Public Identity, Paratext, and the Aesthetics of Intransparency: Charlotte Smith’s Beachy Head
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
For Romantic women writers the paratext itself is essentially a masculine literary space affiliated with established writing practices; however,this paper suggests that Charlotte Turner Smith’s mode of discourse in her use of notes and their relation to the text proper are never fixed in her contemplative blank-verse long poem, Beachy Head (1807). Even though the display of learning in the paratext partly supports the woman writer’s claim to authority, this paper argues that Smith’s endnotes also indicate her way of challenging the double bind for women writers, summoning masculine authority on the margins of her book while simultaneously interrogating essentialist thinking and instructions about one’s identity in a culture and on the printed page. The poem shows how the fringes of the book can be effectively transformed from a masculine site of authority to an increasingly feminized site of interchange as Smith writes with an awareness of patriarchal, imperial abuses of power in that area of the book. There is a persistent transgression of cultural/textual boundaries occurring in Beachy Head, which explores the very scene and languages of imperial encounter. Accordingly, if Wordsworth’s theory of composition suggests a subjective and abstract poetic experience—an experience without mediation—in which its medium’s purpose seems to be to disappear from the reader’s consciousness, an examination of the alternative discourse of self-exposure in Smith’s poem reveals the essentially fluid nature of media-consciousness in the Romantic era, which remains little acknowledged in received accounts of Romantic literary culture.
Abstract
For Romantic women writers the paratext itself is essentially a masculine literary space affiliated with established writing practices; however,this paper suggests that Charlotte Turner Smith’s mode of discourse in her use of notes and their relation to the text proper are never fixed in her contemplative blank-verse long poem, Beachy Head (1807). Even though the display of learning in the paratext partly supports the woman writer’s claim to authority, this paper argues that Smith’s endnotes also indicate her way of challenging the double bind for women writers, summoning masculine authority on the margins of her book while simultaneously interrogating essentialist thinking and instructions about one’s identity in a culture and on the printed page. The poem shows how the fringes of the book can be effectively transformed from a masculine site of authority to an increasingly feminized site of interchange as Smith writes with an awareness of patriarchal, imperial abuses of power in that area of the book. There is a persistent transgression of cultural/textual boundaries occurring in Beachy Head, which explores the very scene and languages of imperial encounter. Accordingly, if Wordsworth’s theory of composition suggests a subjective and abstract poetic experience—an experience without mediation—in which its medium’s purpose seems to be to disappear from the reader’s consciousness, an examination of the alternative discourse of self-exposure in Smith’s poem reveals the essentially fluid nature of media-consciousness in the Romantic era, which remains little acknowledged in received accounts of Romantic literary culture.
참고문헌 (44)
- Charlotte Smith, "Rev. of Beachy Head, with Other Poems", British Critic, 30, pp.170~174 (1807)
- Charlotte Smith, "Rev. of Beachy Head, with Other Poems", Literary Panorama, 2, pp.294~295 (1807)
- Charlotte Smith, "Rev. of Beachy Head, with Other Poems", Monthly Review, 56, pp.99~101 (1808)
- Charlotte Smith, "Rev. of Beachy Head, with Other Poems", Universal Magazine, 7, pp.228~231 (1807)
- Behrendt, Stephen C, "British Women Poets and the Romantic Writing Community" (2009), Johns Hopkins UP
- Bennett, Andrew, "The Author" (2005), Routledge
- Burke, Kenneth, "A Rhetoric of Motives" (1969), U of California P
- Curran, Stuart, "Poetic Form and British Romanticism" (1986), Oxford UP
- Curran, Stuart, "Romantic Poetry: The Altered, In Romanticism and Feminism", pp.185~207 (1988), Indiana UP
- De Almeida, Hermione, "Indian Renaissance: British Romantic Art and the Prospect of India" (2005), Ashgate
- Charlotte Smith, "Rev. of Elegiac Sonnets", Critical Review, 61, pp.467~468
- Charlotte Smith, "Rev. of The Emigrants", British Critic, 1, pp.403~406
- Feldman, Paula R, "Romantic Women Writers: Voices and Countervoices" (1995), UP of New England
- Fletcher, Loraine, "Charlotte Smith: A Critical Biography" (1998), St. Martin
- Fraistat, Neil, "The Poem and the Book: Interpreting Collections of Romantic Poetry" (1985), U of North Carolina P
- Genette, Gérard, "Paratexts: Thresholds of Interpretation" (1997), Cambridge UP
- Gross, Alan G, "The Rhetoric of Science" (1990), Harvard UP
- Hoagwood, Terence Allan, "Charlotte Smith: Political Iconography and a Critique of Imagination, In Politics, Philosophy, and the Production of Romantic Texts", pp.140~149 (1996), Northern Illinois UP
- Hoagwood, Terence Allan, "Colour’ Shadows, In Contexts in Publishing, Printing, and Reading Nineteenth-Century British Women Writers" (2005), Palgrave Macmillan
- Hunt, Jr, "Wordsworth and Charlotte Smith: 1970", Wordsworth Circle, 35(2), pp.80~91 (2004)
- Kelley, Theresa M, "Romantic Histories: Charlotte Smith and Beachy Head", Nineteenth-Century Literature, 59(3), pp.281~314 (2004)
- Labbe, Jacqueline M, "Charlotte Smith: Romanticism, Poetry and the Culture of Gender" (2003), Manchester UP
- Langan, Celeste, "The Medium of Romantic Poetry, In The Cambridge Companion to British Romantic Poetry", pp.239~262 (2008), Cambridge UP
- Linkin, Harriet Kramer, "Taking Stock of the British Romantics Marketplace: Teaching New Canons through New Editions?", Nineteenth-Century Contexts, 19(2), pp.111~123 (1995)
- Linkin, Harriet Kramer, "Romanticism and Women Poets: Opening the Doors of Reception" (1999), UP of Kentucky
- McGann, Jerome J., "The Poetics of Sensibility: A Revolution in Literary Style" (1996), Oxford UP
- Mellor, Anne K, "Romanticism and Gender" (1993), Routledge
- Newlyn, Lucy, "Reading, Writing, and Romanticism: The Anxiety of Reception" (2000), Oxford UP
- Pascoe, Judith, "Female Botanists and the Poetry of Charlotte Smith, In Re- Visioning Romanticism: British Women Writers, 1776-1837", pp.193~209 (1994), U of Pennsylvania P
- Pascoe, Judith, "Romantic Theatricality: Gender, Poetry, and Spectatorship" (1997), Cornell UP
- Pratt, Mary Louise, "Imperial Eyes: Travel Writing and Transculturation" (1992), Routledge
- Ruwe, Donelle, "Charlotte Smith’ Sublime: Feminine Poetics, Botany, and Beachy Head", Prism(s): Essays in Romanticism, 7, pp.117~132 (1999)
- Smith, Charlotte Turner, "The Collected Letters of Charlotte Smith" (2003), Indiana UP
- Smith, Charlotte Turner, "The Poems of Charlotte Smith" (1993), Oxford UP
- Smith, Charlotte Turner, "The Works of Charlotte Smith. Vol. 14" (2007), Pickering & Chatto
- Stanton, Judith Phillips, "Charlotte Smith’ ‘Literary Business’ Income, Patronage, and Indigence, In The Age of Johnson", pp.375~401 (1987), AMS P
- Stillinger, Jack, "The Hoodwinking of Madeline and Other Essays on Keats’ Poems" (1971), U of Illinois P
- Stillinger, Jack, "Multiple Authorship and the Myth of Solitary Genius" (1991), Oxford UP
- Tobin, Beth Fowkes, "Colonizing Nature: The Tropics in British Arts and Letters, 1760-1820" (2005), U of Pennsylvania P
- Trilling, Lionel, "Sincerity and Authenticity" (1971), Harvard UP
- White, Gilbert, "The Natural History and Antiquities of Selborne, in the County of Southhampton: With Engravings, and an Appendix", T. Bensley
- Wilson. Carol Shiner, "Re-Visioning Romanticism: British Women Writers, 1776-1837" (1837), U of Pennsylvania P
- Zimmerman, Sarah M, "‘Dost thou not know my voice?’ Charlotte Smith and the Lyric’ Audience, In Romanticism and Women Poets: Opening the Doors of Reception", pp.101~124 (1999), UP of Kentucky
- Zimmerman, Sarah M, "Romanticism, Lyricism, and History" (1999), State U of New York P