The Recent Development of Chinese Antitrust Law on the Abuse of Market Dominance
0
조회
0
다운로드
3
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Since the Chinese antitrust law entered into force, there has been noteworthy development in its implementation through private litigation rather than public enforcement. The Chinese courts have recently made groundbreaking rulings on the abuse of market dominance cases that demonstrate the potential for the development. In particular, it is important to discuss the 2014 Qihoo ruling that is related to the issue of a two-sided market. This article aims to introduce not only the substantive provisions regarding abuse of market dominance in China, but also its implementation, and discuss the courts’ current approach. This article also suggests proposals for effective public enforcement, thereby ensuring legal certainty through the guidance to economic entities, practitioners, and judges. As the Chinese competition regime has dealt with a number of important cases, rapid development in Chinese antitrust law and policy is foreseeable. In sum, the globalisation of the Chinese economy will contribute to the establishment of global standards as it faces international competition.
Abstract
Since the Chinese antitrust law entered into force, there has been noteworthy development in its implementation through private litigation rather than public enforcement. The Chinese courts have recently made groundbreaking rulings on the abuse of market dominance cases that demonstrate the potential for the development. In particular, it is important to discuss the 2014 Qihoo ruling that is related to the issue of a two-sided market. This article aims to introduce not only the substantive provisions regarding abuse of market dominance in China, but also its implementation, and discuss the courts’ current approach. This article also suggests proposals for effective public enforcement, thereby ensuring legal certainty through the guidance to economic entities, practitioners, and judges. As the Chinese competition regime has dealt with a number of important cases, rapid development in Chinese antitrust law and policy is foreseeable. In sum, the globalisation of the Chinese economy will contribute to the establishment of global standards as it faces international competition.
참고문헌 (71)
- ABA Section of Antitrust Law, "Monopolization and Dominance Handbook" (2011), ABA
- Baker JB, "Competition Law and Policy Vol I" (2008), ABA
- Blodgett MS, "Foreign Direct Investment, Trade, and China’s Competition Laws", Denv. J. Int’l L. & Pol’y, 37, pp.201~ (2009)
- Bo JY, "Hulianwang Shanyezhong Xiangguan Shichang Jieding de Sifa Kunjing yu Chulu―Jiyu Shuangbian Shichang Tiaojian", Faxuejia, 6, pp.58~ (2012)
- Boshoff WH, "Market Definition as a Problem of Statistical Inference", J. Compet. L. & Econ, 10, pp.861~
- Bu QX, "Coca‐Cola v. Huiyuan-Market‐Economy Driven or Protectionism?", Int'l Rev. Intell. Prop. & Competition L, 41, pp.202~ (2010)
- Carlton DW, "Competition Law and Policy Vol I" (2009), ABA
- Cheng TK, "Convergence and Its Discontents : A Reconsideration of the Merits of Convergence of Global Competition Law", Chi. J. Int’l, L, 12, pp.433~ (2012)
- 최요섭, "A Study of the Presumption of Market Dominance Under Article 4 of the MRFTA", 법학연구, 16(2), pp.1~30 (2013), 법학연구소
- Choi YS, "The Enforcement of Merger Control in China : A Critical Analysis of Current Decisions by MOFCOM", Int’l Rev. Intell. Prop. & Comp. L, 44, pp.948~ (2013)
- "China’s 3Q IP War: An Interview with Yaxi Wang (Part I)" (2013)[URL]
- Crane DA, "Search Neutrality and Referral Dominance", J. Compet. L. & Econ, 8, pp.459~ (2012)
- Davis B, "China’s Anti‐Monopoly Law : Protectionism or a Great Leap Forward?", B. C. Int’l & Comp. L. Rev, 33, pp.305~ (2010)
- Emch A, "Antitrust in China-the Brighter Spots", E. C. L. R, 32, pp.132~ (2011)
- Leadership in Multi‐sided Markets and the Dominance in Online Advertising, "Etro F", University Ca’ Foscari of Venice, Dept. of Economics Research, ~, pp.Paper Series No. 19 (2013)
- Evans DS, "Governing Bad Behavior by Users of Multi-Sided Platforms", Berkeley Tech. L. J, 27, pp.1201~ (2012)
- Evans DS, "Attention Rivalry among Online Platforms", J. Compet. L. & Econ, 9, pp.313~ (2013)
- Evans DS., "Defining Antitrust Markets When Firms Operate Two‐Sided Platforms", Colum. Bus. L. Rev, 3, pp.667~ (2005)
- Evans DS., "Competition Law and Policy Vol I" (2008), ABA
- Evans DS., "The Oxford Handbook of International Antitrust Economics Volume I" (2014), OUP
- "The Qihoo v. Tencent Landmark Decision" (2013)[URL]
- "Qihoo 360 v Tencent: First Antitrust Decision by the Supreme Court" (2014)[URL]
- Fisher FM, "Issues in Competition Law and Policy Vol I" (2009), ABA
- Furse M, "Antitrust Law in China, Korea and Vietnam" (2009), OUP
- Furse M, "Merger Control in China : Four and a Half Years of Practice and Enforcement-A Critical Analysis", W. COMP, 36, pp.285~ (2013)
- Harris HS, "The Monopolization and IP Abuse Provisions of China’s Anti‐Monopoly Law : Concerns and a Proposal", Antitrust L. J, 75, pp.213~ (2008)
- Harris HS, "Anti‐Monopoly Law and Practice in China" (2011), OUP
- Jiang T, "The Qihoo", Tencent Dispute in the Internet Messaging Market : The First Milestone in the Chinese Competition Law Enforcement?, 2014, pp.37, 369~
- Jones CA, "New Competition Jurisdictions: Shaping Policies and Building Institutions" (2012), Edward Elgar
- Kaplow L, "Why(Ever)Define Markets?", Harv. L. Rev, 124, pp.437~ (2010)
- Lao M, "Search, Essential Facilities, and the Antitrust Duty to Deal", Northwestern Journal of Technology and Intellectual Property, 11, pp.275~ (2013)
- Lewis D, "Competition Law and Development" (2013), Stanford Law Books
- Li J, "Baidu “Jingjia Paiming” FeiLanyong Shichang Zhipei Diwei Xingwei", Faxue, 3, pp.56~ (2009)
- Lianos I, "Market Dominance and Search Quality in the Search Engine Market", J. Compet. L. & Econ, 9, pp.419~ (2013)
- Lin P, "The Oxford Handbook of International Antitrust Economics Vol. II" (2014), OUP
- Makeham H, "Comparing Apples with Oranges? Drawing Lessons from the Australian Constitutional Experience with the Anti‐Monopoly Law of the People’s Republic of China", H. K. L. J, 40, pp.129~ (2010)
- Mann GA., "Google and the Limits of Antitrust : The Case against the Case against Google", Harv. J. L. & Pub. Pol’y, 34, pp.171~ (2011)
- Mehra SK., "Against Antitrust Functionalism : Reconsidering China’s Antimonopoly Law", Va. J. Int’l L, 49, pp.379~ (2009)
- Meng YB, "Definition of Relevant Market in Internet Industry - Analyzing Qihoo v. Tencent Antitrust Case", Dianzi Zhishi Chanquan, 4, pp.42~ (2013)
- Mezzanotte FE, "Presumptions, Market Dominance and Oligopoly in Europe and China : A Comparison", World Compet, 36, pp.315~ (2013)
- Niels G, "Economics for Competition Lawyers" (2011), OUP
- "The Supreme Court Goes Online with Anti‐Monopoly Law Principles: A Review of Qihoo vs. Tencent Abuse of Market Dominance Case" (2014)[URL]
- O’Donoghue R, "The Law and Economics of Article 102 TFEU 142, 2nd ed" (2013), Oxford
- Owen BM, "China’s Competition Policy Reforms : The Anti‐Monopoly Law and Beyond", Antitrust L. J, 75, pp.231~ (2008)
- Pate RH, "What I Heard in the Great Hall of the People-Realistic Expectations of Chinese Antitrust", Antitrust L. J, 75, pp.195~ (2008)
- Posner R, "Antitrust in the New Economy", Antitrust L. J, 68, pp.925~ (2000)
- Ratliff JD., "Is There A Market for Organic Search Engine Results and Can Their Manipulation Give Rise to Antitrust Liability?", J. Compet. L. & Econ, 10, pp.517~ (2014)
- Rochet JC, "Platform Competition in Two‐Sided Markets", J. Eur. Econ. Assoc, 1, pp.990~ (2003)
- Ryberg B, "Pro‐competitive or Protective? The Chinese Anti‐Monopoly Law, Implications for the United States, and Bilateral Antitrust Cooperation as an Effective Response", Cardozo J. Int’l & Comp. L, 18, pp.527~ (2010)
- Schneider JS, "Administrative Monopoly and China’s New Anti‐Monopoly Law : Lessons from Europe’s State Aid Doctrine", Wash. U. L. Rev, 87, pp.869~ (2010)
- Shan PP et al., "China’s Anti‐Monopoly Law : What is the Welfare Standard?", Rev. Ind. Organ, 41, pp.31~ (2012)
- Shu T, "Reflections on Baidu Monopoly Litigation : Comments on Renren v. Baidu", China Patents and Trademarks, 1, pp.66~ (2010)
- Su J, "Competition Law in the BRICs Countries" (2012), Kluwer Law International
- Rijn Su J, "The Design of Competition Law Institutions: Global Norms, Local Choices" (2013), OUP
- Sullivan ET, "Antitrust Law, Policy and Procedure: Cases, Materials, Problems, 6th ed" (2009), Lexisnexis
- Sullivan LA, "The Law of Antitrust: An Integrated Handbook, 2nd edn" (2006), West Academic Publishing
- Utton MA, "Market Dominance and Antitrust Policy, 2nd edn" (2005), Edward Elgar Publishing
- Walker M, "Issues in Competition Law and Policy Vol II" (2008), ABA
- Wang XY, "The Prospect of Antimonopoly Legislation in China", Wash. U. L. Rev, 1, pp.201~ (2002)
- Wang XY, "Highlights of China’s New Anti‐Monopoly Law", Antitrust L. J, 75, pp.133~ (2008)
- Wang XY, "The New Chinese Anti‐Monopoly Law : A Survey of a Work in Progress", Antitrust Bull, 54, pp.579~ (2009)
- Williams M, "Foreign Investment in China : Will the Anti‐Monopoly Law be a Barrier or a Facilitator?", Tex. Int’l L. J, 45, pp.127~ (2009)
- Williams M, "The Political Economy of Competition Law in Asia" (2013), Edward Elgar
- Wu Z, "Perspectives on the Chinese Anti‐Monopoly Law", Antitrust L. J, 75, pp.73~ (2008)
- Yang Dong, "The Application of the Chinese Anti-Monopoly Law in the Internet Market:Qihoo 360 v. Tencent Case Study", 경쟁법연구, 28, pp.323~346 (2013), 한국경쟁법학회
- Zhang XC, "An Anti‐Monopoly Legal Regime in the Making in China as a Socialist Market Economy", Int’l Law, 43, pp.1469~ (2009)
- Zheng WT, "Transplanting Antitrust in China : Economic Transition, Market Structure, and State Control", U. Pa. J. Int’l L, 32, pp.643~ (2010)
- Zheng WT, "Asian Capitalism and the Regulation of Competition: Towards a Regulatory Geography of Global Competition Law" (2013), Cambridge University Press
- Zhong OQC, "Dawn of a New Constitutional Era or Opportunity Wasted? An Intellectual Reappraisal of China’s Anti-Monopoly Law", Colum. J. Asian L., 24, pp.87~ (2010)
- Zou WN., "The international handbook on private enforcement of competition law" (2010), Edward Elgar
