수직적 구조에서 지배력 남용 판단에 관한 고찰
A Study on Abuse of Dominance Power in Vertical Structures
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
A patentee has the exclusive right, and a use of the right will become the object of protection in the Patent Act. But if the use of patents belongs to the misuse, Patent Act will not protect the use of patents and will be applied the Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trad Act(hereafter MRFTA) will be applied to the use of patents. At the process of the application it is decisive to review the legitimacy of the use of patents, and the review is legally based on the clause 59 in MRFTA, which stipulates that “The provisions of this Act does not apply to a legitimate exercise of rights under the Copyright Act, the Patent Act, the Utility Models Act, the Design Act, or the Trademark Act.” The review of the legitimacy of use of patents will be made by the two criterions, patent policy and competition policy. If the conduct of a patentee is decided as the misuse of patents, MRFTA will be applied to the conduct, and it should be considered whether the conduct corresponds to the breach of the regulations of the abuse of market dominant power. As the abuse of the market dominant power is considered from the two perspective, exploitative abuse and exclusive abuse, the decision on the abuse of patents shall be based on the two criterions. The standard essential patent must be specially considered in two types of review.
Abstract
A patentee has the exclusive right, and a use of the right will become the object of protection in the Patent Act. But if the use of patents belongs to the misuse, Patent Act will not protect the use of patents and will be applied the Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trad Act(hereafter MRFTA) will be applied to the use of patents. At the process of the application it is decisive to review the legitimacy of the use of patents, and the review is legally based on the clause 59 in MRFTA, which stipulates that “The provisions of this Act does not apply to a legitimate exercise of rights under the Copyright Act, the Patent Act, the Utility Models Act, the Design Act, or the Trademark Act.” The review of the legitimacy of use of patents will be made by the two criterions, patent policy and competition policy. If the conduct of a patentee is decided as the misuse of patents, MRFTA will be applied to the conduct, and it should be considered whether the conduct corresponds to the breach of the regulations of the abuse of market dominant power. As the abuse of the market dominant power is considered from the two perspective, exploitative abuse and exclusive abuse, the decision on the abuse of patents shall be based on the two criterions. The standard essential patent must be specially considered in two types of review.
참고문헌 (21)
- 권영주, "수직적 통합 및 분리의 경제적 이유와 사례 분석", 정보통신정책, 15(19) (2003)
- 권오승, "독점규제법" (2016), 법문사
- 권오승, "독점규제법-이론과 실무-" (2016), 법문사
- 설민수, "특허권 소진 법리의 역사적 전개와 한국에서의 적용", 사법논집, 55 (2012)
- 신동권, "독점규제법" (2016), 박영사
- 신현윤, "경제법" (2012), 법문사
- 홍명수, "특허권 남용에 대한 시장지배적 지위남용행위로서 규제 가능성 검토", 경쟁법연구, 34, pp.155~189 (2016), 한국경쟁법학회
- ABA, "Antitrust Law Development" (2007), ABA Publishing
- Akman, P., "The Concept of Abuse in EU Competition Law" (2015), Hart Publishing
- Alison Jones, "EU Competition Law" (2011), Oxford Univ. Press
- Areeda, P., "Antitrust Analysis 4" (1988), Little, Brown and Company
- Bavasso, A., "Recoupment in Predatory Pricing : France Telecom v. Commission" (2009), Allen & Overy
- Furse, M., "Competition Law of the EC and UK" (2004), Oxford Univ. Press
- Gassner, U., "Grundzüge des Kartellrechts" (1999), Verlag Vahlen
- Gavil, A., "Antitrust Law in Perspective", pp.2008, Thomson
- Goyder, J., "EC Competition Law" (2009), Oxford Univ. Press
- Koenig, C., "EC Competition and Telekommunications Law" (2009), Wolters Kluwer
- Lange, K. W., "Handbuch zum Deutschen und Europäischen Kartellrecht" (2006), Recht und Wirtschaft GmbH
- Rittner, F., "Europäisches und deutsches Wirtschaftsrecht" (2008), C. F. Müller
- Whish, R., "Competition Law" (2012), Oxford Univ. Press
- Williamson, O. E., "Antitrust, Innovation, and Competitiveness" (1992), Oxford Univ. Press