본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Farewell to Pacifism the Changing Facet of Japan's Constitutional Identity

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류법학

초록

The term ‘constitutional identity’ has gained increasing popularity in constitutional jurisprudence. However, it remains a contested concept that accommodates diverse approaches to both national and transnational constitutional issues. Drawing on Gary Jacobsohn’s work, the article will outline a theoretical framework to locate the identity of a constitution through a comparative law lens. To put it in perspective, the article argues that pacifism – lying at the heart of Japan’s postwar Constitution– may be considered a constitutional identity of Japan. On top of it, this identity is gradually changing. The article attempts to capture its dynamic by probing recent constitutional discourses on Japan’s self-defense stance.

Abstract

The term ‘constitutional identity’ has gained increasing popularity in constitutional jurisprudence. However, it remains a contested concept that accommodates diverse approaches to both national and transnational constitutional issues. Drawing on Gary Jacobsohn’s work, the article will outline a theoretical framework to locate the identity of a constitution through a comparative law lens. To put it in perspective, the article argues that pacifism – lying at the heart of Japan’s postwar Constitution– may be considered a constitutional identity of Japan. On top of it, this identity is gradually changing. The article attempts to capture its dynamic by probing recent constitutional discourses on Japan’s self-defense stance.

참고문헌 (116)

  1. "His Holiness Kesavananda Bharati Sripadagalvaru and Ors. v. State of Kerala and Anr., 4 SCC 225", ~ (1973)
  2. "BVerfGE Lisbon 2 be 2", 08 (Eng), 2009
  3. Dec. 16, 1959, no. 27660683, 13 Keishū 3225 (Japan), translated with commentary in John Maki, Court and Constitution in Japan: Selected Supreme Court Decisions 1948-60, at 298, "University of Washington Press", 1964
  4. "Judgment of H18 (ne) No. 499 Nagoya High Ct." (2008)[URL]
  5. Alasdair MacIntyre, "After Virtue: A Study in Moral Theory" (1981), University of Notre Dame Press
  6. Alasdair MacIntyre, "Whose Justice? Which Rationality?" (1988), University of Notre Dame Press
  7. Alejandro Arnaiz, "National Constitutional Identity and European Integration" (2013), Intersentia Publishing
  8. Amy Catalinac, "Identity Theory and Foreign Policy: Explaining Japan’s Responses to the 1991 Gulf War and the 2003 US War in Iraq, 35 Politics and Policy", ~ (2007)
  9. András Sajó, "Constitutional Topography: Values and Constitutions" (2010), Eleven International Publishing
  10. Bidyut Chakrabarty, "India’s Constitutional Identity: Ideological Beliefs and Preferences" (2019), Routledge
  11. Bui N. Son, "Globalization of Constitutional Identity", Washington International Law Journal, 26 (2017)
  12. Carol Gluck, "Showa: The Japan of Hirohito" (1990), W.W. Norton & Co.
  13. Chaihark Hahm, "Making we the people : democratic constitutional founding in postwar Japan and South Korea" (2015), Cambridge University Press
  14. Christian Calliess, "Constitutional Identity in a Europe of Multilevel Constitutionalism" (2019), Cambridge University Press
  15. Christian Tomuschat, "The Ruling of the German Constitutional Court on the Treaty of Lisbon", German Law Journal, 10(8), pp.1262~ (2009)
  16. Craig Martin, "Binding the Dogs of War: Japan and the Constitutionalizing of Jus Ad Bellum", University of Pennsylvania Journal of International Law, 30 (2008)
  17. "The Case Against Revising Interpretations of the Japanese Constitution"[URL]
  18. Daiki Shibuichi, "The Article 9 Association, Leftist Elites, and the Movement to Save Article 9 of Japan’s Postwar Constitution", East Asia, 34 (2017)
  19. David Landau, "Abusive Constitutionalism", UC Davis Law Review, 47 (2013)
  20. David Law, "The Anatomy of a Conservative Court: Judicial Review in Japan", Texas Law Review, 87 (2009)
  21. Denis Galligan, "The Social and Political Foundations of Constitutions" (2013), Cambridge University Press
  22. Derek van Hoften, "Declaring War on the Japanese Constitution: Japan’s Right to Military Sovereignty and the United States’ Right to Military Presence in Japan", Hastings International and Comparative Law Review, 26 (2003)
  23. Domenico Amirente, "South Asian Constitutional Systems", pp.1~6 (2020), Eleven International Publishing
  24. Edmund Morgan, "Inventing the People: The Rise of Popular Sovereignty in England and America" (1989), W. W. Norton & Company
  25. Edwin Reischauer, "The Japanese Today: Change and Continuity" (1988), Belknap Press of Harvard University
  26. Ellen Paul, "What Should Constitutions Do?" (2011), Cambridge University Press
  27. Ernst von Hippel, "The Role of Natural Law in the Legal Decisions of the German Federal Republic", Natural Law Forum, 4 (1959)
  28. 3 International Organization, "Far Eastern Commission", ~ (1949)
  29. Frederick Schauer, "On the Migration of Constitutional Ideas", Connecticut Law Review, 37 (2005)
  30. Gary Jacobsohn, "Constitutional Identity" (2010), Harvard University Press
  31. Geoffrey Brennan, "Jose Casas Pardo, A Reading of the Spanish Constitution (1978)", Constitutional Political Economy, 2(1) (1991)
  32. Giulio Pugliese, "Sino-Japanese Power Politics: Might, Money and Minds" (2017), Palgrave Macmillan
  33. Gordon Wood, "The Creation of the American Republic" (1969), University of North Carolina Press
  34. Hans Agné, "Democratic Founding: We the People and the Others", International Journal of Constitutional Law, 10 (2012)
  35. Heinz Klug, "Constitutional Identity and Change", Tulsa Law Review, 47 (2011)
  36. Herbert Bix, "Hirohito and the Making of Modern Japan" (2009), Harper Collins
  37. Ichiro Ozawa, "A Blueprint for a New Japan: The Rethinking of a Nation" (1994), Kodansha
  38. James Auer, "Article Nine of Japan’s Constitution: From Renunciation of Armed Force “Forever” to the Third Largest Defense Budget in the World", Law and Contemporary Problems, 53 (1990)
  39. Jeffery K. Tulis, "The Limits of Constitutional Democracy" (2010), Princeton University Press
  40. John Dower, "Embracing Defeat: Japan in the Wake of World War II" (2000), W. W. Norton & Company
  41. John Dower, "Empire and Aftermath: Yoshida Shigeru and the Japanese Experience, 1878–1954" (1979), Harvard University Press
  42. Andrew Gordon, "Postwar Japan as History" (1993), University of California Press
  43. John Haley, "Waging War: Japan’s Constitutional Constraints", Constitutional Forum, 14 (2005)
  44. John Ikenberry, "American hegemony and East Asian order", Australian Journal of International Affairs, 58 (2004)
  45. John Maki, "The Constitution of Japan: Pacifism, Popular Sovereignty, and Fundamental Human Rights", Law and Contemporary Problems, 53 (1990)
  46. Karl Gustafsson, "Japan’s Pacifism Is Dead", Survival, 60 (2018)
  47. Karl Gustafsson, "Long Live Pacifism! Narrative Power and Japan’s Pacifist Model", Cambridge Review of International Affairs, 32 (2019)
  48. Karl Gustafsson, "Narratives and Bilateral Relations: Rethinking the “History Issue” in Sino-Japanese Relations", PhD, Department of Political Science, pp.2011
  49. Kenneth B. Pyle, "Japan Rising: The Resurgence of Japanese Power and Purpose" (2007), The Century Foundation
  50. Larry Alexander, "Constitutionalism: Philosophical Foundations" (1998), Cambridge University Press
  51. Lawrence Beer, "From Imperial Myth to Democracy: Japan’s Two Constitutions - 1889–2002" (2002), University Press of Colorado
  52. Lawrence Beer, "Peace in Theory and Practice Under Article 9 of Japan’s Constitution", Marquette Law Review, 81 (1998)
  53. Linus Hagström, "Pacifist Identity, Civics Textbooks, and the Opposition to Japan’s Security Legislation", The Journal of Japanese Studies, 45 (2019)
  54. Mark Tushnet, "Taking the Constitution Away from the Courts" (1999), Princeton University Press
  55. Matthew Palmer, "What is New Zealand’s Constitution and Who Interprets It? Constitutional Realism and the Importance of Public Office-holders", Public Law Review, 17 (2006)
  56. Michal Kolmaš, "Identity Change and Societal Pressures in Japan: The Constraints on Abe Shinzo’s Educational and Constitutional Reform", The Pacific Review, 33 (2020)
  57. Michel Rosenfeld, "The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Constitutional Law" (2012), Oxford University Press
  58. Michel Rosenfeld, "The Identity of the Constitutional Subject: Selfhood, Citizenship, Culture, and Community" (2010), Routledge
  59. Miki Ishikida, "Toward Peace: War Responsibility, Postwar Compensation, and Peace Movements and Education in Japan" (2005), iUniverse Pub
  60. Miyazawa Kiichi, "Secret Talks Between Tokyo and Washington: The Memoirs of Miyazawa Kiichi, 1949–1954", pp.31~ (2007), Lexington Books
  61. Osamu Nishi, "The Constitution and the National Defense Law System in Japan", pp.73~ (1987), Seibundo Pub. Co
  62. "Nine Lives?: The Politics of Constitutional Reform in Japan" (2005)[URL]
  63. Patrick Glenn, "Legal Traditions of the World Sustainable Diversity in Law" (2010), Oxford University Press
  64. Ran Hirschl, "Comparative Matters: The Renaissance of Comparative Constitutional Law" (2014), Oxford University Press
  65. Ray Moore, "Donald Robinson, Partners for Democracy: Crafting the New Japanese State Under MacArthur" (2004), Oxford University Press
  66. Robert Post, "The Supreme Court, 2002 Term - Forward: Fashioning the Legal Constitution: Culture, Courts, and Law", Harvard Law Review, 117 (2003)
  67. Rosalind Dixon, "Globalizing Constitutional Moments? A Reflection on the Japanese Article 9 Debate", The American Journal of Comparative Law, 67 (2019)
  68. Sheldon Harris, "Factories of Death, Japan’s Secret Biological Warfare Projects in Manchuria and China, 1932-1945" (2002), Routledge
  69. Shigenori Matsui, "Fundamental Human Rights and ‘Traditional Japanese Values’: Constitutional Amendment and Vision of the Japanese Society", Asian Journal of Comparative Law, 13 (2018)
  70. Sujit Choudhry, "The Migration of Constitutional Ideas" (2006), Cambridge University Press
  71. Takashi Yoshida, "From Cultures of War to Cultures of Peace: War and Peace Museums in Japan, China, and South Korea" (2014), MerwinAsia
  72. Tatsuo Sato, "The Origin and Development of the Draft Constitution of Japan", Contem porary Japan, 24 (1956)
  73. Theodore McNelly, "The Origins of Japan’s Democratic Constitution" (2000), University Press of America
  74. Thomas Kellogg, "Arguing Chinese Constitutionalism: The 2013 Constitutional Debate and the Urgency of Political Reform", University of Pennsylvania Asian Law Review, 11 (2016)
  75. Tom Ginsburg, "We the Peoples: The Global Origins of Constitutional Preambles", George Washington International Law Review, 46 (2013)
  76. Studying Japanese Law because It’s There, "Tom Ginsburg", University of Chicago Public Law & Legal Theory, ~, pp.Working Paper No. 294 (2010)
  77. Tom Ginsburg, "Comparative Constitutional Law – Research Handbooks on Comparative Law" (2011), Edward Elgar Publishing
  78. "Constitutional Identity: An Overview and Some Conceptual Concerns"[URL]
  79. Esin Örücü, "Comparative Law: A Handbook" (2007), Hart Publishing
  80. Yaniz Roznai, "Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendments" (2019), Oxford University Press
  81. Yasuhiro Izumikawa, "Explaining Japanese Antimilitarism - Normative and Realist Constraints on Japan’s Security Policy", International Security, 35 (2010)
  82. Yasuo Hasebe, "Book Review on Making We the People: Democratic Constitutional Founding in Postwar Japan and South Korea by Chaihark Hahm and Sung Ho Kim", Asian Journal of Comparative Law (2016)
  83. Yasuo Hasebe, "The End of Constitutional Pacifism?", Washington Law Review, 26 (2017)
  84. Yasuo Hasebe, "Constitutional Courts in Asia - A Comparative Perspective 289" (2018), Cambridge Univ. Press
  85. Yoichi Higuchi, "Five Decades of Constitutionalism in Japanese Society" (2001), University of Tokyo Press

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (5건)