본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

미국 생명윤리의 경계들과 그 너머

The Boundaries of American Bioethics and Beyond

0

조회

0

다운로드

2

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류의학일반

초록

American bioethicists have established several conceptual boundaries in institutionalizing bioethics into hospitals, academic programs, and the government. Bioethical expertise has been shaped and maintained through such boundary-making practices. This paper examines the following three boundaries of American bioethics: the boundary between bioethics and society, between bioethics and politics, and between scientific knowledge and society. The first boundary designates the view that bioethics is de-contextualized from society, the second boundary results from the view that bioethics should be politically neutral, and the third boundary is built on the dichotomy between scientific knowledge and social values. These boundaries have been both contested and strengthened by American bioethicists. Through the analysis of such boundary-making practices of American bioethics, this paper aims to suggest fruitful lessons concerning the institutionalization of Korean bioethics.

Abstract

American bioethicists have established several conceptual boundaries in institutionalizing bioethics into hospitals, academic programs, and the government. Bioethical expertise has been shaped and maintained through such boundary-making practices. This paper examines the following three boundaries of American bioethics: the boundary between bioethics and society, between bioethics and politics, and between scientific knowledge and society. The first boundary designates the view that bioethics is de-contextualized from society, the second boundary results from the view that bioethics should be politically neutral, and the third boundary is built on the dichotomy between scientific knowledge and social values. These boundaries have been both contested and strengthened by American bioethicists. Through the analysis of such boundary-making practices of American bioethics, this paper aims to suggest fruitful lessons concerning the institutionalization of Korean bioethics.

참고문헌 (42)

  1. Jonsen AR, "The Birth of Bioethics", Hastings Center Report, 23(6) (1993)
  2. Beauchamp TL, "The Principles of Biomedical Ethics", pp.4~ (1994), Oxford University Press
  3. Clouser KD, "A Critique of Principlism", Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, 15, pp.219~236 (1990)
  4. Singer P., "Practical Ethics" (1980), Cambridge University Press
  5. Jonsen AR, "he Abuse of Casuistry : A History of Moral Reasoning" (1988), University of California Press
  6. Hoffmaster B., "Bioethics in Social Context" (2001), Temple University Press
  7. Beauchamp TL, "From Principles of Biomedical Ethics, In Bioethics : an Introduction to the History, Methods, and Practice", pp.142~143 (1997), Jones and Bartlett Publishers
  8. Light DW, "On the Social Embeddedness of Bioethics, In Bioethics and Society : Constructing the Ethical Enterprise", pp.2~ (1998), Prentice Hall
  9. Evans JH, "Playing God? Human Genetic Engineering and the Rationalization of Public Bioethical Debate" (2002), The University of Chicago Press
  10. Fox RC, "he Sociology of Medicine : A Participant Observer’s View", pp.231~ (1989), Prentice Hall
  11. Callahan D., "Why America Accepted Bioethics", Hastings Center Report, 23(6), pp.S8~S9 (1993)
  12. Callahan D., "The Hastings Center and the Early Years of Bioethics", Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 9(1), pp.53~71 (1999)
  13. Capron AM, "What Contributions Have Social Science and the Law Made to the Development of Policy on Bioethics", DaeDalus, 128, pp.298~299 (1999)
  14. Wolpe PR, "The Triumph of Autonomy in American bioethics : a Sociological View, In Bioethics and Society; Constructing the Ethical Enterprise" (1998), Prentice Hall
  15. Anspach RR, "Emotion in Medical and Moral Life, In Bioethics in Social Context", pp.112~136 (2001), Temple University Press
  16. Kleinman A., "Moral Experience and Ethical Reflection : Can Ethnography Reconcile Them?", A Quandary for ‘The New Bioethics’Daedalus, 128(4), pp.71~ (1999)
  17. Bosk CL, "Professional Ethicist Available", DaeDalus, 128(4), pp.65~ (1999)
  18. Callahan D., "Professional Morality : Can an Examined Life be Lived?, In Philosophical Perspectives on Bioethics", pp.11~12 (1996), University of Toronto Press
  19. Weisz G., "Social Science Perspectives on Medical Ethics" (1990), University of Philadelphia Press
  20. DeVries R, "Bioethics and Society : Constructing the Ethical Enterprise" (1998), Prentice Hall
  21. Haimes E., "What Can the Social Science Contribute to the Study of Bioethics : Theoretical, Empirical, and Substantive Consideration", Bioethics, 6(2), pp.108~ (2002)
  22. Turner L., "Social Justice, Bioethics, Social Class, and the Sociological Imagination", Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics, 14, pp.374~378 (2005)
  23. Jennings B., "Autonomy and Difference : The Travails of Liberalism in Bioethics, In Bioethics and Society : Constructing the Ethical Enterprise", pp.262~ (1998), Prentice Hall
  24. Zussman R., "The Contribution of Sociology to Medical Ethics", Hastings Center Report, 30(1), pp.7~11 (2000)
  25. Callahan D, "The Social Sciences and the Task of Bioethics", Daedalus, 128(4), pp.285~ (1999)
  26. Pellegrino ED, "The Origins and Evolution of Bioethics: Some Personal Reflections", Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 9(1), pp.73~88 (1999)
  27. Nelson JL, "Moral Teaching from Unexpected Quarters : Lessons for Bioethics from the Social Sciences and Managed Care", Hastings Center Report, 30(1), pp.12~ (2000)
  28. Winkler E., "Moral Philosophy and Bioethics : Contextualism versus the Paradigm Theory, In Philosophical Perspective on Bioethics", pp.64~ (1996), The University of Toronto Press
  29. Clouser KD, "Medical Ethics: Some Uses, Abuses, and Limitations, In Bioethics: an Introduction to the History, Methods, and Practice", pp.95~ (1997), Jones and Bartlett Publishers
  30. Singer P., "Writing on an Ethical Life", pp.15~ (2000), The Ecco Press
  31. Toulmin S., "How Medicine Saved Life of Ethics, In Bioethics : an Introduction to the History, Methods, and Practice", pp.108~ (1997), Jones and Bartlett Publishers
  32. Jonsen AR, "Bioethics, Our Crowd, and Ideology", Hastings Center Report, 26(6), pp.3~5 (1996)
  33. Jonsen AR, "Beating up Bioethics", Hastings Center Report, 31(5), pp.40~46 (2001)
  34. Moreno JD, "Deciding Together : Bioethics and Moral Consensus", pp.146~ (1995), Oxford University Press
  35. Fox RC, "The Evolution of American Bioethics: a Sociological Perspective, In Social Science Perspectives on Medical Ethics", pp.210~ (1990), University of Pennsylvania Press
  36. Overall C., "Reflections of a Sceptical Bioethicist, In Philosophical Perspectives on Bioethics", pp.179~ (1996), University of Toronto Press
  37. Sherwin S., "Theory versus Practice in Ethics : A Feminist Perspective on Justice in Health Care, In Philosophical Perspectives on Bioethics", pp.191~193 (1996), Jones and Bartlett Publishers
  38. Evans JH, "Between Technocracy and Democratic Legitimation : A Proposed Compromise Position for Common Morality Public Bioethics", Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, 31, pp.213~234 (2006)
  39. Daniels N., "Wide Reflective Equilibrium in Practice, In Philosophical Perspectives on Bioethics", pp.96~114 (1996), University of Toronto Press
  40. Bloor D., "Anti-Latour", Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, 30(1), pp.81~112 (1999)
  41. Fox RC, "Afterword : The Sociology of Bioethics, In Bioethics and Society ; Constructing the Ethical Enterprise", pp.271~ (1998), Prentice Hall
  42. Stevens MLT, "Bioethics in America : Origins and Cultural Politics" (2000), The Johns Hopkins University Press

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (6건)