Recounting the Past: Narratives of the Marginalized and Affective Education in Wordsworth’s “Michael”
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
In this essay, I argue that William Wordsworth poeticizes personal tragedies in rural communities to make their experience transferrable, memorable, and affectively sustainable. By closely reading “Michael: A Pastoral Poem” (1800), I explore Wordsworth’s attempts to transcribe the experience of rural lives and dramatize the pressures of historical change. Unlike traditional historians who prioritize factual accuracy and official documentation, Wordsworth finds a different kind of value in recounting the past and foregrounds emotional resonance of the past lives of the rural poor. For him, poeticizing their lives is not only a way of recording their objective history but also a means of memorializing and creating new meanings for their lives. In “Michael,” Wordsworth reveals that the nostalgic past is unsustainable, no longer possible to teach us how to live, as suggested by the Ciceronian phrase historia magistra vitae. Michael’s way of life is not only outdated but, with its contradictory conditions, has already been influenced by the industrial and modern ways it supposedly opposes. Thus, the past in this poem assumes a new role with its emotive potential, teaching not how to live but how to “feel for others”—becoming a teacher of feelings rather than of life, or historia as magistra affectus. Through its poeticization, “Michael” elevates the personal tragedy of an outmoded shepherd into a meaningful aesthetic experience. It not only preserves personal histories but also presents them as instructors of feeling, countering modern insensibility—an urgent necessity in the face of emerging industrial modernity.
Abstract
In this essay, I argue that William Wordsworth poeticizes personal tragedies in rural communities to make their experience transferrable, memorable, and affectively sustainable. By closely reading “Michael: A Pastoral Poem” (1800), I explore Wordsworth’s attempts to transcribe the experience of rural lives and dramatize the pressures of historical change. Unlike traditional historians who prioritize factual accuracy and official documentation, Wordsworth finds a different kind of value in recounting the past and foregrounds emotional resonance of the past lives of the rural poor. For him, poeticizing their lives is not only a way of recording their objective history but also a means of memorializing and creating new meanings for their lives. In “Michael,” Wordsworth reveals that the nostalgic past is unsustainable, no longer possible to teach us how to live, as suggested by the Ciceronian phrase historia magistra vitae. Michael’s way of life is not only outdated but, with its contradictory conditions, has already been influenced by the industrial and modern ways it supposedly opposes. Thus, the past in this poem assumes a new role with its emotive potential, teaching not how to live but how to “feel for others”—becoming a teacher of feelings rather than of life, or historia as magistra affectus. Through its poeticization, “Michael” elevates the personal tragedy of an outmoded shepherd into a meaningful aesthetic experience. It not only preserves personal histories but also presents them as instructors of feeling, countering modern insensibility—an urgent necessity in the face of emerging industrial modernity.
참고문헌 (29)
- Abrams, M. H., "Romantic Revolutions:Criticism and Theory", pp.320~349 (1990), Indiana UP
- Print. Caruth, Cathy, "Unclaimed Experience : Trauma, Narrative and History" (1996), Johns Hopkins UP
- Chandler, James K., "The Question of Sensibility", New Literary History, 49(4), pp.467~492 (2018)
- Chandler, James K., "Wordsworth’s Second Nature : A Study of the Poetry and Politics" (1984), The U of Chicago P
- Goodman, Kevis, "Making Time for History : Wordsworth, New Historicism, and the Apocalyptic Fallacy", Studies in Romanticism, 35(4), pp.563~577 (1996)
- Halpern, Sheldon, "‘Michael’ : Wordsworth’s Pastoral of Common Man", Notre Dame English Journal, 8(1), pp.22~33 (1972)
- Hobsbawm, E. J., "Industry and Empire : The Birth of the Industrial Revolution" (1999), The New Press
- Johnston, Kenneth R., "The Hidden Wordsworth : Poet, Lover, Rebel, Spy" (1998), W. W. Norton
- Jones, Mark, "Double Economics : Ambivalence in Wordsworth’s Pastoral", PMLA, 108(5), pp.1098~1113 (1993)
- Koselleck, Reinhart, "Futures Past: On the Semantics of Historical Time" (2004), Columbia UP
- Levinson, Marjorie, "Wordsworth’s Great Period Poems : Four Essays" (1986), Cambridge UP
- Makdisi, Saree, "Romantic Imperialism : Universal Empire and the Culture of Modernity" (1998), Cambridge UP
- Marx, Karl, "Capital: A Critique of Political Economy Vol. 1" (1976), Penguin Books
- McCormick, Terry, "The Oxford Handbook of William Wordsworth", pp.629~646 (2015), Oxford UP
- McFarland, Thomas, "Wordsworth : Prophet of the Past", The Wordsworth Circle, 14(4), pp.251~255 (1983)
- Pfau, Thomas, "Romantic Moods: Paranoia, Trauma, and Melancholy, 1790-1840" (2005), The Johns Hopkins UP
- Sales, Roger, "English Literature in History, 1780-1830 : Pastoral and Politics" (1983), St. Matin’s Press
- Schoenfield, Mark, "The Professional Wordsworth : Law, Labor and the Poet’s Contract" (1996), U of Georgia P
- Simpson, David, "Wordsworth, Commodification and Social Concern : The Poetics of Modernity" (2009), Cambridge UP
- Simpson, David, "Wordsworth’s Historical Imagination : The Poetry of Displacement" (1987), Cambridge UP
- Spiegelman, Willard, "Majestic Indolence : English Romantic Poetry and the Work of Art" (1995), Oxford UP
- Spivak, Gayatri Chakravorty, "An Aesthetic Education in the Era of Globalization" (2012), Harvard UP
- Stafford, Fiona, "Plain Living and Ungarnished Stories : Wordsworth and the Survival of Pastoral", The Review of English Studies, 59(238), pp.118~133 (2007)
- Thompson, E. P., "Time, Work-Discipline, and Industrial Capitalism", Past & Present, 38, pp.56~97 (1967)
- Williams, Raymond, "Keywords : A Vocabulary of Culture and Society" (2015), Oxford UP
- Wordsworth, William, "Letters of William Wordsworth: A New Selection" (1984), Oxford UP
- Wordsworth, William, "The Prelude 1799, 1805, 1850" (1979), W. W. Norton
- Wordsworth, William, "Wordsworth’s Poetry and Prose" (2014), W. W. Norton
- Yoon, Ilhwan, "Essays upon Epitaphs and British Burial Reform : Sanitation and Cultivating the Masses", The Journal of English Language and Literature, 68(4), pp.1011~1034 (2022)