본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

화재사건에 있어서 형사법적 쟁점의 검토

The Study on Problems in Criminal Investigation and Trials related to Fire Accidents

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

초록

There are some unique aspects in arson and other crimes related to fire accidents. that is, first. most important evidence or critical data to reconstruct facts of crime usually destroyed by fire or fire fighting. and in many cases, there is a restriction on use or secure direct evidence like eyewitness. we have to depend on circumstantial evidences that have weak proving ability in criminal investigation or trials. second, in according to statistic of fire cases or other sources, as a rule, there is a assumption that the reason of all fire cases is accidents, not criminal behavior. so, in the practice of investigation & trial, we approach fire case with passive attitude. and because of proving structure in which requests proving on and against crime at one time, we have difficult to solve cases. third, during a fire investigation, we need a technical & scientifical expertise above comprehension of lay person. by these reasons, we can see the low arrest or conviction rate in arson,etc., to compare to other crimes. in this study, considering the unique aspects of fire investigation & arson or other crime related to fire, I'll introduce and recommend appropriate investigative & facts finding methods in fire crimes, expecially, about responsibility of supervisors or directors in criminal negligence cases and unique function of fire origin in facts finding.

Abstract

There are some unique aspects in arson and other crimes related to fire accidents. that is, first. most important evidence or critical data to reconstruct facts of crime usually destroyed by fire or fire fighting. and in many cases, there is a restriction on use or secure direct evidence like eyewitness. we have to depend on circumstantial evidences that have weak proving ability in criminal investigation or trials. second, in according to statistic of fire cases or other sources, as a rule, there is a assumption that the reason of all fire cases is accidents, not criminal behavior. so, in the practice of investigation & trial, we approach fire case with passive attitude. and because of proving structure in which requests proving on and against crime at one time, we have difficult to solve cases. third, during a fire investigation, we need a technical & scientifical expertise above comprehension of lay person. by these reasons, we can see the low arrest or conviction rate in arson,etc., to compare to other crimes. in this study, considering the unique aspects of fire investigation & arson or other crime related to fire, I'll introduce and recommend appropriate investigative & facts finding methods in fire crimes, expecially, about responsibility of supervisors or directors in criminal negligence cases and unique function of fire origin in facts finding.

참고문헌 (24)

  1. 이재상, "형법총론 제6신판" (2010), 박영사
  2. 고기봉, "화재조사제도 개선방안에 관한 연구", 한국화재소방학회 논문지, 23(2), pp.101~110 (2009), 한국화재소방학회
  3. 김인범, "통계자료 분석에 의한 화재조사의 문제점에 관한 연구", 한국 화재소방학회 추계학술대회 논문집 (2000)
  4. 김태천, "형법상 감독과실책임과 그 한계", 재판과 판례, 16 (2007), 대구판례연구회
  5. 안경옥, "과실범의 체계와 예견가능성", 한국형사법학의 새로운 지평, 유일당 오선주 교수 정년기념논문집 (2001)
  6. 이종원, "화재사건에 있어서의 예견가능성", 성균관법학, (8) (1997)
  7. 井田誠, "일본형법에서의 조직과실과 감독과실", 청주법학, 32(1) (2010), 청주 대학교 법학연구소
  8. 대검찰청, "2009 범죄분석" (2009)
  9. 인천광역시 소방본부, "화재원인 조사기법" (2003)
  10. 한국화재보험협회, "NFPA 921, 화재폭발조사가이드 2008년판" (2008)
  11. 2008 Fire Report, "한국화재보험협회", ~ (2008)
  12. John J. Letini, "Scientific Protocols for Fire Investigation" (2006), CRC Press
  13. Paul C. Giannelli, "Scientific Evidence Vol 2. 3rd Edt." (1999), Lexis Law Publishing
  14. Marc Price Wolf, "Habeas Relief From Bad Science : Does Federal Habeas Corpus Provide Relief for Prisoners Possibly Convicted on Misunderstood Fire Science?", Minn. J. L. Sci & Tech., 213 (2009)
  15. Arson Prosecution : Issues & Strategies, "Federal Emergency Management Agency", ~ (1988)
  16. Fire and Arson Scene Evidence : A Guide for Public Safety Personnel, "NIJ", ~ (2000)
  17. U.S. Fire Administration, "Fire In the United States 15th edt." (2009)
  18. 大谷實, "刑法講義總論" (2009), 成文堂
  19. 山口厚, "刑法總論 補正版" (2005), 有斐閣
  20. 前田雅英, "刑法總論講義 第4版" (2006), 東京大學出版會
  21. 平塚活司, "放火の方法と鑑定. in: 刑事事實認定重要判決50選" (2005), 立花書房
  22. 警察廳, "平成22年 警察白書"
  23. 司法硏修所, "刑事判決書起案の手引, 平成13年版"
  24. 消防廳, "平成21年 消防白書"

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (10건)