본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Transformation of Countervailing Power in Collaborative Governance: A Case Study of the Shi-Hwa Sustainable Development Committee

0

조회

0

다운로드

5

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류정책학

초록

The existence of adversarial countervailing power has been considereda necessary condition to making collaborative governance fair and effective. However, adversarial countervailing power cannot be easily transformed into acollaborative one that is more appropriate for collaborative governance. This articleexplores a mechanism of power transformation by bridging the theory of trustbuilding and the theory of power in collaborative governance. This article positsthat when there is distrust among parties, comprehensive, up-front prenegotiationon the structure of collaboration may set the stage for a small-wins approach totrust building by managing power imbalances. Power transformation may followthis trust-building cycle accordingly. The framework of power transformationis tested with the case of the Shi-Hwa Sustainable Development Committee, asuccessful experiment of collaborative governance in balancing development andenvironment in Korea in which adversarial countervailing power was transformedinto a collaborative one. The results of this article imply that a key factor insuccessful collaborative governance is power management.

Abstract

The existence of adversarial countervailing power has been considereda necessary condition to making collaborative governance fair and effective. However, adversarial countervailing power cannot be easily transformed into acollaborative one that is more appropriate for collaborative governance. This articleexplores a mechanism of power transformation by bridging the theory of trustbuilding and the theory of power in collaborative governance. This article positsthat when there is distrust among parties, comprehensive, up-front prenegotiationon the structure of collaboration may set the stage for a small-wins approach totrust building by managing power imbalances. Power transformation may followthis trust-building cycle accordingly. The framework of power transformationis tested with the case of the Shi-Hwa Sustainable Development Committee, asuccessful experiment of collaborative governance in balancing development andenvironment in Korea in which adversarial countervailing power was transformedinto a collaborative one. The results of this article imply that a key factor insuccessful collaborative governance is power management.

참고문헌 (68)

  1. Altheide, D. L., "Mediating cutbacks in human services: A case study in the negotiated order", Sociological Quarterly, 29(3), pp.339~355 (1988)
  2. Ansell, C., "Collaborative governance in theory and practice", Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 18(4), pp.543~571 (2008)
  3. Babich, A., "Citizen suits: The teeth in public participation", Environmental Law Reporter, 25(1), pp.10141~ (1995)
  4. Bacharach, S. B., "The perception of power", Social Forces, 55(1), pp.123~134 (1976)
  5. Bacharach, S. B., "Power and politics in organizations" (1980), Jossey-Bass
  6. Booher, D. E., "Collaborative governance practices and democracy", National Civic Review, 93(4), pp.32~46 (2004)
  7. Bryson, J., "Strategic planning: Big wins and small wins", Public Money and Management, 8(3), pp.11~15 (1988)
  8. Bryson, J. M., "Big ideas in collaborative public management", pp.55~78 (2008), M. E. Sharpe
  9. Cormick, G. W., "Strategic issues in structuring multi-party public policy negotiations", Negotiation Journal, 5(2), pp.125~132 (1989)
  10. Cotton, J., "From authoritarianism to democracy in South Korea", Political Studies, 37(2), pp.244~259 (1998)
  11. Das, T., "Between trust and control: Developing confidence in partner cooperation in alliances", Academy of Management Review, 23(3), pp.491~512 (1998)
  12. Eden, C., "The negotiation of purpose in multi-organizational collaborative groups", Journal of Management Studies, 38(3), pp.373~391 (2001)
  13. Edmunds, D., "A strategic approach to multistakeholder negotiations", Development and Change, 32(2), pp.231~253 (2001)
  14. Faysse, N., "Troubles on the way: An analysis of the challenges faced by multistakeholder platforms", Natural Resources Forum, 30(3), pp.219~229 (2006)
  15. Fisher, R., "Getting to YES: Negotiating agreement without giving in" (1981), Penguin
  16. Fung, A., "Deepening Democracy: Institutional Innovations in Empowered Participatory Governance", pp.259~289 (2003), Verso
  17. Futrell, R., "Technical adversarialism and participatory collaboration in the U.S. chemical weapons disposal program", Science, Technology, and Human Values, 28(4), pp.451~482 (2003)
  18. Galbraith, J. K., "American capitalism: The concept of countervailing power" (1952), Houghton Mifflin
  19. Gray, B., "Collaborating: Finding common ground for multi-party problems" (1989), Jossey-Bass
  20. Gulati, R., "Does familiarity breed trust? The implications of repeated ties for contractual choice in alliances", Academy of Management Journal, 38(1), pp.85~112 (1995)
  21. Gunton, T. I., "The theory and practice of collaborative planning in resource and environmental management", Environments, 31(2), pp.5~19 (2003)
  22. Hardy, C., "Strategies of engagement: Lessons from the critical examination of collaboration and conflict in an interorganizational domain", Organization Science, 9(2), pp.217~230 (1998)
  23. Holzinger, K., "Negotiation in public policy-making: Exogenous barriers to successful dispute resolution", Journal of Public Policy, 21(1), pp.81~106 (2001)
  24. Hong, S., "Deliberative governance for consensus building and institutional design", Administration, 47(1), pp.21~45 (2008)
  25. Huxham, C., "Theorizing collaboration practice", Public Management Review, 5(3), pp.401~423 (2003)
  26. Huxham, C., "Leadership in the shaping and implementation of collaboration agendas: How things happen in a (not quite) joined-up world", Academy of Management Journal, 43(6), pp.1159~1175 (2000)
  27. Huxham, C., "Managing to collaborate: The theory and practice of collaborative advantage" (2005), Routledge
  28. Imperial, M., "Using collaboration as a governance strategy: Lessons from six watershed management programs", Administration and Society, 37(3), pp.281~320 (2005)
  29. 전상인, "협력적 공공계획 사례로서의 시화지속협의회 활동 연구", 지역연구, 27(4), pp.153~176 (2011), 한국지역학회
  30. Kim, P. H., "Power dynamics in negotiation", Academy of Management Review, 30(4), pp.799~822 (2005)
  31. Lane, C., "Trust within and between organizations: Conceptual issues and empirical applications" (1998), Oxford University Press
  32. Lasker, R. D., "Broadening participation in community problemsolving:A multidisciplinary model to support collaborative practice and research", Journal of Urban Health: Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine, 80(1), pp.14~60 (2003)
  33. Lawler, E. J., "Power processes in bargaining", Sociological Quarterly, 33(1), pp.17~34 (1992)
  34. Lax, D. A., "The power of alternatives or the limits to negotiation", Negotiation Journal, 1(2), pp.163~179 (1985)
  35. Leach, W. D., "Collaborative public management and democracy: Evidence from Western watershed partnerships", Public Administration Review, 66(s1), pp.100~110 (2006)
  36. Leap, T., "A conceptualization of bargaining power", Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 39(2), pp.202~213 (1986)
  37. 이혜경, "시화호 간척개발사업과 환경관리정책의 변화", 환경법과 정책, 9, pp.153~173 (2012), 비교법학연구소
  38. 이종원, "공공사업의 다목적성과 정책개선", 한국행정논집, 21(4), pp.1155~1176 (2009), 한국정부학회
  39. 이경환, "도시계획 과정에서 합의 형성에 영향을 미치는 요인- ‘시화지역 지속가능발전협의회’ 사례를 중심으로", 도시설계, 8(2), pp.5~16 (2007), 한국도시설계학회
  40. Logsdon, J., "Interests and interdependence in the formation of social problemsolving collaborations", Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 27(1), pp.23~37 (1991)
  41. 마강래, "시화지속협의회의 갈등조정 역할 평가:시화지구 개발사업을 중심으로", 한국정책과학학회보, 16(2), pp.161~181 (2012), 한국정책과학학회
  42. Mitchell, B., "Participatory partnerships: Engaging and empowering to enhance environmental management and quality of life?", Social Indicators Research, 71(1-3), pp.123~144 (2005)
  43. Moon, C., "Weaving through paradoxes: Democratization, globalization, and environmental politics in South Korea", East Asian Review, 15(2), pp.43~70 (2003)
  44. Mooney, L., "The social psychology of power", Sociological Spectrum, 4(1), pp.31~51 (1984)
  45. Murdock, B., "Stakeholder participation in voluntary environmental agreements: Analysis of 10 Project XL case studies", Science, Technology and Human Values, 30(2), pp.223~250 (2005)
  46. Norris-Tirrell, D., "Strategic collaboration in public and nonprofit administration: A practice-based approach to solving shared problems" (2010), Taylor and Francis
  47. O’Toole, L. J., Jr., "Desperately seeking Selznick: Cooptation and the dark side of public management in networks", Public Administration Review, 64(6), pp.681~693 (2004)
  48. Ozawa, P., "Improving citizen participation in environmental decisionmaking:The use of transformative mediator techniques", Environment and Planning C:Government and Policy, 11(1), pp.103~117 (1993)
  49. Phillips, N., "Managing multiple identities: Discourse, legitimacy and resources in the UK refugee system", Organization, 4(2), pp.159~185 (1997)
  50. Purdy, J. M., "A framework for assessing power in collaborative governance processes", Public Administration Review, 72(3), pp.409~417 (2012)
  51. Putnam, L. L., "Transformations and critical moments in negotiations", Negotiations Journal, 20(2), pp.275~295 (2004)
  52. Sagoff, M., "Price, principle, and the environment" (2004), Cambridge University Press
  53. Sanders, L. M., "Against deliberation", Political Theory, pp.347~376 (1997)
  54. Saunders, H., "Negotiation Theory and Practice" (1991), Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School
  55. Steins, N. A., "Platforms for collective action in multiple-use common-pool resources", Agriculture and Human Values, 16(3), pp.241~255 (1999)
  56. Susskind, L., "Breaking the impasse: Consensual approaches to resolving public disputes" (1987), Basic Books
  57. Thomas, C. W., "Deepening Democracy: Institutional Innovations in Empowered Participatory Governance", pp.144~172 (2003), Verso
  58. Thomson, A. M., "Collaboration processes: Inside the black box", Public Administration Review, 66(s1), pp.20~32 (2006)
  59. Susskind, L., "The theory and practice of negotiated rulemaking", Yale Journal on Regulation, 3(1), pp.133~165 (1985)
  60. Vangen, S., "Nurturing collaborative relations: Building trust in interorganizational collaboration", Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 39(1), pp.5~31 (2003)
  61. Vangen S., "Network Theory in the Public Sector: Building New Theoretical Frameworks" (2013), Taylor and Francis
  62. Warner, J. F., "More sustainable participation? Multi-stakeholder platforms for integrated catchment management", Water Resources Development, 22(1), pp.15~35 (2006)
  63. Webb, A., "Coordination: A problem in public sector management", Policy and Politics, 19(4), pp.229~241 (1991)
  64. Weber, E. P., "Bringing society back in: Grassroots ecosystem management, accountability, and sustainable communities" (2003), MIT Press
  65. Weech-Maldonado, R., "Building partnerships with the community:Lessons from the Camden Health Improvement Learning Collaborative", Journal of Healthcare Management, 45(3), pp.189~205 (2000)
  66. Yaffee, S. L., "Collaborative ecosystem planning processes in the United States: Evolution and challenges", Environments, 31(2), pp.59~72 (2003)
  67. Yukl, G., "Consequences of influence tactics used with subordinates, peers, and the boss", Journal of Applied Psychology, 77(4), pp.525~535 (1992)
  68. Zartman, W. I., "Ripe for resolution" (1989), Oxford University Press

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (3건)