기본의학교육 의사학 학습성과 개발:역량바탕교육에 대한 비판적 접근을 중심으로
Learning Outcomes Development for History of Medicine in Basic Medical Education: Focusing on a Critical Approach to Competency-Based Education
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Competency-based education has been criticized for its characteristics including the lack of a solid academic and theoretical foundation, conceptual ambiguity and confusion, job-centeredness, and behaviorist reductionism, etc. However, in spite of these shortcomings, competency-based education is currently accepted virtually uncritically in basic medical education in Korea. In addition, its various limitations have been exposed by being disconnected with the goals of the medical humanities education and, furthermore, the basic medical education. This is because skill-oriented, competency-based education deduced from the context of vocational training is not compatible with professionalism or the establishment of a physician’s identity, which are aimed at the establishment of a higher value system. In order to set the goals of teaching and learning in the history of medicine, it is inevitable to undergo criticism of the pedagogical limitations and restrictions, and insufficient foundations of existing competency-based education. It is because of the belief that only by critically reviewing the social and theoretical origins of competency-based education can enable gaining of a faithful understanding of its current state. Nevertheless, critically intervening the already mainstreamed competency-based education and discussing the possibilities of history of medicine education within it should also be an important goal. The role of the history of medicine in the current competency-based education could be to mitigate the shortcomings of competency-based education, to redefine the competency as a social content competency rather than as an individual behavior, and to focus on and complement the humanities education function underlying the learning outcomes. It is necessary to develop the learning outcomes development for history of medicine in basic medical education in Korea. However, it is not advisable to simply create and hierarchize new learning outcomes within the various listed learning outcomes. History of medicine needs to present the fact that discernment from the perspective of the history of medicine in the competencies and learning outcomes currently being discussed is needed and the contributions that the history of medicine can make at the same time. Moreover, the current medical education needs to make contributions towards the establishment of professional identity and the relationship between the profession and society by moving beyond a narrow understanding and fragmented measurement of physician’s duties. This is why history of medicine education should examine both the limitations of competency-based education and the contribution potentials of the history of medicine concurrently.
Abstract
Competency-based education has been criticized for its characteristics including the lack of a solid academic and theoretical foundation, conceptual ambiguity and confusion, job-centeredness, and behaviorist reductionism, etc. However, in spite of these shortcomings, competency-based education is currently accepted virtually uncritically in basic medical education in Korea. In addition, its various limitations have been exposed by being disconnected with the goals of the medical humanities education and, furthermore, the basic medical education. This is because skill-oriented, competency-based education deduced from the context of vocational training is not compatible with professionalism or the establishment of a physician’s identity, which are aimed at the establishment of a higher value system. In order to set the goals of teaching and learning in the history of medicine, it is inevitable to undergo criticism of the pedagogical limitations and restrictions, and insufficient foundations of existing competency-based education. It is because of the belief that only by critically reviewing the social and theoretical origins of competency-based education can enable gaining of a faithful understanding of its current state. Nevertheless, critically intervening the already mainstreamed competency-based education and discussing the possibilities of history of medicine education within it should also be an important goal. The role of the history of medicine in the current competency-based education could be to mitigate the shortcomings of competency-based education, to redefine the competency as a social content competency rather than as an individual behavior, and to focus on and complement the humanities education function underlying the learning outcomes. It is necessary to develop the learning outcomes development for history of medicine in basic medical education in Korea. However, it is not advisable to simply create and hierarchize new learning outcomes within the various listed learning outcomes. History of medicine needs to present the fact that discernment from the perspective of the history of medicine in the competencies and learning outcomes currently being discussed is needed and the contributions that the history of medicine can make at the same time. Moreover, the current medical education needs to make contributions towards the establishment of professional identity and the relationship between the profession and society by moving beyond a narrow understanding and fragmented measurement of physician’s duties. This is why history of medicine education should examine both the limitations of competency-based education and the contribution potentials of the history of medicine concurrently.
참고문헌 (42)
- 교육부, "보도자료: 대학 교육의 질 제고 및 입학자원 급감 대비를 위한 2015년 대학 구조개혁 평가 기본계획 확정", ~ (2014)
- 대한의사학회, "의사학 학습목표" (1999)
- 한국의과대학, "사람과 사회 중심 기본의학교육 학습성과 개발 제1차워크숍", ~ (2015)
- 한국의과대학, "기본의학교육 학습성과: 사람과 사회 중심", ~ (2017)
- 한국의학교육평가원, "의학교육 평가인증 기준 및 규정", ~ (2010)
- The Fundamental Role of the Arts and Humanities in Medical Education, "Howley, Lisa", Association of American Medical Colleges, ~ (2020)
- 권복규, "의학교육에서 의료인문학의 가치 : 의사학을 중심으로", 의사학, 31(3) (2022)
- 김대현, "사람과 사회 중심의 기본의학 학습성과", 의학교육논단, 18(3) (2016)
- 김민정, "‘역량담론’의 헤게모니와 대학교양교육의 방향", 문화와 융합, 41(5) (2019)
- 김선, "학습성과의 개념과 필요성", Korean Journal of Medical Education, 24(2) (2012)
- 김영전, "의학교육에서의 역량기반교육의 가능성과 한계 탐색", 의학교육논단, 13(1) (2011)
- 김진규, "교육과정과 교육평가" (2015), 동문사
- 김택중, "미국 의료시스템과학 교육의 한국 도입과 그 비판", 의사학, 31(3) (2022)
- 문태준, "醫師･醫學協會" (1985), 샘터
- 박승배, "교육과정학의 이해" (2019), 학지사
- 박휴용, "핵심역량기반 교육에 대한 비판적 고찰", 교육사상연구, 29(4) (2015)
- 서울대학교 교육학과 BK21 역량기반 교육혁신 연구사업단, "역량기반교육" (2010), 교육과학사
- 소경희, "역량기반교육" (2010), 교육과학사
- 송경오, "역량기반교육개혁의 특징과 적용가능성 탐색", 한국교육, 34(4) (2007)
- 안재희, "성과중심교육과정 개발절차에 대한 고찰", 의학교육논단, 15(1) (2013)
- 오헌석, "역량기반교육" (2010), 교육과학사
- 윤정일, "역량기반교육" (2010), 교육과학사
- 이상미, "의사학 교육 80년, 역사와 현황", 의사학, 32(1) (2023)
- 이종식, "일본의 식민지 조선통치론" (2023), 민속원
- 전우택, "한국의 환자중심 의사 역량 연구", 의학교육논단, 24(2) (2022)
- 한재진, "2020 한국의 의사상 연구" (2022), 대한의사협회 의료정책연구소
- 허지원, "‘역량기반 교육’ 개념체제의 이해와 조건 탐색을 통한 과제 제시", 핵심역량교육연구, 6(1) (2021)
- Cultural Competence in Health Care: emerging frameworks and practical approaches, "Betancourt, Joseph R.", Common wealth Fund, Quality of Care for Underserved Populations, ~ (2002)
- Cooke, Molly, "Educating Physicians: a call for reform of medical school and residency" (2010), Jossey-Bass
- Dennhardt, Silke, "Rethinking research in the medical humanities : a scoping review and narrative synthesis of quantitative outcome studies", Medical Education, 50(3) (2016)
- Hodge, Steven, "The origins of competency-based training", Australian Journal of Adult Learning, 47(2) (2007)
- Jones, David S., "Making the case for history in medical education", Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences, 70(4) (2015)
- Leung, Wai-Ching, "Competency based medical training : review", BMJ, 325 (2002)
- Masters, Ken, "Edgar Dale’s pyramid of learning in medical education : further expansion of the myth", Medical Education, 54 (2020)
- Competency-Based Curriculum Development in Medical Education: an introduction, "McGaghie, William C.", World Health Organization, ~ (1978)
- Metzl, Jonathan M., "Structural competency : theorizing a new medical engagement with stigma and inequality", Social Science & Medicine, 103 (2014)
- Moniz, Tracy, "The prism model for integrating the arts and humanities into medical education", Academic Medicine, 96(8) (2021)
- Morcke, Anne M., "Outcome (competency) based education: an exploration of its origins, theoretical basis, and empirical evidence", Advances in Health Sciences Education, 18(4) (2013)
- Steere-Williams, Jacob, "Remaking the case for history in medical education", Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences, 78(1) (2023)
- Tyler, Ralph W., "Basic principles of curriculum and instruction" (1949), The University of Chicago Press
- Weber, Alan S., "Clinical applications of the history of medicine in muslim-majority nations", Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences, 78(1) (2023)
- Wu, Harry Yi-Jui, "Spatial relevance: teaching history to medical students at a medical museum in Hong Kong", Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences, 78(1) (2023)