의료윤리학의 학문적 위상과 학제적 연구의 범위에 대한 일고
Philosophical Perspectives on Medical Ethics and Research
0
조회
0
다운로드
6
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Medical ethics, which is expanding in scope, now includes public health ethics, bioethics, and biomedical or health care ethics. Though it started as a form of professional ethics, medical ethics is one of the most important fields of practical ethics, a branch of philosophy. According to Rawls, much of moral theory is independent from the other parts of philosophy. That is, the study of moral concepts and their relation to our moral sensibility has its own distinctive problems and subject matter, requiring unique forms of study. But what is the relation between ethics and medical ethics? In this article we argue that moral theory and medical ethics are necessarily interconnected and that they support each other. Professional duties are influenced by health care systems and policies, and public health ethics is influenced by ethical and political theory. Therefore, we argue that problems in medical ethics should be addressed from a meta-viewpoint that takes other disciplines into consideration.
Abstract
Medical ethics, which is expanding in scope, now includes public health ethics, bioethics, and biomedical or health care ethics. Though it started as a form of professional ethics, medical ethics is one of the most important fields of practical ethics, a branch of philosophy. According to Rawls, much of moral theory is independent from the other parts of philosophy. That is, the study of moral concepts and their relation to our moral sensibility has its own distinctive problems and subject matter, requiring unique forms of study. But what is the relation between ethics and medical ethics? In this article we argue that moral theory and medical ethics are necessarily interconnected and that they support each other. Professional duties are influenced by health care systems and policies, and public health ethics is influenced by ethical and political theory. Therefore, we argue that problems in medical ethics should be addressed from a meta-viewpoint that takes other disciplines into consideration.
참고문헌 (24)
- 권상옥, "한국에서 의철학하기", 의철학연구, 2, pp.1~17 (2006)
- Engelhardt HT, "Philosophy of medicine and bioethics: an introduction to the framing of a field. Philosophy of Medicine" (2000), Kluwer academic publishing
- Pelligrino E, "What the philosophy of medicine is", Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics, 19, pp.315~336 (1998)
- Engelhardt HT, "The Foundations of Bioethics" (1996), Oxford University Press
- 진교훈, "의학적 인간학: 의학철학의 기초" (2002), 서울대학교 출판부
- Dorothy Emmet, "Rules, Roles, and Relations" (1966), Beacon Press
- Rawls J, "The independence of moral theory. Collected Papers" (1999), Harvard University Press
- Scanlon TM, "Contractualism and utilitarianism, The Difficulty of Tolerance" (2003), Cambridge University Press
- Anscombe GEM, "Modern moral philosophy. Virtue Ethics" (1997), Oxford University Press
- Hare RM, "Medical ethics: can the moral philosopher help? Essays on Bioethics" (1993), Clarendon Press
- Rachels J, "Can Ethics Provide Answers: And other essays in moral philosophy" (1997), Rowman & Littlefield Publishers Inc.
- Scanlon TM, "우리가 서로에게 지는 의무: 계약주의적 도덕개념 분석" (2008), 한울
- Toulmin S, "How medicine saved the life of ethics", Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, 25, pp.736~750 (1982)
- Churchill LR, "What ethics can contribute to health policy. Ethical Dimensions of Health Policy" (2002), Oxford University Press
- Rachels J, "Ethical theory and bioethics. A Companion to Bioethics" (1998), Blackwell Publishing
- Kuhse H, "What is bioethics? a historical introduction. A Companion to Bioethics" (1998), Blackwell Publishing
- Marcum JA, "An Introductory Philosophy of Medicine: humanizing modern medicine" (2008), Springer + Business Media
- Pelligrino E, "The origins and evolution of bioethics: some personal reflections", Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 9, pp.73~88 (1999)
- Beauchamp T, "의료윤리의 네 원칙" (1999), 계축문화사
- Veatch RM, "A Theory of Medical Ethics" (1981), Basic Books
- Callahan D, "Ends and means: the goals of health care. Ethical Dimensions of Health Policy" (2002), Oxford University Press
- Gutmann A, "Just deliberation about health care. Ethical Dimensions of Health Policy" (2002), Oxford University Press
- 유호종, "의료문제에 대한 윤리와 법의 통합적 접근: 의료법윤리학 서설", pp.17~ (2002), 동림사
- Watson G, "Some considerations in favor of contractualism. Rational Commitment, and Morality", Morris C & Coleman