개정해상법의 문제점 검토
A Study on Problems with the Revised Maritime Law
0
조회
0
다운로드
10
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Part 5 of the Commercial Law on maritime law was revised in 2007. Most of the clauses were rearranged as 8 chapters in Part 5 were reorganized into 3 chapters. The rearrangement of the clauses may seem like a major revision, but only 30 out of 157 clauses were inserted, revised or deleted in Part 5. Regarding the formality, the most prominent feature of the revised commercial law is the different formation. Chapters were significantly reduced and the order and the contents of each section were reorganized. The externality has undergone a major change as terms used in each clause were revised as well. However, the changes seem to have caused several unpredicted problems. The relevance of the titles of chapters and sections, logicality of section arrangements and possible ambiguity of certain legal terms are some of the issues. This thesis is focusing on problems that may arise from the formal changes of the revised commercial law and yet could easily be overlooked. Alternatives to secure relevance of chapter titles, logicality of section arrangement and appropriateness of legal terms are provided on this thesis in hopes of contributing to making a more sophisticated code of law. Especially it is “charterer” amd “shipowner” coming out in a commercial law Chapter 2, and these expressions will revise so that there is the number of to understand the meaning easily. A shipowner using in the commercial law must interpret by the only meaning. And It must interpret that charterer in the commercial law includes voyage-charterer, time-charterer and bare-boat charterer.
Abstract
Part 5 of the Commercial Law on maritime law was revised in 2007. Most of the clauses were rearranged as 8 chapters in Part 5 were reorganized into 3 chapters. The rearrangement of the clauses may seem like a major revision, but only 30 out of 157 clauses were inserted, revised or deleted in Part 5. Regarding the formality, the most prominent feature of the revised commercial law is the different formation. Chapters were significantly reduced and the order and the contents of each section were reorganized. The externality has undergone a major change as terms used in each clause were revised as well. However, the changes seem to have caused several unpredicted problems. The relevance of the titles of chapters and sections, logicality of section arrangements and possible ambiguity of certain legal terms are some of the issues. This thesis is focusing on problems that may arise from the formal changes of the revised commercial law and yet could easily be overlooked. Alternatives to secure relevance of chapter titles, logicality of section arrangement and appropriateness of legal terms are provided on this thesis in hopes of contributing to making a more sophisticated code of law. Especially it is “charterer” amd “shipowner” coming out in a commercial law Chapter 2, and these expressions will revise so that there is the number of to understand the meaning easily. A shipowner using in the commercial law must interpret by the only meaning. And It must interpret that charterer in the commercial law includes voyage-charterer, time-charterer and bare-boat charterer.
참고문헌 (27)
- 김인현, "해상법" (2007), 법문사
- 배병태, "주석 해상법" (1981), 한국사법행정학회
- 손주찬, "상법(하)" (2005), 박영사
- 송상현, "해상법원론 제3판" (2005), 박영사
- 정동윤, "제3판 상법(하)" (2003), 법문사
- 정찬형, "상법강의(하)(제10판)" (2008), 박영사
- 강정혜, "?개정해상법의 문제점 검토? 토론문", 한국상사법학회 2008 하계학술대회 (2008)
- 김인현,"2007년 상법 해상편의 편제 및 복합운송에 대한 개정경위와 그 내용",한국해법학회 지 제30권 제1호,한국해법학회, "2007년 상법 해상편의 편제 및 복합운송에 대한 개정경위와 그 내용", 한국해법학회지, 30(1) (2008), 한국해법학회
- 김인현, "2007. 7. 3.개정 상법 해상편에 관한 고찰" (2007)
- 김인현, "해상법 개정시안에 대한 검토 및 건의사항", 한국해법학회지, 27(2) (2005)
- 김인현, "상법 제806조의 법적 검토", 한국해법학회지, 24(1) (2004)
- 박찬재, "해상법 개정시안에 대한 의견, 상법(해상편) 개정공청회 자료(법무부)" (2005)
- 배병태, "해상법 체계와 해상기업 책임법제의 개정개요, 해양한국" (2008)
- 송호신, "2007년 개정상법 해상편 주요내용의 법리분석", 법학논총(한양대학교 법학연구소), 24(3) (2007)
- 송호신, "상법 해상편 개정조문의 해석과 입법쟁점의 재검토", 기업법연구, 22(1) (2008), 한국 기업법학회
- 송호신, "개정해상법의 문제점 검토?에 대한 토론문", 한국상사법학회 2008 하계학술대회 (2008)
- 蔡利植, "海上運送契約法의 體系와 立法에 관한 硏究", 韓國海法學會誌, 22(2) (2000)
- 蔡利植, "해상물건운송법 체계의 재검토", 韓國海法學會誌, 24(1) (2002)
- 최재선, "해상법 개정 방향과 주요 쟁점, 해양수산 현안 분석" (2005), 한국해양수산 개발원
- 최종현, "개정 해상법 하에서의 해상운송인의 지위 - 해상운송인의 손해배상책임제도를 중심으로 -", 한국해법학회지, 30(1), pp.49~83 (2008), 한국해법학회
- 국회 법제사법위원회, "상법 일부개정법률안 심사보고서" (2007)
- 법무부, "상법(해상편) 개정공청회 자료" (2005)
- 법무부, "상법개정특별분과위원회 회의록" (2006)
- 한국해법학회 해상법개정문제연구회, "해상법(상법 제5편) 개정문제연구보고서" (2004)
- 韓國海法學會 海商法改正問題硏究會, "海商法改正試案 및 繼續檢討事項", 韓國海法學會誌, 26(1) (2004)
- 고려해운, "상법개정시안에 대한 의견, 한국선주협회-해운자료" (2005)
- 한성선박, "한국선주협회의 해상법 개정의견", 韓國海法學會誌, 23(2) (2001)
