가치기반 체계에 근거한 의료기술평가: 영국 NICE의 신뢰 지향적 가치판단 과정을 중심으로
Health Technology Assessment and Appraisal: Lessons from Reliability-Based Health Technology Appraisal in NICE, England
1
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This paper is a general review contextualizing the state of the domestic health technology assessment. The aim of the paper is to present an overview of health technology assessment in Korea based on examining clinical efficacy as well as cost-benefit analysis, and to suggest the issue of appraisal based on social value. We have included a discussion of a major case study of the technology appraisal process of NICE (the National Institute for Clinical Excellence) in the UK. The review of the existing process of NICE shows that the appraisal both gives interest in health technology a sense of value perspective and raises methodological issues in terms of reliability. Details of the appraisal process and several guidelines for best practice have emerged. Suggestions are listed and their role in assessing is explained as a conclusion.
Abstract
This paper is a general review contextualizing the state of the domestic health technology assessment. The aim of the paper is to present an overview of health technology assessment in Korea based on examining clinical efficacy as well as cost-benefit analysis, and to suggest the issue of appraisal based on social value. We have included a discussion of a major case study of the technology appraisal process of NICE (the National Institute for Clinical Excellence) in the UK. The review of the existing process of NICE shows that the appraisal both gives interest in health technology a sense of value perspective and raises methodological issues in terms of reliability. Details of the appraisal process and several guidelines for best practice have emerged. Suggestions are listed and their role in assessing is explained as a conclusion.
참고문헌 (25)
- 이상무, "근거중심 보건의료: 끊어진 선순환의 고리를 찾아서", 대한의사협회지, 52(6), pp.532~535 (2009), 대한의사협회
- J. O’Donell, "Health Technology Assessment: Lessons Learned from Around the World – an Overview", Value in Health, 12, pp.S1~S5 (2009)
- E. Y. Bae, "Challenges in Drug Re-evaluation System Based on Health Technology Assessment", Health Economics and Policy, 6(3), pp.163~176 (2010)
- 이노우에 유스케, "뇌졸중 재활치료에 있어서 병원군집간 의료서비스 제공실태와 치료성과 -일본 뇌졸중 환자 데이터베이스를 이용하여 -", 보건의료산업학회지, 5(3), pp.53~61 (2011), 보건의료산업학회
- B. J. Park, "Evidence Based Healthcare", pp.3~19 (2009), Korea Medical Book Publisher
- F. Kristensen, "What is Health Technology Assessment?, in Health Technology Assessment and Health Policy-Making in Europe", pp.31~53 (2008), European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies
- 윤순진, "공공참여적 에너지 거버넌스의 모색", 전력정책에 대한 시민합의회의 사례에 대한 평가를 바탕으로, 2005, pp.15(4), 121~153[DOI]
- 주성수, "시민참여,자치권능,심의민주주의 제도-정책 갈등 해결방안의 탐색", 경제와 사회, (63), pp.124~145 (2004), 비판사회학회
- M. H. Lim, "New Health Technology Assessment and Health Insurance Coverage Determinations in Canadian Medicare", Health and Welfare Policy Forum, 155, pp.66~76 (2009)
- S. M. Lee, "Evidence Based Health", Pharmaceutical Policy Affairs, 3(2), pp.83~96 (2008)
- Y.J. Choi, "HTA Development Plan", HIRA Service, 6(4), pp.26~35 (2012)
- Economic Analysis and Performance Evaluation of Health Technology, "SNU Medical Policy Office", Ministry of Health & Welfare, 15~45, pp.Ministry of Health & Welfare 2008-12 (2008)
- Long-term Development Plan for National Evidence-based Healthcare Collaborating Agency, "NECA", NECA, 37~40, pp.NECA-P-12-012 Research PJT 1.31 (2013)
- Policy Directions to Facilitate the Economic Evaluation of New Health Technologies: Focused on Pharmaceuticals, "Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs", 229~234, pp.Research PJT 2005-02 (2005)
- T. Walley, "Health Technology Assessment in England: Assessment and Appraisal", Health Care, 187(5), pp.283~295 (2007)
- NICE, "Guide to the Technology Appraisal Process", 18~45 (2009)
- Research Review and Social Value Review Committee, "S. M. Lee", 36~43 (2010)
- W. Y. Lee, "Review on the Patient and Public Involvement in Health Technology Appraisals at NICE", Critical Social Policy, 34, pp.47~75 (2012)
- J.H. Chang, "Consumer Participation in NICE, England", HIRA Service, 7(3), pp.71~77 (2013)
- Foreign Expert Evaluation and Evidence-based Healthcare Capabilities, "NECA", NECA, 81~86, pp.NECA-P-12-007 Research PJT (2012)
- NECA, "NECA’s Guidance for Undertaking Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses for Intervention", 203~210 (2011)
- 이선희, "신의료기술 안전성·유효성 검증을 위한 체계적문헌 고찰", 대한의사협회지, 55(3), pp.279~291 (2012), 대한의사협회
- Round Table Conference for Healthcare Utilization Studies of the Public Interest, "NECA", NECA, 17~50 (2011)
- 지경자, "뇌혈관질환 환자가 인지하는 의료서비스 질이 지각하는 가치, 만족도 및 재이용 의도에 미치는 영향", 보건의료산업학회지, 7(2), pp.53~67 (2013), 보건의료산업학회