본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

기본의학교육에서 동료지원학습의 활용과 효과

Utilization and Effects of Peer‐Assisted Learning in Basic Medical Education

노혜린
연세대학교 의과대학 (Yonsei University College of Medicine)|2021.02|의학교육논단 (Korean Medical Education Review)|제23권 제1호|pp. 11-22|DOI https://doi.org/10.17496/kmer.2021.23.1.11

1

조회

0

다운로드

3

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

MentoringMedical studentsUndergraduate medical education

초록

This review of the literature explored the experiences and effects of peer-assisted learning in basic medical education. Peer-assisted learning is most commonly utilized to teach clinical skills (including technical skills) and medical knowledge (76.4%). It has also been used, albeit less frequently, to facilitate small-group discussions including problem-based learning, to promote students’ personal and professional development, to provide mentoring for career development and adaptation to school, to give tutoring to at-risk students, and to implement work-based learning in clinical settings. Near-peer learning is a common type. The use of active learning techniques and digital technology has been increasingly reported. Students’ leadership had frequently been described. Student tutor training, programs for teaching skills, institutional support, and assessments have been conducted for effective peer-assisted learning. There is considerable positive evidence that peer-assisted learning is effective in teaching simple clinical skills and medical knowledge for tutees. However, its effects on complex skills and knowledge, small-group discussions, personal and professional development, peer mentoring, and work-based learning have rarely been studied. Additionally, little evidence exists regarding whether peer-assisted learning is effective for student tutors. Further research is needed to develop peer-assisted learning programs and to investigate their learning effects on student tutors, small-group discussion facilitation, personal and professional development, peer mentoring, and peer-led work-based learning in the clinical setting in South Korea. Formal programs and system advancement for a student-led learning culture is needed for effective peer-assisted learning.

Abstract

This review of the literature explored the experiences and effects of peer-assisted learning in basic medical education. Peer-assisted learning is most commonly utilized to teach clinical skills (including technical skills) and medical knowledge (76.4%). It has also been used, albeit less frequently, to facilitate small-group discussions including problem-based learning, to promote students’ personal and professional development, to provide mentoring for career development and adaptation to school, to give tutoring to at-risk students, and to implement work-based learning in clinical settings. Near-peer learning is a common type. The use of active learning techniques and digital technology has been increasingly reported. Students’ leadership had frequently been described. Student tutor training, programs for teaching skills, institutional support, and assessments have been conducted for effective peer-assisted learning. There is considerable positive evidence that peer-assisted learning is effective in teaching simple clinical skills and medical knowledge for tutees. However, its effects on complex skills and knowledge, small-group discussions, personal and professional development, peer mentoring, and work-based learning have rarely been studied. Additionally, little evidence exists regarding whether peer-assisted learning is effective for student tutors. Further research is needed to develop peer-assisted learning programs and to investigate their learning effects on student tutors, small-group discussion facilitation, personal and professional development, peer mentoring, and peer-led work-based learning in the clinical setting in South Korea. Formal programs and system advancement for a student-led learning culture is needed for effective peer-assisted learning.

참고문헌 (89)

  1. Giles JA, "Peer assisted learning", BMJ, 338, pp.b2498~ (2009)
  2. Gibson DR, "The role of cooperative learning in the training of junior hospital doctors: a study of paediatric senior house officers", Med Teach, 22(3), pp.297~300 (2000)
  3. Walton MM, "Improving safety and quality: how can education help?", Med J Aust, 184(S10), pp.S60~S64 (2006)
  4. Herrmann-Werner A, "Peer-assisted learning(PAL)in undergraduate medical education : an overview", Z Evid Fortbild Qual Gesundhwes, 121, pp.74~81 (2017)
  5. Dandavino M, "Why medical students should learn how to teach", Med Teach, 29(6), pp.558~565 (2007)
  6. Ross MT, "Peer assisted learning: a planning and implementation framework: AMEE guide no. 30", Med Teach, 29(6), pp.527~545 (2007)
  7. Grzega J, "The didactic model LdL(Lernen durch Lehren)as a way of preparing students for communication in a knowledge society", J Educ Teach, 34(3), pp.167~175 (2008)
  8. Topping KJ, "The effectiveness of peer tutoring in further and higher education : a typology and review of the literature", High Educ, 32(3), pp.321~345 (1996)
  9. Trevino FM, "Evaluation of a basic science, peer tutorial program for first-and second-year medical students", J Med Educ, 55(11), pp.952~953 (1980)
  10. Tai J, "Same-level peer-assisted learning in medical clinical placements : a narrative systematic review", Med Educ, 50(4), pp.469~484 (2016)
  11. 김지영, "의과대학 소그룹 지도 프로그램 운영의 사례연구: SNU 학습멘토링, 피어튜터링, 학습코칭, 의학연구 멘토링 프로그램을 중심으로", 의학교육논단, 14(2), pp.78~85 (2012), 연세대학교 의과대학
  12. 이수현, "일개 의과대학 피어튜터링 프로그램 소개 및 효과분석", 의학교육논단, 14(2), pp.86~94 (2012), 연세대학교 의과대학
  13. 윤소정, "의학전문대학원생의 학습동아리 참여 경험에 대한 성찰 에세이분석", 의학교육논단, 18(3), pp.167~173 (2016), 연세대학교 의과대학
  14. 김윤학, "상호동료교수법을 활용한 교대해부실습이 해부실습 시험 성적에 미치는 영향", 해부·생물인류학, 31(3), pp.83~89 (2018), 대한체질인류학회[DOI]
  15. Kirkpatrick DL, "Evaluating training programs: the four levels" (2006), Berrett-Koehler
  16. Henning JM, "Peer assisted learning in clinical education : literature review", Athl Train Educ J, 3(3), pp.84~90 (2008)
  17. Olaussen A, "Peer-assisted learning : time for nomenclature clarification", Med Educ Online, 21, pp.30974~ (2016)
  18. Thompson L, "A clinical procedures curriculum for undergraduate medical students : the eight-year history of a third-year immersive experience", Med Educ Online, 21, pp.29486~ (2016)
  19. Harvey PR, "Peer-led training and assessment in basic life support for healthcare students : synthesis of literature review and fifteen years practical experience", Resuscitation, 83(7), pp.894~899 (2012)
  20. Rogers DA, "Peer teaching and computer-assisted learning: an effective combination for surgical skill training?", J Surg Res, 92(1), pp.53~55 (2000)
  21. Sheahan G, "Comparison of faculty versus structured peer-feedback for acquisitions of basic and intermediate-level surgical skills", Am J Surg, 217(2), pp.214~221 (2019)
  22. Blohm M, "Voluntary undergraduate technical skills training course to prepare students for clerkship assignment : tutees’ and tutors’ perspectives", BMC Med Educ, 14, pp.71~ (2014)
  23. Pelloux S, "Peripheral venous catheter insertion simulation training : a randomized controlled trial comparing performance after instructor-led teaching versus peer-assisted learning", Anaesth Crit Care Pain Med, 36(6), pp.397~402 (2017)
  24. Knobe M, "Peer teaching : a randomised controlled trial using student-teachers to teach musculoskeletal ultrasound", Med Educ, 44(2), pp.148~155 (2010)
  25. Hudson JN, "Clinical skills education : outcomes of relationships between junior medical students, senior peers and simulated patients", Med Educ, 42(9), pp.901~908 (2008)
  26. Blank WA, "Can near-peer medical students effectively teach a new curriculum in physical examination?", BMC Med Educ, 13, pp.165~ (2013)
  27. Han ER, "Peer-assisted learning in a gross anatomy dissection course", PLoS One, 10(11), pp.e0142988~ (2015)
  28. Jackson TA, "Can medical students teach? : a near-peer-led teaching program for year 1 students", Adv Physiol Educ, 36(3), pp.192~196 (2012)
  29. Sobral DT, "Cross-year peer tutoring experience in a medical school : conditions and outcomes for student tutors", Med Educ, 36(11), pp.1064~1070 (2002)
  30. Batchelder AJ, "The role of students as teachers : four years’ experience of a large-scale, peer-led programme", Med Teach, 32(7), pp.547~551 (2010)
  31. Tayler N, "Near peer teaching in medical curricula : integrating student teachers in pathology tutorials", Med Educ Online, 20, pp.27921~ (2015)
  32. Cianciolo AT, "Observational analysis of near-peer and faculty tutoring in problem-based learning groups", Med Educ, 50(7), pp.757~767 (2016)
  33. Kassab S, "Student-led tutorials in problem-based learning : educational outcomes and students’perceptions", Med Teach, 27(6), pp.521~526 (2005)
  34. Kam JK, "A vertical study programme for medical students : peer-assisted learning in practice", Med Teach, 35(2), pp.e943~e945 (2013)
  35. Koenemann N, "Clinical case discussions: a novel, supervised peer-teaching format to promote clinical reasoning in medical students", GMS J Med Educ, 37(5), pp.Doc48~ (2020)
  36. Kibble JD, "A peer-led supplemental tutorial project for medical physiology : implementation in a large class", Adv Physiol Educ, 33(2), pp.111~114 (2009)
  37. Sullivan BT, "A novel peer-directed curriculum to enhance medical ethics training for medical students : a single-institution experience", J Med Educ Curric Dev, 7, pp.2382120519899148~ (2020)
  38. Cusimano MC, "Medical students learn professionalism in near-peer led, discussion-based small groups", Teach Learn Med, 31(3), pp.307~318 (2019)
  39. Liu GZ, "Reflective writing for medical students on the surgical clerkship: oxymoron or antidote?", J Surg Educ, 73(2), pp.296~304 (2016)
  40. McEvoy M, "Near-peer role modeling:can fourth-year medical students, recognized for their humanism, enhance reflection among second-year students in a physical diagnosis course?", Med Educ Online, 21, pp.31940~ (2016)
  41. Sin D, "Evaluation of constructing care collaboration : nurturing empathy and peer-to-peer learning in medical students who participate in voluntary structured service learning programmes for migrant workers", BMC Med Educ, 19(1), pp.304~ (2019)
  42. Hayes AJ, "Improving awareness of patient safety in a peer-led pilot educational programme for undergraduate medical students", Educ Health(Abingdon), 27(2), pp.213~216 (2014)
  43. Tang TS, ""Learning by teaching" : a peerteaching model for diversity training in medical school", Teach Learn Med, 16(1), pp.60~63 (2004)
  44. Bugaj TJ, "Peer-led stress prevention seminars in the first year of medical school: a project report", GMS J Med Educ, 33(1), pp.Doc3~ (2016)
  45. Moir F, "A peer-support and mindfulness program to improve the mental health of medical students", Teach Learn Med, 28(3), pp.293~302 (2016)
  46. Lehrer MD, "Peer-led problem-based learning in interprofessional education of health professions students", Med Educ Online, 20, pp.28851~ (2015)
  47. Knobloch AC, "The impact of near-peer teaching on medical students’ transition to clerkships", Fam Med, 50(1), pp.58~62 (2018)
  48. Andre C, "Students helping students : vertical peer mentoring to enhance the medical school experience", BMC Res Notes, 10(1), pp.176~ (2017)
  49. Barker TA, "Hidden benefits of a peer-mentored ‘Hospital Orientation Day’ : first-year medical students’ perspectives", Med Teach, 34(4), pp.e229~e235 (2012)
  50. Rastegar Kazerooni A, "Peer mentoring for medical students during the COVID-19 pandemic via a social media platform", Med Educ, 54(8), pp.762~763 (2020)
  51. DeVoe P, "Lessons learned from a study-group pilot program for medical students perceived to be ‘at risk’", Med Teach, 29(2-3), pp.e37~e40 (2007)
  52. Miller CJ, "Implementation of a study skills program for entering at-risk medical students", Adv Physiol Educ, 38(3), pp.229~234 (2014)
  53. Prunuske A, "Alignment of roles of near-peer mentors for medical students underrepresented in medicine with medical education competencies : a qualitative study", BMC Med Educ, 19(1), pp.417~ (2019)
  54. Hamso M, "Medical students as teachers at CoSMO, Columbia University’s student-run clinic : a pilot study and literature review", Med Teach, 34(3), pp.e189~97 (2012)
  55. Choudhury N, "Peer mentorship in student-run free clinics : the impact on preclinical education", Fam Med, 46(3), pp.204~208 (2014)
  56. Lin JA, "Impact of near-peer teaching rounds on student satisfaction in the basic surgical clerkship", Am J Surg, 213(6), pp.1163~1165 (2017)
  57. Doumouras A, "Peer-assisted bedside teaching rounds", Clin Teach, 12(3), pp.197~202 (2015)
  58. Yu TC, "Medical students-as-teachers : a systematic review of peer-assisted teaching during medical school", Adv Med Educ Pract, 2, pp.157~172 (2011)
  59. Bergeron D, "Impact of a student-driven, virtual patient application on objective structured clinical examination performance : observational study", J Med Internet Res, 20(2), pp.e60~ (2018)
  60. O’Donovan J, "Distant peer-tutoring of clinical skills, using tablets with instructional videos and Skype : a pilot study in the UK and Malaysia", Med Teach, 37(5), pp.463~469 (2015)
  61. Gulati RR, "Instagram for peer teaching : opportunity and challenge", Educ Prim Care, 31(6), pp.382~384 (2020)
  62. Murphy R, "Problem-based, peer-to-peer global mental health e-learning between the UK and Somaliland : a pilot study", Evid Based Ment Health, 20(4), pp.142~146 (2017)
  63. Burke J, "Peer-assisted learning in the acquisition of clinical skills : a supplementary approach to musculoskeletal system training", Med Teach, 29(6), pp.577~582 (2007)
  64. Wong JG, "Formal peer-teaching in medical school improves academic performance : the MUSC supplemental instructor program", Teach Learn Med, 19(3), pp.216~220 (2007)
  65. Iwata K, "Do peer-tutors perform better in examinations? : an analysis of medical school final examination results", Med Educ, 48(7), pp.698~704 (2014)
  66. Schwill S, "The AaLplus near-peer teaching program in family medicine strengthens basic medical skills : a five-year retrospective study", PLoS One, 15, pp.e0233748~ (2020)
  67. Burgess A, "Medical students as peer tutors : a systematic review", BMC Med Educ, 14, pp.115~ (2014)
  68. Akinla O, "A systematic review of the literature describing the outcomes of near-peer mentoring programs for first year medical students", BMC Med Educ, 18(1), pp.98~ (2018)
  69. Guraya SY, "Determining the effectiveness of peer-assisted learning in medical education : a systematic review and meta-analysis", J Taibah Univ Med Sci, 15(3), pp.177~184 (2020)
  70. Lim SY, "Enhancing geriatric oncology training through a combination of novice mentoring and peer and near-peer mentoring : a thematic analysis of mentoring in medicine between 2000 and 2017", J Geriatr Oncol, 11(4), pp.566~575 (2020)
  71. Rees EL, "How does peer teaching compare to faculty teaching? : a systematic review and meta-analysis", Med Teach, 38(8), pp.829~837 (2016)
  72. Nnodim JO, "A controlled trial of peer-teaching in practical gross anatomy", Clin Anat, 10(2), pp.112~117 (1997)
  73. AlShareef SM, "Comparing the impacts of reciprocal peer teaching with faculty teaching : a single-centre experience from KSA", J Taibah Univ Med Sci, 15(4), pp.272~277 (2020)
  74. Johnson JH, "Importance of dissection in learning anatomy : personal dissection versus peer teaching", Clin Anat, 15(1), pp.38~44 (2002)
  75. Sophia Hernandez, "Near-Peer Learning During the Surgical Clerkship: A Way to Facilitate Learning After a 15-Month Preclinical Curriculum", Journal of Surgical Education, 78(3), pp.828~835 (2020), Elsevier BV[DOI]
  76. Haist SA, "Are fourth-year medical students effective teachers of the physical examination to first-year medical students?", J Gen Intern Med, 12(3), pp.177~181 (1997)
  77. Perkins GD, "Peer-led resuscitation training for healthcare students : a randomised controlled study", Intensive Care Med, 28(6), pp.698~700 (2002)
  78. Hughes TC, "Advanced Cardiac Resuscitation Evaluation (ACRE): a randomized single-blind controlled trial of peer-led vs. expert-led advanced resuscitation training", Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med, 18, pp.3~ (2010)
  79. Walsh CM, "Learning in the simulated setting: a comparison of expert-, peer-, and computer-assisted learning", Acad Med, 86(10Suppl), pp.S12~S16 (2011)
  80. Kuhl M, "Student tutors for hands-on training in focused emergency echocardiography : a randomized controlled trial", BMC Med Educ, 12, pp.101~ (2012)
  81. Steele DJ, "A comparison of learning outcomes and attitudes in student-versus faculty-led problem-based learning : an experimental study", Med Educ, 34(1), pp.23~29 (2000)
  82. Huhn D, "Interactive peer-guided examination preparation course for second-year international full-time medical students: quantitative and qualitative evaluation", GMS J Med Educ, 35(5), pp.Doc57~ (2018)
  83. Agius A, "Undergraduate peer assisted learning tutors’performance in summative anatomy examinations : a pilot study", Int J Med Educ, 9, pp.93~98 (2018)
  84. Peets AD, "Involvement in teaching improves learning in medical students : a randomized cross-over study", BMC Med Educ, 9, pp.55~ (2009)
  85. Gregory A, "Both preparing to teach and teaching positively impact learning outcomes for peer teachers", Med Teach, 33(8), pp.e417~22 (2011)
  86. Nestel D, "Peer assisted learning in patient-centred interviewing : the impact on student tutors", Med Teach, 27(5), pp.439~444 (2005)
  87. Donohoe CL, "Docemur docemus : peer-assisted learning improves the knowledge gain of tutors in the highest quartile of achievement but not those in the lowest quartile", J Surg Educ, 72(6), pp.1139~1144 (2015)
  88. HyeRin Roh, "Negative school experiences of Late Millennial Korean medical students: a qualitative study using the critical incident technique", Korean Journal of Medical Education, 32(3), pp.197~211 (2020), 한국의학교육학회
  89. Blatt B, "A multi-level assessment of a program to teach medical students to teach", Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract, 12(1), pp.7~18 (2007)

관련 논문AI추천

일개 의과대학 피어튜터링 프로그램 소개 및 효과분석양은배, 이수현, 전우택연세대학교 의과대학 · 의학교육논단2012 · 제14권 제2호간호교육에서 동료학습의 효과와 전략에 대한 체계적 문헌고찰박인희, 신수진, 홍정민연세대학교 의과대학 · 의학교육논단2016 · 제18권 제2호의학교육에서의 팀 바탕학습 운영과 효과성에 대한 고찰김선, 조아라, 허예라한국의학교육학회 · Korean Journal of Medical Education2013 · 제25권 제4호의과대학 문제중심학습에서 튜터의 전문분야와 교수경험이 학습결과에 미치는 영향강명희, 김민정, 김민지, 이수지연세대학교 의과대학 · 의학교육논단2011 · 제13권 제2호의학교육에서의 효과적인 팀 바탕학습 운영 방안 및 기대효과김선, 박주현, 유남진, 윤상헌, 조아라, 한상익한국의학교육학회 · Korean Journal of Medical Education2010 · 제22권 제1호의과대학 소그룹 지도 프로그램 운영의 사례연구: SNU 학습멘토링, 피어튜터링, 학습코칭, 의학연구 멘토링 프로그램을 중심으로김은정, 김지영, 김혜림, 이승희, 황진영연세대학교 의과대학 · 의학교육논단2012 · 제14권 제2호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (8건)

“Learning by Teaching” 특집호를 준비하며임기영pp. 1-2미래학습에서의 Learning by Teaching 적용가능성최효선pp. 3-10교육자로서 전공의 역량과 교육과정의 분석과 제안박장희pp. 23-36한국형 임상실습 교육환경 평가척도 타당화옥지원, 박영순, 천경희pp. 37-45의과대학 학생의 온라인 수업에 대한 인식 및 학습행동에 관한 질적 연구김도환, 강예지pp. 46-55
원문 보기