War after War: State Allegory in an Age of Security
0
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
What is the nature and cultural function of literature in a “War on Terror”? Some commentators have struggled to answer this question because they expect such a literature to emphasize combat or they fail to appreciate the allegorical nature of the most incisive fictions of the War on Terror. “State allegory” played an essential role in underwriting the Bush administration’s “War on Terror.” In the years after September 11, 2001, it also played an increasingly important role in the critique of US policy. Before 9/11, a popular form of melodrama laid the ground for the rise of the US Homeland Security State by dramatizing the purported efficacy of emergency measures and allegorizing citizens as wards of a massive and clandestine security state. After the intelligence failures of the US War in Iraq, however, this type of melodrama expressed growing skepticism about US policy by allegorizing a growing American public discomfort with the work of the security state. Literary fiction also developed sophisticated critiques of American policy through fabulous, psychologically rich, and sometimes surreal allegories. This paper surveys this history of state allegory before turning to an extended example: Colson Whitehead’s 2011 novel Zone One. Whitehead’s novel powerfully illustrates the role of speculative allegory in critiquing the new US paradigm for state security.
Abstract
What is the nature and cultural function of literature in a “War on Terror”? Some commentators have struggled to answer this question because they expect such a literature to emphasize combat or they fail to appreciate the allegorical nature of the most incisive fictions of the War on Terror. “State allegory” played an essential role in underwriting the Bush administration’s “War on Terror.” In the years after September 11, 2001, it also played an increasingly important role in the critique of US policy. Before 9/11, a popular form of melodrama laid the ground for the rise of the US Homeland Security State by dramatizing the purported efficacy of emergency measures and allegorizing citizens as wards of a massive and clandestine security state. After the intelligence failures of the US War in Iraq, however, this type of melodrama expressed growing skepticism about US policy by allegorizing a growing American public discomfort with the work of the security state. Literary fiction also developed sophisticated critiques of American policy through fabulous, psychologically rich, and sometimes surreal allegories. This paper surveys this history of state allegory before turning to an extended example: Colson Whitehead’s 2011 novel Zone One. Whitehead’s novel powerfully illustrates the role of speculative allegory in critiquing the new US paradigm for state security.
참고문헌 (14)
- J. J. Abrams, "Mission: Impossible III", Paramount Pictures, ~ (2006)
- Caputo, Phillip, "Casualties of War.Sunday Book Review", The New York Times, 1~ (2010)
- Fanon, Franz, "The Wretched of the Earth" (1963), Grove
- Filkins, Dexter, "The Forever War: Dispatches from the War on Terror" (2009), Vintage
- Gallagher, Matt, "Where’s the Great Novel about the War on terror?", Atlantic Monthly, ~ (2011)
- Paul Greengrass, "The Bourne Ultimatum", Universal Pictures, ~ (2007)
- Hamid, Moshin, "The Reluctant Fundamentalist" (2007), Harcourt
- Hoberek, Andrew, "Living with PASD", Contemporary Literature, 53(2), pp.410~ (2012)
- Joseph Kosinski, "Oblivion", Universal Pictures, ~ (2013)
- Melley, Timothy, "The Covert Sphere: Secrecy, Fiction, and the National Security State" (2012), Cornell UP
- Melley, Timothy, "War on terror. American Literature in Transition, 2000-2010", pp.275~290 (2017), Cambridge UP
- Walter, Jess, "The Zero" (2006), Harper
- Whitehead, Colson, "Zone One" (2011), Doubleday
- Young, Alan, "The Harmony of Illusions: An Ethnography of Post-Traumatic Stress Syndrome" (1995), Princeton UP