달의 위상변화 원인에 대한 초등학생들의 논증과 개념 분석
Elementary School Students’ Arguments on Causes of Phases of the Moon and Concept Analysis
0
조회
0
다운로드
8
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The purpose of this study is to characterize students' conceptions on causes of the phases of the moon. For this purpose, students were given a worksheet for argumentative writing activity where in they need to choose the right answer between five statements and provide reasonable evidences about causes of the phases of the moon. Written arguments collected were used as analysis data and TAP(Toulmin’s argument pattern) including conceptual analysis of TAP elements were utilized to figure out logical structures and subordinate conceptions. The result showed that students had various alternative concepts about causes of the phases of the moon and associated with celestial. Also 70.5% of subjects had incomplete argument structures, and error types of concepts had difference according to types of alternative concepts as well as TAP. These results mean that importance of checking students' preconceptions, need of scientific argumentation, and appropriate instructional strategies considering alternative conception types and fallacy types that students had.
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to characterize students' conceptions on causes of the phases of the moon. For this purpose, students were given a worksheet for argumentative writing activity where in they need to choose the right answer between five statements and provide reasonable evidences about causes of the phases of the moon. Written arguments collected were used as analysis data and TAP(Toulmin’s argument pattern) including conceptual analysis of TAP elements were utilized to figure out logical structures and subordinate conceptions. The result showed that students had various alternative concepts about causes of the phases of the moon and associated with celestial. Also 70.5% of subjects had incomplete argument structures, and error types of concepts had difference according to types of alternative concepts as well as TAP. These results mean that importance of checking students' preconceptions, need of scientific argumentation, and appropriate instructional strategies considering alternative conception types and fallacy types that students had.
참고문헌 (34)
- 교육부, "초등학교 교사용 지도서 과학 6-1" (2015), 교육부
- 박지현, "지구와 달의 공전궤도를 고려한 달의 위상 변화 관찰 교구의 효과", 대한지구과학교육학회지, 9(3), pp.323~340 (2016), 대한지구과학교육학회[DOI]
- 양일호, "2007과 2009 개정 과학교과서에 제시된 달의 위상 변화 삽화에 대한 초등학교 5학년 학생들의 이해", 대한지구과학교육학회지, 8(1), pp.56~65 (2015), 대한지구과학교육학회
- 이효녕, "학교 과학교육에서의 과학적 논증활동을 위한 탐구학습 지도방법 탐색", 대한지구과학교육학회지, 5(2), pp.175~188 (2012), 대한지구과학교육학회
- 정진우, "중학교 학생들의 지구과학 개념에 대한 오개념의 형성 원인 분석", 청람과학교육연구논총, 2(1), pp.248~266 (1992)
- 채동현, "학생들의 달 위상변화의 원인에 대한개념 조사", 초등과학교육, 15(1), pp.45~55 (1996)
- 채동현, "중학교 3학년 과학 교과서의 ‘달의 위상변화’ 문제점 분석", 한국과학교육학회지, 29(8), pp.874~885 (2009), 한국과학교육학회
- Abell, S, "That’s what scientists have to do : pre-service elementary teachers’ conceptions of the nature of science during a Moon investigation", International Journal of Science Education, 23(11), pp.1095~1109 (2001)
- Bailey, J. M, "A review of astronomy education research", Astronomy Education Review, 2(2), pp.20~45 (2003)
- Baxter, J, "Children’s understanding of familiar astronomical events", International Journal of Science Education, 11(5), pp.502~513 (1989)
- Bell, R. L, "The use of a computer simulation to promote scientific conceptions of moon phases", Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 45(3), pp.346~372 (2008)
- Brunsell, E, "Identifying a baseline for teachers’ astronomy content knowledge", Astronomy Education Review, 2(3), pp.38~46 (2005)
- Chen, Y, "The effects of writing-to-learn activities on elementary students’ conceptual understanding : learning about force and motion through writing to older peers", Science Education, 97(5), pp.745~771 (2013)
- Erduran, S, "TAPing into argumentation : Development in the use of Toulmin’s argumentation pattern in studying science discourse", Science Education, 88(6), pp.915~953 (2004)
- Hammer, D, "More than misconceptions : Multiple perspectives on student knowledge and reasoning, and an appropriate role for education research", American Journal of Physics, 64(10), pp.1316~1325 (1996)
- Hannust, T, "Children's knowledge of astronomy and its change in the course of learning", Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 22(1), pp.89~104 (2007)
- Hasan, S, "Misconceptions and the certainty of response index(CRI)", Physics education, 34, pp.294~299 (1999)
- Hewson, P. W, "An appropriate conception of teaching science : A view from studies of science learning", Science Education, 72(5), pp.597~614 (1988)
- Kanli, U, "A Study on Identifying the Misconceptions of Pre-service and In-service Teachers about Basic Astronomy Concepts. Eurasia Journal of Mathematics", Science &Technology Education, 10(5) (2014)
- Korur, F, "Exploring Seventh-Grade Students'and Pre-Service Science Teachers' Misconceptions in Astronomical Concepts. Eurasia Journal of Mathematics", Science & Technology Education, 11(5) (2015)
- Lawson, A. E, "Science teaching and the development of thinking" (1995), Wadsworth
- McNeill, K. L, "Teachers’ use of curriculum to support students in writing scientific arguments to explain phenomena", Science Education, 93(2), pp.233~268 (2009)
- Osborne, J, "Enhancing the quality of argumentation in school science", Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 41(10), pp.994~1020 (2004)
- Schoon, K. J, "The origin and extent of alternative conceptions in the earth and space sciences : A survey of pre-service elementary teachers", Journal of Elementary Science Education, 7(2), pp.27~46 (1995)
- Sherrod, S. E, "A study of how classroom dialogue facilitates the development of geometric spatial concepts related to understanding the cause of moon phases", International Journal of Science Education, 31(7), pp.873~894 (2009)
- Simon, S, "Learning to teach argumentation: Research and development in the science classroom", International Journal of Science Education, 28(2-3), pp.235~260 (2006)
- Stahly, L. L, "Third grade students' ideas about the lunar phases", Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 36(2), pp.159~177 (1999)
- Toulmin, S. E, "The uses of argument" (2003), Cambridge university press
- Trumper, R, "University students’ conceptions of basic astronomy concepts", Physics Education, 35(1), pp.9~15 (2000)
- Trumper, R, "A cross-age study of senior high school students' conceptions of basic astronomy concepts", Research in Science & Technological Education, 19(1), pp.97~109 (2001)
- Trundle, K. C, "Preservice elementary teachers' conceptions of moon phases before and after instruction", Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 39(7), pp.633~658 (2002)
- Trundle, K. C, "A longitudinal study of conceptual change : Preservice elementary teachers' conceptions of moon phases", Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 44(2), pp.303~326 (2007)
- Vosniadou, S, "Modes of knowing and ways of reasoning in elementary astronomy", Cognitive Development, 19(2), pp.203~222 (2004)
- Wilhelm, J. A, "Young children do not hold the classic Earth's shadow misconception to explain lunar phases", School Science and Mathematics, 114(7), pp.349~363 (2014)