본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

레코드 컨티뉴엄의 기록 평가 논리 분석 - 라이프사이클과의 비교를 통한 핵심 요소 도출 -

A Study of Appraisal in Record Continuum Theory: Derivation of Key Elements through the Comparison with Appraisal in Life Cycle Model

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류문헌정보학

초록

본고에서는 레코드 컨티뉴엄에서의 평가 논리를 분석하였다. 전자기록 환경에서의 평가가 지닌 보다 근원적인 함의를 파악하기 위해서는 레코드 컨티뉴엄에 내재되어 있는 평가 논리에 대한 분석이 필수적으로 요구된다. 레코드 컨티뉴엄은 기존의 라이프사이클을 기반으로 한 평가 논리 및 여기서 연유한 양분화된 기록관리체제에 대한 반론에서 출발한 이론체계라는 점에서, 전자기록 환경에서의 평가에 관한 이론적 기반을 제공해 줄 수 있다. 특히 평가는 기록이 지닌 의미를 모색하는 합목적적 행위임을 감안할 때, 레코드 컨티뉴엄에서 의도한 기록의 개념 및 의미에 대한 재해석은 이전과는 다른 평가상의 논리들을 도출할 수 있게 해준다. 이에 본고에서는 라이프사이클 평가 논리와의 비교 및 레코드 컨티뉴엄에서 제시한 새로운 기록에 대한 인식을 기반으로, 레코드 컨티뉴엄 평가 논리상의 핵심 요소를 세 가지 측면에 초점을 맞추어 분석하였다.

Abstract

In this study, the appraisal in record continuum theory is analyzed in conjunction with the appraisal in life cycle model. In order to understand the more fundamental implications of appraisal in electronic record environment, it is essential to analyze the appraisal inherent in record continuum theory. Record continuum theory can provide a theoretical basis for appraisal in electronic record environment in that it is a theoretical system in opposition of the appraisal based on life cycle model and dualistic records management system resulting from it. In particular, considering that the appraisal is a purposive act of seeking the meaning of records, the reinterpretation of the concept and meaning of records intended in record continuum theory enables us to derive the different appraisal logics than before. Therefore In this study, based on comparison with the appraisal based on life cycle model and the new record concept presented in record continuum, the appraisal in record continuum theory is analyzed focusing on three aspects.

참고문헌 (59)

  1. 김명훈, "전자기록 평가론" (2009), 진리탐구
  2. 김명훈, "레코드 컨티뉴엄과 평가, 그리고 기록콘텐츠 -기록콘텐츠 개념 정립을 위한 시론-", Journal of Information Science Theory and Practice, 41(3), pp.131~153 (2010), 한국과학기술정보연구원
  3. 김명훈, "레코드 컨티뉴엄 이론의 기원에 관한 연구 : 라이프사이클 모델과의 비교를 중심으로", 기록학연구, (68), pp.5~39 (2021), 한국기록학회[DOI]
  4. 김명훈, "전자기록 환경에서 레코드 컨티뉴엄의 의의와 한계: 기록의 의미 및 속성을 중심으로", 한국기록관리학회지, 21(3), pp.1~16 (2021), 한국기록관리학회[DOI]
  5. 이승억, "디지털 정보기술 환경에서 보존기록 평가론의 전환", 기록학연구, (67), pp.57~97 (2021), 한국기록학회[DOI]
  6. 이승억, "한국 공공분야 '기록보유(Recordkeeping)'체제 전망 -'기록물분류기준표'의 제도적 의의와 특성", 기록학연구, (4), pp.31~62 (2001), 한국기록학회
  7. Schellenberg, Theodore R., "현대 기록학개론" (2002), 진리탐구
  8. Schellenberg, Theodore R., "현대 공공기록의 평가. 기록학의 평가론" (2005), 진리탐구
  9. Angel, H., "Archival Janus : The Records Center", American Archivist, 31(1), pp.5~12 (1968)
  10. Atherton, J., "From life cycle to continuum : some thoughts on the records management-archives relationship", Archivaria, 21, pp.43~51 (1985)
  11. Bantin, P. C., "Strategies for managing electronic records : a new archival paradigm? an affirmation of our archival traditions?", Archival Issues, 23(1), pp.17~34 (1998)
  12. Bearman, D., "Electronic Evidence : Strategies for Managing Records in Contemporary Organizations" (1994), Archives & Museum Information
  13. Bearman, D., "Archival strategies", American Archivists, 58(4), pp.380~413 (1995)
  14. Bettington, J., "Standardised recordkeeping : reality or illusion?", Archives & Manuscripts, 32(2), pp.46~69 (2004)
  15. Brooks, P. C., "The selection of records for preservation", American Archivist, 3(4), pp.221~234 (1940)
  16. Brothman, B., "The past that archives keep : memory, history, and the preservation of archival records", Archivaria, 51, pp.48~80 (2001)
  17. Cox, R. J., "Appraisal and the Future of Archives in the Digital Era, The Future of Archives and Recordkeeping" (2010), Facet Publishing
  18. Dan, K, "Acquisition, Appraisal and International Standard ISO 15489", Comma, 2002(1-2), pp.71~74 (2002)
  19. Dingwall, G., "Currents of Archival Thinking" (2010), Libraries Unilimited
  20. Duranti, L., "The odyssey of records management. part ⅱ: from the middle ages to modern times", Records Management Quarterly, 23, pp.3~11 (1989)
  21. Duranti, L., "Preservation of the Integrity of Electronic Records" (2002), Kluwer Academic Publishers
  22. Evans, F. B., "Archivists and records managers : variations on a theme", American Archivist, 30(1), pp.45~58 (1967)
  23. Flynn, S. J. A., "The records continuum model in context and its implications for archival practice", Journal of the Society of Archivists, 22(1), pp.79~93 (2001)
  24. "Records Management in the Digital Age" (2016)[URL]
  25. Gracy II, D. B., "Is there a future in the use of archives?", Archivaria, 24, pp.3~9 (1987)
  26. Grover, C., "Recent developments in federal archival activities", American Archivist, 14(1), pp.3~12 (1951)
  27. Hammitt, J. J., "Government archivists and records management", American Archivist, 28(2), pp.219~222 (1965)
  28. Hare, C. E., "Records management in the next millennium : conference report", Records Management Journal, 8(2), pp.113~117 (1998)
  29. Harris, V., "Recordkeeping and records continuum thinkers : examining a seminal Australian text", Archives & Manuscripts, 33(2), pp.160~170 (2005)
  30. Hartland, R., "Archives: Recordkeeping in Society(Australasian Library and Information Studies 24)" (2005), Centre for Information Studies Charles Sturt University
  31. Henry, L. J., "Schellenberg in cyberspace", American Archivist, 61(2), pp.309~327 (1998)
  32. Hofman, H., "Archives: Recordkeeping in Society(Australasian Library and Information Studies 24)" (2005), Centre for Information Studies Charles Sturt University
  33. Holmes, O. W., "The national archives at a turn in the road", American Archivist, 12(3), pp.339~354 (1949)
  34. Hurley, C., "The making and keeping of records(1) : what are finding aids for?", Archives & Manuscripts, 26(1), pp.58~77 (1998)
  35. Lane, V., "The Future of Archives and Recordkeeping: A Reader" (2011), Facet Publishing
  36. Lybeck, J., "Appraisal 2000: A Project of the Finnish National Archives and Its International Context", Principles of Appraisal and Their Application in Electronic Enviroment - European Models and Concepts: Proceedings of the DLM-Experts' Meeting in Tampere (2000), National Archives of Finland
  37. Maclean, I., "Trends in organising modern public records with special reference to classification needs", Archives & Manuscripts, 1(3), pp.1~17 (1956)
  38. McKemmish, S., "The Records Continuum: Ian Maclean and Australian Archives First Fifty Years" (1994), Ancora Press & Australian Archives
  39. McKemmish, S., "Evidence of Me", The Australian Library Journal, 45(3), pp.174~187 (1996)
  40. McKemmish, S, "Yesterday, Today and Tomorrow: A Continuum of Responsibility", Proceedings of the Records Management Association of Australia 14th National Convention (1997)
  41. "The Smoking Gun: Recordkeeping and Accountability" (1998)[URL]
  42. McKemmish, S., "Placing records continuum theory and practice", Archival Science, 1(4), pp.333~359 (2001)
  43. McKemmish, S., "Research in the Archival Multiverse" (2017), Monash University Publishing
  44. McKemmish, S., "Describing records in context in the continuum : the Australian recordkeeping metadata schema", Archivaria, 48, pp.3~37 (1999)
  45. McKemmish, S., "Archives: Recordkeeping in Society(Australasian Library and Information Studies 24)" (2005), Centre for Information Studies Charles Sturt University
  46. McLeod, J., "The record’s lifecycle : myth, mantra or misnomer", Records Management Journal, 6(1), pp.5~12 (1996)
  47. Menne-Haritz, A., "Appraisal and Disposal of Electronic Records and the Principle of Provenance: Appraisal for Access-Not for Oblivion", Principles of Appraisal and Their Application in Electronic Environment - European Models and Concepts:Proceedings of the DLM-Experts' Meeting in Tampere (2000), National Archives of Finland
  48. Nesmith, T., "Re-exploring the continuum, rediscovering archives", Archives &Manuscripts, 36(2), pp.34~53 (2008)
  49. Palmer, M., "Records management and accountability vs. corruption, fraud and maladministration", Records Management Journal, 10(2), pp.61~72 (2000)
  50. Piggott, M., "The history of Australian record-keeping : a framework for research", The Australian Library Journal, 47(4), pp.343~354 (1998)
  51. Piggott, M., "Building collective memory archives", Archives & Manuscripts, 33(1), pp.62~83 (2005)
  52. Reed, B., "Reading the records continuum : interpretations and explorations", Archives & Manuscripts, 33(1), pp.18~43 (2005)
  53. Reed, B., "Archives: Recordkeeping in Society(Australasian Library and Information Studies 24)" (2005), Centre for Information Studies Charles Sturt University
  54. "Dictionary of Archives Terminology" (2005)[URL]
  55. Stuckey, S., "The Custodial Role of Australian Archives—Its History and Its Future. The Records Continuum: Ian Maclean and Australian Archives First Fifty Years" (1994), Ancora in association with Australian Archives
  56. "In Search of the Continuum: Ian Maclean's ‘Australian Experience’Essays on Recordkeeping" (1994)[URL]
  57. "Structuring the Records Continuum - Part One: Postcustodial Principles and Properties" (1996)[URL]
  58. Upward, F., "Modelling the continuum as paradigm shift in recordkeeping and archiving processes, and beyond-a personal reflection", Records Management Journal, 10(3), pp.115~139 (2000)
  59. Wickman, D., "What's new? functional analysis in life cycle and continuum environments", Archives & Manuscripts, 26(1), pp.114~127 (1999)

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (18건)