논문KCI 등재
Restorative Justice Dialogue : Three Decades of Victim Offender Mediation Practice & Research in the Global Community
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
주제분류법학
초록
Restorative justice provides opportunities for those most directly affected by a crime (victim, offender, families, and other community members) to be actively involved in the process of addressing harms, needs and obligations. Restorative Justice is about offender accountability, victim healing, and community safety, through mediation and dialogue whenever possible. While restorative justice is far more than a specific program and it is grounded in values that effect our entire way of understanding and responding to crime and victimization among individuals and communities, three types of restorative justice dialogue are particularly expressive of restorative justice principles and they are developing in numerous countries. These include victim-offender mediation, group conferencing, and circles. This article examines participation rates and reasons, participant satisfaction, participant perception of fairness, restitution and repair of harm, diversion, recidivism and cost. A total of 53 victim offender mediation studies are reviewed, including 3 meta-analyses.
Abstract
Restorative justice provides opportunities for those most directly affected by a crime (victim, offender, families, and other community members) to be actively involved in the process of addressing harms, needs and obligations. Restorative Justice is about offender accountability, victim healing, and community safety, through mediation and dialogue whenever possible. While restorative justice is far more than a specific program and it is grounded in values that effect our entire way of understanding and responding to crime and victimization among individuals and communities, three types of restorative justice dialogue are particularly expressive of restorative justice principles and they are developing in numerous countries. These include victim-offender mediation, group conferencing, and circles. This article examines participation rates and reasons, participant satisfaction, participant perception of fairness, restitution and repair of harm, diversion, recidivism and cost. A total of 53 victim offender mediation studies are reviewed, including 3 meta-analyses.
참고문헌 (69)
- Abrams, L, "Youthful Offenders Response to Victim Offender Conferencing in Washington County" (2002), MN. St. Paul, MN: Center for Restorative Justice & Peacemaking
- Bazemore, G, "Rethinking the Sanctioning Function in Juvenile Court: Retributive or Restorative Responses to Youth Crime", 41(3), pp.296~316 (1995)
- Bradbury, B, "Deschutes County Delinquent Youth Demonstration Project" (2002), Salem, OR: Office of the Secretary of State
- Bradshaw, W, "Crime Victims Meet Juvenile Offenders: Contributing Factors to Victim Satisfaction With Mediated Dialogue", 49(3), pp.17~25 (1998)
- Carr, C, "VORS Program Evaluation Report" (1998), Inglewood, CA.: Centenela Valley Juvenile Diversion Project
- Clarke, "Mediation of Interpersonal Disputes An Evaluation of North Carolina′s Programs Institute of Government University of North Carolina" (1992)
- Coates, R. B, "Victim Participation in Victim Offender Conferencing: Washington County, Minnesota Community Justice Program" (2002), St. Paul, MN: Center for Restorative Justice and Peacemaking
- Coates, "An Evaluation of Victim-Offender Reconciliation Programs PACT Institute of Justice" (1985)
- Collins, "Final Evaluation Report on the Grande Prairie Community Reconciliation Project For Young Offenders Ministry of the Solicitor General of Canada" (1984)
- Davis, "Mediation and Arbitration as Alternatives to Prosecution in Felony Arrest Cases An Evaluation of the Brooklyn Dispute Resolution Center VERA Institute of Justice" (1980)
- Dignan, "An Evaluation of an Experimental Adult Reparation Scheme in Kettering Centre for Criminological Legal Research Faculty of Law University of Sheffield", (rthamptonshire) (1990)
- Dissel, A, "Restoring the Harmony: A Report on a Victim Offender Conferencing Pilot Project" (2000), Johannesburg, South Africa: Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation
- Evje, A, "A Summary of the Evaluations of Six California Victim Offender Reconciliation Programs" (2000), San Francisco, CA: Judicial Council of California, Administrative Office of the Courts
- Fercello, C, "Client Satisfaction with Victim Offender Conferences in Dakota County" (1999), Minnesota. St. Paul, MN: Center for Restorative Justice and Peacemaking
- Flaten, C, "Victim Offender Mediation: Application with Serious Offences Committed by Juveniles", pp.387~401 (1996), Monsey, NY: Criminal Justice Press
- Galaway, "Mediation between Offenders and Victims ″ In Albrecht", pp.103~116
- Gehm, "An Exploratory Analysis of Factors Related to Victim Participation", pp.177~182, Criminal Justice Press
- Greenwood, J, "National Survey of Victim Offender Mediation Programs in the US" (1998)
- Hayes, H, "Conferencing and Re-offending in Queensland", 37(2), pp.167~191 (2004)
- Hughes, "Victim-Offender Mediation in the Juvenile Justice System Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention" (1990)
- Katz, J, "Victim Offender Mediation in Missouri’s juvenile courts: accountability, restitution, and transformation" (2000), Jefferson City, MO: Missouri Department of Public Safety
- Latimer, J, "The Effectiveness of Restorative Practices: A Meta-Analysis" (2001), Ottawa, CAN: Department of Justice, Research and Statistics Division Methodological Series
- Marshall, "″Results of Research from British Experiments in Restorative Justice ″ In Galaway", pp.83~107 (1990), Criminal Justice Press
- Miers, D, "An Exploratory Evaluation of Restorative Justice Schemes", 9 (2001), London, UK: Home Office
- Nelson, S, "Evaluation of the Restorative Justice Program" (2000), Eugene, OR.: Lane County Department of Youth Services
- Niemeyer, M, "A Preliminary Study of a Large Victim", Offender Reconciliation Program, 1996, pp.60(3), 30~34
- Nugent, W. M, "The Effect of Victim-Offender Mediation on Severity of Reoffense", 12, pp.353~367 (1995)
- Nugent, W, "Participation in Victim-Offender Mediation and Severity of Subsequent Delinquent Behavior: Successful Replications?", 11(1), pp.5~23 (1999)
- Nugent, W, "Participation in Victim-Offender Mediation and the Prevalence and Severity of Subsequent Delinquent Behavior: A Meta-Analysis", 2003(1), pp.137~165 (2003)
- Perry, "Planning and Evaluation Office of the Attorney General" (1987)
- Roberts, L, "Victim Offender Mediation: An Evaluation of the Pima County Juvenile Court Center′s Victim Offender Mediation Program (VOMP)" (1998)
- Roberts, T, "Evaluation of the Victim Offender Mediation Project" (1995), Langley, BC: Final Report Victoria, BC, CAN: Focus Consultants
- Roy, "″Two Types of Juvenile Restitution Programs in Two Midwestern Counties", pp.48~53 (1993)
- Schneider, "″Restitution and Recidivism Rates of Juvenile Offenders Results from Four Experimental Studies", ″ crimi(logy), pp.533~552 (1986)
- Stone, K, "An Evaluation of Recidivism Rates for Resolutions Northwest’s Victim-Offender Mediation Program" (2000)
- Juvenile Court Mediation Program Evaluation, , 1998, ~, pp.Carrolton, Ga.: State University of West Georgia
- Strode, E, "Victims of Property Crime Meet their Juvenile Offenders: Victim Participants’Evaluation of the Dakota County (MN) Community Corrections Victim Offender Meeting Program" (1997), Northampton, Mass.: Smith College of Social Work
- "″Mediation of Victim Offender Conflict ″ Journal of Dispute Resolution", pp.85~105 (1988)
- and Galaway, "″ In Wright" (1989)
- New Mexico, "The Impact of Mediation in Albuquerque", pp.90~100 (1993)
- "The Impact of a Minneapolis Mediation Program ″ Research On Social Work Practice 4", pp.436~447 (1994)
- Umbreit, M. S, "Restorative Justice through Mediation: The Impact of Offenders Facing Their Victims in Oakland", 5, pp.1~13 (1995)
- Umbreit, M. S, "Mediation of Criminal Conflict: An Assessment of Programs in Four Canadian Provinces" (1995), St. Paul, MN: Center for Restorative Justice and Peacemaking
- Umbreit, M. S, "Humanistic mediation: A Transformative journey of peacemaking", 14, pp.201~213 (1997)
- Umbreit, M. S, "Restorative Justice Through Victim-Offender Mediation: A Multi-Site Assessment", 1 (1998)
- Umbreit, M. S, "The Handbook of Victim Offender Mediation: An Essential Guide to Practice and Research" (2001), San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass
- Umbreit, M. S, "Victim Experience of Meeting Adult vs. Juvenile Offenders: A Cross-National Comparison", 61(4), pp.33~39 (1997)
- Umbreit, M. S, "Factors that Contribute to Victim Satisfaction with Mediated Offender Dialogue in Winnipeg: An Emerging Area of Social Work Practice", 9(2), pp.35~51 (1999)
- Umbreit, M. S, "Assessing Victim Satisfaction with Victim Offender Mediation & Dialogue Services: The Development and Use of the Victim Satisfaction with Offender Meeting Scale (VSOM)" (2000), Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Justice, Office for Victims of Crime
- Umbreit, M. S, "Victims of Severe Violence Meet the Offender: Restorative Justice Through Dialogue", 6(4), pp.321~344 (1999)
- Umbreit, M. S, "Victims of Severe Violence Meet the Offender in Ohio", 3(3), pp.35~36 (1999)
- Coates, "″The Impact of Mediating Victim Offender Conflict An Analysis of Programs in Three States", pp.1~8 (1992)
- Coates, "An Analysis of Programs in Four States of the US Minnesota Citizens Council on Crime and Justice" (1992)
- Coates, "″Cross-Site Analysis of Victim-Offender Mediation in Four States", pp.565~585 (1993)
- Umbreit, M. S, "Impact of Victim-Offender Mediation in Canada, England and the United States", pp.20~92 (1998)
- Umbreit, M. S, "The Impact of Victim Offender Mediation: Two Decades of Research", 65(1), pp.29~35 (2001)
- Umbreit, M. S, "Juvenile Victim Offender Mediation in Six Oregon Counties" (2001), Salem, OR: Oregon Dispute Resolution Commission
- Umbreit, M. S, "The Impact of Restorative Justice Conferencing: A Multi-National Perspective", 1(2), pp.21~48 (2002)
- Umbreit, M. S, "Mediation of Criminal Conflict in England: An Assessment of Services In Coventry And Leeds" (1996), St. Paul, MN: Center for Restorative Justice and Peacemaking
- Umbreit, M.S, "Facing Violence: The Path of Restorative Justice and Dialogue" (2003), Monsey, NY: Criminal Justice Press
- Van Ness, D, "Restoring Justice" (2002), Cincinnati, OH: Anderson Publishing Company
- Warner, "Justice for Victims and Offenders" (1992)
- White, L, "Hope in Process: A Qualitative Study of Victim Offender Mediation Dialogue in Texas" (2001)
- Winnimaki, L, "Victim-Offender Reconciliation Programs: Juvenile property offender recidivism and severity of reoffense in three Tennessee counties" (1997)
- Wynne, J, "Leeds Mediation and Reparation Service: Ten Years Experience of Victim-Offender Mediation", pp.443~461 (1996), Monsey, NY: Criminal Justice Press
- Wynne, J, "Can Mediation Cut Reoffending?", 45(1), pp.21~26 (1998)
- Wyrick, P, "Predictors of Client Participation in Victim-Offender Mediation", 16, pp.253~257 (1999)
- Zehr, "A New Focus For Crime and Justice" (1990), Herald Press
- Mediation Quarterly, "The Little Book of Restorative Justice" (2002), Intercourse, PA: Good Books
관련 논문AI추천
Restorative Justice Developments in the Pacific Region: A Comprehensive Survey임이랑, Gabrielle MAXWELL, Hennessey Hayes법학연구소 · 법학논집2009 · 제13권 제3호Restorative Justice Policies & ProgramsDaniel W.Van Ness한국교정학회 · 교정연구2007 · 제37권 Restorative Justice Conferencing for Juvenile OffendersGeorge Mousourakis한국피해자학회 · 피해자학연구2005 · 제13권 제2호Restorative Justice in Taiwan: An Overview黃 蘭 媖법학연구소 · 법학논집2010 · 제15권 제1호회복적 경찰활동(회복적 대화 프로그램) 평가: 가해자 및 피해자를 중심으로김문귀, 임형진치안정책연구소 · 치안정책연구2020 · 제34권 제3호A Critical Analysis of Restorative Justice in Britain: Focused on the Theory, National Policy, and Practice of Youth Justice최관한국경찰연구학회 · 한국경찰연구2018 · 제17권 제3호