의학교육 학생평가의 객관성에 대한 쟁점
Issues Related to the Objectivity of Student Assessment in Medical Education
1
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This paper addressed various issues related to the objectivity of student assessment in medical education. The objectivity of assessment was related to all the steps of test development, administration, and results reporting in terms of reliability and validity. Specifically, the objectivity of item formats, representativeness of test content, standardization of test administration, consistency of scoring procedures, and appropriateness of reporting test results were discussed by comparing performance assessment with traditional paper-and-pencil tests. The conclusions were derived from current measurement theories such as standards-based assessment, evidencebased design, and outcome-based assessment. Further, based on Shepard’s propositions (2006), the objectivity of student assessment could be achieved by improving the concordance between educational objectives and assessment components such as item types, test contents, and test administration, scoring, and reporting.
Abstract
This paper addressed various issues related to the objectivity of student assessment in medical education. The objectivity of assessment was related to all the steps of test development, administration, and results reporting in terms of reliability and validity. Specifically, the objectivity of item formats, representativeness of test content, standardization of test administration, consistency of scoring procedures, and appropriateness of reporting test results were discussed by comparing performance assessment with traditional paper-and-pencil tests. The conclusions were derived from current measurement theories such as standards-based assessment, evidencebased design, and outcome-based assessment. Further, based on Shepard’s propositions (2006), the objectivity of student assessment could be achieved by improving the concordance between educational objectives and assessment components such as item types, test contents, and test administration, scoring, and reporting.
참고문헌 (19)
- Allen, M. J., "Introduction to measurement theory" (1979), Waveland Press
- Amin, Z., "Practical guide to medical student assessment" (2006), World Scientific
- Cohen, A. S., "Test administration, security, scoring and reporting, In Educational measurement", pp.355~386 (2006), Praeger Publishers
- Cronbach, L. J., "Generalizability analysis for performance assessments of student achievement or school effectiveness", Educ Psychol Meas, 57(3), pp.373~399 (1997)
- Dent, J. A., "A practical guide for medical teachers" (2009), Churchill Livingstone Elsevier
- Drasgow, F., "Technology and testing, In Educational measurement", pp.471~515 (2006), Praeger Publishers
- Epstein, R. M., "Assessment in medical education", N Engl J Med, 356(4), pp.387~396 (2007)
- Kane, M. T., "Validation, In Educational measurement", pp.17~64 (2006), Praeger Publishers
- Kogan, J. R., "Tools for direct observation and assessment of clinical skills of medical trainees : a systematic review", JAMA, 302(12), pp.1316~1326 (2009)
- Lane, S., "Performance assessment: the state of the art. (SCOPE student performance Assessment Series)" (2010), Stanford University, Stanford Center for Opportunity Policy in Education
- Lane, S., "Performance assessment, In Educational measurement", pp.387~431 (2006), Praeger Publishers
- Lohr, S. L., "Sampling: design and analysis" (1999), Duxbury Press
- Mavis, B. E., "A survey of student assessment in US medical schools : the balance of breadth versus fidelity", Teach Learn Med, 13(2), pp.74~79 (2001)
- Miller, G. E., "The assessment of clinical skills", competence, Acad Med, pp.1990, 65(9 Suppl)[DOI]
- Miller, M. D., "Measurement and assessment in teaching" (2009), Pearson Education International Co
- A brief introduction to evidence-centered design, "Mislevy, R. J.", Educational Testing Service, ~, pp.RR-03-16 (2003)
- Mullis, I. V., "Scoring direct writing assessment: what are the alternatives?", Educ Meas: Issues Pract, 3(1), pp.16~18 (1984)
- Shepard, L. A., "The role of assessment in a learning culture", Educ Res, 78(1), pp.153~188 (2000)
- Performance assessment in an era of standards-based educational accountability, "Stecher, B.", Stanford University, Stanford Center for Opportunity Policy in Education, ~ (2010)