본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

1주1의결권원칙과 차등의결권원칙에 대한 검토

One Share One Vote vs. Dual Class Voting System

윤영신
한국상사법학회|2009.05|상사법연구 (KOREAN COMMERCIAL LAW ASSOCIATION)|제28권 제1호|pp. 203-241

0

조회

0

다운로드

28

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

지배권순환출자차등의결권복수의결권1주1의결권pyramid structure다수의결권현금흐름권dual-class recapitalization. multiple voting sharesone share one voteconrtrolling minority shareholderscontrol enhancing mechanism
주제분류법학

초록

Abstract

The concept of multiple voting shares is not allowed under the Korean Commercial Code(KCC). Although the amendment bill of KCC is considering allowance of non-voting common shares, the multiple voting shares or priority shares are not permitted under the amendment bill. This paper analyzed whether multiple voting shares should be allowed under the current corporate governance environment in Korea. In the United States, a company is able to issue multiple voting right shares without any limitation under most of state corporate laws, but the dual class recapitalization by listed companies is prohibited by listing rules. Many European countries allow multiple voting share system, even though pyramidal share ownership is prevalent among European companies. In Korea, controlling shareholders have disproportionately higher control right compared to their cash flow right through pyramidal and circular share ownership and the private benefit of control seems to be larger than U.S. or European Companies. Under this corporate governance settings, the agency cost of additional control enhancing mechanism like multiple voting shares might be likely to exceed its benefit. Under this analysis, it may not be desirable to allow multiple voting shares in the listed companies where pyramidal and circular share ownership is prevalent.

참고문헌 (47)

  1. 김건식, "21세기 회사법개정의 논리" (2008), 소화출판사
  2. 김화진, "기업인수합병" (2007)
  3. 경영권에 대한 연구-실증분석과 제도정비방안을 중심으로, KDI 연구보고서, "연태훈", ~ (2005)
  4. EU의 경영권 방어수단 현황 및 그 함의: 과연 EU는 경영권 방어의 천국인가?, "경제개혁연대", ~, pp.경제개혁리포트 2008-11호 (2008)
  5. 김두식, "M&A 법제의 개선방안 연구", 상장협, (50) (2004)
  6. 독약증권(poison Pill): 우리나라에선 진짜 독, "김우찬", 경제개혁연대, ~, pp.경제개혁리포트 2008-6호 (2008)
  7. 노혁준, "경영권 이전에 관한 몇 가지 쟁점: 공개매수에 관한 EU의 제13지침과 그 시사점", 서울대학교 법학, 48(4), pp.260~313 (2007), 법학연구소
  8. 상장자료실, "차등의결권제도의 각국 사례와 검토과제", 상장 (2008)
  9. 송 종 준, "방어적 주식제도의 국제적 입법동향과 도입 과제 - 2006년 회사법 개정안을 중심으로 -", 경영법률, 17(2), pp.91~128 (2007), 한국경영법률학회
  10. 연태훈, "적대적 M&A 방어수단 강화에 관한 소고", 기업지배구조연구, 41 (2008)
  11. 유영일, "차등의결권주에 관한 연구 - 도입필요성을 중심으로 -", 상사판례연구, 21(4), pp.93~135 (2008), 한국상사판례학회
  12. 윤진수, "적대적 M&A 방어를 위한 기업지배구조 개선의 필요성", 기업지배구조리뷰, 37 (2008)
  13. 임중호, "상법 일부개정법률안(정부제출) 검토보고", ~ (2007)
  14. 加藤貴仁, "株主間の議決權配分" (2007), 商事法務
  15. 木村芳彦, "公開會社における議決權コントロールの柔軟化に關るす一考察-證券取 引所におけるコーポレート․ガバナンス關與の今日的意義", ソフトロー硏究, (2) (2005)
  16. ISS Europe, "Report on the Proportionality Principle in the European Union", ~
  17. Bainbridge, Stephen M, "The short Life and Resurrection of SEC Rule 19c-4", Wash. Univ. L. Q., 69, pp.565~568 (1991)
  18. Bebchuk, Lucien A, "A Rent-Protection Theory of Corporate Ownership And Control", pp.7203~ (1999), NBER Working Paper
  19. Bebchuk, Lucian A., "Stock Pyramids, Cross-Ownership and Dual Class Equity: The Mechanism and Agency Costs of Separating Control From Cash-Flow Rights" (2000), Concentrated Corporate Ownership
  20. Bianco, Magada, "Pyramidal Groups and Internal Capital Markets: Efficiency vs. Expropriation" (1998), Working paper
  21. The One-Share - One Vote Debate: A Theoretical Perspective, "Burkart, Mike", ~, pp.ECGI Finance Working Paper No. 176 (2007), 2007
  22. Dual Class IPOs, Share Recapitalizations, and Unifications: A Theoretical Analysis, "Chemmanur, Thomas J", ~, pp.ECGI Finance Working Paper No. 129 (2006), 2006
  23. Classens, Stijn, "The Separation of Ownership and Control in East Asian Corporations", J. of Fin. Econ., 57, pp.1~ (2002)
  24. Deminor Rating, "Application of the One Share - One Vote Principle in Europe (Commissioned By Association of British Insurers)", ~ (2005)
  25. Private Benefits of Control: An International Comparison, "Dyck, Alexander", Harvard Law School Program on Negotiation PON Working Paper, ~, pp.The Center for Research in Security Prices Working Paper No. 535 (2001)
  26. One Share - One Vote: A European Rule?, "Ferrarini, Guido", ~, pp.ECGI　Law Working Paper No. 58 (2006), 2006
  27. Ferrarini, Guido, "Share Ownership, Takeover Law and the Contestability of Corporate Control, in Company Law Reform in OECD Countries. A Comparative Outlook of Current Trends", Conference Proceedings(fothcoming)
  28. Corporate Governance Convergence: Evidence from Takeover Regulation Reforms in Europe, "Georgen, Marc", ~, pp.ECGI Law Working Paper No. 33 (2005), 2005
  29. Gilson, Ronald J, "Evaluating Dual Class Common Stock: The Relevence of Subsitutes", Va. L. Rev., 73, pp.807~ (1987)
  30. Extreme Governance: An Analysis of Dual-Class Firms in the United States (May 1, 2008) AFA 2005 Philadelphia Meetings, "Gompers, Paul A", ~, pp.White Center for Financial Research Working Paper No. 12-04; Rock Center for Corporate Governance Working Paper No. 39 (2008)
  31. Gordon, J, "Ties That Bond: Dual Class Common Stock and the Problem of Shareholder Choice", Calif. L. Rev., 76, pp.1~ (1988)
  32. Grossman. S, "One share one vote And the Marker for Corporate Corporate Control", J. of Fin. Econ., 20 (1988)
  33. Holmen, Martin, "Corporate Control and Security Design in Initial Public Offerings" (1999), Working draft, Stockholm School of Economics
  34. Investor Responsibility Research Center Inc, "Corporate Takeover Defenses 2004", ~
  35. Joh, Sung Wook, "Corporate Governance and Firm Profitability: Evidence From Korea Before the Economic Crisis", J. of Fin. Econ., 68, pp.2~ (2003)
  36. The One-Share-One-Vote Controversy in the EU, "Khachaturyn, Arman", ~, pp.ECMI Paper No. 1 (2006)
  37. 1999 Emerging Market Business Group, Foreign Investors, and Corporate Governance, "Khanna, Tarun", National Bureau of Economic Research, ~, pp.NBER Working Paper no. 6955 (1999)
  38. The One Share-One Vote Debate: A Theoretical Perspecttive, "Lee, Samuel", ~, pp.ECGI Finance Working Paper No. 176 (2007), 2007
  39. Why Some Double Taxation Might Make Sense: The Special Case of Inter-corporate Dividends, "Morck, Randall", ~, pp.University of Alberta Centre for Financial Research Working Paper No. 03-01 (2003)
  40. Corporate Governance, Economic Entrenchment and Growth, "Morck, Randall", ~, pp.NBER Working Paper 10692 (2004)
  41. Published R, "Corporate Governance, Economic Entrenchment, and Growth", Journal of Economic Literature, 43, pp.1~ (2005)
  42. Determinants and Consequences of the Unification of Dual-Class Shares, "Pajuste, Anete", ~, pp.ECB Working Paper No. 465 (2005)
  43. "Report of The High Level Group of Company Law Experts on Issues Related to Takeover Bids", ~ (2002)
  44. Seligman, Joel, "Equal Protection In Shareholder Voting Rights: The One Common Share, One Vote Controversy", Geo. Wash. L. Rev., 54, pp.687~ (1986)
  45. Skog, R, "A Remarkable Decade: The Awakening of Swedish Institutional Investors", The Future of Corporate Governance, The Stockholm Symposium 2004 (2004)
  46. Smart, Scott, "Control as a Motivation for Underpricing: A Comparison of Dual and Single-Class IPOs", J. Fin. Econ, 69, pp.85~ (2003)
  47. Weil, Gotshal, "Comparative Study of Corporate Governance Codes Relevant to the European Union And Its Member States Final Report & Annexes", ~ (2002)

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (7건)

독일 주식법상 이사의 의무와 책임추궁조지현pp. 9-41일본 회사법상 이사의 의무와 책임추궁양만식pp. 43-91한국 상법상 이사의 의무와 책임추궁김병연pp. 93-130어음交換規約上의 事故申告, 事故申告擔保金김교창pp. 131-169완결조항에 관한 소고최영홍pp. 171-202
원문 보기