without pulp treatment, the survival rate of stainless steel crowns was significantly higher than that of zirconia crowns. However, in the groups that received pulp therapy, no significant difference in the survival rates was observed between the two preformed crowns. Notably, abnormal root resorption or periapical lesions were identified as the primary cause of restorative failure in stainless steel crowns, whereas loss of restoration was the predominant cause in zirconia crowns. This study holds valuable implications for clinicians when selecting preformed crowns for primary molars.

참고문헌 (37)

  1. Patel MC, "Choice of Material for the Treatment of Proximal Lesions in Deciduous Molars among Paediatric Post Graduates and Paediatric Dentists of Gujarat: A Cross Sectional Study", Adv Hum Biol, 9, pp.258~263 (2019)
  2. Novaes TF, "The influence of interdental spacing on the detection of proximal caries lesions in primary teeth", Braz Oral Res, 26, pp.293~299 (2012)
  3. Allison PJ, "Interproximal contact points and proximal caries in posterior primary teeth", Pediatr Dent, 25, pp.334~340 (2003)
  4. Sengul F, "Clinical Evaluation of Restorative Materials in Primary Teeth Class II Lesions", J Clin Pediatr Dent, 39, pp.315~321 (2015)
  5. Chen K, "A 2-year clinical evaluation of stainless steel crowns and composite resin restorations in primary molars under general anaesthesia in China’s Guangdong province", Br Dent J, 225, pp.49~52 (2018)
  6. Zahdan BA, "Survival rates of stainless steel crowns and multi-surface composite restorations placed by dental students in a pediatric clinic", J Clin Pediatr Dent, 42, pp.167~172 (2018)
  7. Murali G, "Clinical Evaluation of Pediatric Posterior Zirconia and Stainless Steel Crowns : A Comparative Study", Int J Clin Pediatr Dent, 15, pp.9~14 (2022)
  8. Abuelniel G, "Clinical and Radiographic Evaluation of Stainless Steel versus Zirconia Crowns on Primary Molars : Randomized Controlled Trial", Egypt Dent J, 64, pp.977~989 (2018)
  9. Kaushik M, "Comparative Evaluation Of Commercially Available Stainless Steel Crowns : An In-Vitro Study", Univ J Dent Sci, 7, pp.91~95 (2021)
  10. Padmapriya S, "Success Rate of Zirconia Crowns over Stainless Steel Crowns in Primary Molars : A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis", J South Asian Assoc Pediatr Dent, 4, pp.212~218 (2021)
  11. Alamoudi RA, "Evaluation of the Clinical Performance of NuSmile Pedodontics Zirconia Crowns in Pulp-Treated Primary Teeth-2 Years Follow-Up Study", Eur J Dent, 17, pp.82~90 (2023)
  12. Mathew MG, "Evaluation of Clinical Success, Parental and Child Satisfaction of Stainless Steel Crowns and Zirconia Crowns in Primary Molars", J Fam Med Prim Care, 9, pp.1418~1423 (2020)
  13. Hanafi L, "Evaluation and comparison two types of prefabricated zirconia crowns in mixed and primary dentition : A randomized clinical trial", Heliyon, 7, pp.E06240~ (2021)
  14. Harshitha K, "Comparative evaluation on clinical success rate of prefabricated zirconia crowns and stainless steel crowns in primary molars", Int J Oral Health Dent, 7, pp.180~186 (2021)
  15. Seale NS, "The use of stainless steel crowns", Pediatr Dent, 24, pp.501~505 (2002)
  16. Duggal M, "Best clinical practice guidance for treating deep carious lesions in primary teeth : an EAPD policy document", Eur Arch Paediatr Dent, 23, pp.659~666 (2022)
  17. Nikhil DKR, "Clinical evaluation of zirconia and stainless-steel crowns in primary molars-A randomized control trial", Int J Pedo Rehabil, 7, pp.30~38 (2022)
  18. Tremblay L, "Perceptions of self in 3-5-year-old children : a preliminary investigation into the early emergence of body dissatisfaction", Body Image, 8, pp.287~292 (2011)
  19. Pani SC, "Esthetic Concerns and Acceptability of Treatment Modalities in Primary Teeth : A Comparison between Children and Their Parents", Int J Dent, 2016, pp.3163904~ (2016)
  20. Fishman R, "Children’s selection of posterior restorative materials", J Clin Pediatr Dent, 31, pp.1~4 (2006)
  21. Agrawal R, "Clinical Evaluation of Stainless Steel Crown versus Zirconia Crown in Primary Molars : An In Vivo Study", Int J Clin Pediatr Dent, 15, pp.15~19 (2022)
  22. Clark L, "Comparison of Amount of Primary Tooth Reduction Required for Anterior and Posterior Zirconia and Stainless Steel Crowns", Pediatr Dent, 38, pp.42~46 (2016)
  23. Alzanbaqi SD, "Zirconia Crowns for Primary Teeth : A Systematic Review and Meta-Analyses", Int J Environ Res Public Health, 19, pp.2838~ (2022)
  24. Chen Y, "Analysis of survival and factors associated with failure of primary tooth pulpectomies performed under general anaesthesia in children from South China", Int J Paediatr Dent, 30, pp.225~233 (2020)
  25. 방세정, "유치 치수치료가 치아 탈락에 미치는 영향에 관한 후향적 연구", 대한소아치과학회지, 50(1), pp.24~34 (2023), 대한소아치과학회
  26. Yang B, "Influence of saliva contamination on zirconia ceramic bonding", Dent Mater, 24, pp.508~513 (2008)
  27. Mulder R, "In vitro analysis of the marginal adaptation and discrepancy of stainless steel crowns", Acta Biomater Odontol Scand, 4, pp.20~29 (2018)
  28. 최지은, "유구치 치관 및 기성금속관이 크기에 관한 계측학적 연구", 대한소아치과학회지, 28(3), pp.355~362 (2001), 대한소아치과학회
  29. Güçlü ZA, "Can zirconia crowns be the first restorative choice after endodontic treatment of primary teeth?", Int J Clin Pract, 75, pp.E14888~ (2021)
  30. 정윤영, "12세 이하 아동의 제1대구치 복합레진 수복의 재수복률에 관한 연구", 대한소아치과학회지, 45(3), pp.370~377 (2018), 대한소아치과학회[DOI]
  31. Alomari Q, "Recurrent caries at crown margins : making a decision on treatment", Med Princ Pract, 18, pp.187~192 (2009)
  32. Lopez-Cazaux S, "Preformed pediatric zirconia crown versus preformed pediatric metal crown : study protocol for a randomized clinical trial", Trials, 20, pp.530~ (2019)
  33. Alhissan AS, "Factors Influencing the Survival of Preformed Zirconia Crowns in Children Treated under General Anesthesia", Int J Dent, 2021, pp.5515383~ (2021)
  34. Srinivasan SR, "Comparison of Three Luting Cements for Prefabricated Zirconia Crowns in Primary Molar Teeth : a 36-month Randomized Clinical Trial", Pediatr Dent, 45, pp.117~124 (2023)
  35. Yang B, "Influence of saliva contamination on zirconia ceramic bonding", Dent Mater, 24, pp.508~513 (2008)
  36. Ninawe N, "Zirconia Crowns In Pediatric Dentistry : A Review", J Posit Sch Psychol, 6, pp.1718~1724 (2022)
  37. 김재용, "Comparison of Bonding Strength by Cleaning Method of Pediatric Zirconia Crown Contaminated with Saliva or Blood", 대한소아치과학회지, 45(2), pp.185~194 (2018), 대한소아치과학회[DOI]

관련 논문AI추천

유구치에서 우식의 깊이에 따른 기성 금속관 수복물 생존율 연구라지영, 유현경, 이제우대한치과의사협회 · 대한치과의사협회지2019 · 제57권 제10호Retrospective study of survival rate according to the type of dental restoration of proximal caries in maxillary primary incisors김두수, 남옥형, 이난영, 지명관치의학연구원 · Oral Biology Research2019 · 제43권 제4호치과용 수복재료에 따른 유구치부 인접면 수복물의 생존율연구 : 후향적연구이난영, 이상호, 지명관대한소아치과학회 · 대한소아치과학회지2015 · 제42권 제3호유동성 복합레진을 이용한 유구치 II급 수복의 생존율박소영, 서혜준, 신종현, 이은경, 정태성대한소아치과학회 · 대한소아치과학회지2021 · 제48권 제1호Micro-CT를 이용한 발거된 유구치의 기성금속관 평가김신, 김지연, 신종현, 정보람, 정태성대한소아치과학회 · 대한소아치과학회지2015 · 제42권 제1호제1대구치 복합레진 수복의 5년 누적 생존율신지선, 정윤선대한소아치과학회 · 대한소아치과학회지2019 · 제46권 제3호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (9건)

치과의사를 위한 노이즈 필터링 이어플러그의 청력 보호 효과에 관한 연구조다영, 이태양, 김익환, 정진세, 송제선, 박원서, 신승호pp. 239-251제퍼슨의 공감 척도를 사용한 치과 대학생의 공감 능력 측정김희민, 이대우, 양연미, 김재곤pp. 252-262유치의 치근단 방사선 사진에서 딥 러닝 알고리즘을 이용한 모델의 인접면 우식증 객체 탐지 능력의 평가전홍주, 김선미, 최남기pp. 263-276An in Vitro Study of the Effects of Different Dentin Bonding Agents on the Prevention of Tooth Discoloration and the Sealing Ability of Calcium Silicate-Based Cement in Regenerative Endodontic Procedures이제식, 김기민, 한지은pp. 277-291Analysis of Dental Antibiotic Prescriptions for Children and Adolescents in South Korea김지훈, 이승준pp. 292-306
원문 보기