의료영역에서의 샤프롱(Chaperone)제도
The Use of Chaperones in Clinical Practice
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Personal relationships between doctors and patients are essential for effective treatment. Optimal care is possible only when there is trust between the doctor and patient. In recent years, disputes between healthcare providers and patients have been increasing. In particular, there have been disputes related to the sexual harassment of patients during physical examinations, causing harm to doctor-patient relationships. Fundamental measures are needed to deal with these disputes. In some countries, such disputes are prevented by means of a chaperone system that helps to establish trust between the doctor and the patient. With the chaperone system, when a doctor conducts a physical examination of a patient, an assistant helps with the examination or is present during the examination. When the chaperone system is used, communication between the doctor and the patient is enhanced, thereby reducing the chances of legal disputes. This article argues that a chaperone system with detailed guidelines is needed in South Korea in order to ensure patient safety and effective treatment, especially for gynecological and other intrusive physical examinations.
Abstract
Personal relationships between doctors and patients are essential for effective treatment. Optimal care is possible only when there is trust between the doctor and patient. In recent years, disputes between healthcare providers and patients have been increasing. In particular, there have been disputes related to the sexual harassment of patients during physical examinations, causing harm to doctor-patient relationships. Fundamental measures are needed to deal with these disputes. In some countries, such disputes are prevented by means of a chaperone system that helps to establish trust between the doctor and the patient. With the chaperone system, when a doctor conducts a physical examination of a patient, an assistant helps with the examination or is present during the examination. When the chaperone system is used, communication between the doctor and the patient is enhanced, thereby reducing the chances of legal disputes. This article argues that a chaperone system with detailed guidelines is needed in South Korea in order to ensure patient safety and effective treatment, especially for gynecological and other intrusive physical examinations.
참고문헌 (44)
- 의학교육연수원, "임상윤리학", pp.95~ (2005), 서울대학교출판부
- "부산고등법원 2008.4.16. 선고 2008노47 판결", ~ (2008)
- 데일리메디, "캐나다 의사, 女환자 29명 마취 후 성폭행", 2010년 10월 1일자 보도자료, ~ (2010)
- [URL]
- "Worcestershire Mental Health Partnership NHS Trusts", Chaperone Policy, 3~ (2006)
- J Cusden, "Chaperone Policy", 4~ (2005)
- "대법원 2005. 7. 14. 선고 2003도7107 판결", ~ (2005)
- "대법원 2002.4.26. 선고 2001도2417 판결", ~ (2002)
- "대법원 2002. 8. 23. 선고 2002도2860 판결", ~ (2002)
- "대법원 2009.9.24.선고2009도2576 판결", ~ (2009)
- 김혁돈, "강제추행죄에 있어서의 강제추행의 개념", 형사법연구, 21(1), pp.493~512 (2009), 한국형사법학회
- 배종대, "형법각론", pp.237~ (2007), 홍문사
- 이재상, "형법각론", pp.164~ (2007), 박영사
- 손동권, "형법각론", pp.154~ (2008), 율곡출판사
- "대법원 1998. 1. 23. 선고 97도2506 판결", ~ (1998)
- 이정원, "형법각론", pp.21~ (2004), 법지사
- Schonke, "Strafgesetzbuch", Kommentar, 28(11)
- "대법원 1995. 10. 12. 선고 95도1589 판결", ~ (1995)
- "대법원 2005. 7. 14. 선고 2003도7107 판결", ~ (2005)
- 권복규, "개원의를 위한 의료윤리사례집", 대한의사협회, 140~ (2006)
- Chaperones and Communication, "Oregon Board of Medical Examiners", BME, 1~ (2001)
- 류화신, "의료분쟁과 화해 - 체계적인 의사소통과정을 통한 자율적 분쟁처리 -", 한국의료윤리학회지, 9(2), pp.113~124 (2006), 한국의료윤리학회
- Bismark M, "Motivations for medico-legal action. lessons from New Zealand", J leg Med, 27(1), pp.55~70 (2006)
- "Chaperone Policy for Intimate Examination", 2008, ~ (2008)
- J Cusden, "Chaperone Policy", Isle of Wight Healthcare, 7~ (2005)
- S Sinha, "Use of Chaperone during Breast Examination", Scottish Medical Journal, 55, pp.25~ (2010)
- Joe Rosenthal, "Chaperones for intimate examinations", BMJ, 330, pp.234~ (2005)
- Massachusetts Medical Society, "Should a chaperone be present for this exam?", The Legal Advisor, 15(4) (2007)
- "The use of chaperones on general practice", RACGP Position paper, 2~ (2007)
- GMC, "Maintaining Boundaries-guidance for doctors", ~ (2006)
- "Northern Health and Social Care Trust", Chaperone policy, 3~ (2010)
- "Birmingham East and North", Chaperone Policy for Intimate Examination, 7~ (2008)
- MIMS Women’s Health, "Medico-legal issues in intimate examination", 5~ (2008)
- The university of Manchester, "Guidance for Students on Intimate Examinations and use of Chaperones", 2~ (2008)
- 김중호, "의학윤리란 무엇인가", pp.140~ (1995), 바오로딸
- "세브란스병원 환자권리장전/"[URL]
- "여의도성모병원 환자권리장전"[URL]
- "서울아산병원 환자권리장전"[URL]
- WHO, "Promotion of the Rights Patients in Europe", ~ (1995)
- Tem L. Beauchamp, "Contemporary Issues in Bio-ethics", pp.127~128 (1988), Wadworth, Inc
- 김민중, "의료분쟁의 법률지식", pp.221~ (2000)
- 국민일보, "양승조 의원, 전공의 진료실 출입제한 결국 일내나", 2010년 12월 7일자 보도자료, ~ (2010)
- Clinical Governance Support Team, "Guidance on the role and effective use of chaperones in primary and community care settings", 13~ (2005)
- 이상태, "의사의 설명과 환자의 동의", pp.160~ (1991), 고시계