Combining Multi-Criteria Analysis with CBR for Medical Decision Support
2
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
One of the most visible developments in Decision Support Systems (DSS) was the emergence of rule-basedexpert systems. Hence, despite their success in many sectors, developers of Medical Rule-Based Systems havemet several critical problems. Firstly, the rules are related to a clearly stated subject. Secondly, a rule-basedsystem can only learn by updating of its rule-base, since it requires explicit knowledge of the used domain. Solutions to these problems have been sought through improved techniques and tools, improveddevelopment paradigms, knowledge modeling languages and ontology, as well as advanced reasoningtechniques such as case-based reasoning (CBR) which is well suited to provide decision support in thehealthcare setting. However, using CBR reveals some drawbacks, mainly in its interrelated tasks: the retrievaland the adaptation. For the retrieval task, a major drawback raises when several similar cases are found andconsequently several solutions. Hence, a choice for the best solution must be done. To overcome theselimitations, numerous useful works related to the retrieval task were conducted with simple and convenientprocedures or by combining CBR with other techniques. Through this paper, we provide a combiningapproach using the multi-criteria analysis (MCA) to help, the traditional retrieval task of CBR, in choosingthe best solution. Afterwards, we integrate this approach in a decision model to support medical decision. Wepresent, also, some preliminary results and suggestions to extend our approach.
Abstract
One of the most visible developments in Decision Support Systems (DSS) was the emergence of rule-basedexpert systems. Hence, despite their success in many sectors, developers of Medical Rule-Based Systems havemet several critical problems. Firstly, the rules are related to a clearly stated subject. Secondly, a rule-basedsystem can only learn by updating of its rule-base, since it requires explicit knowledge of the used domain. Solutions to these problems have been sought through improved techniques and tools, improveddevelopment paradigms, knowledge modeling languages and ontology, as well as advanced reasoningtechniques such as case-based reasoning (CBR) which is well suited to provide decision support in thehealthcare setting. However, using CBR reveals some drawbacks, mainly in its interrelated tasks: the retrievaland the adaptation. For the retrieval task, a major drawback raises when several similar cases are found andconsequently several solutions. Hence, a choice for the best solution must be done. To overcome theselimitations, numerous useful works related to the retrieval task were conducted with simple and convenientprocedures or by combining CBR with other techniques. Through this paper, we provide a combiningapproach using the multi-criteria analysis (MCA) to help, the traditional retrieval task of CBR, in choosingthe best solution. Afterwards, we integrate this approach in a decision model to support medical decision. Wepresent, also, some preliminary results and suggestions to extend our approach.
참고문헌 (52)
- I. Bichindaritz, "Computational Intelligence in Healthcare 4: Advanced Methodologies", pp.127~157 (2010), Springer
- S. Montani, "Exploring new roles for case-based reasoning in heterogeneous AI systems for medical decision support", Applied Intelligence, 28(3), pp.275~285 (2008)
- D. A. John, "A framework for medical diagnosis using hybrid reasoning", Proceedings of the International MultiConference of Engineers and Computer Scientists (2010)
- I. Bichindaritz, "Introduction to the special issue on case-based reasoning in the health sciences", Computational Intelligence, 25(3), pp.161~164 (2009)
- N. Armaghan, "An application of multi-criteria decision aids models for case-based reasoning", Information Sciences, 210, pp.55~66 (2012)
- M. Velasquez, "An analysis of multi-criteria decision making methods", International Journal of Operations Research, 10(2), pp.56~66 (2013)
- B. Roy, "Aide multicritère à la decision: méthodes et cas" (1993), Economica
- A. Aamodt, "Case-based reasoning : foundational issues, methodological variations, and system approaches", AI Communications, 7(1), pp.39~59 (1994)
- C. Marling, "Toward case-based reasoning for diabetes management : a preliminary clinical study and decision support system prototype", Computational Intelligence, 25(3), pp.165~179 (2009)
- M. K. Jha, "Diabetes detection and care applying CBR techniques", International Journal of Soft Computing and Engineering(IJSCE), 2(6), pp.132~137 (2013)
- X. Song, "A case-based reasoning approach to dose planning in radiotherapy", Proceedings of 7th International Conference on Case-Based Reasoning, pp.348~357 (2007)
- F. J. De Paz, "Case-based reasoning as a decision support system for cancer diagnosis : a case study", International Journal of Hybrid Intelligent Systems, 6(2), pp.97~110 (2009)
- F. L. Schwartz, "Use of case-based reasoning to enhance intensive management of patients on insulin pump therapy", Journal of Diabetes Science and Technology, 2(4), pp.603~611 (2008)
- "Multicriteria decision analysis methodology for medical diagnosis aid" (2003)[URL]
- M. Shanbezadeh, "Developing a clinical decision support model to evaluate the quality of asthma control level", Middle-East Journal of Scientific Research, 14(3), pp.387~393 (2013)
- G. Van Valkenhoef, "Multicriteria benefit : risk assessment using network meta-analysis", Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 65(4), pp.394~403 (2012)
- A. Erjaee, "A multicriteria decision making model for treatment of Helicobacter pylori infection in children", Hong Kong Journal of Paediatrics, 17(4), pp.237~242 (2012)
- A. Bouhana, "An integrated case-based reasoning and AHP method for personalized itinerary search", Proceedings of 4th International Conference on Logistics, pp.460~467 (2011)
- K. A. Kumar, "Hybrid approach using case-based reasoning and rule-based reasoning for domain independent clinical decision support in ICU", Expert Systems with Applications, 36(1), pp.65~71 (2009)
- S. Begum, "Case-based reasoning systems in the health sciences : a survey of recent trends and developments", IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, Part C (Applications and Reviews), 41(4), pp.421~434 (2011)
- C. Marling, "Integrations with case-based reasoning", The Knowledge Engineering Review, 20(3), pp.241~245 (2005)
- H. Li, "Hybridizing principles of the Electre method with case-based reasoning for data mining : Electre-CBR-I and Electre-CBR-II", European Journal of Operational Research, 197(1), pp.214~224 (2009)
- G. F. Royes, "A hybrid fuzzy-multicriteria-CBR methodology for strategic planning support", Proceedings of IEEE Annual Meeting of the Fuzzy Information, 2004. Processing (NAFIPS '04), pp.208~213 (2004)
- A. K. Araujo de Castro, "Towards the neuropsychological diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease: a hybrid model in decision making", Proceedings of 2nd World Summit on the Knowledge Society (WSKS 2009), pp.522~531 (2009)
- R. Schmidt, "Cased-based reasoning for medical knowledge-based systems", International Journal of Medical Informatics, 64(2-3), pp.355~367 (2001)
- S. Begum, "A case-based decision support system for individual stress diagnosis using fuzzy similarity matching", Computational Intelligence, 25(3), pp.180~195 (2009)
- L. Verma, "Integration of rule based and case based reasoning system to support decision making", Proceedings of International Conference on Issues and Challenges in Intelligent Computing Techniques (ICICT), pp.106~108 (2014)
- J. Agarwal, "Implementation of hybrid image fusion technique for feature enhancement in medical diagnosis", Human-centric Computing and Information Sciences, 5 (2015)
- K. M. Prabusankarlal, "Assessment of combined textural and morphological features for diagnosis of breast masses in ultrasound", Human-centric Computing and Information Sciences, 5 (2015)
- V. Vijayarajan, "A generic framework for ontologybased information retrieval and image retrieval in web data", Human-centric Computing and Information Sciences, 6 (2016)
- Fatemeh Momenipour Moghadam, "Comparative Study of Various Persian Stemmers in the Field of Information Retrieval", JIPS(Journal of Information Processing Systems), 11(3), pp.450~464 (2015), 한국정보처리학회[DOI]
- Ravinder Kumar, "A Robust Fingerprint Matching System Using Orientation Features", JIPS(Journal of Information Processing Systems), 12(1), pp.83~99 (2016), 한국정보처리학회[DOI]
- M. Szelag, "Similarity-based classification with dominance-based decision rules", Proceedings of International Joint Conference on Rough Sets, pp.355~364 (2016)
- H. Malekpoor, "An efficient approach to radiotherapy dose planning problem : a TOPSIS case-based reasoning approach", International Journal of Systems Science:Operations & Logistics, 4(1), pp.4~12 (2016)
- A. Bouhana, "An ontology-based CBR approach for personalized itinerary search systems for sustainable urban freight transport", Expert Systems with Applications, 42(7), pp.3724~3741 (2015)
- J. Qi, "Hybrid weighted mean for CBR adaptation in mechanical design by exploring effective, correlative and adaptative values", Computers in Industry, 75, pp.58~66 (2016)
- B. Noori, "Developing a CBR system for marketing mix planning and weighting method selection using fuzzy AHP", Applied Artificial Intelligence, 29(1), pp.1~32 (2015)
- Haiqiao Wang, "Hybrid similarity measure for retrieval in case-based reasoning systems and its applications for computer numerical control turret design", Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part B: Journal of Engineering Manufacture, 232(5), pp.918~927 (2016), SAGE Publications[DOI]
- 윤석범, "창의적 캡스톤 디자인 교육 방법 개발", 한국융합학회논문지, 5(4), pp.15~20 (2014), 한국융합학회
- T. Pelaccia, "Comment les médecins raisonnent-ils pour poser des diagnostics et prendre des décisions thérapeutiques? Les enjeux en médecine d’urgence", Annales Françaises de Médecine D'urgence, 1(1), pp.77~84 (2011)
- J. P. Kassirer, "Teaching clinical reasoning : case-based and coached", Academic Medicine, 85(7), pp.1118~1124 (2010)
- "Sexual and Reproductive Health"[URL]
- "Family Planning/Contraception"[URL]
- B. Roy, "The outranking approach and the foundations of ELECTRE methods", Theory and Decision, 31(1), pp.49~73 (1991)
- S. B. Mena, "Introduction aux méthodes multicritères d'aide à la décision", Biotechnologie, Agronomie, Société et Environnement, 4(2), pp.83~93 (2000)
- J. A. Recio-Garcia, "jCOLIBRI2 Tutorial" (2008), Universidad Complutense de Madrid
- J. A. Fortney, "The importance of family planning in reducing maternal mortality", Studies in Family Planning, 18(2), pp.109~114 (1987)
- L. R. Beach, "Developing and testing a decision aid for birth planning decisions", Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 15(1), pp.99~116 (1976)
- E. B. Schwarz, "Clinical decision support to promote safe prescribing to women of reproductive age : a clusterrandomized trial", Journal of General Internal Medicine, 27(7), pp.831~838 (2012)
- Birth Spacing: Three to Five Saves Lives, Population Reports, "V. Setty-Venugopal", ~ (2002)
- Contraception and Beyond: The Health Benefits of Services Provided at Family Planning Centers, "M. L. Kavanaugh", Guttmacher Institute, ~ (2013)
- "Contraceptive Method Choice Data Set" (1999)[URL]