Mapping of the Universe of Knowledge in Different Classification Schemes
2
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Given the variety of approaches to mapping the universe of knowledge that have been presented and discussed in the literature, the purpose of this paper is to systematize their main principles and their applications in the major general modern library classification schemes. We conducted an analysis of the literature on classification and the main classification systems, namely Dewey/Universal Decimal Classification, Cutter’s Expansive Classification, Subject Classification of J.D. Brown, Colon Classification, Library of Congress Classification, Bibliographic Classification, Rider’s International Classification, Bibliothecal Bibliographic Klassification (BBK), and Broad System of Ordering (BSO). We conclude that the arrangement of the main classes can be done following four principles that are not mutually exclusive: ideological principle, social purpose principle, scientific order, and division by discipline. The paper provides examples and analysis of each system. We also conclude that as knowledge is ever-changing, classifications also change and present a different structure of knowledge depending upon the society and time of their design.
Abstract
Given the variety of approaches to mapping the universe of knowledge that have been presented and discussed in the literature, the purpose of this paper is to systematize their main principles and their applications in the major general modern library classification schemes. We conducted an analysis of the literature on classification and the main classification systems, namely Dewey/Universal Decimal Classification, Cutter’s Expansive Classification, Subject Classification of J.D. Brown, Colon Classification, Library of Congress Classification, Bibliographic Classification, Rider’s International Classification, Bibliothecal Bibliographic Klassification (BBK), and Broad System of Ordering (BSO). We conclude that the arrangement of the main classes can be done following four principles that are not mutually exclusive: ideological principle, social purpose principle, scientific order, and division by discipline. The paper provides examples and analysis of each system. We also conclude that as knowledge is ever-changing, classifications also change and present a different structure of knowledge depending upon the society and time of their design.
참고문헌 (43)
- Afolabi, M., "Spiritual Matters : Provision for Independent African Churches in General Classification Schemes", International Classification, 19(4), pp.210~213 (1992)
- Buchanan, B., "Theory of Library Classification" (1979), Clive Bingley
- Broughton, V., "Essential Classification" (2015), Facet
- Comaromi, J. P., "History of the Indianisation of the Dewey Decimal Classification", Libri, 35(1), pp.1~20 (1985)
- Cutter, C. A., "Expansive Classification" (1893), Cutter
- Foskett, D. J., "The Classification Research Group, 1952-1962", Libri, 12(2), pp.127~138 (1962)
- López-Huertas, M. J., "Challenges in Knowledge Representation and Organization for the 21st Century: Integration of Knowledge Across Boundaries: Proceedings of the Seventh International ISKO Conference, 10-13 July 2002, Granada, Spain (Vol. 8)" (2002), Ergon-Verlag
- Gnoli, C., "Paradigms and Conceptual Systems in Knowledge Organization: Proceedings of the Eleventh International ISKO Conference, 23-26 February 2010, Rome, Italy" (2010), Ergon-Verlag
- Hjørland, B., "The concept of ‘subject’ in Information Science", Journal of Documentation, 48(2), pp.172~200 (1992)
- "Universe of knowledge. In: Lifeboat for Knowledge Organization" (2006)[URL]
- Judge, A. J. N., "Functional Classification", International Classification, 11(3), pp.145~ (1984)
- Koford, A. B., "Engaging an Author in a Critical Reading of Subject Headings", Journal of Critical Library & Information Studies, 1(1), pp.10~ (2017)
- Langridge, D. W., "Classification and indexing in the humanities" (1976), Butterworths
- Langridge, D. W., "Knowledge and Communication: Essays on the Information Chain", pp.1~18 (1991), Library Association Publishing
- Martínez-Ávila, D., "Library Classifications Criticisms: Universality, Poststructuralism and Ethics", Scire, 19(2), pp.21~26 (2013)
- Martínez-Ávila, D., "Methodological Aspects of Critical Theories in Knowledge Organization", Knowledge Organization, 43(2), pp.118~125 (2016)
- McGarry, K., "Knowledge and Communication: Essays on the Information Chain" (1991), Library Association Publishing
- Maltby, A., "Sayers manual of classification for librarians" (1975), Andre Deutsch
- Meadows, A. J., "Knowledge and Communication: Essays on the Information Chain" (1991), Library Association Publishing
- Miksa, F. L., "The DDC, the Universe of Knowledge, and the Post-Modern Library" (1998), Forest Press
- Oh, D-G, "Suggesting an Option for DDC Class Religion (200) for Nations in which Religious Diversity Predominates", Knowledge Organization, 28(2), pp.75~84 (2001)
- Olson, H. A., "Book reviews: Francis L Miksa: The DDC, the Universe of Knowledge, and the Post-Modern Library. 1998, Albany, New York: Forest Press. 1998. 99 pages", Knowledge Organization, 25(4), pp.216~218 (1998)
- Olson, H. A., "The Power to Name: Locating the Limits of Subject Representation in Libraries" (2002), Kluwer
- Parrochia, D., "Towards General Theory of Classification" (2013), Birkhauser
- Ranganathan, S. R., "The Sayers Memorial Volume", pp.72~79 (1961), The Library Association
- Ranganathan, S. R., "Self-perpetuating scheme of classification", Journal of Documentation, 4, pp.223~244 (1949)
- Ranganathan, S. R., "Prolegomena to Library Classification" (1967), Asia
- Richardson, E. C., "Classification, theoretical and practical" (1901), Charles Scribner’s Sons
- Satija, M. P., "Relationships in organization of knowledge", pp.199~210 (2001), Kluwer Academic Publishers
- "Colon Classification. In: ISKO Encyclopedia of Knowledge Organization" (2017)[URL]
- Satija, M. P., "Modes of Growth of Subjects", Knowledge Organization, 41(3), pp.195~204 (2014)
- Sahadath, C., "Classifying the Margins : Using Alternative Classification Schemes to Empower Diverse and Marginalized Users", Feliciter, 59(3), pp.15~17 (2013)
- Shera, J. H., "Sociological Foundation of Librarianship" (1970), Asia
- Smiraglia, R. P., "Interactions between elementary structures in universes of knowledge", Classification and ontology: formal approaches and access to knowledge: proceedings of the International UDC Seminar, 2011, pp.25~40 (2011), Ergon
- Szostak, R., "Letter to the Editor: How Universal is Universality?", Knowledge Organization, 41(6), pp.468~470 (2014)
- "The Scientific Policy Resolution – A Landmark in Indian Science" (2000)[URL]
- Batty, C. D., "Knowledge and its organization" (1976), University of Maryland
- Chan, L. M., "Cataloguing and classification: an introduction", pp.387~398 (1994), McGraw Hill
- Evans, W. M, "Knowledge & power in global society" (1981), Sage Publications
- Gnoli, C., "Phylogenetic Classification", Knowledge Organization, 33(3), pp.138~152 (2006)
- Iyer, H., "Classificatory Structures: Concepts, Relations and Representatious", pp.12~29 (1995), Indeks Verlag
- Langridge, D. W., "The Universe of Knowledge" (1969), College of Library Services
- McGarry, K., "Changing context of information" (1993), LA