체질진단설문지 정확률 연구의 연구방법론 고찰
The Methodological Review on the Accuracy Study of Questionnaire for Sasang Constitution Diagnosis
2
조회
0
다운로드
13
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Objectives For the methodological review on the accuracy study of questionnaire for Sasang constitution diagnosis, we searched the various diagnostic accuracy study of the questionnaires for Sasang constitution. Methods We searched MEDLINE, the Cochrane Library, KISS, and DBPIA. Additionally, We hand-searched the main oriental medical journals. All articles were independently reviewed and selected by two evaluators. And selected articles were assessed by "Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies Tool"(QUADAS Tool) for the methodological review. Results The twenty eight studies initially identified studies were included in the methodological review. The part of "Acceptable reference standard", "Uninterpretable results reported" and "Withdrawals explained" was very weak in the risk of bias. The part of "Representative spectrum", "Acceptable delay between tests", "Incorporation avoided", "Reference standard results blinded", "Index test results blinded" was unclear in the description. Conclusions For the further study on the accuracy study of Sasang constitution diagnosis, we have to improve the aforementioned errors. Additionally, the checklist for the description of study might be needed.
Abstract
Objectives For the methodological review on the accuracy study of questionnaire for Sasang constitution diagnosis, we searched the various diagnostic accuracy study of the questionnaires for Sasang constitution. Methods We searched MEDLINE, the Cochrane Library, KISS, and DBPIA. Additionally, We hand-searched the main oriental medical journals. All articles were independently reviewed and selected by two evaluators. And selected articles were assessed by "Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies Tool"(QUADAS Tool) for the methodological review. Results The twenty eight studies initially identified studies were included in the methodological review. The part of "Acceptable reference standard", "Uninterpretable results reported" and "Withdrawals explained" was very weak in the risk of bias. The part of "Representative spectrum", "Acceptable delay between tests", "Incorporation avoided", "Reference standard results blinded", "Index test results blinded" was unclear in the description. Conclusions For the further study on the accuracy study of Sasang constitution diagnosis, we have to improve the aforementioned errors. Additionally, the checklist for the description of study might be needed.
참고문헌 (21)
- Ware JE, "Conceptual framework and item selection", MedCare, 30(6), pp.473~83 (1992)
- Lee SW, "Current researches on the methods of diagnosing sasang constitution: an overview", eCAM, 6(S1), pp.43~49 (2009)
- Koh BH, "An essay on pattern identification of Sasang constitution", J Korean Oriental Med, 6(1), pp.40~47 (1985)
- Koh BH, "Study for pattern identification methodology of Sasang constitution", J Korean Oriental Med, 8(1), pp.146~160 (1987)
- Lee EJ, "The Study on The Validity of "Questionnaire of Sasang Constitution Classification (I)"", J Sasang Constitut Med, 7(2), pp.89~100 (1995)
- Kim SH, "A Validation Study of Questionnaire of Sasang Constitutional Classification (QSCC)", J Sasang Constitut Med, 5(1), pp.67~85 (1993)
- Kim SH, "A study on the standardization of QSCCII (Questionnaire for the Sasang Constitution Classification II)", J Sasang Constitut Med, 7(1), pp.187~246 (1995)
- Lee JC, "The Validation Study of the Questionnaire of Sasang Constitution Classification", J Sasang Constitut Med, 8(1), pp.247~294 (1996)
- Park HS, "A Study on clinical application of the QSCC II (Questionnaire for the Sasang Constitution Classification II)", J Sasang Constitut Med, 14(2), pp.35~44 (2002)
- 설유경, "의사용, 환자용 설문지의 중요도 분석", 사상체질의학회지, 18(3), pp.94~123 (2006), 사상체질의학회
- Kim YW, "Study in Objectification of the Diagnosis of Sasang Constitution (According to Analysis of the Past Questionnaires)", J Sasang Constitut Med, 11(2), pp.151~179 (1999)
- Kim SB, "A Study on responses to the questionnaire based on of revised Sasang Constitution Classification Ⅱ (QSCCⅡ+)", J Sasang Constitut Med, 13(3), pp.15~22 (2001)
- Lee EJ, "The Analysis of Self-checking Questionnaires for Identifing Sasangin", J Sasang Constitut Med, 15(3), pp.74~87 (2003)
- 김종열, "Sasangin Diagnosis Questionnaire: Test of reliability", JOURNAL OF ALTERNATIVE AND COMPLEMENTARY MEDICINE, 13(1), pp.111~122, MARY ANN LIEBERT INC
- 이시우, "환자용 사상체질진단 설문지의 체질별 응답차이에 관한 연구", 사상체질의학회지, 19(3), pp.89~98 (2007), 사상체질의학회
- 김영원, "사상체질 진단을 위한 2단계 설문지(TS-QSCD)의 개발 연구", 사상체질의학회지, 18(1), pp.75~90 (2006), 사상체질의학회
- 신동윤, "사상체질 진단을 위한 2단계 설문지(TS-QSCD)의 표준화 연구", 사상체질의학회지, 21(1), pp.99~126 (2009), 사상체질의학회
- Whiting P, "The development of QUADAS: a tool for the quality assessment of studies of diagnostic accuracy included in systematic reviews", BMC Med Res Methodol, 3, pp.25~ (2003)
- Mariska M.G. Leeflang, "Constantine Gatsonis, Patrick M.M. Bossuyt. Systematic Reviews of Diagnostic Test Accuracy", Annals of Internal Medicine, 149, pp.889~897 (2008)
- Deeks JJ, "Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Diagnostic Test Accuracy Version 1.0.0" (2009), The Cochrane Collaboration
- Bossuyt PM, "Towards complete and accurate reporting of studies of diagnostic accuracy: the STARD initiative", BMJ, 326, pp.41~44 (2003)