A Meta-Analysis Study on Oral Feedback Effect between ESL and EFL Contexts
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This study investigates how different L2 learning environments produce differing effects of oral corrective feedback (CF) in second language (L2) classrooms. The results of this research using the random effect model are presented according to the English teaching environments (EFL or ESL). The quantitative meta-analyses for four variables (types, linguistic domains, L1, age) are conducted and compared between research works of ESL and EFL environment. The data were collected from research papers. In total, 42 studies are coded, 19 of which are identified as EFL studies and 23 as ESL. It is found that (a) the overall effect of the corrective feedback is greater in the ESL environment; (b) its effect degree is variable-dependent; (c) both EFL and ESL environments have contributed differentially to the effect size. Possible explanations and justifications for the results are sought through cross-tabulation and with reference to the theoretical background of the second language acquisition.
Abstract
This study investigates how different L2 learning environments produce differing effects of oral corrective feedback (CF) in second language (L2) classrooms. The results of this research using the random effect model are presented according to the English teaching environments (EFL or ESL). The quantitative meta-analyses for four variables (types, linguistic domains, L1, age) are conducted and compared between research works of ESL and EFL environment. The data were collected from research papers. In total, 42 studies are coded, 19 of which are identified as EFL studies and 23 as ESL. It is found that (a) the overall effect of the corrective feedback is greater in the ESL environment; (b) its effect degree is variable-dependent; (c) both EFL and ESL environments have contributed differentially to the effect size. Possible explanations and justifications for the results are sought through cross-tabulation and with reference to the theoretical background of the second language acquisition.
참고문헌 (61)
- Adams, R, "Explicit and implicit feedback, modified output, and SLA: Does explicit and implicit feedback promote learning and learner–learner interactions", The Modern Language Journal, 95, pp.42~63 (2011)
- Alhaysony, M, "Saudi EFL preparatory year students' perception about corrective feedback in oral communication", English Language Teaching, 9(12), pp.47~61 (2016)
- Ammar, A, "One size fits all? : Recasts, prompts, and L2 learning", Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 28(4), pp.543~574 (2006)
- Agudo, M, "An investigation into how EFL learners emotionally respond to teachers' oral corrective feedback", Colombian Applied Linguistics Journal, 15(2), pp.265~278 (2013)
- Bagheridoust, E, "The impact of dynamic corrective feedback in developing speaking ability of Persianian intermediate EFL learners", Journal of Language Teaching & Research, 6(5), pp.1063~1074 (2015)
- Carpenter, H, "Learners' interpretations of recasts", Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 28(2), pp.209~236 (2006)
- Cohen, J, "Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences" (1988), Hillsdale
- Cooper, H, "The Handbook of Research Synthesis", pp.3~14 (1994)
- Dekhinet, R, "Online enhanced corrective feedback for ESL learners in higher education", Computer Assisted Language Learning, 21(5), pp.409~425 (2008)
- Dilans, G, "Corrective feedback and L2 vocabulary development : Prompts and recasts in the adult ESL classroom", Canadian Modern Language Review, 66(6), pp.787~816 (2010)
- Egi, T, "Uptake, modified output, and learner perceptions of recasts: Learner responses as language awareness", The Modern Language Journal, 94(1), pp.1~21 (2010)
- Ellis, R, "Implicit and explicit corrective feedback and the acquisition of L2 grammar", Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 28(2), pp.339~368 (2006)
- Gass, S, "Input, interaction, and the second language learner" (1997), Mahwah
- Junqueira, L, "Exploring the relationship between training, beliefs, and teachers’ corrective feedback practices : A case study of a novice and an experienced ESL teacher", Canadian modern language review, 69(2), pp.181~206 (2013)
- Han, Z, "A study of the impact of recasts on tense consistency in L2 output", TESOL Quarterly, 36, pp.543~572 (2002)
- Harmandaoglu Baz, E, "Perceptions of English instructors and learners about corrective feedback", European Journal of Foreign Language Teaching, 1(1), pp.54~68 (2016)
- Hunter, J. E, "Methods of meta-analysis: Correcting error and bias in research findings" (2004), Sage
- Kaivanpanah, S, "Preferences for interactional feedback : Differences between learners and teachers", Language Learning Journal, 43(1), pp.74~93 (2015)
- Kamiya, N, "The relationship between stated beliefs and classroom practices of oral corrective feedback", Innovation in Language Learning and Teaching, 10(3), pp.206~219 (2016)
- Kartchava, E, "Learners' beliefs about corrective feedback in the language classroom : Perspectives from two international contexts", TESL Canada Journal, 33(2), pp.19~45 (2016)
- Kennedy, S, "Corrective feedback for learners of varied proficiency levels : A teacher's choices", TESL Canada Journal, 27(2), pp.31~50 (2010)
- 김지현, "The Effects of Different Types of Oral Corrective Feedback on the Development of Explicit", Implicit L2 Knowledge of English Articles, 2016, pp.71(3), 53~77[DOI]
- 김인영, "The Relation Between Self-Correction and L2 Oral Proficiency of Korean EFL Learners", 응용언어학, 24(3), pp.421~441 (2008), 한국응용언어학회
- 이보영, "Effects of Task and Feedback Types on Korean Adult EFL Learners’ Oral Proficiency", 영어교육, 65(2), pp.101~130 (2010), 한국영어교육학회[DOI]
- Lee, E. J, "Advanced ESL students' prior EFL education and their perceptions of oral corrective feedback", Journal of International Students, 6(3), pp.798~816 (2016)
- Li, S, "The effects of the timing of corrective feedback on the acquisition of a new linguistic structure", The Modern Language Journal, 100(1), pp.276~295 (2016)
- Lightbown, P. M, "Focus-on-form and corrective feedback in communicative language teaching : Effects on second language learning", Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 12(4), pp.429~448 (1990)
- Lipsey, M. W, "Practical meta-analysis" (2001), Sage Publications
- Loewen, S, "Uptake in incidental focus on form in meaning‐focused ESL lessons", Language learning, 54(1), pp.153~188 (2004)
- Loewen, S, "Recasts in the adult English L2 classroom : Characteristics, explicitness, and effectiveness", The Modern Language Journal, 90, pp.536~556 (2006)
- Lyster, R, "Negotiation of form, recasts, and explicit correction in relation to error types and learner repair in immersion classrooms", Language Learning, 51, pp.265~301 (2001)
- Lyster, R, "Corrective feedback and learner uptake : Negotiation of form in communicative classrooms", Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 19(1), pp.37~66 (1997)
- Lyster, R, "Prompts versus recasts in dyadic interaction", Language Learning, 59, pp.453~498 (2009)
- Lyster, R, "Oral feedback in classroom SLA : A meta-analysis", Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 32(2), pp.265~302 (2010)
- Lyndon, P. A, "The efficacy of corrective feedback and textual enhancement in promoting the acquisition of grammatical redundancies", The Modern Language Journal, 95, pp.104~129 (2011)
- McDonough, K, "Identifying the impact of negative feedback and learners’ response on ESL question development", Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 27(1), pp.79~103 (2005)
- Mackey, A, "How do learners perceive interactional feedback?", Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 22(4), pp.471~497 (2000)
- Mackey, A, "Interactional input and the incorporation of feedback : An exploration of NS–NNS and NNS–NNS adult and child dyads", Language Learning, 53(1), pp.35~66 (2003)
- McDonough, K, "Responses to recasts : Repetitions, primed production, and linguistic development", Language Learning, 56, pp.693~720 (2006)
- Milla, R, "Corrective feedback episodes in oral interaction : A comparison of a CLIL and an EFL classroom", International Journal of English Studies, 14(1), pp.1~20 (2014)
- Monteiro, K, "An experimental study of corrective feedback during video-conferencing", Language Learning & Technology, 18(3), pp.56~79 (2014)
- Munro, M. J, "Foreign accent, comprehensibility, and intelligibility in the speech of second language learners", Language Learning, 49, pp.285~310 (1999)
- Nabei, T., "Learner awareness of recasts in classroom interaction : A case study of an adult EFL student's second language learning", Language Awareness, 11(1), pp.43~63 (2002)
- Nassaji, H, "Elicitation and reformulation and their relationship with learner repair in dyadic interaction", Language Learning, 57, pp.511~548 (2007)
- Nassaji, H, "Effects of recasts and elicitations in dyadic interaction and the role of feedback explicitness", Language Learning, 59, pp.411~452 (2009)
- Norris, J. M, "Effectiveness of L2 instruction : A research synthesis and quantitative meta‐analysis", Language Learning, 50(3), pp.417~528 (2000)
- Öztürk, G, "An investigation on the use of oral corrective feedback in Turkish EFL classrooms", Journal of Language and Linguistic Studies, 12(2), pp.22~37 (2016)
- Panova, I, "Patterns of corrective feedback and uptake in an adult ESL classroom", TESOL Quarterly, 36(4), pp.573~595 (2002)
- Poorahmadi, M, "The effect of recast vs. clarification request as two types of corrective feedback on Persianian intermediate EFL learners' structural knowledge", Journal of Language Teaching & Research, 8(1), pp.87~96 (2017)
- Rassaei, E, "Investigating the effects of three types of corrective feedback on the acquisition of English Wh-question forms by Persianian EFL learners", English Language Teaching, 4(2), pp.97~106 (2011)
- Rassaei, E, "Recasts, metalinguistic feedback, and learners' perceptions : A case of Persian EFL learners", Innovation in Language Learning and Teaching, 8(1), pp.39~55 (2014)
- Rassaei, E, "Video chat vs. face-to-face recasts, learners' interpretations and L2 development: A case of Persian EFL learners", Computer Assisted Language Learning, 30(1), pp.16~ (2017)
- Rahimi, M, "The role of incidental unfocused prompts and recasts in improving English as a foreign language learners' accuracy", Language Learning Journal, 44(2), pp.257~268 (2016)
- Russell, J, "The effectiveness of corrective feedback for the acquisition of L2 grammar", Synthesizing Research on Language Learning and Teaching, 13, pp.133~164 (2006)
- Sagarra, N, "Optimizing the noticing of recasts via computer-delivered feedback : Evidence that oral input enhancement and working memory help second language learning", The Modern Language Journal, 97, pp.196~216 (2013)
- Schwartz, S, "Comparing different types of performance feedback and computer-based instruction in teaching medical students how to diagnose acute abdominal pain", Academic Medicine, 10(2), pp.35~42 (1993)
- Sippel, L, "Teacher vs. peer oral corrective feedback in the German language classroom", Foreign Language Annals, 48(4), pp.688~705 (2015)
- Shabani, K, "Immediate vs delayed correction feedback(CF)and accuracy of oral production : The role of anxiety", Theory & Practice In Language Studies, 6(11), pp.2222~2230 (2016)
- Spada, N, "Instruction and the development of questions in L2 classrooms", Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 15, pp.205~224 (1993)
- Wang, W, "Nonverbal behavior and corrective feedback in nine ESL university-level classrooms", Language Teaching Research, 20(4), pp.459~478 (2016)
- Yang, Y, "Effects of form-focused practice and feedback on Chinese EFL learners' acquisition of regular and irregular past tense forms", Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 32(2), pp.235~263 (2010)
