처벌의 효과: 억제이론에 대한 비판적 검토
The Effect of Punishment : A Critique of Deterrence Theory
0
조회
0
다운로드
21
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Abstract
There has been a lot of empirical studies on the deterrent effect of punishment. In general, these studies have shown inconsistent findings. This suggests that deterrence theory's basic explanatory frame have some flaws. First of all, the assumption of rational choice is problematic especially when it is applied to the explanatory model for criminal behaviors. And deterrence theory, at least in its basic version, does not properly consider the effectiveness of informal social sanctions. Most importantly, this theory needs to take into account the role of decision-makers' characteristics in the calculation of perceived outcomes of their criminal behaviors. Those characteristics might determine the sizes of weights which definitely affect his or her evaluation of costs and benefits from a specific criminal behavior. And criminological theories provide useful information on those characteristics. Therefore, it is necessary to have more elaborated deterrence models which take into account the factors from other criminological theories to examine the effect of punishment properly. In addition, we need to remember the fact that only a part of population tends to engage in the rational calculation regarding the outcomes of their criminal behaviors. Most people do not feel the need for that calculation because they have internalized norms. And the size of the group who would be willing to calculate the outcomes of their criminal behaviors might vary with different natures of crimes. In addition, other important issues on the effect of punishment are discussed.
참고문헌 (36)
- 김준호, "범죄에 대한 합리적 선택이론의 적용 및 평가", 형사정책, 7, pp.105~125 (1995)
- 에이커스, "범죄학 이론" (2005), 나남출판
- 이성식, "청소년비행론에 있어서 허쉬의 사회통제이론에 대한 수정된 논의", 형사정책연구, 6(4), pp.183~204 (1995)
- 이성식, "간접손실효과: 확대억제이론의 검증", 형사정책연구, 9(3), pp.221~246 (1998)
- 이성식, "사이버犯罪에 대한 知覺된 處罰의 抑制效果 檢證", 矯正硏究, 22, pp.91~114 (2004), 한국교정학회
- 이성식, "약물사용과 처벌의 억제효과", 한국공안행정학회보, 16(3), pp.261~281 (2007), 한국공안행정학회
- Akers,Ronald L, "Deviant Behavior: A Social Learning Approach" (1973), Wadsworth Publishing Company.
- Becker,Howard S, "Outsiders: Studies in The Sociology of Deviance" (1963), Free Press
- Berk, Richard A., "The Deterrent Effect of Arrest in Incidents of Domestic Violence: A Bayesian Analysis of Four Field Experiments", American Sociological Review, 57(5), pp.698~708 (1992)
- Burgess, Robert L, "A Differential Association Reinforcement Theory of Criminal Behavior", Social Problems, 14(2), pp.128~147 (1966)
- Clark,Ronald Ⅴ., "Modeling Offenders' Decisions: A Framework for Research and Policy", Crime and Justice, 6, pp.147~185 (1985)
- Durkheim,Emile, "The Rules of Sociological Method" (1938), Free Press
- Gottfredson, Michael, "A General Theory of Crime" (1990), Stanford University Press
- Grasmick, Harold G, "Conscience, Significant Others, and Rational Choice: Extending the Deterrence Model", Law and Society Review, 24(3), pp.837~862 (1990)
- Hirschi,Travis, "Causes of Delinquency" (1969), University of California Press
- Hoffman,Martin L, "Moral Internalization: Current Theory and Research", Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 10, pp.86~135 (1977), Academic Press
- Kahneman,Daniel, "A Perspective on Judgment and Choice: Mapping Bounded Rationality", American Psychologist, 58(9), pp.697~720 (2003)
- Lemert,Edwin M, "Human Deviance, Social Problems, and Social Control" (1967), Prentice-Hall
- Merton,Robert K, "Social Structure and Anomie", American Sociological Review, 3(5), pp.672~682 (1938)
- Merton,Robert K, "Social Theory and Social Structure" (1957), Free Press
- Nagin, Daniel S, "Enduring Individual Difference and Rational Choice Theories of Crime", Law and Society Review, 27(3), pp.467~496 (1993)
- Pate,Antony M., "Formal and Informal Deterrents to Domestic Violence: The Dade County Spouse Assault Experiment", American Sociological Review, 57(5), pp.691~697 (1992)
- Paternoster,Raymond, "Assessments of Risk and Behavioral Experience: An Exploratory Study of Change", Criminology, 23(3), pp.417~436 (1985)
- Pogarsky,Greg, "Identifying "Deterrable" Offenders: Implications for Research on Deterrence", Justice Quarterly, 19(3), pp.431~452 (2002)
- Shaw,Clifford R., "Juvenile Delinquency and Urban Areas" (1942), University of Chicago Press
- Sherman,Lawrence W, "Defiance, Deterrence, and Irrelevance: A Theory of the Criminal Sanction", Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 30(4), pp.445~473 (1993)
- Sherman,Lawrence W., "The Specific Deterrent Effects of Arrest for Domestic Assault", American Sociological Review, 49(2), pp.261~272 (1984)
- Sherman,Lawrence W., "Crime, Punishment, and Stake in Conformity: Legal and Informal Control of Domestic Violence", American Sociological Review, 57(5), pp.680~690 (1992)
- Sutherland,Edwin H., "Principles of Criminology, 7th edition" (1966), Lippincott
- Tittle,Charles R, "Deterrents or Labeling?", Social Forces, 53(3), pp.399~410 (1975)
- Tyler,Tom R, "Why People Obey the Law" (2006), Princeton University Press
- Yu, Jiang, "Alcohol Addiction and Perceived Sanction Risks: Deterring Drinking Drivers", Journal of Criminal Justice, 34, pp.165~174 (2006)
- Vold,George B., "Theoretical Criminology, 4th edition" (1998), Oxford University Press
- Williams,Kirk R., "Perceptual Research on General Deterrence: A Critical Review", Law and Society Review, 20(4), pp.545~572 (1986)
- Williams,Kirk R., "The Meaning of Arrest for Wife Assault", Criminology, 27(1), pp.163~181 (1989)
- Zimring, Franklin E, "Deterrence: The Legal Threat in Crime Control" (1973), University of Chicago Press